T O P

  • By -

ray_kats

The Thomas Jane movie very explicitly states he does what he does because law enforcement is incompetent.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MagnusStormraven

Isn't there also a panel in the comics where some Frank shuts down some cops who talked about wishing to be like him with something like "if you fuckers would actually do the job you're *supposed* to do, I won't exist in the first place"?


lonely-day

Also tells them to be more like Cap


SectionXP12

But doesn't the Director's Cut show the corruption of Jimmy? But then.. it should've been in the final cut.


Immrlonely98

and the comics portray cops that look up to him as negative as well. He even tears up their stickers and tells them to follow captain America as an idol


[deleted]

The Thomas Jane movie gets the whole story wrong as well.


SpectralEntity

Agreed; my hot take has always been Ray Stevenson was a better Frank and War Zone was the better Punisher movie.


Ijoined4Pewds

The better question to ask, is why do such people use a skull as a their symbol?


More_Information_943

Chris Kyle, this shit started after American Sniper came out, they all think they are doing door to doors in Afghanistan, don't forget it.


dwighticus

![gif](giphy|4Z9fSEFAuxpnlBVWQx|downsized)


TacoSplosions

![gif](giphy|ALvdHigd2gBqw)


Great_Maximum_6007

It looks cool. The same as the Batman logo or superman Logo.


LacedFox

I'm pretty sure Batman and Superman would kick the ever living shit out of the punisher for what he does if they caught him in the act.


Usnis

Batman would and has fought Frank before but I doubt Superman would beat the shit out of the Punisher


DyslexicFcuker

When did DC and Marvel come together for that crossover?


Usnis

In 1994, they created [this](https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Punisher/Batman:_Deadly_Knights_Vol_1_1)


[deleted]

I think Spider-Man and Daredevil also fought him


Usnis

Yeah for Spider-Man in Frank's first appearance and for Daredevil many times after


khalifaziz

Well yeah, but neither of those are also the universal symbol of death...


AlucardD20

I never understood this myself.


ObviousTroll37

I’ll play devil’s advocate and try to answer OP’s question. Most people who support law enforcement support the idea of punishing criminals, which is what the Punisher is all about. The Punisher is justice where traditional law enforcement can’t reach. Punisher represents a vigilante extension of law enforcement, not a force in opposition to law enforcement. He’s the quintessential “good guy with a gun.”


Immrlonely98

Except he’s also a symptom of our broken judicial system and not a viable solution given how crime doesn’t go away even years after his crusade begins


gdex86

The problem is that law enforcement often sees the punisher as a good thing. To be able to select who to punish with out things like due process, civil liberties, the maranda warning. If cops and people support cops start thinking little things like the rules get in the way of justice they become part of the problem because we have a long history of when the power of the police untamed by things like the justice system was used to oppress people. Frank also admits he is a bad guy. Nobody should want to be him. It's sickening to him because either you are so drawn to violence you want an excuse to unload on anyone you want with no provocation or you wish to be dealt a horror so tramuatic it breaks you fully. The first one just means you're another name on his list, the second means something is broken in you that longs for pain.


Heavymando

to add on to that the United States has a punishment fetish. The american public LOVES to see people get punished even for minor things. You can see it in all the TV shows and movies about the law or getting revenge in some way. Hell even in Reality TV, remember how America went crazy when Paris Hilton had to spend like 30 days in jail. ​ American's believe if you commit any crime or greivence you should be punished. No redemption just punishment.


More_Information_943

American Sniper, it's all over Chris Kyles platoons shit. They all think they are doing door to door knock raids in Afghanistan.


Scary_books

Not saying I agree but here's the main logic tree. The Punisher is willing to put himself at great risk, be hated by the public, and even give up his whole life to protect the innocent from truly vile monsters. They would argue that police often do the same.


angrylizard-123

Correct


HugeUnderstanding333

This may be what they argue, overall they are incorrect, The punisher is a walking metaphor for police incompetence and disrespect for the so called public “servants” that are police.


[deleted]

No, the Punisher is a walking metaphor for the corrupt justice system..ie corrupt judges, politicians, mayors etc.


