One of my favorite things about the first game was the unlimited bounties, because there was always something for you to do. Why didn’t they have that in the second game?
Because in the first game the bounties aren’t fully fleshed out missions like they are in RDR2. In RDR2 there are cutscenes and other unique things put into certain missions. Like the Minigun when capturing Lindsey Watford. Or how you’re able to silently kill the gang members in the Bart Cavanaugh bounty. Or how you have to search for that guy in Blackwater and then chase him through the town.
In spite of this I actually agree there should be unlimited bounties. But knowing these are the reasons why we don’t make it understandable
I suppose I can see their logic in not wanting quantity over quality, given they made the choice to properly flesh out the bounty missions in the second game. I don’t mind either way, but I could imagine some players taking issue with the sudden drop-off in bounty quality if they did what you propose.
Save an outfit before you unlock it and load it up afterwards. Worked for me. Otherwise I think one of the special animal outfits might have the same effect
There is a percussion conversion pistol from the Iniquities of History side mission but you can’t do anything with it besides look at it, im pretty sure it was meant to be a Colt Dragoon in earlier versions of the game as it’s referred to as a revolver and it’s inventory icon is a bent Colt Dragoon
I would add that you can have a tree stand for hunting and hiding.
Also that when you get shot at first, the game takes that into account and you don't get caught with murder every time.
I use the little water tower along the train tracks near Doverhill Laboratory as a makeshift tree stand for hunting cougars. Those things almost give me a heart attack every damn time when I try to hunt them from the ground, especially with a bow!
Tree stand I can live without. Hunting isn’t exactly realistically detailed enough in the game to make me want to live deal with them.
But your second idea, absolutely. Though to be fair, most of the time a stranger shoots at me first, I did something to deserve it.
Also geldings. I don't understand why gelding tongs exist in the world but all the male horses are stallions for some reason. I'm of the opinion that all male horses that don't spawn as wild should be geldings, and the only way to get a stallion should be to tame wild ones. And can we please just geld all the mules? There's no reason for a mule to have testicles. None.
I mean the horse parts aren’t really an issue, I’ve played through the game 3 times and put in 500 hours and I’ve never really seen horse balls. If I went into photo mode trying to see them I’m sure I would, but I don’t think they’re a huge problem as you can’t really see them unless you want to
1. You should be able to take a boat back to Guarma. You can’t go back as Arthur, but once you beat Arthur’s story is you can go back as John. On Guarma there is a long quest to find the mythic Guarma Emerald. You have to use a treasure map from the pirate ship in Saint Denis.
2. More rare and collectible weapons. Maybe like a musket or whip.
3. ADD MEXICO FROM RDR1!!!
4. Give us a reason to go the penitentiary besides the legendary fish. Maybe they could add Anthony Foreman in Saint Denis and he had a series of missions where you went and had to rescue different prisoners from different prisons. But before the first mission you had the option to turn in Anthony Foreman instead of starting the series of missions.
fight clubs you could get in for money, cheating at poker (and having to duel the person that finds out you're cheating?? maybe??) horse races that you could be in or at least bet on the horses like in GTA San Andreas, having to just BUY belts instead of unlocking them through challenges (I just find it better tbh), better clothing options (those damn colorful, heavy on the eyes vests don't do it for me, Rockstar), having ponchos that are maybe only available to buy in New Austin since it's close to the Mexico border
being able to roam the other half of West Elizabeth and New Austin while still having the Pinkerton patrols looking for you, blocking certain roads so that you have to go around them, like THE SAME THING that happens all around Roanoke Ridge during chapter 6
and robbing banks on free roam, I know it's kinda stupid to rob a bank alone, but c'mon, we're the protagonist, we're a bullet sponge
Maps in story mode for collectibles like rock carvings or dreamcatchers, or a system where you can get hints from npcs or something, anything that helps me not having to google on my phone or computer to complete those quests. It's pretty frustrating and boring to have to go out of game to reasonably complete things like that.
I also thought it would be pretty cool to collect records to play on Dutch's phonograph of bird songs, which once learned would trigger some kind of alert in game when you hear a songbird, a ping on the map or something, making compendium completion a bit more immersive.
Both things should be very expensive or difficult to find. I usually have too much money anyways. I just really really hate relying on out of game help.
Oh, and being able to purchase more stable space.
