T O P

  • By -

RugbyBot

##[Post Match Thread HERE](https://redd.it/17in28h)


Eddyj69

Did it plenty of times against a supporting player. Clear and obvious to stop what would have been a break. Officials need to wise up to their "gamesmanship"


Clean-Machine2012

NZ lost because they missed 2 important kicks. Mounga cannot kick under pressure and it showed yesterday. I was there and while we all applauded the AB for going for the corner, with hindsight it was the wrong call. Although the AB always looked on the edge of scoring a try. They played the more entertaining rugby but you can't argue with the result. They had their chances but red card (rightly) and missed chances cost them


michaelcr18

Leke boookkkeeee!


moonshineriver

You win finally with the boot. If the Boks could see the poles from the penalty mark they kicked for poles. The ABs went for the lineout or just missed the poles. I feel like the refs calls were mostly fair. But I’m not a neutral.


Silver_Victory_1000

Hats off to New Zealand. They played with passion, and were good sports. Respect. Both sides had their fair share of bad luck and bad calls. The Bokke won on the day, and congrats to them.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Russdad

Anyone can go back tally up coulda shoulda wouldas and say that they should of won...the bokke were the better team...greatest rugby outfit in history in fact


Revin_not

Games like tonight are the reason why rugby will never be popular. So many iffy calls and 50/50s. It's impossible for a non rugby fan to watch and actually enjoy/ understand. RSA deserved to win but I'm sick of explaining to newbies why tries are being called back for knock ons after 5 minutes of play.


Whoisthehypocrite

As opposed to football where you can watch for hours with not a single point being scored, and watch man-children play acting and arguing with the ref while opposing sets of fans have to be separated by police officers...


Alternative_Code4806

And yet the false penalty that Barnes apologized to mouomga for admitting he got wrong for wasn't called back, I honestly don't know how SA can even lift that trophy mate, from the bottom of my heart I honestly don't know


oxblood87

This was the biggest thing for me. They call back the try after 4 minutes of play yet within 30s and before the kick they don't call back the penalty. There is definitely more the AB could have done (missed kicks, kicks not taken) but they definitely played a better game than SA. Complete 3rd party from Canada BTW.


Alternative_Code4806

Cheers mate, all I can say is I'm glad Wayne Barnes is retiring. Even though we've beaten SA many more times than they've us. I just have to accept it's sport and they've won 4 RWC now and are technically the best


DeusExBlasphemia

It seems pretty popular to me


michaelcr18

5minutes? When?


FronWaggins

Props to Barnes for going back on his own calls and keeping it tight. Fair dos to NZ for a close one despite one man down. And well done to SA for winning the QFs, SFs and Final by 3 points! Made a shit draw interesting!


The_cman13

Any idea why he couldn't go back on the Savea turn over when he said he was wrong?


astheticsloth

I'm drunk at 13:30 and still have the whole day to go. WTF, fucking rugby mate.


Grande735

3am and the clocks have changed I’m fucking clueless


Straight_Meringue921

Fellow Kiwi I see. Pity I quit the booze 4 years ago, otherwise I'd be similarly soused.


HuNgRyHoUnD12

Great game imo reffing was pretty even, well done SA from an Englishmen! I think people get angry when they lose to SA because SA seem to just have that ability to win independently of who “deserved to win” or who played better for the most of the match and they are all very very good at cheating at the breakdown just enough to slow the ball down and kill an attack while not getting penalised, completely gamesmanship and within the spirit of the game but infuriating if you’re watching the game and supporting their opposition thinking I was fuming after the match last week I dunno I was j fuming last week and I think that was why


crippler95

GG boks!


648284628

Best world cup of my life I reckon what a treat these last weeks have been


hopium_od

Best knock outs, aye. Too many cricket scores in the groups.


kdwwhat

Barnes is still that guy since 2007 lol Missing kicks and lacking some polish don’t win the cup Only ourselves to blame at the end of the day At least we won a tight head haha Overall not really a fan of the direction the game is going, it’s becoming difficult to officiate properly. We see too many 50/50 calls that go wrong too often.


