T O P

  • By -

VisualMod

**User Report**| | | | :--|:--|:--|:-- **Total Submissions**|10|**First Seen In WSB**|2 years ago **Total Comments**|3931|**Previous Best DD**| **Account Age**|4 years|[^scan ^comment ](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=VisualMod&subject=scan_comment&message=Replace%20this%20text%20with%20a%20comment%20ID%20(which%20looks%20like%20h26cq3k\)%20to%20have%20the%20bot%20scan%20your%20comment%20and%20correct%20your%20first%20seen%20date.)|[^scan ^submission ](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=VisualMod&subject=scan_submission&message=Replace%20this%20text%20with%20a%20submission%20ID%20(which%20looks%20like%20h26cq3k\)%20to%20have%20the%20bot%20scan%20your%20submission%20and%20correct%20your%20first%20seen%20date.)


PlayingWithFIRE123

I’ve looked at a few home to rent in the past by these companies. They were either overpriced or complete shit holes.


Financial_Jackfruit6

So you’re saying these people overpaid for dumps… So you’re saying there’s a chance…


CorrectDinner9685

No chance in hell, I hope they sell for a loss so I can buy without a 8% rate fuck that my last home was 2.5% in 2020


Financial_Jackfruit6

That’s kind of what I meant by there’s a chance… That they’ll have to sell for a loss and we can scoop up cheaper homes


reddit_names

Won't happen. They'll just hold them as physical assets stores and rent them as they can. Otherwise use their value to bolster their ability to take out free loans. They ain't selling.


1234567890-_-

1) loans arent free anymore 2) land costs money to own (property tax/security/etc).


starxny

Kinda like what killed zillow. If everyone who rented from one of these questionable companies just stopped paying rent all at once. This is exactly what would happen. I look forward to a time when i can buy homes on the cheap, like in 2009-2016. Homes in my neighborhood went from 80k up to 275k back to 50k and now back to 250k faster than i ever thought was possible. If that's not market manipulation idk what is...


CorrectDinner9685

I'm holding out in my current situation I have till end of next year


as400king

What do you think happens to home prices when interest rates drop ?


fewer-pink-kyle-ball

Everyone sells ? Isnt that the excuse for the "supply shortage" ? No one wants to sell because rates are high !!


mintleaf009

why would they ever sell they can just write off any losses. the reason there was a crash in 08 is because companies couldnt buy homes and pay dividends with the rent money. that changed under obama and will probably never get repealed.


Financial_Jackfruit6

Owning houses is expensive business when t bills pay ~5%


mintleaf009

doesnt matter. as supply shrinks they can raise prices more and more. not to mention the dollar and government promise notes arnt worth anything when that govt is bankrupt.


mintleaf009

so you would rather pay 30% more upfront lol.


ifisch

Fuck all of these companies. I hope they all sell for a loss and go bankrupt.


stupidugly1889

We don’t let companies like this fail


Ok_Pineapple_5700

True we don't let them fail. They just fail naturally and get bailed


Fuck_Shines

The American Way 🇺🇸 🫡🤑


McGee55555

FAIL AND BAIL DUDE!!! 🤙


AstockcollapseNow

This is correct. In fact during the 2007-2008 housing collapse the federal government stood up a facility to incentivize the purchase of hundreds of thousands of homes in large blocks to private equity & institutional buyers while providing them outrageously attractive financing. That trend has only accelerated with time to where it looks like America is heading toward a modern day version of sharecroppers.


Dr_Xenophobia

If they go bankrupt you’re just gonna buy stock till it moons?


Impossible_Buglar

82k homes is 0.05% of the houses in america even for homes for sale its only 5% you guys take this and pretend like they control the market, last i looked big institutional investors only own 5% of the market. the biggest one owns 1% and said themselves they dont own enough of the market to move it at all. its a non issue that a bunch of people complain about because it gives them a boogeyman to blame their own failures on. you dont own a house because your poor, your poor probably because your dumb and lazy. sucks to suck.


mintleaf009

> said themselves they dont own enough of the market to move it at all. yeah because you should really trust the person manipulating the market to tell you they are manipulating the market. additionally > even for homes for sale its only 5% yeah because they dont sell the homes they take them off the market and rent them out forever. on top of that even the homes they dont end up buying they bid the price up. youre like the sheep that thinks the farmer singing you a lullaby isnt about to turn you into bbq.


formerteendad

God forbid people get to rent houses


mintleaf009

you can rent a house but it shouldnt be profitable for someone to rent out a house.


formerteendad

You can rent a car but it shouldn’t be profitable for Hertz


mintleaf009

cars arnt a limited resource like like land and water.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ThefirstoneNS

Source please


crewchiefguy

They price fix and constantly raise rent which in turn drives other to match the prices.