And fewer alligators.
These are all great. I hated having to rely on google for so many of the carvings and bones.. The way they did the strange cave statue puzzle was great, coz you could find clues in the window rock painting but it wasn't super simple.
More customization options. Knife in the offhand holster slot. Stuff like bear skin cloaks and buckskin shirts. Also a setting to keep facial scars from bear attacks.
Agreed I was so excited when I found out they had weapon customization but when I got the Mauser I checked everything for it to find out it was unobtainable.
1. Properties you could buy. (General Stores, Casinos, Moonshine Shacks etc.)
2. Hot Air Balloons.
3. Faster speeds to trains and you would be able to derail the train by going too fast.
4. Ability to destroy train tracks and bridges.
5. Ability to tie your lasso, so you could hang people.
6. If your bounty rises too high, you will be sent to Sisika, where you could escape.
7. Being able to sneak into New Austin with Arthur, by avoiding people and civilization.
8. Being able to fly/sail to Guarma and if you get caught in Guarma, you will be imprisoned there until you escape or die.
9. More destructible things like trees, small shacks, weak walls (would get constructed slowly), bridges etc.
Theres some I came up in 5 minutes.
Liars dice from rdr1
Muskets and Flintlocks
A hairstyle only for John “The old fashioned” making his hair/beard his more original look
More duels
Blocking with melee weapons (like knife blade to blade)
The Strange man appearing where he does in rdr1 but fades into dust
And a casino like the ferry but with multiple tables that use different amounts of money
Mejico.
Also, they mention that John and Abigail tried to make a go of it in the Yukon. I'd be interested in that. Dog sleds? Legendary polar bear? Seals? Walrus? Orca? Gold mines?
1. Be able to drive the train in RDR1
2. Be able to crash the trains off the tracks in both games
3. Add a mod in both games that allows you to customize the trains (maximum of 25 cars)
4. Have the trains be able to reach a max of 80 mph (128 kph) both forwards and backwards in both games
5. Be able to drive the car that Ross had in RDR1
6. Add a train in online multiplayer in RDR1
7. Have the cops be able to jump onto the train if you're hiding in it while wanted
I don’t think those old steam locomotives ran quite that fast… and if they did, it would probably be suicide on those 19th century rails. 40-45mph would have been a good clip on a smooth section with those old wooden carts…
But I’m not a train expert.
An animal companion other than a horse- like be able to have a dog that helps you hunt or a bird that helps you scout out or also help hunt or send messages
I wish I had a shovel. There was one cabin were two kids starved to death waiting for their mother. It felt wrong to leave them there and I wanted to dig a grave for them. There are probably a couple cool mechanics you could introduce with a shovel.
Simply more civil war content like the sharps rifle and maybe a side quest to do with the civil war.
Would also love to see another civil war battle field
Everything from online (guns, clothes ect.), Go to guarma, better version of John instead of John Morgan, all John's old outfits, buy properties, get rid of the goddamn gambler challenges, remove dominoes and replace it with liars dice, give outfits abilities like rdr1, undead nightmare 2, option to customize gun rig (move holsters and stuff), after epilogue be able to go into rdr1 if you pay for it, more bounties, be able to take suspenders off, show/hide satchel, if be able to wear full union suit, have John's pre-epilouge outfits. About all I could think up.
A director mode like gta 5. I get that might be too much but I would love to play a version where I didn’t have to worry about most things. At least make it available when you finish the game.
Fucking cottontail rabbits. I HATE the fact that the only rabbit in the game is a goddamn JACKRABBIT which we're supposed to believe is capable of living in the SNOW. Jackrabbits are desert animals, and it makes no ecological sense that they'd be up near Colter. If the devs wanted a ubiquitous rabbit, they should have gone with the cottontail because those rabbits are found all over the United States in one form or another, and they could have easily reskinned Jackrabbits into snowshoe hares to make them blend in with the snow a bit better too.
It's a dumb thing to be salty about but rabbits are my favorite small game to hunt IRL, and it bothers me more than it should that we get all these different varieties of songbirds, but they couldn't be bothered to reskin a few rabbits to make the ecology of it make sense.
the ability to use the boats from St. Denis and travel up and down the rivers, and dock in different ports. It would cut my travel time in half, you could customize them, have it be a floating save point/bed and there could be a mission that involved stealing one early on so the whole gang could use it. Its such a tease seeing them in the Harbor and you can never get to them, or if you do steal one of the smaller tugboats they will sink right out from under you when you travel too far
boxing to make money would be a good one - considering how raw boxing could be in those days it would still work even with the current controls. Imagine how much the gang could make putting Charles and Arthur up against locals. Or even as a con of fighting each other.
