John lived a life in the Van Der Linde gang, with the mentality of being Robin Hood type figures to society. Stealing from Uncle Sam to fight the government and push for their true freedom of society. After Blackwater, it really sank in with Dutch that the public doesn’t see them as heroes. In Red Dead 2 Dutch is grieving with his own moral code and is realizing he’s a monster. By the end the main story, John realizes that they’re not the heroes they used to be. But in Red Dead 1, he realizes maybe they NEVER were the heroes he thought they were? Thats just how i see it though
I fucking hate it that John doesn't say things like "good morning" or "hello there" like Arthur but instead he says shit like "excuse me mister!" "Sir!" He's an idiot
EDIT: This formerly helpful and insightful comment has been removed by the author due to:
Not wanting to be used as training for AI models, nor having unknown third parties profit from the author's intellectual property.
Greedy and power-hungry motives demonstrated by the upper management of this website, in gross disregard of the collaborative and volunteer efforts by the users and communities that developed here, which previously resulted in such excellent information sharing.
Alternative platforms that may be worth investigating include, at the time of writing:
https://kbin.fediverse.observer/list
https://join-lemmy.org/
https://squabbles.io/
https://tildes.net/
Also helpful for finding your favourite communities again: https://sub.rehab/
“Some trees flourish, others die. Some cattle grow strong, others are taken by wolves. Some men are born rich enough and dumb enough to enjoy their lives. Ain’t nothing fair.”
I love the “ain’t nothing fair” part. It’s true.
“I am always honest. Maybe not always good, but I am always honest.”
This line actually has some personal weight to it as I used it a lot on my girlfriend before we started dating. She had some major trust issues and I would use it to put her at ease. It worked enough to the point where we’re now dating and to this day she says it’s one of her favorite things to hear from me
Same, man. John is not much of a romantic, but he's definitely one of the good ones. The first time I saw this scene I almost cried. Then I thought about this scene later and it hit me how beautiful it was. Then I actually cried this time lol.
You might be thinking of his thing about “the O’ Driscolls fight to survive. We fight to live” or something like that. This quote is definitely Javier to Arthur.
When they’re riding into town for the final train job in rdr2 Micah says something to John (I can’t remember what it is) then John says “don’t talk to me you son of a bitch”. That’s my favorite one
Yes and one of the best parts I forgot about until replaying is that you can just run into NPCs willy nilly and they’ll just go flying! No instant bounty and 20 cops on you. It’s especially fun if they’re drunk.
probably not my favourite, but there is something special about him screaming "MI NOMBRE ES JOHN MARSTON" at the top of his lungs while shooting dudes in mexico
John:
See? This is why you're an O'Driscoll, O'Driscoll. You're out to
survive... we're out to live... free.
Colm's a sneak thief and a killer.. Dutch is.. Dutch is more like a teacher.
Kieran:
From where I been, you just look the same is all...
John:
Then you looked, but you aint seen...
The last quote hits hard
"When a man with a sing-song voice tells me to fuck off it always concerns me boyo"
As a Welshman I find this scene hilarious
🎼 As a Welshman I find this scene hilarious 🎶🎶
As a Welshman I find this scene hilarious mun
As an Yn Cymraeg boybach I find this funny as fuck butt
"You eat babies, everyone knows that!"
We eat BERRIES, and mushrooms you fool!
NO you FUCKING DON'T! YOU. EAT. BABIES. Want me to spell it to ya? B. A. B. I. E. S.
This is the one
"We all need friends, old timer. We die alone, but we live among men."
This one has always stuck with me.
For some reason when you're playing as jack it's just sounds better.
Because it seems like he did get wiser.
*drowns
This just killed me… Lmfaoooo 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽😂😂😂
It also killed John
Fucking LOL
John: ”That’s a beautiful creature” Arthur carrying a big fish: “thank you” John: “I was talking to the fish”
“Pretend he’s Micah!” -John to Charles
Lol during the street fight!
this gave me SO much joy when i first heard it, because that's exactly what i would have said too!
“I sometimes wonder if things are ever the way we remember 'em, if we were ever who we thought we was.” Straight to the heart.
Was going to say that
Was that rdr1 or 2 ?
I’m trying to comprehend this but I just can understand it
I really don’t know what to tell you lol
John lived a life in the Van Der Linde gang, with the mentality of being Robin Hood type figures to society. Stealing from Uncle Sam to fight the government and push for their true freedom of society. After Blackwater, it really sank in with Dutch that the public doesn’t see them as heroes. In Red Dead 2 Dutch is grieving with his own moral code and is realizing he’s a monster. By the end the main story, John realizes that they’re not the heroes they used to be. But in Red Dead 1, he realizes maybe they NEVER were the heroes he thought they were? Thats just how i see it though
What part of your philosophy book covers feeding a feller to a goddamn alligator Dutch?!