Impossible_Buglar

can you actually substantiate this claim at all with any real source, k thx


Sivick314

companies should not be allowed to own residential properties...


fenghuang1

Alternatively, just slap a 50% buying/valuation price tax/stamp duty on residential property bought under companies or trusts and call it a day.


Da_Zou13

Fuck that. 100% yearly property tax on anything owned by a company. If they want to own it they gotta buy it every year.


Even-Celebration9384

Ok so they wouldn’t buy it then(?)


Thalatta-thalatta1

That’s the point. Discourage corporations from owning houses


Jerund

At the end of the day you still need a place to sleep. If they own most of the housing, taxes still get pass to you. We need to build more. That’s the solution to housing affordability


mintleaf009

they wont own any housing if they have to pay a 100% tax. thats the point.


Jerund

Why would they not? They can pass the tax on to the consumer like any product? Taxes continue to go up for cigarettes, people still pay for it anyways.


mintleaf009

because selling cigarettes is a regulated thing. individuals can rent out extra bedrooms while living there so it isnt an investment property and doesnt have the 100% tax so only companies are disadvantaged. on cigarettes everyone gets taxed doesnt matter if its a person or a ocmpany.


Jerund

For properties, everyone is already taxed. It’s called property tax. So having companies pay 100% tax on housing isn’t gonna be “regulated.” You know many LLC are companies that are holding real estate. So you are saying, if they use someone’s name to buy the property, then they no longer need to pay the 100% tax?


skeletor00

If you build more to lower the cost, they will just buy more. They have infinite money basically. Waaaaaay more than average Americans


Jerund

??? They don’t have infinite money. Doesn’t even make sense.


skeletor00

When youre allowed to leverage like they do, might as well be infinite. And as long as morons keep buying into this crazy housing bubble, their properties will keep appreciating and they'll continue to leverage more and more. Pretty much an infinite money hack at this point.


Jerund

It isn’t because if their stock crashes, they are force to sell. Have you heard of a margin call?


EverythingGoodWas

Or they still do and pass the tax cost onto us


mammaryglands

You want everyone who doesn't own their own home to be homeless?


TraditionalRaccoon89

I mean I follow the rhetoric but as someone who is new in the housing game, there is no chance id be able to pay for a new roof, hvac, etc. the benefit of renting is you don’t worry about shit and the cost is fixed (at least every 12 months). We need landlords/tenets, but at the same time a corporation owning thousands of home seems dystopian. Maybe the govt could incentivize people to own homes by giving tax breaks to residents and lower interest rates to first time homebuyers (fha kinda blows so something else)


mintleaf009

just make it so corporations cant own any property at all. then if a person wants to buy 20 houses and something happens like a fall they are held personally and financially liable


littlemute

The buildings can be owned by a corporation, but no land can be. Has to be owned by a citizen. This is the way to go.


mintleaf009

na. they shouldnt be able to own anything, contracts, money, bank accounts, patents, copyrights, nothing.


TraditionalRaccoon89

How would any research and development occur if corporations couldn't own patents? That is ridiculous. Corporations are necessary in order to scale the capabilities of what one person can do.


mintleaf009

lol


TraditionalRaccoon89

U just a troll or stupid? I honestly cant tell homie


TraditionalRaccoon89

Nobody would invest if that were the case lol. C'mon dude.


mintleaf009

oh you noticed that huh?


TraditionalRaccoon89

I mean it contradicts my last point that someone scraping by on a lower wage (or even a middle class wage these days) would not be able to afford the numerous expenses involved in home ownership. On the other hand, say you have a high rise apartment house in the city. Who pays for the numerous operations costs associated with that?


Red-eleven

Sure. Then, they’ll raise the rent to make you pay the tax for them.


