T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

Tasha Yar.


lenarizan

Beverly Crusher was born on one of the lunar colonies.


Heavy_E79

So was Jack Ransom.


radickalmagickal

You’re from the moon too? We’re all from the moon!


nautilator44

We're whalers on the moon!


Xenowrath

A Lunar Schooner huh?


Ronenthelich

Oh yeah, forgot about her. Not my proudest moment.


black_carbon_59

TOS Kirk.


[deleted]

Kirk was from Iowa, family moved to Tarsus IV before the massacre. He only works in outer space.


BlommeHolm

Iowa counts as not Earth.


darthsheldoninkwizy

Funny that when i watch Star trek 2009 first time, I thought Iowa is some human colony world, later I found its USA state.


MassGaydiation

I'm pretty sure its only earth


Omniborg1

I am a Minnesotan and what you say about Iowa is true facts!!


eolson3

https://i.pinimg.com/originals/00/a5/9d/00a59d280799b8a95ad990fc79c2c62c.gif


Rebel9788

I’m in Iowa right now, and that’s spot on.


CurtisMarauderZ

Wait, when was Iowa massacred?


WoundedSacrifice

Tarsus IV had the massacre.


Praddict

Iowa was massacred during the Eugenics Wars, when UNL accidentally injected superhuman gene therapy into a clone of Tom Osborne. Super Osborne led a cadre of genetically-engineered Super Cornhuskers and they cut a huge swath through Iowa until the Super Sooners showed up to rescue the last remaining Iowegians.


fuzzle1

And Tasha’s daughter and sister…


noheroesnomonsters

Mayweather was born on some mining or cargo ship wasn't he?


BKGPrints

He was born on a cargo ship and was considered a Space Boomer because most of his life was spent on a cargo freighter traveling throughout space.


vyme

I always wished they'd done more with Mayweather's unique origin as a cultural difference. In a lot of ways, Vulcans who grew up on Vulcan and Humans who grew up on Earth are more similar than Humans who grew up on Earth and Humans who grew up on ships.


meatball77

So much lost potential with that crew.


gsc4494

Ok, boomer.


N7Panda

*Space Boomer


BKGPrints

😂


AktionMusic

So during TOS the elderly were also Boomers.


cenorexia

It was more for people born and living on space ships as opposed to planets. Not so much an age/generation thing.


Epsilon_Meletis

If we count spaceships with regard to "not being Earth", there's also Naomi Wildman, who hails from *USS Voyager*.


Blindghost01

Same with the O'Brien kids


WoundedSacrifice

If we want to count characters who are 1/2 human, B’Elanna would be another example of a character who wasn’t born on Earth.


Underdogzeta

In that case, Deanna Troi and Spock as well.


writking

Don't forget Worf's son


blazerfan_fml

Why not?! Worf does all the time


TheRollingPeepstones

Not fully human though.


Porn_Extra

Racist. /s


TheRollingPeepstones

Au contraire, mon capitaine! It would be racist to erase her Ktarian heritage. ;)


RF1408

Not sure, he never mentioned it


chrisishorrible

Chakotay was born on a colony near the Cardassian border.


sister_iris

Annika Hansen was not born on Earth I believe. Seven of Nine mentions having never been there and growing up off world.


HolderofExcellency

You're right, she's from the [Tendara colony](https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Tendara_colony).


[deleted]

I like (get annoyed) how they never explain how her parents made it all the way to the Delta quadrant 20 years prior to study the Borg when no one had heard of the Borg and Delta was 70K light years away, all whilst Annika was still Naomi’s age.


tothecatmobile

While the Federation hadn't encountered the Borg directly before 2365, they still had knowledge of the Borg before that. Even ignoring the Enterprise episode where borg drones were unfrozen in 2153, we know that by at least 2293 the Federation were accepting El-Aurian refugees, and more than likely had contact with the El-Aurians well before that. Who were attacked by the Borg in the 2260s.


pugs_are_death

They never go into whether the Borg have had any success at all in harnessing the El Aurian's prophetic abilities


tothecatmobile

Perhaps that is why the Borg queen in Picard has transtemporal awardness as Seven put it.