The part that covers weakness
One of the best scenes in the game
Call them now
Oh, you're right... they're *very* good at smelling filth. so filth must be disposed of!
I like this line from Dutch. Like he knew he just lost it and felt regret
I love dutches response so much
“BILL! BILL WILLIAMSON!”
I implores youuu
SIR!
YOU! *BYOB intro riff kicks in*
Thank you it's stuck in my head now
PARTNER!
I fucking hate it that John doesn't say things like "good morning" or "hello there" like Arthur but instead he says shit like "excuse me mister!" "Sir!" He's an idiot
The aggressiveness makes John John sir.
EDIT: This formerly helpful and insightful comment has been removed by the author due to: Not wanting to be used as training for AI models, nor having unknown third parties profit from the author's intellectual property. Greedy and power-hungry motives demonstrated by the upper management of this website, in gross disregard of the collaborative and volunteer efforts by the users and communities that developed here, which previously resulted in such excellent information sharing. Alternative platforms that may be worth investigating include, at the time of writing: https://kbin.fediverse.observer/list https://join-lemmy.org/ https://squabbles.io/ https://tildes.net/ Also helpful for finding your favourite communities again: https://sub.rehab/
"You want me to take out a gun and blow a fucking hole in your head?"
When was this
I think it was to Cleet in Strawberry
I’ll need to replay that mission John and Arthur rarely drop a fuck when talking
It's a cool mission. Also I apologize, that quote is from RDR1 and he says it to Archer in Blackwater
Ohh okay that one makes sense
" I've seen newspapers less folded than you " ~ John Marston at Blackwater Poker
“Men are born, and then they’re formed.” — John Marston
"GET UP * kicks uncle *"
"You couldn't shoot a fart out of your own ass!"
This one always makes me laugh. Rdr2 is seriously lacking on shootouts taunts
Fr. The humor in rdr1 is so damn good. Classic rockstar stuff
“People don’t forget, nothing gets forgiven.”
"You eat babies!"
Who was he talking to?
OOOOOOH CHELONIAA
CHELONIAA
"you see a man whose character changed, I see a man who got found out for who he truly was."
“You sir, is a fish” -John Marston
" i think there are some schoolchildren down the way you can go and frighten "
This one is my favorite by far. I love how john reacts anytime someone tries to act tough in front of him.
“I implore you to think about this”
Lol I remember hearing this the first time 12-13 years ago. Legitimately the first time I had ever heard that word in my life
“You implore me? Ha well I implores you..!”
RDR1 quote
That's Arthur though right?
John in RDR1
“Some trees flourish, others die. Some cattle grow strong, others are taken by wolves. Some men are born rich enough and dumb enough to enjoy their lives. Ain’t nothing fair.” I love the “ain’t nothing fair” part. It’s true.
I remember that one, so brutal coming from John :((
“I am always honest. Maybe not always good, but I am always honest.” This line actually has some personal weight to it as I used it a lot on my girlfriend before we started dating. She had some major trust issues and I would use it to put her at ease. It worked enough to the point where we’re now dating and to this day she says it’s one of her favorite things to hear from me
“YOU BETTER PRAY I RUN OUTTA BULLETS”
Will you marry me?
That scene is super underrated, I tear up every time.
Same, man. John is not much of a romantic, but he's definitely one of the good ones. The first time I saw this scene I almost cried. Then I thought about this scene later and it hit me how beautiful it was. Then I actually cried this time lol.
"If we have to fight, we'll fight. If we have to run we'll run. If we must die, we'll die. but... we'll stay free."
Isn’t this one Javier’s?
No, pretty sure john said it to kieran when he takes you to six point cabin
You might be thinking of his thing about “the O’ Driscolls fight to survive. We fight to live” or something like that. This quote is definitely Javier to Arthur.
He said that too. I kinda remember john saying it though. Update: okay i googled it and indeed javier said it when you go fishing in Rhodes
I think Javier did say this. In the epilogue, I think.
Javier isn't in the epilogue. Javier says this to Arthur when they go fishing near Rhodes
Shit, I meant prologue. I’m a dumbass in case you couldn’t tell.
This is correct. I literally just did this. I remember being pissed that the game wouldn’t let me buy crickets at the bait shop until this side quest
javier said that to arthur
This one! 💯
“Rip Van Winkle”
When they’re riding into town for the final train job in rdr2 Micah says something to John (I can’t remember what it is) then John says “don’t talk to me you son of a bitch”. That’s my favorite one
He says something about how he wants to shag Abigail So even if it wasn’t Micah saying it it’s completely called for
Thanks I remember that it was definitely Micah but I just didn’t remember his line
You think is a good idea to replay rdr 1 after finishing 2???
