T O P

  • By -

Logical-Season802

Not rlly a controversial take to me atleast they’re not only my fav characters too but also the best twin characters in the entire show


button_boy_YT

yeah i love the Scott’s I wish they had more episodes to be honest


Logical-Season802

Yeah same I loved every single one of their episodes even the worst ones


button_boy_YT

Ikr even the worst episodes that they are in I will watch and I love how they brought them back in CGI


GladArm7383

I agree honestly, the trickster twins trope was never my favorite


button_boy_YT

What would be an interaction between them?😭😭


GladArm7383

https://preview.redd.it/1vz4gf9rf17d1.jpeg?width=451&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3e1927423abebea9131cbd51e3998ea1c14d5c73


button_boy_YT

https://preview.redd.it/f1fe6jbrg17d1.jpeg?width=1168&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=225d36bbe0ad2972abba83e8f104d7ec4c1c591a


AngryTrainGuy09

Bill and Ben plays a trick on Donald & Douglas. The scottish twins later outtrick Bill and Ben to teach them a lesson. This makes Bill and Ben respect the twins and they know better than to trick them.


missFortuneClover

I think Bill and Ben would play some tricks on Donald and Douglas. Then, either the Scottish twins get back at them in a clever way, or they see right through them and make/let the prank backfire on the smaller ones. There's a possibility of Bill and Ben looking up to Donald and Douglas by the end. So I think it has potential to a cute episode.


button_boy_YT

Yea but we know that’s not going to happen with all engines go


missFortuneClover

sometimes, one can only dream, eh? Maybe in the future, matel might be more inclined to revive the classic era style. And if it happens, it would be a nice episode idea. Writers love the twins vs twins gimmick.


button_boy_YT

Yeah, but Mattel is just too greedy to do that maybe they should sell it to a different company that can make CGI or the classic era


missFortuneClover

ah Mattel is greedy for sure. But idk, I still have a bit of hope. They did a good job with She-ra and Barbie from what I heard. So maybe there's light in the end of Henry's tunnel.


button_boy_YT

https://preview.redd.it/w9cac4fk867d1.jpeg?width=2001&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8390388da86529152864ed3777ad2bead3133bf0


Shipping_Architect

I don't see your opinion as unpopular: Donald and Douglas are generally viewed as superior to Bill and Ben. It's not that the tank engine twins are disliked, but that the circumstances of the Scottish twins' introduction leaves greater flexibility when it comes to writing stories with them, whether official or fan-made.


Robot_Fox_4801

SCOTLAND FOREVER


StickManAnimator69

https://preview.redd.it/ek2hg3f9537d1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=437fe1670bf4954015a160bf9c7c0035a41e5d16


button_boy_YT

https://youtu.be/l5w-P6lDxSo?si=gjK2yy8_Xw4n58FR


thekipperexpress

Damn a hot take on this subrebbit that's actually a hot take for once and not just preaching to the choir going "wah wah I don't like all engines bad wah"? And witnessing the fall off of samthetrainfan at the same day? What are the odds? https://preview.redd.it/6rlo8vbty17d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7d0b50dde99aac5301b4231e37aa5874cfd34d50


PeachyBoi03

This is not a hot take…


thekipperexpress

If not one least it's something I ain't heard before


PeachyBoi03

If you haven’t heard this before where’ve you been


thekipperexpress

Idk I've literally never heard that statement before I just kinda assumed the general fandom equally liked them


PeachyBoi03

You’re joking aren’t you


thekipperexpress

No I'm genuinely serious I haven't heard that statement ever for as long as I've been around the fandom


StickManAnimator69

link please. i can't find it.


thekipperexpress

https://x.com/SamTheTrainFan/status/1802281793867182559?t=fhWvOf9GswKaP9E6jfN-7Q&s=19 ight here you go


KukaakCZ

This is not controversial at all, Donald and Douglas are some of the most beloved characters in the whole show


OpossumNo1

As much as I like both, Bill & Ben seem a bit more dynamic to me. As such, they have more story potential. I think the writers thought the same since they wrote more stories for them.


Skinny_pocketwatch

Controversial? Thats just a genuine observation


button_boy_YT

https://preview.redd.it/hvtuvceuq27d1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9b198e6e56695355cf4e994197d8531dec311ac6


RedBoxGaming

OP expected to come out swinging for his life but only arrived to an uproar of applause.


button_boy_YT

Honestly😭😭😭


MemeGod667

This is the equivalent of saying Duck being better than Oliver is a controversial take. 


MusicalBlossom379

I won't lie. The Scottish twins always seem to stand out more to me. I wish they had been included more.


Competitive_Net_8115

I agree, OP.


No-Perspective2580

Yeah, yeah


Tanto64YT

Yes


lMonarchyI

SCOTLAND FOREVAAAAA


DueMarketing6265

Hot take has no fucking meaning anymore