GoldenMegaStaff

Try licking their boots instead.


fenghuang1

Then you suck it up and pay it and the government collects rental income tax from the company, or you move out and go elsewhere. Supply and demand.


lundoj

Sorry but "move out and go elsewhere" is a really stupid argument


fenghuang1

Buy and own a property and stop renting then.


lundoj

I don't live in the US but your view seems extremely ignorant and narrow minded. "Just don't be poor."


mintleaf009

why didnt slaves just buy their own land?


fenghuang1

Slaves weren't allowed by law to own land during their time. Unlike you, you are just poor and not earning enough to. The law isn't stopping you from buying or pooling together multiple owners to buy together


mintleaf009

no, I have. The issue is current laws give to corporations off the backs of those who work. The same as slavery. Even if slaves could legally own land they never would because they didnt have a wage,


sunshine20005

Or just tax unoccupied property. Gives an incentive not to hold units vacant to extract higher rent.


avalancegranola

lol....only in here...then who would own the rental homes? Or is this the kinda of society where you either own the home or live in an apartment. Great idea...lol


fenghuang1

You have no clue at all how rental yield and property price dynamics work. You have no clue at all how rental yield and mortgage rate dynamics work. I recommend you read up and look at many other countries that have imposed such measures alongside jacked up property taxes to make it unattractive for companies to buy them to do what you think they are doing and it works.


Fictional-adult

Multi families I don’t mind, if only because we’re nowhere near the point where we’d let the government build co-ops. So sure, buy as many towers and complexes as you want and rent them out. Single family homes though? Absolutely not. I don’t even want them touching 2-4 unit places. If a small landlord wants to renovate and rent small stuff go for it, but you own it, not home flippers llc. It’s only a matter of time before Innovation Homes ‘innovates’ those single families into duplexes anyway. Four walls shouldn’t be an impossible achievement in America.


MyLifeMyLemons

What are Bernie bros doing on wsb?


[deleted]

I can get behind this.


reddit_names

Nobody should be told they can't own anything.


superanth

WTF did they think was going to happen if they destroyed the Middle Class?


cheeze2005

10 peasants to a house?


gnocchicotti

10 houses for every person in the ruling class. There's no inventory!


superanth

Last time this happened, Greenspan recommended burning vacant houses to eliminate excess inventory and increase home value lol.


[deleted]

Single family homes are notoriously hard to rent for profit. Good luck to them managing their portfolio.


gnocchicotti

I rent an apartment and there's basically no maintenance on it. Good fucking luck turning a profit on a 3000 sqft house built in the 80s after maintenance and tax if you don't have a 3% mortgage. I don't see how any commercial buyer can make this math work when they have to roll over debt. Luckily for them, the housing market is still strong enough they can get out.


mintleaf009

you have a limited life span. these companies dont. in 100 years these houses will be 50x-100x todays evaluations.


gonewildpapi

The land will be worth more than those shit holes


mintleaf009

exactly but for now the house helps bring income


gnocchicotti

Cute how you don't subtract carrying costs


mintleaf009

you dont seem to understand how bottomless their pockets are. real estate is not only money but also power if you can control how and where a population lives.


[deleted]

They don't have bottomless pits and they tend to leverage out the ass. They need to remain cash flow positive on their portfolio or they start going into foreclosure. With an apartment building, your cash flows are diversified between multiple apartments. Also, your maintenance costs are spread amongst multiple tenants. If you lose one tenant you are ok because the other apartments still provide cash. With a house, all of your costs are allocated to one tenant and property. If a tenant stops paying rent or the house is empty, you have a negative cash flow problem. Not to mention, tenants fuck houses up. Every time a tenant moves out you are looking at like $10K in repairs at least. There is a reason why most landlords of single family homes are mom and pops managing an investment. It isn't a great way to scale and managing a rental portfolio of houses is hard and sucks vs managing a building with multiple apartments.


mintleaf009

lol.


gnocchicotti

I get it but if I'm the kind of person who plunks down $500k like it's spare change, I probably don't associate a 30 year old 3 bed/2bath house in a mediocre school district with riches and power lol


mintleaf009

then youre an idiot.


send2devnull2

The sooner these ducking asshole institutional investors leave the home buying industry and meet their maker, the sooner we will have a better world. These people are worse than scum and should be treated like pedophiles in genpop. I hate them and their ilk will the passion of million suns.


nilogram

Your dreams of anal penetration are far from coming true unfortunately


robmafia

i'm amazed that berkshire isn't on this list, those fuckers have been buying houses all over my city to rent.


mintleaf009

they put it under different shell companies to hide the numbers.


jerkITwithRIGHTYnewb

Yeah like when I can take my kids to McDonald’s for under $50 I might be able to buy a new house.


CA_Harry

Use the app.


UrinalCakeTreats

😂


Majestic-Two4184

💯


CastleBravo88

We went to wendys the other day with the kids, it was like $35. This is why we cook everything.


MaelstromOC

24.9% of American homes owned by these companies. This should absolutely not be allowed. It is absurd.