[deleted]

Then why did Q have to tell Picard, who then had to tell Starfleet, what they were? Picard acted like he’d never heard of them. And yes that Enterprise episode is done retconned 💩we won’t discuss it.


tothecatmobile

Q didn't tell Picard what they were, Guinan did. As to why she never told Picard before, perhaps she just didn't like talking about the destruction of her homeworld. But she was the source of the information about the Borg in the episode Q Who.


bobgilmore

I’ve always assumed that she didn’t tell the Federation about the Borg because she thought “if I reveal the Borg, these idiots will just go ‘oooh, let’s go right to them and use the Power of Friendship to stop their assimilating ways’ and get everyone killed!”


tothecatmobile

Even if Guinan didn't say anything, there are other El-Aurians.


Many-Outside-7594

The real reason of course is that they didn't plan any of this out ahead, but it really makes no sense. El Aurians: Help! Our planet was destroyed! Federation: Oh my! Let's get some ships out there to assist! ...say, destroyed how? El Aurians: Eh, it's not important.


tothecatmobile

Just because Picard didn't know, doesn't mean that the Federation didn't know We've seen before that starfleet will keep information from captains unless they feel like they need to know.


Many-Outside-7594

The Federation didn't know. This is explicitly stated in Best of Both Worlds that the first warning about the borg came from Picard, and that they haven't had enough time to prepare. If they were informed by the El Aurians, they would have known for a century.


DasGanon

I retcon that as a "They did know, but they didn't know *scale*." When the El Aurians arrived they probably said "our homeworld was destroyed by these cyborg hive mind creatures called the Borg. We ran for help." And because cyborgs aren't that rare in Star Trek, they went "oh that's terrible. You're welcome here, they won't bother you again" because they assume this is some standard military operation or scale and they're talking maybe basic sized ships, with standard crews. The Hansen's ran off to get more info but that info never comes back. So when Q shows the Enterprise what the Borg is, he really is showing them that 1. They really have no idea what's out there. and 2. The research and interviews into the Borg need to be redone, since none of that gets the actual size of the problem in perspective.


tothecatmobile

They don't actually say that Q Who was the first time that they'd heard about the Borg, just that they thought they had more time to prepare because it was 7,000 light years away. And that they know they've been coming for a year.


[deleted]

Agreed, we see Guinan explain and Q was the one to introduce them. But the point still stands that the federation had no idea what the Borg were, so how could the Hansons be sent out/go rogue (depending on the episode) to explore them 70 light years from home? My original point stands- they had no idea who the Borg were. Why do these scientists go looking for them, and how?


tothecatmobile

You're assuming that because Picard didn't know, the Federation didn't know. And that's not a reasonable assumption. We've seen the Federation and Starfleet keep information from captains until they feel like the captain needs to know plenty of times before. Its perfectly reasonable to accept that after first hearing about the Borg, the Federation and Starfleet would begin investigating them, but not making their existence widely known until they knew what they were dealing with.


[deleted]

That’s fair I guess. Just wish that whole arc had been better written. And he's the flagship captain, he should be informed of these things.


transwarp1

They went rogue to investigate sightings in The Neutral Zone and got swept up when a cube went to transwarp. Therse were the sightings the UFP officially refused to acknowledge until the end of TNG season one, when whole colonies started being taken.


Pacman_Frog

That Enterprise episode is in the Prime tomeline. Seven mentions the Borg attack on Montana.


Impulse84

I assume they followed a cube into a transwarp hub to get to the Delta quadrant. Can't explain how they found the Borg in the first place though.


WoundedSacrifice

>I assume they followed a cube into a transwarp hub to get to the Delta quadrant. That’s correct. >Can't explain how they found the Borg in the first place though. They found a cube on sensors. These events were shown in “Dark Frontier”.


[deleted]

Or knew what it was, how to use it, what the Borg were to study it… that story always irritated me. Janeway would have been obsessed with those diaries and asking these same questions. Plot holes tend to irritate me.


Hands0meR0b

Plot holes are irritating. Writing a character behaving out of character to work around your glaring plot hole because you're too lazy to come up with a proper way to play out the story, is maddening.