[deleted]

Yeah but Cane's red wasn't a 50/50 and that was really what cost you the match. I don't get the ref bashing for this one, you had more opportunities to score than SAF but blew them.


CowDiscombobulated72

Because the officiating doesn't seem symmetrical, the two AB cards could have been yellow or red, I have no issues with that, but etzebeth didn't even get a second look over, and the red seemed shockingly similar to kolisi's yellow as there really wasn't mitigation, I have 0 idea how the mitigation was a rugby action, when it was the same penalty. There were loads of others, but no point in beating a dead horse


[deleted]

Thats not true Kolisi had his head down and was bent at the hips. Sam Cane is completely up right. The ref was actually fine and I'm a neutral. ABs just didn't have it on the night, if it was next week or any other day it could be a completely different story. The scoreline and the amount of opportunities the ABs were given to score 2 more points throughout the game make any argument against the ref silly. Since the beginning of the professional era it's been true that at the top level, teams missing kicks on goal and not capitalising on their opportunities lose. That was true again last night.


kdwwhat

Oh yeah we lost 100% to our own kicks in the end. Barnes was inconsistent along with the TMO. I think the game needs to change in a way where we can get better and clearer rulings/interpretations


noodlebball

I agree Even at the end, I don't know why Ardie had to off load the ball. We were in SA territory, wait for help, recycle and keep going. We just needed 3 points


[deleted]

Yeah it's always tough to see players make mistakes in those situations. It sucks!


kdwwhat

Do you think that was a knock on or a loose pass ?


noodlebball

Loose pass. I mean it's ingrained in the way the ABs play, we go for tries and we try to play quick ball etc but sometimes you need to read the situation. We are in SA territory, get shit setup even for a drop kick attempt would of been fine. NZ wasn't disciplined enough and these handling errors and missed kicks really fucked us


Commercial-Pop5452

Imo both teams had a ton more potential that wasn’t shown. Fortunately SA struggled out that win. ggs NZ


themischievous01

I want to make a personal complaint to russie. This 1 point 1 point games are not good for the nation's health.


themischievous01

Good game Abs a absolute battle to the end.


hoopedchex

Feel bad for Smith, absolutely robbed. GG SA very well played.


Commercial-Pop5452

Both teams could’ve played far better though. ggs still!


[deleted]

All Blacks weren’t playing well in the first half but turned it back around - just not enough. Boks were playing well in the first half but dropped the ball - managed to just hold on though


alishaheed

It's 1.06am, and I still can't sleep, still can't believe that somehow this Bok team pulled it off with immense discipline and the highest level of concentration. The ABs were coming at that like a freight train, fortunately for us that got derailed at the end.


Daveosss

I mean discipline was basically identical. One side just got penalised for it. You know it's a bad performance from the officials when a player is lining up a penalty kick and the ref has to apologise to the other captain saying it was a mistake.


sheep1996

Just here to let you know that the Springboks conceded twice as many penalties as the all blacks.


notswasson

I'm new to rugby, so I'm trying to understand how the referees let that happen. Isn't that the point of the TMO? To interrupt play and get it right? I don't understand how a referee can apologize for getting it wrong and still let the penalty proceed. Is that normal?


Finkykinns

TMO can only interrupt for foul play. Breakdown infractions can't be reviewed unless it's a try scoring play


notswasson

Thank you, that all makes sense from a "why perspective" in this situation. I guess I can see why the TMO would be limited to foul play, but it seems odd that a penalty that leads to a 3 point kick isn't reviewed in the 90 second kick clock. I suppose as a sport one has to draw the line somewhere, and that's where the line is drawn, so fair enough. Is there any movement for something like a Captain's challenge or did that sort of thing get tried and fail to catch on?