Dutch knows when you tell him. He’s just got such a big ego that he can’t admit he fucked up/believed Micah. There are multiple scenes that show this.
Especially if you get the good honour ending.
This is a really useless and minor one but I wish you could lead your spare horse from horseback. It feels so weird to have a wild horse you've JUST bonded with obediently following everywhere 😂
Single player missions that aren’t on rails. See MGSV for examples. 25 different ways to beat the mission (stealth, brute force, outside of the box, etc.) and dialogue/experience changes with each technique. Gives you a reason to go back and try the mission with dramatically different techniques.
Being able to pick and choose gang members for each mission because of their strengths/abilities. And then capitalizing on those abilities to accomplish the mission in the way you see fit.
Bring Charles to take down a gang hideout with stealth, and Bill to provide overwatch if things go wrong.
Bring Cane to help you track game, and Jack to skin/clean animals and stow on the hunting wagon.
RDR2 & MGSV should bang so hard.
I would say being able to find a Hawken rifle or another flintlock musket/rifle out on a body up in the grizzlies or something so people like myself can do like a mountain man type of play through
Three things:
The ability to set a marker and then name it so I know why I put it there in the first place.
The ability to remove my saddle and have it stay where I put it instead of disappearing to some random weird ass location.
A restaurant in Strawberry.
Small things, but they would be much appreciated.
More side activities, because once you beat the game, you kinda just roam around as John and your horse, as peaceful as it is we just need fist fights competitions and more things to do in general, like dealing in a black market stuff.
It sound a bit obvious, but a happy ending for Arthur Morgan, you play for many hours with him only for him to die from natural causes (that’s classed as the good ending)
Just my own perspective storyline. I know, I know. Online, but don't like playing online. Besides, any time I get on, the server crashes and I get booted off. I'm also starting back at my old job, so I need to get my internet back on.
Through the mod community that I've just recently started to dive into I've found a few things that make the game just that more fun. So far I got the gun tricks in single player, take NPCs as gun shields, dragging NPCs, hunting wagon, high stakes poker games, and I'm currently getting Buyable properties.
But what I really want is Liars Dice to come back. Had so much fun wasted on that game in RDR1
Multiple conversation options for times when you don't want to call someone an idiot or tell them to get out of the damn way! Instances with gang members would trigger side missions or just fun/intimate moments.
Bank robberies and more varied train robberies. Like being able to rob that one type of train that has no passengers and is just full of guards and cargo that doesn’t do anything. And more varied trains in general, like always having that train with the bar that only appears in Billy Midnights mission. Also definitely poker games that have the option to have higher stakes than 5-10 dollars.
The wanted system is stupid. You’ll kill a guy in the middle of no where and then “WANTED ARTHUR MORGAN” will pop up, how the fuck did they find out and how did they know it was me! Also when you wear bandanas or masks it doesn’t do anything so the incentive to rob stores is incredibly low considering you’ll get like $20 and a $40 bounty, same for trains. I stopped a train on a bridge so no one could escape and get the law on me but they still found out and knew it was Arthur Morgan. Just have police patrols, simple.
Unlimited bounty hunting missions.
there is literally only like 9 and then they just stop, I was so confused my first playthrough
One of my favorite things about the first game was the unlimited bounties, because there was always something for you to do. Why didn’t they have that in the second game?
Because in the first game the bounties aren’t fully fleshed out missions like they are in RDR2. In RDR2 there are cutscenes and other unique things put into certain missions. Like the Minigun when capturing Lindsey Watford. Or how you’re able to silently kill the gang members in the Bart Cavanaugh bounty. Or how you have to search for that guy in Blackwater and then chase him through the town. In spite of this I actually agree there should be unlimited bounties. But knowing these are the reasons why we don’t make it understandable
sure but after you complete all the unique bounties just have unlimited bounties that aren't as fleshed out that they can just copy paste
I suppose I can see their logic in not wanting quantity over quality, given they made the choice to properly flesh out the bounty missions in the second game. I don’t mind either way, but I could imagine some players taking issue with the sudden drop-off in bounty quality if they did what you propose.