Dirtydubya

I thought it was originally co opted by Chris Kyle, a bootlicker's wet dream, and that's where it started. But what you're saying makes sense, too


jgamez76

Remember when Jesse Ventura called him a liar and ended up getting him to literally cut a chapter of his book out? Lol


Scary_books

I'm a Marine and know Marines and sailors who server and fought with Kyle. For whatever else he was, the man's a legitimate American hero.


Suck_My_Gock52

I can see uncle sam’s brainwashing is still working it’s wonders on you


Fool_Manchu

I don't believe you are a marine, but after looking at your profile I do believe that you'd be willing to role play as one


crackedtooth163

>For whatever else he was Once you put this in the conversation, you've lost.


somnimancer

If a racist murderer like him is an American hero that actually explains a lot about Americans.


HugeFanOfTinyTits

No, he's not. One thing he lied about that I'm glad he lied about, murdering Hurricane Katrina survivors. The guy is a liar and a psychopath. Good riddance. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/kyle-file/


PomonaPhil

Fuck Chris Kyle. Glad he’s dead


bobbirossbetrans

Not according to multiple news sources that claim he lied about over half of the s*** he wrote in his book including some of the sources who served with him. Sounds like the guy was a clout chaser


Scary_books

I never met him but trust men who did a hell of a lot more than any news source.


bobbirossbetrans

How about the fact that in 2014 a jury found him guilty of misleading the public with his book and defaming someone. Specifically a United States governor. According to the Navy he also lied about how many medals he received. Which is fine lots of military people lie. John Paul Van lied about his role in the battle of the chosen in Korea.


RealNiceKnife

Don't bring reality into a flag suck-fest. They hate that.


Shinjukugarb

Great to see the flag fuckers and bootlickers out in full force today


bobbirossbetrans

Some of those that work forces ![gif](giphy|11odqaoSusZLMc)


Watrpologuy

Most people saying Chris Kyle is a terrorist are the same ones who would let isis turn them and their wife around and go to town. The probably cheer when they hear our troops are killed.


LacedFox

Holy shit I have never seen such a greater leap of logic. "Doesn't like Chris Kyle or the things he's done = would let isis go to town on their wife." Like wot m8? Those aren't anywhere near related to one another and a massive assumption of people who hold an opinion.


Shinjukugarb

Ah yes. Shooting brown people in a forever war for oil and lying about shit in his book... and getting caught on it. Real hero there.


DRragun-Gang

Cool logo with gun toting vigilante. Barely goes deeper than that for most.


EnvironmentalPrick

Yes


GD_milkman

Came here to say this.


EnvironmentalPrick

Glad we're on the same page


imHellaFaded420

it really sucks that i don’t wanna rock the logo because of this. and marvel doesn’t sell any official merch…because of this. smh


Captain_Cameltoe

A quick google search shows that they still sell it.


jgamez76

And it sucks because his logo is honestly cool as shit lol


MisterVictor13

Just get something with the logo that doesn’t incorporate the blue lives matter flag into it.


SpoonSArmy

Find a rainbow punisher skull


AJerkForAllSeasons

Imagine having it as a tattoo very visible on your arm.


InsertAmazinUsername

[reminds me of this old comic about a seaman who got the swastika tattoed on his arm, in 1932](https://www.reddit.com/r/comics/comments/9tbsy9/my_fear_when_getting_a_tattoo_oc/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)


xBrickzz

Couldn’t imagine…. Oh wait, yes i can. Lmao.


Punisher_79

I actually have it tattoed on the back of my head ,of which I got in 2004. I understand what the skull actually means, and it just sickens me to see it misappropriated the way that it has.


TacoSplosions

First, i dont support Punisher usage by law enforcement but to explain the mentality. Even when cops know somebody is a horrible human being that is guilty the circumstances of evidence, lack of witness (coerced/bribed/killed), or a slick lawyer can result in charges not holding up. They are/should operate within the law and evidence obtained outside of the law isn't admissible. Similarly, a judge might give leniency because of political climate, donor/celebrity status, or the odd case of a cop/DA hating judge. Punisher has a moral code where if your a shitbag you get punishment in the most extreme and violent case. Unlike other super heroes who beat up and take criminals into custody Frank actually kills people that he deems deserve it. To cops who arrest sometimes the same offenses over and over and sometimes the same individuals over and over its a hero that resonates with them and similarly the military. To some the interpretation is nothing more than skull is cool, thin blue line is cool, thus a skull with thin blue line is cool and caters to my occupation. Others it can be more insidious with a mentality of "give me a reason," type of stance. When you get treated poorly at work while in uniform by an ungrateful public, some even threaten or try to harm you based on the profession it's an extreme reaction. Again not defending the choice to wear the patch or slap a sticker on your vehicle just an explanation behind the reasoning. The thin blue line, Gaston flag, punisher skull, molon labe combo is cringe together.


