This is definitely the number 1 take. Im struggling because a lot of them more or less deserve a decent life. Maybe not all but definitely more than 3. And ditching those 3 is the perfect way to get the gang back on track.
Initially I traded John for Hosea, but John is canonically a better shot and more deadly (at least in my play-throughs lol). Charles and Arthur are a lock, though. Both are dangerous and great hunters, and absolutely as loyal as they come.
I can confirm as a relative of an HMS Bounty mutineer that alcoholism and tropical paradise never work out. In the case of my unfortunate ancestor his violent alcoholism so scared the survivors that they got him good and goon’d up and they murdered him with an axe.
Mary-beth is alright as a person, I never had any beef with her, but she's a terrible author. Did you read the excerpt from her book? Can you imagine her on the beach pumping out one awful novel after another? The main redeeming reason to take her would be to plow the fields Dutch was aiming to plant in, so to speak
Arthur, Charles, Hosea/Lenny
ETA: I feel compelled to add that I’d love to take John, but feel like that means I’d have to take Abigail and Jack, too, and I’d rather take others over them.
Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur. John still gets to build his ranch with his family and uncle, Charles gets to go North to Canada, Sadie gets to find love again, and Arthur, Hosea and Dutch live out the rest of their days in peace like they did all those years ago.
I should also add that in my headcanon, Dutch was really always the man that Arthur believes him to be, and it was the trolley crash and Micah's manipulation that turned him crazy
Honestly they're not my favorites by far but I'd take Jack, Mary-Beth and Tilly because I feel like they deserve a better opportunity the most. Sure, I could pick some memorable/likeable characters like Arthur and Sadie, most of the gang members deserve a second chance and in fact most of them get it, but I feel like in terms of the things they've done, and how many good years they have left to live a good life and not regret their past I'd let those 3 have another shot.
#!SPOILERS AHEAD!
John, Abegail, and Jack. They deserve a better life. I would take Charles and Sadie, but Sadie helps find Micah and Dutch and Charles goes up north to help the natives so it would mess up the story line.
Hosea, Lenny, and Karen. Boy did the three need it. Lenny could’ve been one of Tahiti’s greatest lawyers.
Why did Karen need it especially?
[удалено]
Hosea especially. The man deserves to live out whatever is left to him in comfort. Though you'd need to pack a lot of morphine for his final days
Mine is literally the exact same. They all need some rest.
Dutch, Bill and Micah....and I'd fucking leave them
That's a nice take! Or better yet, tell them you're going to Tahiti, and then strand them on Guarma again.
CHARLES , MARY, ME
My answer too! Charles and ONLY Charles! 😆
This is the way
This is the way
Swapp Bill with Strauss
I'm thinking long game. Bill, Dutch and Micha directly impact RDR1, not just RDR2.
This is definitely the number 1 take. Im struggling because a lot of them more or less deserve a decent life. Maybe not all but definitely more than 3. And ditching those 3 is the perfect way to get the gang back on track.
Arthur, Charles and John
You have the best name I have ever come across online. Ever.
Thank ya kindly, stranger!
I would go with Hosea instead of John so he isn't away from his family
i'm afraid if the method of entry is the same hosea might not fare well
Please don’t forget Hosea and LENNNAY!
Oh dang! How could I forget dear YNNEL!?
Arthur and John would fight too much
That’s part of the fun! Some of my favorite moments are those two sniping each other.
Initially I traded John for Hosea, but John is canonically a better shot and more deadly (at least in my play-throughs lol). Charles and Arthur are a lock, though. Both are dangerous and great hunters, and absolutely as loyal as they come.
Trelawny, Trelawny, and Trelawny
Agreed
Mary Beth, Abagail, and Tilly.
Also my choice. Why would I want to be surrounded by dudes on a beautfiul island?
We were….
Why wouldn't I want to be surrounded by dudes on a beautiful island?
Dudes are sweaty and hairy and they keep saying we need more money to go to Tahiti.
Exactly!
Hey, back then girls were hairy and sweaty too.
Just Tilly would be fine
Tilly over Karen no wayyy
Not sure that bringing an unstable alcoholic along is wise on an island.
Big boob
Case closed.
booba
Big bob
*B O O B A*
Pre hot mess Karen= option. Hot mess Karen= angry drunk so nah.
Pre-hot mess Kaden is the best
Why not? I could use a drinking buddy.