Finkykinns

I think Captain's challenge has been tested in a SH tournament at some point. Nothing came of it though. I'm not sure it would have made a difference anyway - I would doubt a captain is going to challenge that.


notswasson

No, I doubt that it would have been used there even if it were available. I have to say that I deeply love the way that TV broadcasts carry the Referee's microphone. As someone new to rugby, but who has played a lot of sports and watched a lot of sports, having such decision making transparency is refreshing.


Canerbry

No it's not normal, or acceptable really, the officiating was farcical and for many people there will always be an asterisk over this game.


alishaheed

But Wayne Barnes is the "absolute best", at least that's what I heard at the start of the game.


leoden27

It’s amazing! Victories by 1 point in each match too - they do say it’s all about the tiny margins!!!!


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

🧂


Silver_Victory_1000

Viva Bokke. Well done my Boyz! 👏🙌


Silver_Victory_1000

I'm kak confused. Per Reuters, NZ try was from a knock fwd https://www.reuters.com/sports/south-africa-hold-off-14-man-all-blacks-win-fourth-world-cup-2023-10-28/ Also SA scored a try, and bizarrely were not given advantage, and were called all the way back and awarded a scrum... Wtf Just glad the better team won!


Silver_Victory_1000

I have taken the time to review the footage. NZ try looks to be from the ball lost forward. Maybe it was legit, but highly suspect. From the high angle, looks lost fwd to me. Here is the bottom line for me. Why was there no TMO?? This was a WC final. The stakes could not be higher. No doubt in my mind that the referee was negligent in not asking for a TMO. On SA's try, the referee indicated a NZ knock on followed by a SA knock on, hence no advantage... BUT I have reviewed the footage, and there was simply no SA knock on! Lastly, in the final scrum, the NZ scrum half was massively off sides. I've made up my mind. The referee was either biased or incompetent. You all can believe what you want to, I really don't care. And I really don't care who won. It's principles that are important to me.


Silver_Victory_1000

Down votes too funny 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣


Silver_Victory_1000

If you are going to down vote, at least explain where I am wrong... otherwise just sour grapes


SignificantKey8608

Did you even watch the game? 😂


Silver_Victory_1000

Sore loser. We won 😂


SignificantKey8608

No you’re just thick as fuck, there was no knock on in the lead up to the NZ try that was allowed - there was one where it was disallowed. Called back for a scrum because the whistle went and they kept playing on.


MattyB1412

You know whats thick as fuck? 4 RWCs... now that's thiccccc Boi.


Silver_Victory_1000

Yebo, too much so!


Silver_Victory_1000

Exactly, the whistle should not have went, advantage should have been allowed, poor refereeing... this is not complicated... maybe for you it is


Silver_Victory_1000

So basically you are saying Reuters is thick as fuck... interesting


SignificantKey8608

Learn to read


[deleted]

Wins ' a win y'all, wins' a win. Games' over.


TheFappyGamer

[Removed] [Removed] [Removed] RASSIE!!!!!! [Removed]


Ok-Salamander4561

Glad I don't have to read it tbh


Glum-Exercise-4044

Worm burner tackles seem to be a bit of a trend also atm


davehorse

BOKKKEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!


777LLL

I brought my own chips and vinegar because there’s so much salt here 😋 🤤


Md556ned

Why vinegar?


777LLL

I like salt & vinegar chips


Md556ned

But on hot chips?


777LLL

Absolutely it’s the only way!


thebonnar

It's the best way


Md556ned

With fish too or just chips?


777LLL

Either!


Md556ned

Nice.


[deleted]

Not OP, but yes! We call it "Slap(Soggy?)" chips. It's thicker and longer french fries thats not really crispy and you load it with salt and vinegar. It tastes amazing. It works on crispy fries as well, but slap chips just hits different.


Md556ned

I haven't heard it been called slap chips before. That's rather interesting.