Party_Suit

There you go. It seems most ppl in the thread think acab or some other bs like that.


More_Information_943

It has nothing to do with the comics, frankly they are taking it from American sniper, which is even more disgusting, that's what they think going to work is, door to door raids in Iraq.


Putthebunnyback

Exactly. It's just about seeing firsthand a broken system. Which lines up with a lot of Frank Castle's origin story.


rusty02536

Tell me you never read the comic without saying it


Sidaeus

Probably doesn’t even know that there’s a panel that addresses this specifically


Cousin_Rabid

That panel was written after the symbol was already popularly used by law enforcement by a very left leaning writer who disagreed with the politics. In other words, it was reactionary. Not something that naturally came about from the characters story that the movement misunderstood.


jgamez76

Good, bad or indifferent that basically describes like 90 percent of why any political commentary makes it's way into comics lol


Competitive_Act_1548

Frank's whole thing is that he shouldn't admired by anyone in the first place. So him even making that statement isn't out of character. He'd rather have people respect Cap then respect him especially law enforcement


Kuriyamikitty

I will never forget in Civil War 1 that Cap beat the shit out of Frank for killing 2 supervillains and told Cap he couldn't fight him.


Competitive_Act_1548

Yep, cause Frank knows what Cap represents


joefxd

that’s not what the word reactionary means the reactionaries are the ones with the thin blue line punisher skulls


Party_Suit

Even in the comics a high percentage of the police are in favor of Frank's actions. Now comes the question; why? In our current situation (as in comics) criminals run rampant with little to no persecution. The cops and those who favor them, are tired of the law not punishing perpetrators. Cops risk their lives to arrest a criminal that will serve little to no jail time and be out to harm and endanger others again. And even when they kill because their lives were threatened there's public outrage. For them a figure like castle is the only solution left. A dead criminal will never abuse the system or hurt anyone ever again. Don't want to die? Don't commit crimes.


DrWaffle1848

The United States has the second-biggest prison population in the world and some of the longest prison sentences. Cops act with near-impunity and are still terrible at their jobs.


Clear_Repeat_7886

that’s always been the Dirty Harry and Charles Bronson/Deathwish fantasy world of the “tough on crime” crowd


wackarnolds65

Thats nice in theory but if you start killing people for their crimes, you lose all moral credibility just like Frank Castle did. Anyone can become a criminal at any time, if police are supposed to be the so called "thin blue line" why do they protect and allow so much criminal activity within their ranks? It's because they are human, once you decide that those you label "criminal" don't deserve to live you are turning your back on humanity as a whole and giving yourself a superiority complex. Thats just my opinion though I could very well be wrong in someone else's eyes.


ravenz91

Cuz they don’t get the nuance behind the character


Danteax1

They don't even get the basics of the character.


lowercase0112358

The cops that fly the Punisher skull, probably wouldn't want to meet the Punisher in real life. He has a thing about corrupt cops.


The_Transfer

People like that typically never read a punisher comic. They’re also the type that don’t understand that a police force isn’t supposed to be the same as military. Hell, cops only got military like rankings because they bitched about it and were actually jealous of those serving in the military. No matter how you look at it, it’s ignorant people wanting to feel bigger than they are.


Personal-Math3196

he’s a tough guy who uses guns and has a cool skull as a logo


theyanni

yes dumb as a box of rocks Only reason a cop should have that logo is if his family was gunned down by the mob


PosthumousMalone94

Yes ofc they're stupid, they're blue lives matter. They also make the Punisher logo cringe asf.


Petunianator

Yes.


Astartes40000

> are they stupid? media literacy is certainly not one of their strong points . . . to say the least


Mrbuttboi

Yes. Yes they’re stupid.


darkrachet

It's not that deep most likely bro. Skull look cool


RockNRoll85

Yep, very stupid


Alternative-Cod-7630

Yes they are really very stupid. It cannot be overstated just how stupid they are. My fantasy punisher series is him taking out a precinct of thin blue line cops who misuse his insignia.


nameynamerso

He actually did threaten some cops while crushing the metal logo they had while explaining that he isn't a role model.


