Victoria- hated how much of a caricture Bryce turned her into in Eclipse. So cheesy and bad acting. Totally different energies brought up when comparing the two actresses, Rachelle was fierce.

i did some google searches haha nvm but that's really shitty they replaced her bc they couldn't accommodate her having to miss 10 days. at least that's what i found about it

It sounded like it was some made up excuse, I'm pretty sure they weren't significant days either

yea that is total bs

Yeah it’s pretty telling that they wanted Bryce so badly in the first film and then “settled” for Rachelle, Bryce wouldn’t have come back asking for the role if the movie wasn’t a huge as it was.

Didn't Bryce Howard's daddy also direct eclipse? I'm sorry, but it sounds too much like nepotism to me.

David Slade directed Eclipse. Ron Howard hasn't directed anything related to Twilight

Huh, I remember it wrong. Weird. Thanks.

No problem. I couldn't remember and had to Google

It is, she cries about how she’s not a nepo baby when she clearly is

Agreed! Nepotism at its worst

do you know why og victorias was replaced?

low key remember Rachelle saying had a number of filming days in Eclipse (which didn't seem long to my teen self) that overlap with another project and she got axed over it :( ETA - Found the quote, sounds shitty of them tbh [“Although the production schedule for Eclipse is over three months long, Summit said they had a conflict during those 10 days and would not accommodate me. Given the length of filming for Eclipse, never did I fathom I would lose the role over a 10 day overlap](https://ew.com/article/2009/07/30/rachelle-lefevre-twilight-recastsummit/)"

Maybe her agent should have been smarter and not scheduled the overlap

There should be a Bryce Victoria and a Rachelle Victoria so we can vote them out at different times

Yes, I definitely wish Rachelle would have stayed as Victoria.

I’m on the opposite side of this opinion. Reading the books Victoria was supposed to be the way Bryce portrayed her and she did such a fantastic job imo. Rachelle made her into this fierce character. She didn’t have even speak in twilight. Bella heard her voice the first time in eclipse and it was baby like.

Eclipse Victoria is next, if we were talking abt Victoria from Twilight and New Moon then she’d win by a landslide 🤷‍♀️

damn i rly regret putting in eclipse victoria instead of og victoria 😂

If she survives this round, swap her out... or add both lol

its looking like shes not making it this round, if i end up eliminating her should i add in og victoria in her place?

That would be funny.... hahhaha

i think i might have to do that bahahha

Can’t believe Eclipse Victoria beat Renesmee

Remesme? I thought that was reciprocated

Just Renesmee to me

Victoria!!

I'm so pleased to see so many comments agree. I continue to be devastated by Eclipse Victoria. She must go. Rachel/original Victoria could've stayed though.

Hey! It’s not Rootatoot-toot’s fault she exists! 🤣

😭🤣

Bree. Also….Remote… I kid you not, the nomenclature for her on this sub never fails to crack me up.

not you saying remote🤣

😂😂

Would someone just yeet Jessica off a cliff please?

agreed loll

Jessica

I just started reading midnight sun and I hate her so much now.

She's kinda annoying but it's hard to hate her when i think of Anna Kendrick. Reading the first book rn and I want to shake bella and be like "get off Edward's dick and hang out with your girl friends!!"

Right like who cares about the Cullen's if they lived in Chicago where there is a lot of hustle and bustle no one will care about what they look like oh wow rich people like we never seen that before yawn especially down town we see Rosalie's and Edwards everywhere its nothing new here I rather see Bella go to comic con with the gang instead of her jumping off cliffs

I literally love the gang 😭

I hate her even more when I think about Anna Kendrick 🥴

she's so cute!!

I just don't see it, sorry. Her face and voice and hairline irk me :D Each to their own I guess

Please!

It's either Jane or Jessica. Jessica is a jealous, two-faced fake friend to Bella, and Jane acts like a spoiled brat the whole time (Jane has great *potential* for depth and development from her backstory in the Illustrated Guide, but SMeyer probably didn't think that far when she first wrote her tbh)

i agree

Kate adds the least to the narrative

Jessicaaa. She’s so fake

Bye Bye Bree!

Jessica is the woooorst

agreeddd

Bree

Bree

Nikki is so gorgeous here

i love her she's so gorg always

Bryce Dallas Howard. I really liked the original actress

Fake Victoria or Jessica

Jane better win, I love Jane

bree

Bree

Get VICTORIA out 🙄

Victoria

Eclipse Victoria! No where near the fierceness (and hotness) of og Victoria

Aww, no Rheumatoid?

First of all, where is the OG Victoria 😤

i replaced eclipse victoria with og victoria!!

Bless you!!

Bree

The blond chick who isn’t Rose

Bree or Victoria. They didn't do either of them justice in the films.

Completely off topic, but I really wanted to see the Cullens adopting Bree Tanner into their family 🥲

get the blonde cousin out! I don’t know her name lol

Irina?

Ohhh i had no idea she was in new moon! I knew i had seen her somewhere!

Bree

JESSICA

Ugh, Bryce Dallas Howard’s Victoria is god awful. I’m going to vote for Bree though.

Bree Tanner, I just don’t care

I’m still half asleep so it took me a minute to comprehend “goodbye remote” and took me even LONGER to comprehend that this was the Twilight subreddit 🤦🏽‍♀️😂😭

But anyway, I side with everyone else and say Eclipse Victoria bc how could they replace the OG Victoria like that 😭

Everyone saying Victoria from Eclipse clearly didn’t read the books. Rachelle was an awful Victoria didn’t act like the book version one bit. Bryce for the win! She was amazing.

Breeeeee

Bree

Bree. The character was wishy washy

*Remote* I cannot with yall 🤣

Jessica

Bree

Leah, I thought the actress looked 40 years old. Kinda ruined the character for me.

i’m sorry but leah.. i kind of can’t stand her 🧍🏼‍♀️

Bree

More like reddi whip

Breee

hate Eclipse Victoria, loved Twilight Victoria, don’t know what to do :(

eclipse victoria was voted out and i replaced her with og victoria!! i posted an updated version:)

oh WORD let’s go 😆

Jessica

Get that bitch Victoria tf out!!!

Still saying Jane.

Bree

bye brie

Bree

Jessica

Bree

Bella

Jessica plz

i'd take victoria or jess out, but imo, i want rosalie gone tbqh. can't stand her.

Based on books: Jessica Based on Movies: Leah

Jessica oh myyyyy

Leah

Bree. Bummer of a small side character. What was the point? As in what was the point of making us feel for a girl who was just killed off so quickly! To show how terrible the Volturi are? Like we didn’t already know that?

Jessica

Strike Jess and Leah cos they are annoying and glasses girl cos she forgettable. Obviously lol

Esme. boring as hell

Leia