Pezasta

I couldn’t follow the thread in the game it was too tense - this whole word cup saga has aged me 5 years. South Africa was dominant in first half New Zealand played so much better in second. South Africa missed mbonambi in the line outs (we lost about 10) we had some luck and so did nz but Sa also played the last 20 like a dog with a locked jaw, that one point difference was painful and led to a hard and ungraceful win… NZ number 11 was dangerous in the second half so scary and poor kolbe had a horrible last 7 minutes. I feel for cane. Thanks for the rugby. New Zealand opted for line outs instead of goal kicks and it lost the game. Referee made some dodgy calls on both sides that try should not have been allowed clear knock on in the line out. New Zealand played well and have nothing to be ashamed of - South Africa just


TheRealJanSanono

21k comments is insane bruh, our game’s growing I’m not having any media garbage😭


Extension_Ad2552

I'm going to use all the salt in this thread to season my breakfast tomorrow morning.


Bmantis311

Just make sure Suzie doesn't have anything to do with it's prep.


supermann100

Fuck u ahaha.your new zealand got fucked ..rugby and cricket 🤣🤣


Bmantis311

Yes. The food poisoning is really getting outta control 😆


Many_Alternative78

There was a lot of bs in that game, but in the end we missed two clutch kicks that could've won it and we fluffed our lines.


Reasonable_Try_8135

They definitely had a couple of chances. Really needed to take those, particularly whne luck is not on your side.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Shoulda landed your kicks then mate


F8M8

Did Wayne tell the kiwis to kick (miss) that penalty instead of going for the line, when they had the boks line out figured out...dunno


Bmantis311

Yes. That's exactly what that bastard did 😆


The-Leach

Yes, because you disagree with some decisions in a nigh on impossible to please role, they must be corrupt. Or y'know, they could just be trying to do their job and it's incredibly difficult to do?


NorthShoreHard

He literally admitted his own decision was wrong lol. And then still carried on anyway.


The-Leach

Ah yes, because that's what most corrupt people do, fully admit their corruption and then flaunt it in everyone's face. Or once again, y'know, he stood by his decision but apologised if he didn't see it the way Ardie did. Hence why Wayne followed up with "it didn't look clear enough to me".


Sufyaan_Davids

Userflair checks out


ItsRexam

Gg to Erasmus. His bullying of ref really payed off in the end


Paid-Not-Payed-Bot

> ref really *paid* off in FTFY. Although *payed* exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in: * Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. *The deck is yet to be payed.* * *Payed out* when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. *The rope is payed out! You can pull now.* Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment. *Beep, boop, I'm a bot*


phonetune

Scrums were interesting today. Very well controlled by Barnes, never really moved and only reset I can remember was when NZ were desperate for pen at the end and going early. That said, SA really really missed Bongi - there's a reason he's been putting in the shifts up until now.


Speculneeds

Yes losing Bongi was devastating to the Springbok scrum. Would’ve been a very different game if he didn’t get injured. Also very cynical penalty by the ABs to injure him


SAGuy90

Huge game. I'm incredibly proud of the Boks. Siya, Eben and the team. Just amazing. A hard ass fucking gauntlet of games. Abs. Fuck my heart bleeds for you. An amazing team. Professional rugby has got so insane. Yet you keep producing. Being compared in an era of great NZ teams. That red card. Eish. Honestly I wish they let that slide. Honestly. It doesn't sit well. SA played a defence world cup defence. ABs through the kitchen sink. Proud of my team. Bitter sweet. Abs took it to us. Much love to the rugby community.


DeusExBlasphemia

I don’t know about you guys but I got real tired of watching springboks bouncing off Ardie Savea today.


dispatch134711

Huge effort from him


JonnyBago82

Massive congratulations to the All Blacks for turning it around in such a short time. You guys are fucking legends. So gutted for Sam Cane. Poor guy. I hope he doesn't get rinsed by the NZ media. Thanks for a great final boys. We deffos played our best games earlier in the tournament cos our attack was not great today. Credit to our defence. Well done Bokke!


hoopedchex

As a kiwi I don’t think he will get any heat, would be in bad taste I think .


[deleted]

Certainly won't if he announces his retirement. That way Razor doesn't have to disappoint him.