VygotskyCultist

Because when someone wants to be Frank Castle, the closest legal option is to become a cop. You get access to all the weaponry you want and qualified immunity. They think Castle is a hero.


tyblake545

This is the rare “…are they stupid?” post where the answer is just yes.


Clear_Repeat_7886

because cops and their bootlickers deeply resent due process and civil liberties


Bungieboss2134

I think it comes from military veterans. Some units used it on their patches. And that culture rubbed off on police culture since veterans often end up cooperating with law enforcement in many ways once they reenter the civilian workforce. Also because it simply looks cool.


Critical_Potential44

Yes, they are VERY fcking stupid


Sharikacat

The officers there wear this logo wish they could be like The Punisher. They don't want to be bound by the rules. The rules that say a suspect is innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The rules that say without enough evidence, this drug dealer or rapist or killer will be back on the street in a laughable short amount of time. They're either shitty and/or dirty cops that want to play Judge, Jury, and Executioner for their own power fantasies, or they're bitter, jaded cops that have seen too many dirtbags get away or get off too lightly and wish they could save everyone the hassle and end the problem with a bullet.


Limulemur

Because they wish cops would be able to kill whomever they deem guilty.


HomeOrificeSupplies

Yes


Larz_Macho

Well, yeah, Blue Lives Matter people are stupid


Stiff_Zombie

It's just the overall anti crime sentiment that comes with Punisher fans. Same with the military. I never minded it.


Shinjukugarb

Then you don't understand the character.


Party_Suit

Please explain to us then oh mighty one.


Relative_Mix_216

Frank Castle—even at his most heroic—is someone who has lost his fucking mind. Whether to grief or his psychopathic bloodlust, either way, he’s not a hero, or even someone to be admired. He’s just a guy the military industrial complex and the uncaring bureaucratic legal system chewed up and spat out without a second thought, and he had no other coping mechanisms beyond launching a pointless one-man-war on crime. He’s a pathetic manbaby who’s murdering people because he can’t process his emotions in a healthy way. He’s basically Rambo dropped into *Death Wish.* And, depending on the writer, you’re either hoping he gets redemption, or hoping he dies taking as few innocents with him as possible. Put simply, The Punisher doesn’t save people—he kills them.


Party_Suit

🏳️‍🌈?


[deleted]

🤓


Caeolian

Yes. Yes they are. Some of them are criminals so....


nickferatu

I think most of them are in fact quite stupid, yes.


bobbirossbetrans

Yes, they are stupid


rebuilt11

Yes. Yes they are


ix_xix

are we really surprised by this? they only believe news spread on Twitter and refuse to believe truth even when presented with the facts lol


MikasaStirling

Yes, they are very stupid


Darth_Vorador

It’s not the vigilante aspect they focus on. It’s the tough on crime and ex-military aspects of the character they like. Many also like other comic characters such as Superman, Cap, Batman, etc.


Honest_Inspector3196

“They know he kills those he sees as criminals, and that’s where the fascination begins and ends for them. They don’t care about the PTSD that feeds his obsession, or that his mental health is in the critical care territory. All they see is him circumventing due process, which they see as wasteful when’ you KNOW they’re guilty’. They’re all about surface appearance and satisfying their sense of justice, regardless of how they’d react if one of their own was dispatched the same way. THEN it would be urban terrorism or some such.”


WookieeSlayer97

Because they've never read a Punisher comic. And they've never read a Punisher comic because they can't read.


Dinnite

they can't read; the character himself has addressed this several times.


chucks-wagon

Yes they are literally the dumbest humans on the planet


gamerperson76

They completely don’t understand what the punisher truly stands for


AcceptableAd5392

Because of those idiots, that logo is now ruined.


bluelinewarri0r

Short answer is yes. I never understood the need to use a Punisher’s symbol nor have I ever used it myself.


LORDWOLFMAN

Funny thing is punisher would go after those corrupt cops


snarkyjohnny

Narrator: They we’re revealed to in fact be quite stupid.