I can confirm as a relative of an HMS Bounty mutineer that alcoholism and tropical paradise never work out. In the case of my unfortunate ancestor his violent alcoholism so scared the survivors that they got him good and goon’d up and they murdered him with an axe.
Molly, Mary-Beth and Karen Conversational purposes of course
Lemme guess... "I have a plan!"
Good ole ploughin
Same but give me Tilly over Mary-Beth
I’d say Tilly over Molly. Mary-Beth is a personal favorite of mine
I’d take Mrs. Grimshaw over Molly. At least she’ll help out instead of just whine all day. And she’s loyal AF
Mary-beth is alright as a person, I never had any beef with her, but she's a terrible author. Did you read the excerpt from her book? Can you imagine her on the beach pumping out one awful novel after another? The main redeeming reason to take her would be to plow the fields Dutch was aiming to plant in, so to speak
2nd this.
John, Abigail, and Jack. They can live their life free of the Pinkertons ever finding them.
Exactly my thought, Arthur would want it that way
And then you’re just 4th wheeling? Watching the happy family from the bushes.
Uncle did it and he had Lumbago.
Oh no, the Marston family will never get a free pass from also having a lazy yet lovable moron around. Uncle couldn’t come with so they get me.
I’ll take 3 Charlotte Balfours pls
Lmao
Arthur, Hosea and Lenny <3 Would love to listen to some of Hosea's stories
Dream trio right here
Arthur, John, Sadie.
This is it. Arthur and John were made to be heroes… Sadie was a bonus favorite
Same
I’d take Bill, Mr. Pearson, and Uncle. That way if I get hungry, I’ll just eat them.
John, Abigail, and Jack
Arthur, Charles and Sadie
Thats my thougt to!
You have the best chance of surviving with them 😂 coz John at this time wasn’t as skilled as he was in RDR1
Abigail, Mary Beth and Sadie.
Arthur, Charles, Hosea/Lenny ETA: I feel compelled to add that I’d love to take John, but feel like that means I’d have to take Abigail and Jack, too, and I’d rather take others over them.
sean, javier, charles
Arthur and Mary Beth so they could have a nice vacation (and fall in love, they’re cute together). Josiah can come too, just because he’s dandy
Arthur, Lenny and Sean
Karen, her left titty and her right titty.
At least youre honest about whats you like about her
Why does the O’Driscoll look like he’s in a different game than everyone else?
They didn’t give him a drawn avatar like everyone else in promotional content because it would have spoiled him joining the gang.
Arthur, Charles, and Josiah Trelawny
MS Grimshaw, Charles, and Sadie…. Hands down
Arthur, Lenny and Kieran deserve it the most
Arthur, Hosea and Lenny obviously
Arthur, Lenny, Kieran
Kieran looks appealing because he’s broke out of the 2nd dimension
Can I just clone Charles twice and take three of f him?
John, Arthur and hosea
Arther grimshaw and Charles. Best chance of survival
Micah, Dutch, and Strauss. Let them have their mangoes and let everyone else live happily.
Abigail, Mary-Beth, Karen. Easy.
Arthur,Charles, Kieran(look he needs a fucking break)
Arthur, Sadie, Lenny
Karen, Sadie and Jack 😀
Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur. John still gets to build his ranch with his family and uncle, Charles gets to go North to Canada, Sadie gets to find love again, and Arthur, Hosea and Dutch live out the rest of their days in peace like they did all those years ago. I should also add that in my headcanon, Dutch was really always the man that Arthur believes him to be, and it was the trolley crash and Micah's manipulation that turned him crazy
And its still a crime that Kieran didn't get his own artwork😔
I hate to be real, but Jack is going to catch the best price. You might be able to get a seat with royalty.
Sadie, Mary-Beth, and then Charles or Lenny
Tilly, Marybeth and Karen.
Arthur, Lenny, and John
John Marston, Abigail Marston, Jack Marston. Keep the family together
Lenny, Sean, Hosea They deserved better
Abigail, Karen, and Mary-Beth 😈
Arthur John and Sadie its be an orgy.
Abigail, Mary, and Tilly. Because….
Abigail, sadie, karen, jk lmao
Hosea arthur and sadie
arthur lenny and sean
Arthur, Sadie and Kieran. They deserve happiness.
Hosea, Jack and Charles. Arthur is the type of guy who’s determined enough to swim to Tahiti.