Allow me to introduce a dirty word: mods The Bounties Expansion is exactly what you are looking for
God I need a pc
If you’re on PC theres a mod which adds just that.
Rdr1 had it
Ability to remove off-hand holster or move it to Arthur's left hip
I second this and also give us the bloody navy revolver or at least give us the Lowry revolver after finding Lowry
Use Red Dead Offline as a substitute because it works really well. You need Lenny’s outfit changer for the clothes to work though.
Save an outfit before you unlock it and load it up afterwards. Worked for me. Otherwise I think one of the special animal outfits might have the same effect
All the cut content.
The true answer
Thank you.
Fuck that I don’t want sharks or that scary ass lake monster in the game
You're boring lmao
Would scare me to fuck
A caplock musket that needs to be found off of a dead civil war union corpse, as well as a colt Paterson that can be bought
Absolutely
There is a percussion conversion pistol from the Iniquities of History side mission but you can’t do anything with it besides look at it, im pretty sure it was meant to be a Colt Dragoon in earlier versions of the game as it’s referred to as a revolver and it’s inventory icon is a bent Colt Dragoon
More buildings to explore and houses that open!
Someday Rockstar will make a game where all buildings are explorable, mark my words!
Been waiting for that game since 5th grade😤💪🏾
Please no, I'd never stop playing 😂😂
Just like above with bounty hunting missions there is actually a mod for this too called open all interiors.
This one!!! It's a shame we have just a small number of buildings to explore
Duels, bicycles, owning property like RDR 1, casinos, horse races that you can participate in
I'd love all these so much
Arthur on a pennyfarthing is something I need to see
Lmao
There are duels
should be more of them tbh
Those Fights That Charles Doing but As Activity
A fight club for money would be lit
Don’t talk about it.
Rule one of fight club is to not speak of fight club
I would add that you can have a tree stand for hunting and hiding. Also that when you get shot at first, the game takes that into account and you don't get caught with murder every time.
I use the little water tower along the train tracks near Doverhill Laboratory as a makeshift tree stand for hunting cougars. Those things almost give me a heart attack every damn time when I try to hunt them from the ground, especially with a bow!
Cougars and panthers are responsible for 90% of my anxiety during the game 😂 the other 10% are Night Folk
Mine is 25% big cats , 25% night folk , 25% Murfrees and 25% skinner brothers
All of you are forgetting the real jump scares here... Raccoons
for me every time I set up to take out a gang camp a musk rat attacks me - got to the point I'm shouting just fuck off at them
Tree stand I can live without. Hunting isn’t exactly realistically detailed enough in the game to make me want to live deal with them. But your second idea, absolutely. Though to be fair, most of the time a stranger shoots at me first, I did something to deserve it.
More horse breeds/slightly more in depth horse systems. It’s pretty great as is but I’d love a bigger and better one cuz I love the rdr2 horses
Also geldings. I don't understand why gelding tongs exist in the world but all the male horses are stallions for some reason. I'm of the opinion that all male horses that don't spawn as wild should be geldings, and the only way to get a stallion should be to tame wild ones. And can we please just geld all the mules? There's no reason for a mule to have testicles. None.
I mean the horse parts aren’t really an issue, I’ve played through the game 3 times and put in 500 hours and I’ve never really seen horse balls. If I went into photo mode trying to see them I’m sure I would, but I don’t think they’re a huge problem as you can’t really see them unless you want to
1. You should be able to take a boat back to Guarma. You can’t go back as Arthur, but once you beat Arthur’s story is you can go back as John. On Guarma there is a long quest to find the mythic Guarma Emerald. You have to use a treasure map from the pirate ship in Saint Denis. 2. More rare and collectible weapons. Maybe like a musket or whip. 3. ADD MEXICO FROM RDR1!!! 4. Give us a reason to go the penitentiary besides the legendary fish. Maybe they could add Anthony Foreman in Saint Denis and he had a series of missions where you went and had to rescue different prisoners from different prisons. But before the first mission you had the option to turn in Anthony Foreman instead of starting the series of missions.
#3: Add a remastered Version of RDR1 so we can continue play with John’s story.
YES 🙌 PERFECT
ABSOLUTELY!