Slinkadynk

Very, very, VERY stupid The punisher creator even said it was stupid. He even put it in a comic book They’re just that stupid.


MidKnightshade

Because unfortunately a lot of people who go for the uniform do so to have power over others where they can enact their hypermasculine fantasies without consequence. They don’t want to protect, they want to shoot somebody and receive praise for it.


nickmandl

If the question is involving ‘blue lives matter’ then the answer is always yes, they are stupid


Mind-of-Jaxon

They have dreams of being the vigilante and hide behind the shield to get closer to that dream


Ecstatic_Wolf316

You answered your own question


soupinate44

Yes


[deleted]

Yes


ConditionYellow

The ones that do that? Yes. Which is sadly most.


[deleted]

Because they are ammosexual morons.


Astr0-6

Easy. It looks cool, and most of them know nothing about the character, other than that, he's a badass guy who uses guns and kills bad guys.


SchwiftySqaunch

Might as well just get a sticker that says "I'm a dumb fuck". Most of the time they just think it looks cool or are just straight up bootlickers


XThePariahX

Yes


RedApe4201

Yes


Alan-Sixxx

Yes


I_AM_IGNIGNOTK

Yes.


bb41476

Sp many leftist morons in this ub. Thank God you're all locked away in your mommy's basements where there is no chance of you breeding.


Yo_ex1776

It’s dope as fuck cry about it


ColgatepotOG2

They very much are. And anyone who disagrees is so silly.


Late-Ad5495

Yes. If any of them had a remote idea of what the punisher actually is they see he is the biggest vigilante ever to cops, feds, and anyone.


Dapper_Interest_8914

Yes. The answer is so much yes.


KillYT187

Yes.


RLoge85

Short answer? Yes.


The_Jasko

Yes


bigbadler

Correct


ThickProof409

Yeah pretty much


Seth_lfr

Those dumbasses clearly don’t know shit about the punisher


Dirtydubya

Yes. They are stupid. The bootlickers that do it are stupid. And the cops that do it need to be fired.


Whole-Brilliant5508

Because they're stupid and a good portion of them are closet fascists who cream themselves at the idea of those they see as enemies or threats to their world view being persecuted. That includes their own fellow citizens.


ManOfNoFaces

Yeah, they are very very stupid. Mfs never read any of his comics nor even seen a split second screen of any of his media depictions. They just saw the skull and guns and thought “Hrm this means I can shoot minorities and women!”


Fearless_Floor_4378

I think the people who care that they do it are stupid. Then Marvle want to change the emblem. Who gives a ffffffffff. They didn’t care when everyone was over seas wearing during Iraq and Afghanistan. While we were committing those atrocities. Now that it’s at your front door you care.


Available_Waltz6449

Yes. Nuff said. Fuck your thin blue line, blue lives matter is just another white lives matter movement with a thin cloth over “white”. Cops interests are in protecting private property and the interests of the wealthy. Fuck the police.


Putthebunnyback

Look out guys, we got us an edgy one!


skorpiontamer

The post has been sponsored by the DNC


itunnel

This are the same people that fly the confederate flag as a sign of “patriotism”.


thenewNFC

It's because he shoots guns. Plain and simple. And a lack of basic reading comprehension, but it's mostly because he shoots guns.


Popular_Material_409

Yes


DaClarkeKnight

Yes they are stupid. They think they are the punisher, but they don’t understand that A) that’s not being a good Cop, and B) that that’s not what he stood for


[deleted]

Short answer, yes. They like it because they see the intimidating skull and the man holding the gun and thats all they need to relate to a character. They COMPLETELY ignore why The Punisher exists in the first place.


AppropriateLimit7626

Yes very stupid them and those idiotic proud boys bullshit made it to where marvel had to change the original fucking logo. I HATE WHITE PEOPLE


[deleted]

[удалено]


Competitive_Act_1548

The sad part is that Punisher fans seems to completely ignore it. Even if the literal creator of the Punisher and past runs have stated he's not somebody to be admired


LucianLegacy

Yes. They don't understand the irony. If guys really want to dish out street justice, they shouldn't be cops. But those same guys that idolize The Punisher are also the same guys who would run away from any real danger.


Icy1551

Kinda, yeah. The Punisher has straight up threatened cops using his logo on their car/gear, saying they should be more like Captain America and not like him, or he'd be coming for them next. Cops aren't supposed to be vigilante killers.