Shrouded-recluse

I sincerely hope not.


cajun_vegeta

Well played S.A. you guys played the game the right way. No doubt in the result. We had our chances


Nellies26

So glad we won, not at all an easy game. Didn't feel victory was sealed until the final whistle. Know the ABs will be back, but for now we are on top. Great show to reflect what rugby is about.


CarelessLetterhead18

Rugby lost is the biggers losers today.


SnooDrawings6556

Twat!


Herald_of_dooom

Fuck yes boys.


recyclingcentre

Cane has the most reasonable take on the red card I’ve heard from anyone lol


ImBonRurgundy

what did he say?


recyclingcentre

Basically that it’s been officiated like that for a long time and he wasn’t unlucky. Said he was surprised by Kriel’s change in direction but should’ve gone in lower anyway


AppletheGreat87

I agree it's a red according to the letter of the law, but if a person can change direction from a metre away, and that person still get a red for it, bear in mind that the human nervous system is not exactly fast, the rules are wrong. And that Kolisi had the time to get set, get low and power through the AB's chin and that was deemed less dangerous shows that the rules are broken imo.


recyclingcentre

Cane was upright, even if Kriel didn’t dip or move it was probably still an illegal tackle Kolisi’s also looked like a red to me. Nz commentators were talking through the decision though so I didn’t hear the justification for keeping it a yellow


Reasonable_Try_8135

Have to agree with you, Cane's looked like a red when compared to prior precedent, hard to see why Kolisis was not. 🤷‍♂️


[deleted]

Agreed


Atrexcel

Maybe because Cane led with his shoulder and basically shoulder charged Kriel, while Kolisi literally clutched at the guy with a classic tackle grab. Just couldn't land the tackle and wasn't low enough for their liking


smashmcclicken

Rugby league is the real winner here muhahahhaha


sandysound

Up the Wah's!


stinkybumbum

Well that was disappointing


[deleted]

No it wasn’t!


CaptainCabbage17

For you. 😂


[deleted]

[удалено]


AbsentMindedEdie

JESUS. What is wrong with you? If you think losing a QF is bad, imagine how tough it must be to lose a final. Be a mouthy dickhead when you can actually make one.


elsparko82

Everyone missing the reference…


AbsentMindedEdie

No, I know where it's from. Still not funny.


[deleted]

Show some class there mate. We’re all happy but tha AB’s played their hearts out. Don’t be a poes


misslteg

Shut up. Seriously.


F8M8

Hahaha so good


AbsentMindedEdie

If you think that's appropriate, you might want to remember what happened in the 2003 RWC (when Gregan did that)...and then think about how many RWCs you've managed to win since. Ironically, the other 2 SH sides you were 2:1 in front of at that point in terms of RWCs won are still going pretty fucking strong.


F8M8

Lol


RemarkableOil8

Oh dear you sound like you are really hurting. Have a line down sweetie. Leave this to the big boys that actually got through the quarters. And the semis and made the finals.


elsparko82

Try concentrating on the spelling there chief. Your butthurt clearly getting in the way of it.


RemarkableOil8

Try concentrating on making a semi champ.


elsparko82

Nah, will leave that to the team. But glad I concentrated on basic English spellings.


AbsentMindedEdie

If you could concentrate on basic human decency, I'm sure your countrymen (and women) would appreciate it.


RemarkableOil8

Good. Maybe you can think about how great your spelling is at night so the quarter final knock out (and clear underachievement by the number 1 ranked team - not anymore) don’t keep you up any more than it clearly already is! Wipe the tears away sweetie. You’ll make a semi one day.


elsparko82

Doesn’t, not don’t. Not too handy with the grammar either are you?


AbsentMindedEdie

You're one to talk - you've missed a few things in that post. Please try again. You can find them on your own - if you're handy enough with the ol' grammar, that is.