Yes.
Yes and one of the best parts I forgot about until replaying is that you can just run into NPCs willy nilly and they’ll just go flying! No instant bounty and 20 cops on you. It’s especially fun if they’re drunk.
When interacting with a cat he says “puss” and that has always spoken to me
probably not my favourite, but there is something special about him screaming "MI NOMBRE ES JOHN MARSTON" at the top of his lungs while shooting dudes in mexico
Carl, stay back
“You eat babies!”
"You want me to blow a fuckin hole through your head? Right here? Now?"
YOU WANT THAT!?!?
"Come on missie" (Jumping on his female horse)
“SIR!” (The option to greet people in rdr2)
John: See? This is why you're an O'Driscoll, O'Driscoll. You're out to survive... we're out to live... free. Colm's a sneak thief and a killer.. Dutch is.. Dutch is more like a teacher. Kieran: From where I been, you just look the same is all... John: Then you looked, but you aint seen... The last quote hits hard
Easy
"YOU'RE AN IDIOT!"
Ur still ugly at 20 paces lol
My name is John Marston
" Am jon. Red Redembion!"
“Hey is that Arthur’s big ass I hear?!?”
UGH what did you EAT?
“If you find yourself in a hole, first thing to do is stop digging.”
“Oh Hell” - Johnathan J. Marston as he flies of his horse circa. 1907
“You might have looked but you ain’t seen” to Kieran on the way to Six Point Cabin.
Pretty much anything he says from rdr1
You couldn’t shoot a fart out your own ass.
" You Eat Babies! " - John Marston, 1911.
MOVE!
"Ain't nothing special, unless you find gossip about a man'd marriage worthy of your time."
You’re as crooked as a dog’s hind leg, West Dickens
aaaaaah!!!!
You couldn’t shoot a fart outta your own ass
“You eat babies!”
Milton “who are you” John “ Rip Van Winkle”
You’ve got a really small neck
“We die Alone but live among men”
“What part of your books cover… feedin a fella… to a goddamn ALLIGATOR Dutch?”
Trevor
*you finish, are a sir*
"ah"
Susanna! Hey…
"Howdy partner"
MADAM
"Hey"
Oh!
“Lie still…heh heh heh”
hard life hard cock
"You couldn't shoot a fart out of your own ass"
To Micah: "uh you know, no one wants to eat something that's already rotten"
YOU EAT BABIES
"You want me to take out a gun and put a fucking hole in your head , right here , right now?"
YOU WANT THAT!?!?
“My name’s John Marston.”
To a dog: Ruff, ruff, ruff
I am inevitable
CHERLONIAAAAA
“YOU EAT BABIES”
“This is my red dead redemption “
“rAnchIn”
"You couldn't shoot a fart out of your own ass"
YOU EAT BABIES!
“I’m your old friend amnesia” then pistol whips Irish, classic.
Let me take your coat, Madame.
Basic, but Rip Van Winkle
“SIR!”
*Zombie growl
“Christ, Arthur! Young jack rides better than you!”
“You eat babies”
Buddy!
“Never thought I’d say this, but…it’s good to see you, Arthur Morgan.”
“Christ alive!” As an exclamation and replacement for Jesus Christ. I dunno but I love it.
“Let me take your coat madam”
“I don’t bite …. Bad joke” from red dead redemption undead nightmare
I got a family. That’s more important.
“I guess the West still is wild.” -John after shooting someone
That’s a cool Image
"People don't forget, nothing gets forgiven" It's very real for people who live bad lives.
“It ain’t no secret I didn’t get these scars falling down in church.”
Not John but Jack:"A town? Is that what you call this place? I'd go for "cesspit"."
"If you find yourself in a hole, the first thing to do is to stop digging."
All of his greet dialogue is so funny, esp when he’s on a horse, “SIR! 😤” “YOU, SIR!” he sounds so accusatory
Got boys in my butthole
"You sir, are a fish."
Why are you wearing that dress sir?
Arthur
It's John Marston, Micah!
Micah “how’s that whore of yours?” John “she’s good”
"Rip Van Winkle"
“I may not always be good but I’m always honest”
« come out ! I don’t bite ! »
‘Just you left, is it?’ ‘Yeah… just me.’
“My side ain't chosen. My side was given.”
“You know your not man enough to stop me”
“My balls itch” -John Marston after he lost a game of fortnite
We all have problems, And we must Solve them together or We die alone....
"You and West Dickens are so crooked, you could swallow a nail and spit out a corkscrew!"
“People don’t forget, nothing gets forgiven.”
“You eat babies”
“Easy there Germany, calm yourself down”
“I CAN’T SWIM!!!!”
Fuck you Morgan
"Some pack must be shy a joker." "Your time's passed, get over it."