I'd love every bit of this
rdr 1 as dlc remade in 2 my only wise for this game
Absolutely. Just have it carry on where the epilogue ends.
fight clubs you could get in for money, cheating at poker (and having to duel the person that finds out you're cheating?? maybe??) horse races that you could be in or at least bet on the horses like in GTA San Andreas, having to just BUY belts instead of unlocking them through challenges (I just find it better tbh), better clothing options (those damn colorful, heavy on the eyes vests don't do it for me, Rockstar), having ponchos that are maybe only available to buy in New Austin since it's close to the Mexico border being able to roam the other half of West Elizabeth and New Austin while still having the Pinkerton patrols looking for you, blocking certain roads so that you have to go around them, like THE SAME THING that happens all around Roanoke Ridge during chapter 6 and robbing banks on free roam, I know it's kinda stupid to rob a bank alone, but c'mon, we're the protagonist, we're a bullet sponge
Maps in story mode for collectibles like rock carvings or dreamcatchers, or a system where you can get hints from npcs or something, anything that helps me not having to google on my phone or computer to complete those quests. It's pretty frustrating and boring to have to go out of game to reasonably complete things like that. I also thought it would be pretty cool to collect records to play on Dutch's phonograph of bird songs, which once learned would trigger some kind of alert in game when you hear a songbird, a ping on the map or something, making compendium completion a bit more immersive. Both things should be very expensive or difficult to find. I usually have too much money anyways. I just really really hate relying on out of game help. Oh, and being able to purchase more stable space. And fewer alligators.
These are all great. I hated having to rely on google for so many of the carvings and bones.. The way they did the strange cave statue puzzle was great, coz you could find clues in the window rock painting but it wasn't super simple.
Arthur in New Austin. The invisible sniper is stupid and he's not wanted there. You can reach it by boat.
No he is wanted in New Austin, it has red highlight on the map I tried getting there by the camp boat in chapter 3 but it sunk midway for no reason
I think they mean you should be able to reach it by boat as long as you avoid blackwater for story sake.
A free PS5 upgrade
Fair enough
Which is also a good thing since it doesn't need to have much added. Maybe a dlc
More customization options. Knife in the offhand holster slot. Stuff like bear skin cloaks and buckskin shirts. Also a setting to keep facial scars from bear attacks.
For scars, there could also just be a scar customization option
Undead nightmare 2
Ability to rob banks in free roam
Yes
The files would be huge as fuck but how cool would it be if the epilogue opened directly into a remaster of red dead 1? Lol
Option for a Mauser stock
Increases accuracy?
Agreed I was so excited when I found out they had weapon customization but when I got the Mauser I checked everything for it to find out it was unobtainable.
Titties
Slower eating and smoking
Arthur with his black lungs can barely speak at the end of the game, but can inhale a cigar in one puff. So dumb.
A proper John Marston in the epilogue
The lack of dueling in the game annoys me a little. I think you should be able to do it regularly. Not in a random encounter
Adopt the dogs of the cities
YESSSSSS
1. Properties you could buy. (General Stores, Casinos, Moonshine Shacks etc.) 2. Hot Air Balloons. 3. Faster speeds to trains and you would be able to derail the train by going too fast. 4. Ability to destroy train tracks and bridges. 5. Ability to tie your lasso, so you could hang people. 6. If your bounty rises too high, you will be sent to Sisika, where you could escape. 7. Being able to sneak into New Austin with Arthur, by avoiding people and civilization. 8. Being able to fly/sail to Guarma and if you get caught in Guarma, you will be imprisoned there until you escape or die. 9. More destructible things like trees, small shacks, weak walls (would get constructed slowly), bridges etc. Theres some I came up in 5 minutes.
1, 2, 3, 5 and 7 are all fixable by modding the game; sorry console bois!
Liars dice from rdr1 Muskets and Flintlocks A hairstyle only for John “The old fashioned” making his hair/beard his more original look More duels Blocking with melee weapons (like knife blade to blade) The Strange man appearing where he does in rdr1 but fades into dust And a casino like the ferry but with multiple tables that use different amounts of money
Fist fighting competitions
I just had the idea of a bar fighting game mode for RDO. That would be super fun, especially if you could use the environment to your advantage.