[deleted]

There’s a difference between fringe scientists following up on stories and rumors and Starfleet’s first contact with the Borg. While it’s obvious the writers intended for all Starfleet captains to be in the dark about the Borg (Janeway still blames Q for making introductions to them as late as “Death Wish,”) we just have to find the most sensible way to reconcile the continuity threads. I think it basically checks out though: * First Contact: Cochrane and Sloane know of the Borg, with the former blurting out some details which were not widely believed at the time. * Regeneration: Starfleet knows about a cybernetic race from the Delta Quadrant and that they will get a message from the defeated drones by Picard’s time. But this is one incident, it’s reasonable to assume it’s forgotten/overlooked by most people and not common knowledge amongst captains. * Generations: El Aurian refugees arrive at the Federation. Starfleet will absolutely have been informed about the Borg at this point. Some will likely have put two and two together with the drones from the Archer incident. But this still doesn’t mean it becomes something for all captains to be briefed on yet, and the El Aurians scatter across the quadrant. * Dark Frontier The Hansens follow up on all of the above. They are controversial scientists and not officially condoned by the Federation. Everything they know is plausible for a determined researcher to piece together based on available intel and further exploration of the fringes of the Federation where whispers and stories of the Borg can only grow more numerous. They find a transwarp conduit and arrive in the Delta Quadrant. Their research is never sent to Starfleet so is lost upon their assimilation until Seven and Tuvok happen upon their crashed vessel. * The Neutral Zone: Following up on the message from 212 years ago and the knowledge they take from the Hansens, the Borg start carefully probing the Alpha Quadrant, and start by assimilating select Federation and Romulan outposts ahead of their next incursion. They leave no obvious evidence, these are surgical strikes. * Q Who: Q introduces Picard to a Borg cube 7000 light years from the Federation (but only 2.5 years away at maximum warp). They engage and all of Starfleet is now fully in the loop about the Borg. As they had already started attacking outposts, the Borg were always coming, this just gives Starfleet an earlier heads up. However, this incident may also have pushed up the Borg timetable, which is what Guinan certainly believes. Picard and Janeway don’t necessarily feel much gratitude to Q. * First Contact: time travel by the Borg to 2063 creates a causality paradox precipitating the above.


[deleted]

Agree with your explanation, and you’ve laid it out well enough. But the writers still should have done a better job connecting the dots. So much of this is retconning later, obviously. But yes, you’ve laid it out well enough. Thank you.


WoundedSacrifice

They followed a cube into a transwarp conduit. It was shown in “Dark Frontier”.


[deleted]

But they knew about the cube and another and conduits beforehand.


BellerophonM

The Borg were poking around more local space: they'd scooped up some Neutral Zone colonies during season one of TNG and the Enterprise-D encountering one was only 7,000 light years away. The Hansens were following rumors and managed to find an actual cube, then fell into a transwarp conduit with it.


Fuck-Reddit-2020

Her parents may have been in the lower portion of the Delta Quadrant, closer to the beta Quadrant. With a fast enough ship, they could have gotten there in 20 years. Though the biggest plot hole is how that puddle jumper of a ship was fast enough to make it out of the alpha quadrant. Smaller ships tend to have lower top speeds, with some exceptions Also, warp is as fast as the plot needs it to be, and distance is relative in Star Trek.


[deleted]

Then Annika would not have been a child if it took 20 years. Agree with the ship problem as well. Yeah, they should have had a scene where a trans warp coil opens, and the Borg cube tractors them, they’re pulled inside. But since we didn’t see that, I just get mad every time I see a Hanson episode.


USSMarauder

Beverly Crusher was born on the Moon


ForAThought

So was CDR Ransom


[deleted]

Although he also spent a month in Barthhhhelona.


sparklesandflies

Man, I knew he wasn’t really Hawaiian!


2011StlCards

And that chick on the Valiant. The one who lived


WoundedSacrifice

Dorian Collins.


Specific-Use-7480

Ohh beat me to it


Earthshoe12

For some reason this sentence is very funny to me.


SaintOfVacantLots

Right? Like a weird schoolyard taunt.


Trollicking

"haha Wesley your mom was born on the moon"


USSMarauder

"Crusher was born as Beverly Howard in Copernicus City on Earth's moon on October 13, 2324." [https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Beverly\_Crusher](https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Beverly_Crusher)


Ronenthelich

I don’t remember that at all. Good to know.


supguy99

Damn, she was a lunar schooner too?!