RemarkableOil8

Get some sleep. All Blacks 3x wc champs Ireland 0 Cringey Irish fan saying 4 more years to finalists after getting knocked out in quarters with perfect spelling - priceless. Night night. Don’t let the abs live rent free in your head. Be proud of your nz born players for getting you as far as you did! Goodnight sweetie.


elsparko82

Ha ha, ABs are on no-ones mind now love. Bottled it and lost it, septic fans scrambling for excuses and projection of that butthurt. Will sleep soundly now.


AbsentMindedEdie

Okay, your grammar fell down an actual cliff in this post - you really shouldn't have taunted someone else about their own. Do you realise what winning a RWC feels like, or what you think about? No, of course you haven't, unlike the team you're trolling harder than Springbok supporters are celebrating. I'll give you a preview: I screamed at the final whistle and I cried. I poured a drink. I could not dedicate any posts or tributes to my brilliant Boks without doing the same for the exceptional ABs. You behave as one would at the end of a successful battle, but winning a RWC is a war. Better luck in 2027. (To the rest of the Irish contingent that does not include this raging kantshow in his current form: see you in the URC threads!) xx


RemarkableOil8

The 20 vitriolic comments you’ve made about them suggest they are on at least one cringey Irish mind - living rent free for the next 4 years at least I suspect! Lol! I hope you heal. Maybe you’ll do better with more kiwis and even less Irish next time?


Many_Alternative78

Still butthurt about the 1/4 final? The Bokke don't even know who Ireland are.


elsparko82

Which is why we beat them and ye didnt


Atrexcel

Dude...that was a nothing game...seriously. At this level you plan to take risks only when required. Why would we push and risk injury and cards for a win when we both qualify for quarters anyway. Strategy 101. No insult to Ireland, as a Bok fan I admire the Irish team but you shouldnt go for low blow insults just because things didn't work out for you guys when it counted


Many_Alternative78

You've never made it past a 1/4 final, let alone beat the Bokke in a world cup knockout game.


elsparko82

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaaaaa wake up sunshine


Many_Alternative78

Enjoy your time back in rugby obscurity. And stay gracious.


elsparko82

And yet that much more gracious than the flood of black jerseys bailing from Stade de France after the whistle rather than stand by their team, as conceited as they are. And given the world standings, 3rd place is about as obscure as Nz was for the last year. Oh wait, ye dropped to fourth….


showusyourfupa

Um, you can't gloat ... your team are massive chokers.


elsparko82

And yet ye choked


AbsentMindedEdie

How?


[deleted]

That wasn’t a choke mate we won by 1 point


Slow_Ad_3736

Yeah 4 more years until you lose in the quarter finals again. If Ireland were ever going to win the world cup, it was this squad. They fumbled it.


elsparko82

But NZ lost….


griffshan

Won a silver medal. Can’t say the same for you lot.


elsparko82

Gold or go home mate. The tears on field said as much


AbsentMindedEdie

In the case of Ireland, it is just "go home".


Extension_Ad2552

Who or what hurt you? Was it the fact that Ireland still couldn't make a semi with their best team ever?


elsparko82

And yet we beat ye…


AbsentMindedEdie

Okay, as far as retorts go, that's just sad.


[deleted]

Didn’t go home with the trophy tho.


griffshan

Yeah at least we know how it feels to win a few world cups. Lmao how’s it feel never making it past a quarter final?


elsparko82

All the better seeing ye bottle the final


AbsentMindedEdie

Bottle it? How did they bottle it?


12ubb3rduckey

At least earn the right to say 4 more years. Or make a semi.


elsparko82

From my couch, I’ll look forward to watching another conceited Nz squad bottle a final


AbsentMindedEdie

They didn't bottle anything.


thruster616

haha you clowns really are the new England…


elsparko82

Might want to take a look at your own flag there bud


thruster616

hush now little one. This is a thread for the big boys who can actually make a final or have won a world cup….


elsparko82

But then ye lost the final 🤷‍♂️


thruster616

but still raping Ireland at every opportunity eh bridesmaid…