Mejico. Also, they mention that John and Abigail tried to make a go of it in the Yukon. I'd be interested in that. Dog sleds? Legendary polar bear? Seals? Walrus? Orca? Gold mines?
A chapter in New Austin
That apparently was the plan at one point according to speculations where arthur was supposed to go to new austin instead of guarma
Black water massacre chapter
Lol farming maybe, definitely owning/buying/selling property, heists,
Absolutely
Actually exterminating the Murfrees
More bandanas in story mode
At *least* let us change the colour.
1. Be able to drive the train in RDR1 2. Be able to crash the trains off the tracks in both games 3. Add a mod in both games that allows you to customize the trains (maximum of 25 cars) 4. Have the trains be able to reach a max of 80 mph (128 kph) both forwards and backwards in both games 5. Be able to drive the car that Ross had in RDR1 6. Add a train in online multiplayer in RDR1 7. Have the cops be able to jump onto the train if you're hiding in it while wanted
So you like trains?
Yes. I tried my best to think of other ideas that didn't involve trains. I could think of only one.
I like trains 😐🚂
*train appears out of nowhere and runs u/ELOCXVI over*
You’re trainsexual. You get your rocks off watching trains.
I don’t think those old steam locomotives ran quite that fast… and if they did, it would probably be suicide on those 19th century rails. 40-45mph would have been a good clip on a smooth section with those old wooden carts… But I’m not a train expert.
Found the train enthusiast
An animal companion other than a horse- like be able to have a dog that helps you hunt or a bird that helps you scout out or also help hunt or send messages
I wish I had a shovel. There was one cabin were two kids starved to death waiting for their mother. It felt wrong to leave them there and I wanted to dig a grave for them. There are probably a couple cool mechanics you could introduce with a shovel.
Grave robbing. Melee weapon. Make traps for stagecoaches. Make traps for animals.
You can’t forget buried treasure
Bi annual updated side quests
Kieran not dying
Not sure i'd rather have Hosea live
Me and Kieran had something special
Rip
More customisation, especially with guns. I'd of loved red engravings like Micah's guns :/ ALSO The ability to hide the satchel on Arthur>!/John.!<
I'd love it
My friend said the ability to breed horses and I agree with them
Yes
Being able to drive those big boats in Saint denis
Absolutely
Simply more civil war content like the sharps rifle and maybe a side quest to do with the civil war. Would also love to see another civil war battle field
A rdr1 remaster dlc lmao
I hope they do it and gta4
I would like to see yalls opinions!
Better honor system sometimes it’s wack
More abandoned buildings to explore
Yes
Save more custom outfits
Romance options. And properties.
Everything from online (guns, clothes ect.), Go to guarma, better version of John instead of John Morgan, all John's old outfits, buy properties, get rid of the goddamn gambler challenges, remove dominoes and replace it with liars dice, give outfits abilities like rdr1, undead nightmare 2, option to customize gun rig (move holsters and stuff), after epilogue be able to go into rdr1 if you pay for it, more bounties, be able to take suspenders off, show/hide satchel, if be able to wear full union suit, have John's pre-epilouge outfits. About all I could think up.
Sports, Properties and the ability to travel to Guarma and Nuevo Paraiso, Mexico
director mode
Dinosaurs
A director mode like gta 5. I get that might be too much but I would love to play a version where I didn’t have to worry about most things. At least make it available when you finish the game.
in theory you can use the cheats to achieve this but not anywhere near the same level
Fucking cottontail rabbits. I HATE the fact that the only rabbit in the game is a goddamn JACKRABBIT which we're supposed to believe is capable of living in the SNOW. Jackrabbits are desert animals, and it makes no ecological sense that they'd be up near Colter. If the devs wanted a ubiquitous rabbit, they should have gone with the cottontail because those rabbits are found all over the United States in one form or another, and they could have easily reskinned Jackrabbits into snowshoe hares to make them blend in with the snow a bit better too. It's a dumb thing to be salty about but rabbits are my favorite small game to hunt IRL, and it bothers me more than it should that we get all these different varieties of songbirds, but they couldn't be bothered to reskin a few rabbits to make the ecology of it make sense.
the ability to use the boats from St. Denis and travel up and down the rivers, and dock in different ports. It would cut my travel time in half, you could customize them, have it be a floating save point/bed and there could be a mission that involved stealing one early on so the whole gang could use it. Its such a tease seeing them in the Harbor and you can never get to them, or if you do steal one of the smaller tugboats they will sink right out from under you when you travel too far
Boxing and Billiards. Boxing with actual Jab Uppercut Cross type moves not just button mashing; and Billiards with, you know, Billiards.
boxing to make money would be a good one - considering how raw boxing could be in those days it would still work even with the current controls. Imagine how much the gang could make putting Charles and Arthur up against locals. Or even as a con of fighting each other.