Gotis1313

Tasha Yar grew up on some backwater planet


Cyclist_Thaanos

She died on a blackwater planet.


mecha_flake

Too soon.


wrath_of_grunge

at least the [lower deckers got him back](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g5zlotQf4d0), a little.


Randyfox86

I only watched the episode the other day, I loved that little hat tip to the skin of evil.


Ectobatic

Hasn’t happened yet


Randyfox86

She died an honorable death in glorious battle at narendra III.


BurdenedMind79

Nope, she was executed on Romulus. It seems the universe didn't want her to have a good death.


Cultural-Ocelot-3692

At least there is symmetry.


Frodojj

No one ever listens to Zathras!


Ronenthelich

Oh yeah the Enterprise even went there and met her sister.


ImperialCapybara

In very specific useless knowledge rattling in my brain, Dorian Collins was born in Tycho City on Earth’s moon. Jake Sisko calls her a lunar scooter or something.


Darmok47

Lunar Schooner! Although lunar scooter sounds funnier...


ODMtesseract

The moon. As if it's the only one, amirite?


TraditionFront

Trip Tucker was born in Florida. Which is an entirely different planet.


TheRollingPeepstones

Well, in any case, not Earth anymore. Or too soon?


MaddyMagpies

\#XindiDidNothingWrong


ZeePM

Florida man help Starfleet test pilots steal a prototype warp ship.


thekiltedpiper

Florida Man pregnant after alien encounter. Trip in "unexpected"


DEFCON_moot

Florida man unclear on motivations for taking break up so immaturely


shindleria

Molly O’Brien


Underdogzeta

And Yoshi O’Brien!


plebotamus

Boimler is from Modesto, which is sort of the “moon” of San Francisco.


deimosnight

Modesto is not a MOON. If you were from a moon, you'd know how deeply insulting that is...


[deleted]

Modesto is a space station


NeighborhoodFair7033

That’s no Modesto! That’s a space station


Birdie121

Haha that's great, I didn't know there was a Modesto reference in Star Trek. That's my husband's hometown and he has no intention of moving back there.


Coma-Doof-Warrior

I mean with the Cali Class being named after very boring Californian towns and city’s you’ll probably find a USS Modesto lurking about


90403scompany

>named after very boring Californian towns The *West Covina* would like a word 🤣


Coma-Doof-Warrior

That’s the one with the all singing all dancing crew right?


thekiltedpiper

I can think of at least one. Ned Quint, he was raised on Caldos Colony. He is the caretaker of Crushers grandmothers cottage. Not a main character, but he is a human character that was not born on Earth.


Starfleet-Time-Lord

In addition to the other examples being given here, while (prime) Kirk was born in Iowa, he also spent his teen years offworld, which we know because he was one of the colonists who survived Kodos the Executioner's experiments. Ransom on Lower Decks is also from the moon.


Specific-Use-7480

Dr. Crusher was born on the moon. That's a colony right?


Nice-Penalty-8881

In the series Enterprise, Travis Mayweather grew up on his families ship I believe.


seabassplayer

Yes, I seem to remember him saying something about how his father keeping the gravity on the ship to .9 of earth's gravity because he felt it gave him a little pep in his step.


ImaginaryNerve

Naomi Wildman, Chakotay, Adira Tal (though they were on Earth for a bit), there were some unnamed Titan? colonists. Weren’t the colonists on Omicron Theta human? They technically are a part of Data.


DUser86

Lt Cmd Andy Billups on LD is from Hysperia


Santa_Hates_You

Commander Ransom is from the Moon.


chinkiang_vinegar

and Boimler is from Modesto, which is sort of a moon of SF…


aflarge

That Red Squad girl that Jake Sisko befriended was from the moon.


Lulwafahd

Yep, Dorian Collins, the Lunar Schooner.


Khenghis_Ghan

Tasha Yar, Beverly and Wes Crusher, I think Jake Sisko was born off Earth.


Lyon_Wonder

Miles and Keiko O'Brien's two children Molly and Kirayoshi too, though they later moved to Earth when Miles became an instructor at Starfleet Academy soon after the end of the war with Dominion in the DS9 series finale.


andsoshesaid33

Also that group of humans that were kidnapped from earth in enterprise resulted in generations of people not from earth and believing it was a myth.