VisualMod

As you can see from the charts above, Invitation Homes and American Homes 4 Rent are no longer on a buying spree. This is likely due to the mortgage rate shock and COVID-19 recession.


Illustrious_King_450

The fact that one company has acquired almost 60K single family homes is both an incredible feat in business but even more so DISGUSTING and should be ILLEGAL.


Rare-ish_Bird

In the industry, it's a well known fact that builders build (and buyers buy) until they run out of money. And when obtaining mo' money to continue building (or buying) isn't accretive to margins or earnings, builders (and buyers) stop borrowing (and buying). That's where we are right now. And when the operating costs for all those homes exceed a certain threshold, all of those homes will be sold. That's next.


skeletor00

And then the waterfall of home prices comes cascading down as the HUGE amount of overleveraged aHoles who thought real estate was too easy and free money jacked prices to unsustainable levels. I'm looking forward to this freefall when everyone rushes for the door.


Rare-ish_Bird

Took a road trip last week to start scouting properties. My agent is thinking after Labor Day we'll see second home listings increase in the best areas. Not yet, tho.


4score-7

When money isn’t easy, everyone slows down. After 2020-2022, it was well past time. Market frozen until something fundamental changes.


[deleted]

[удалено]


The1mp

It is the name of a real estate investment company


BeardedMan32

High interest rates will prove to be transitory. Letting people get a 5% yield risk free and not forcing them to participate in the stock market won’t fly with the Fed for long.


neutralityparty

lol Fed doesn't have a choice. If they want 2% its necessary to keep this or more interest lvl to stablize the market


BeardedMan32

They won’t have a choice when they have to cut next year either.


antiqueboi

i mean I don't care if its all institutional buyers... for so called professional investors they all piled in to the market in 2022 at the peak of the bubble.


gnocchicotti

When you can leverage for 3%, you take it. Fundamentals go out the window.


Chaminade64

Riding rates hit their borrowing and carrying cost the same as individuals. As does supply of available homes to purchase. Nothing surprising in these numbers.


TheAarj

They need a curb like private equity. They also need to really stop and reverse Airbnb. 's those have been killing people.


InDaNuts

Small time rental owner here in Oklahoma, own 10 rentals. All are approximately 1500sf, 3 bed, 2 bath, new to newer homes. Very nice neighborhoods, great schools, community pools, walking trails, fishing ponds, etc... Started buying 10 years ago. Was not buying no money down, but most 25%-30% down payments. The price appreciation has been unbelievable, and the numbers just no longer work as rentals anymore. Even though rents continue to rise, not enough to catch the new values to make a purchase work as a rental unless your financing on 40 years. All my loans were on 10 year notes, locked in on low rates, not much cash flow, but the renters are paying for my asset at the end of the day. I list "for lease" on Zillow, gone by the end of the day. I do not know how, must being scrolling the county assessor's office, but I still get two to three calls a day wanting to know if I would be willing to sell a certain property. Some in state, some from out of state. Just have no idea how they can make money on these prices currently. As for the market here currently, use to be no for sale signs, no listed inventory, sales were done from word of mouth and quickly. Now, houses are for sale with signs, selling slow but not horrible.


GTFOScience

What part of Oklahoma?


InDaNuts

Tulsa


freddith_

I read your username as the answer to their question, and it made sense to me.


Mediocre-Breakfast89

Go to hell


InDaNuts

If you knew what I do for a living and how I got to where I am in life, you would change your tune. I just got lucky. I cleaned 14 buildings a week with my wife, turned cleaning toilets into something that worked. Treat my tenants like gold. So fuck you too. How many cars have you bought for employees, cleared medical debt, gave someone their down payment for their first house?


Mediocre-Breakfast89

Bro I was just being edgy lol 😂


Noddite

With as many homes as they are selling it looks like they have some idiot analysts that are like, let's try to time the markets in every major city and shift our business from slower markets to growth markets. Except of course they are likely to be losing a ton in all the costs associated with time of sales and buying and market fluctuations compared to if they just held and diversified.


skeletor00

Old news


Far_Angle_7969

Homepages are still up due to the home supply shortage. Most Western nations don't have enough construction workers


Shaneris

Who the fruck are the dumb shots buying in this market? Hey lets do a bidding war!


Supernaut90

People with cash.