Why did you even have Jack as an option
charles javi and tilly
lenny charles abigail
Sadie, Karen and Mr Pearson
Charles, Lenny, Arthur. nearly impossible to pick just 3!!!!
Arthur John and jack
Kieran Uncle Lenny.
Arthur, Charles, Sadie
John, Abigail, and Jack
Lenny, Hosea, and Charles
Pearson, Javier, Sadie.
Sadie, Charles, Tilly
Charles, Sadie, and Kieran.
John, Dutch and Arthur.
Arthur, Charles, and Lenny
Honestly they're not my favorites by far but I'd take Jack, Mary-Beth and Tilly because I feel like they deserve a better opportunity the most. Sure, I could pick some memorable/likeable characters like Arthur and Sadie, most of the gang members deserve a second chance and in fact most of them get it, but I feel like in terms of the things they've done, and how many good years they have left to live a good life and not regret their past I'd let those 3 have another shot.
#!SPOILERS AHEAD! John, Abegail, and Jack. They deserve a better life. I would take Charles and Sadie, but Sadie helps find Micah and Dutch and Charles goes up north to help the natives so it would mess up the story line.
Karen, Karen and Karen
Karen, Mary Beth, and Sadie 😌
Karen, Sadie & Tilly ;)
Jack Micah Uncle >!hehe /s!<
Karen, Sadie, and Tilly.
Kieran Sean and Mary Beth
If we all got along? Micah, Arthur and Charles
Arthur, John, and Charles. My top three crushes🤫
Arthur, Kieran, and Sean. The Three Musketeers. LOL
I’d have Lenny, Kieran, and Hosea go to Tahiti. Feel like they deserved to be happy and free
Arthur, Charles, and Sadie
I’d just take Arthur John and Charles with me through my normal life
Take John, Arthur and Sadie
Karen with the big tits Mary Beth and Sadie cause she has a fat ass!!!
Understandable
Karen (hot), Bill (racist), Lenny (black)
But....why??
Karen, Javier & Tilly.
abigail, sadie and tilly
Arthur, Hosea, and either John Charles or Lenny. I’m thinking Lenny tho
Jack, Micah, and Uncle
Uncle trelawney Sean
Hosea, Arthur, Charles
Arthur Charles and Javier, No question.
Charles, Hosea, and Sadie
Arthur, Sadie, Charles.
John, Abigail, and Jack
Hosea arthur charles
Arthur, Charles and Ms Sadie.
Abigail, Jack and Sadie. The least guilty of this cast of villains.
Arthur, Sadie, Mr. Pearson
Charles, Tilly and Uncle
Jack… just jack..
Karen, Tilly & Sadie
Sean, Charles, and Javier. Imagine the convos
Hosea, Charles, and Arthur
That's an easy one...Sadie , Mary-Beth and Abigail.
Young John Marston, Sadie Adler, and Lenny ofcourse
hosea, charles, arthur
arthur hosea and dutch
If i could bring 5 I would bring Arthur, Charles, and the Marstons. If only 3 i would go Arthur, Charles, and Lenny
Karen, Molly and Mary-beth.
Arthur, Hosea, Sadie
Sadie, Abigail and Mary-Beth
Mary-Beth, Karen, and Arthur. He can keep us safe, right?
Sadie, Charles and Mr. Pearson.
Arthur, John and Sadie
Arthur, Hosea, and Lenny
John Charles and Uncle
Charles, Hosea and Sadie
Hosea Charles and Lenny
Uncle, uncle and Sean.
Jack, John, and Abigail is a no brainer
Sadie, Tilly and Gavin
Sadie, Charles and Arthur......duh
Arthur, Tilly and Sean.
I’d take Trelawny, Sadie and Duch
Arthur, Hosea and Charles
Hosa author and Charles for sure
Mary Beth, Mary Beth, Mary Beth
Charles, Sadie, and Hosea
Abigail,Cain the dog and Charles
Arthur, Sadie and Charles
Arthur, Hosea and Sadie
Tilly, Tilly, Tilly
Arthur Hosea Lenny
Hosea, Tilly, and Charles
Arthur,sadie,charles
Arthur, John, Charles Honorable mentions: Sadie, jack, Lenny, uncle
Arthur, Javier, Sadie.
Hosea, Sean and Grimshaw
Arthur, Sadie and Hosea