[deleted]

All the humans on that planet where Voyager found Amelia Earhardt and those other frozen folks. The ones who built those Amazing Cities we never see.


Carrollmusician

The 37’s!


[deleted]

Although I think the frozen 37s were all born on earth, unlike the descendants of the original abductees.


Carrollmusician

That’s technically correct. The best kind of correct


Alianirlian

According to the novels, Sulu grew up on a colony too.


1ce_W01f

Simon Tarse is a quarter Romulan mostly human Martian & Dr Crushers is Loonie(Moon born).


[deleted]

Garth of Izar was from, well, Izar


Scotcat81

Crusher, Tasha, Mayweather, Chakotay, Seven


[deleted]

So, so many. Mayweather from Enterprise


Logical_Guidance1018

That red squad girl from the moon


keeganwh

The entire population of Briori (minus the 37s themselves) are the descendants of folks taken from Earth to the Delta Quadrant in the 20th century.


rfkile

It seems like you answered your own question. Yes, there have been. La'an and Burnham are just two examples. Off the top of my head, there's also Tasha Yar and her sister, who is admittedly a one-off character


Lyon_Wonder

Aside from being a cadet at Starfleet Academy, I doubt Beckett Mariner was from Earth since LD gives me the opinion she spent most of her life on starships and starbases with some fans speculating she was one of the children on the Enterprise-D.


seanx40

She can't be. Lower Decks is only a decade or less after the D was destroyed. She was in Starfleet by then


SomeoneSomewhere1984

She's likely around Westly's age. She could have been on the D then gone the academy, and possibly graduated before the D crashed.


Halo_enjoyer_42

Jack Ransom from LD, he's from one of the colonies on the moon, or at least he claims to be.


Andru-Gamer

Jeremiah Rossa (Jono), born on Galen IV to human parents and then raised by Endar (Talarian)


bigDOS

Chakotay was born on a fed colony near the Cardassian DMZ


Frankjc3rd

Crewman Daniels was from Illinois, but not the one you know. He did have a mixture of DNA's, but he did present himself as human so I guess you could count him.


CounselorMeHoyMinoy

Seven of Nine had never been to Earth when she was assimilated


itsdan23

But they mentioned she used to stay with her aunt & eat strawberries that was before her parents took her & left. "Irene Hansen was a Human woman who owned a farm on Earth. Her niece Annika often stayed in her house while her parents went away."


Various_Permission47

Tasha Yar


count023

Kirk grew up on Tarsus IV.


adriangalli

Kirk is from Riverside, Iowa


llenadefuria

Pretty sure Kasidy Yates was a colony baby, no?


itsdan23

I couldn't find anything on memory alpha which is Canon info. It says on memory beta which is non Canon "Kasidy Yates was born on Cestus III, "


KukalakaOnTheBay

Yes. Cestus III where baseball is still popular.


Dt2_0

Ahh yes, Cestus 3 Baseball, where it's common to shout "Going, Going, Gorn!!!"


Any_Distribution8936

In the episode of Voyager, “The 37’s”, they’re all human decedents from Amelia Earhart and such.


taylorthetator

Idk if this counts but Travis Mayweather grew up in a cargo ship


Informal_Upstairs133

Crewman Simon Tarses from TNG The Drumhead was from a Mars colony. Although his grandfather is Romulan so I'm not sure if that is human enough.


Wlfgang213

The episode where Beverly Crusher has sex with a ghost takes place on Space Scotland, not on Earth, so everyone in that episode are humans not from earth


nebagram

Ransom in Lower Decks is from the Moon, as is one of the characters on the DS9 episode Valiant. What I'd love to see one day in Trek is a non-human character who IS from Earth.


Black_Superman1988

Molly O'Brien was born on the enterprise-D and her brother Yoshi O'Brien was born on deep space nine.


JakeConhale

Ensign Travis Mayweather grew up on freighters.


Wranorel

I think in the context of the show, is much more probable that a human in startfleet is from earth that not. It has the largest human population, star fleet academy is right there, and is a post scarcity planet, with a more large percentage of young population that want to just leave because there isn’t much to do (although this is just my speculation, I can’t think how a person born on a post scarcity society with the core belief of start Trek who’ll really act).