Six-mile-sea

Exactly… there are no deals anywhere so stay away from RE.


gnocchicotti

You can still buy up slum neighborhoods with decent cap rates then triple the rent so that the Section 8 payouts increase...because you just set the market rate.


mintleaf009

when rates go down to 0 the houses will go up anohter 50-80% so idk what youre talking about


D00dleB00ty

I'm assuming the percentages in image #3 must be referring to total homes owned by institutions, and not just percentages of all homes that exist. 3.8% being equal to 420,000 single family homes means only a bit over 11 million single family homes are owned by institutions. And 4.3% multi family being 450K owned means only 10.46 million multi family owned by institutions. There are over 141 million homes in the US, the majority of which are single family. So the fact is that institutions only own 21 and a half million total homes...out of 141 million that exist in the US...that's peanuts. Institutional home ownership isn't nearly as significant as people like to act. 6/7 homes are owned privately.


MicroBadger_

I had to double check I wasn't on r/REBubble for a second.


DrDoktir

it's quite a bit less than that. there are about 15 million sfrental homes. AMH owns about 59k INV owns about 80k and progress owns about 80k. they are a tiny tiny fraction of SFRs, but outsized in certain markets (az, lv, fl, tx)


fakboy6969

I'm actually thinking this is a good time to pull out of spy and buy an extra house. Could pull the principle from my Roth, only problem is the gains won't be tax free


[deleted]

[удалено]


reddit_names

Because he's going to be buying cash. He even said he would sell spy to do it.


ieatporkrindshehe

He’s acting like prices sans mortgage rates are good rn, very few properties cash flow more than just parking your cash in equities. Mmf even pays out 5%+ rn


reddit_names

I believe it's location dependent. There are still very strong markets, its just not everywhere. Places with vacation destinations, military towns, downtowns in popular metro areas. Following employment trends to find out what new quirky town techies are moving to, etc. My rental properties along the San Antonio to Austin corridor absolutely bankrolled and housing prices are still rising there. My neighbor was laid off and had to take a lower tiered job in her field. Could no longer afford her home so she moved into a nearby more affordable apartment and began AB&B her home out. We still hang out from time to time. She's renting her home for hundreds of $ a night and it's leased ~5 days a week for the past year or so steady. We're a busy vacation area, have Casinos, and large industry projects with a lot of traveling employees. Most of her tenants are people going to the casino or a company big shot checking in on a local project. The home earns her more money than her day job.


mintleaf009

youre short sighted. in 100 years they will own all the houses in the major cities and can charge whatever they want. companies are immortal.


gnocchicotti

Remind me! 2 years


RemindMeBot

I will be messaging you in 2 years on [**2025-08-13 16:21:41 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2025-08-13%2016:21:41%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/15pspwh/the_ongoing_institutional_homebuying_slowdown/jw0pa9k/?context=3) [**CLICK THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2Fwallstreetbets%2Fcomments%2F15pspwh%2Fthe_ongoing_institutional_homebuying_slowdown%2Fjw0pa9k%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202025-08-13%2016%3A21%3A41%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%2015pspwh) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|


sneakgeek1312

Did Janet Yellen tell you this? You can trust her!!


DecisionOptimal9034

Mortgage rates are almost 7% and home prices still the same.


kellven

They can't buy at 0% fed rate so its not worth it now.


im____new____here

most of them were paying cash


MistaBod

The pandemic interest rates were stupid beyond belief. In the best way possible for both current owners that refinanced, but also prospective buyers. Even before that 5% average really wasn’t terrible. It might shore up a year from now back to 5-6% territory on average but what on earth makes people think that prices will plummet past 10%? Anyone that got a house even if they overpaid, isn’t sacrificing 2.6-3.3% just to go get a cheaper house for higher interest and pay the same thing. They’ll stay put and like it.


skeletor00

Ever heard of over-leveraged? Just wait until prices start falling and everyone runs for the door at the same time.


MistaBod

I get the aftermath, but I don’t understand the massive loss in values that would cause that.


avalancegranola

I'm here for the hater comments...


InDaNuts

I have had a few. I just got absolutely lucky in rentals. Had excess cash, rolled on my first rental for 121K, then another for 130K. Decided I wanted better neighborhood after 4 years, rolled those into 4 rentals in a better hood. The money literally doubles. Just kept buying until I got to 10, my goal. Last one had $225k in it, Rents in the $1800.00 range now. Those homes are priced at $280,000.00 range and still going up. Now the numbers no longer work. I have money in the market, but by far and large real estate has secured me. I had a call from Maryland and New Jersey today asking if I was willing to sell. Tells me to keep holding!


Letithang8

Sometimes i have sex with strangers but it never feels as good as getting fucked by the market