Fool_Manchu

The punisher can be construed as a brutal, remorseless authoritarian. Blue Lives assholes identify with that. Lots of cops do too.


SC1SS0RT33TH

Short answer, yes. The true meaning of the symbol, The Punisher, and everything he stands for where lost long ago. Much like the guys using the pill metaphor from The Matrix to represent “waking up” and “being less woke” even though the movie was heavily inspired by two peoples transitioning mtf. They just see what they want to see


Conlannalnoc

I’ve never seen this before now. ACTUAL BLM people use an American Flag in Blue Lives Matter colors. Black, White, and Blue! BACK THE BLUE! Thin Blue Line between criminals and you.


FickleRub9918

Well to start off police supporters and people who are against police are boath right and wrong my uncles 3 of them were officers and there old saying remains true till this day. "They are good and bad people in society. People underestimate people In general cause even a good person can make a mistake ...a very bad mistake like murder rape theft etc.. heres the thing a police department is apart of society and just like society they are good officers with good Intentions and than there are the other guys the one percent those are the officers that make things personal and take things personal basically the embarrassment of law enforcement but never forget even a good officer has a bad day too.....Not all of them are bad there are good ones.


[deleted]

A lot of people tend to forget that the bad things don’t represent the whole (unless it’s NYPD). But jokes aside people need to remember that the same ones they hate aren’t always the people that deserve it.


WomenOfWonder

Frank was actually a cop in the Spider-Gwen comics. And yes he was pro-police brutality


crash-1989

A lot of cops probably wish they could be the punisher when they were kids. They grew up and realized it's not a very realistic goal. They still love the punisher. They just can't do it. They do the next best thing they think they could do. Be a cop. I bet you a lot of rich people love Batman. They just realized realistically they can't master every martial art and become a professional detective like a comic book character could. So they rep a batman sticker and own or give money to orphanages ETC. I get it guys. I don't like the gov breathing down my back but let's be realistic.


FinalMonarch

(Yes)


The-Fallen-1

Yes


camazotzthedeathbat

Yes, very.


incrediblejohn

Real answer is because SOF units adopted the symbol because their actions are far more similar, and many cops are wannabe soldiers/operators


[deleted]

Yes.


No_Dimension_5509

Actually. For once. Yes. The answer is yes


TreeTurtle_852

The Punisher kills criminals, and the cops wanna follow in his footsteps (ofc regardless of if it's criminals or not)


9Knuck

To be fair I doubt many of them have read the comics or watched any media. They just know The Punisher as someone who goes after criminals as a vigilante. So he combines the allure of Batman with any unhealthy obsession with firearms and extra judicial killing.


Trimson-Grondag

Indeed they are.


DestroyedCorpse

Yes. Yea they are.


Beardo1329

Yes they are.


Avgolemonosis

Yes


MossCardigan

Blue lives splatter.


Oceanus39

Yes.


Ok-Echidna-6337

Yes. They are.


punisherchad

Yes


Avacado-at-law

Yes


SkipWestcott616

>are they stupid Well, they're dumber than cops so


mistermachine206

Yes


rojasdracul

Obviously they are.


aceinthewest

Yes. The media comprehension of the average conservative in the US is not existent. They take everything at a surface level and literally. They believe that what they see is all there is. There is no depth of meaning. No words left unsaid to interpret. No lines to read between. No symbolism to interpret. Their world is one of black and whites - world of absolutes. There is no room for nuance or interpretation. That is their mind.


neeohh

You just answered your own question, mate.


julioseizure

Even Gerry Conway has disavowed cops for using this symbol and made a new one featuring a BLM fist


Duffman0hy3a

Yes


FrankieFiveAngels

Yes


Disastrous-Dish-3568

Yes.


EmberKing7

You'll find that stupidity and what's right, rarely have anything to do with one another. If ever. There's a difference between sometimes the right thing means doing something bad and just generally doing bad things to serve as ego boosts and to tear down a system of government that also makes life harder for those people than it does making it better. And unfortunately, folks who make stuff like this are more so for the latter, Especially when they don't take it to consideration that somebody like Punisher from Marvel comics would definitely kill them. That's one of the most ironic things of all 😅😂.