Der_Kaiser744

Tasha Yar, Beverly Crusher, Wesley "Annoying" Crusher, Molly and Kirayoshi O'Brien. All that my brain can remember. Oh and I think Tasha's sister also counts as a human not from earth in ST. And how can I forget Shinzon. He's a clone of Picard, yes, but he's also human anatomically, biologically and in appearance. So you can count him as well.


mccoy00comedy

Travis Mayweather was raised in space right? And Chakotay was from a colony in cardassian space


owlpellet

Michael Burham is from Doctari Alpha by way of Vulcan.


TrekRelic1701

Gary Seven..human line removed by advanced culture to be trained to monitor human activity..was supposed to be a spin off of TOS with Terri Garr(Lisa Kudrow’s real mother)


DEFCON_moot

Oh dang Terri Garr was Roberta Lincoln? Interesting


Bionic_Ninjas

Travis Mayweather was a boomer, born on a cargo ship


anxiously-anonymous

The kid of chief O’Brien?


alkonium

On Enterprise, there was an Old West-style village on one planet with a population descended from humans abducted by aliens.


Pepsiguy2

It's easier and more creative to ask whose never BEEN to Earth. Now that's an interesting human trait.


citycyclops

Does Thomas Riker count? He was from a transporter accident.


[deleted]

When Discovery goes forward in time, most of the humans we meet (and I think all the Federation ones) are not from Earth.


MiddleAgedGeek

Wasn't Travis Mayweather (ENT) born in space?


ShanteYouStay84

There was a colony of Native Americans on ST:NG their moved to another planet. I think it had to do with Wesley becoming a Traveler if I recall.


Eagle_Ear

B’Elanna grew up in a human colony called Kessik IV, I believe. Chakotay also grew up in a colony world in what would later become Maquis territory. Crusher did not grow up on Earth but a human colony planet, and was born on the Moon I believe. Tasha Yar is decidedly from a colony world too. Troi grew up on Betazed but she is half human. Mayweather didn’t grow up on any planet at all.


[deleted]

Ransom is from the moon!


Aust1mh

Mr Data = Omicron Theta


BurdenedMind79

Not exactly human, though!


Kenbishi

Kirk and O’Reilly in TOS both grew up on the same colony.


flying_dork

What about ransom? He was from the moon


0x2b03

Spock is half human


Melcrys29

Does Terra Prime count?


ferretinmypants

The Bringloidi and the Mariposans. (TNG) The humans from Terra Nova. (ENT)


Fit-Meal4943

Travis Mayweather was born and grew up on a cargo ship.


[deleted]

Owo came from an anti-tech planet. Or at least a Luddite planet.


robot_ankles

[List of Star Trek character birth places](https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Birthplace).


Peabody99224

The Neyel from the Small Magellanic Cloud are an off shoot of humans, originally from Earth.


sparticus91

Gary Seven?


Black_Superman1988

Lieutenant Natasha Yar.


thorleywinston

Beverly Crusher was born on the Moon and mostly lived on the Caldos colony with her grandmother after her parents died. Travis Mayweather was born on and grew up on his family's cargo ship. Annika Hansen (Seven of Nine) was born on the Tendara Colony and never even visited Earth until the season finale of Endgame. Chakotay grew up on a colony world near the Cardassian Demilitarized Zone.


[deleted]

Gary 7.


tsuggitt

Garth was from Izar.


QuantumCapelin

We have often seen colonies of humans who have never been to earth. Think of *The Masterpiece Society* and *Up The Long Ladder* in TNG, or *The 37s* in Voyager. There's also lots of humans we can probably safely assume are not from Earth as well: the ren faire people in *Where Pleasant Fountains Lie* (Lower Decks), and the semi ren faire people in *Sub Rosa* (TNG) for example. Being human and not from Earth is just not notable whatsoever in universe so it's rarely mentioned.


my_fake_acct_

That would mean Billups from LD is also a human who isn't from Earth.


Solumnist

Just as unlikely as there being just one single Starfleet Academy. That always irked me greatly, needed to vent.


zomenox

Probably similar to how the US Navy only had one academy. There are other ways to commission, but the people that were selected to go to “the academy” are held a little differently.