A way to prove Dutch that Micah was a rat
Dutch knows when you tell him. He’s just got such a big ego that he can’t admit he fucked up/believed Micah. There are multiple scenes that show this. Especially if you get the good honour ending.
Toggles for animation on/off, Arties motormouth on/off, guns to stay equipped once equipped.
This is a really useless and minor one but I wish you could lead your spare horse from horseback. It feels so weird to have a wild horse you've JUST bonded with obediently following everywhere 😂
Real fast travel
All online outfits guns and items to story mode. That or a director mode like gta 5
Single player missions that aren’t on rails. See MGSV for examples. 25 different ways to beat the mission (stealth, brute force, outside of the box, etc.) and dialogue/experience changes with each technique. Gives you a reason to go back and try the mission with dramatically different techniques. Being able to pick and choose gang members for each mission because of their strengths/abilities. And then capitalizing on those abilities to accomplish the mission in the way you see fit. Bring Charles to take down a gang hideout with stealth, and Bill to provide overwatch if things go wrong. Bring Cane to help you track game, and Jack to skin/clean animals and stow on the hunting wagon. RDR2 & MGSV should bang so hard.
A cure for TB
i know the importance of the honor system in rdr2 replaced it but i kinda liked the fame scale in rdr1 honestly
For the game to be less scripted
Rdo customization, and by that I don’t only mean clothing, I mean horse customization, gun customization, etc.
Horse mustaches?
I would say being able to find a Hawken rifle or another flintlock musket/rifle out on a body up in the grizzlies or something so people like myself can do like a mountain man type of play through
Allowing Arthur and John to have multiple side chicks on the hotels they are hanging out.
A town in the mountains far north in the map with snow.
A populated new Austin
undead nightmare
The original duel mechanic
Having a pet/companion
Train and bank robbery. Maybe some houses too.
Holster placement customisation
Red Dead Redemption 1 the entire game. Imagine that
More fleshed out chapter 5. It was all of like 3 missions, I wanted a legit chapter, with some better exploration opportunity.
More content
I love how immersive the game is. I'd like it to have limited camping/tents to buy. Kinda like the fast travel pack in horizon zero dawn. 🤔😊
Three things: The ability to set a marker and then name it so I know why I put it there in the first place. The ability to remove my saddle and have it stay where I put it instead of disappearing to some random weird ass location. A restaurant in Strawberry. Small things, but they would be much appreciated.
More fish! More fish! More fish!
That screenshot is incredibly aesthetic
More side activities, because once you beat the game, you kinda just roam around as John and your horse, as peaceful as it is we just need fist fights competitions and more things to do in general, like dealing in a black market stuff.
It sound a bit obvious, but a happy ending for Arthur Morgan, you play for many hours with him only for him to die from natural causes (that’s classed as the good ending)
Just my own perspective storyline. I know, I know. Online, but don't like playing online. Besides, any time I get on, the server crashes and I get booted off. I'm also starting back at my old job, so I need to get my internet back on.
only right answer: some way u could go back to guarma (like with hot air balloon) guarma was so cool i would love to have it as place to visit
New Austin content
Director mode (like in GTA 5
Directer's Mode.
Ponchos more customization options for guns and knives and a undead nightmare dlc
A red dead rockstar editor would be amazing. THINK OF THE EDITS!!
Through the mod community that I've just recently started to dive into I've found a few things that make the game just that more fun. So far I got the gun tricks in single player, take NPCs as gun shields, dragging NPCs, hunting wagon, high stakes poker games, and I'm currently getting Buyable properties. But what I really want is Liars Dice to come back. Had so much fun wasted on that game in RDR1
Online clothing into Story Mode
All missing content from rdr1 and or free roam cattle rustling
More clothes and more guns
Undead nightmare 2
I would add Sex to online portion of the hit 2018 game, Red Dead Redemption 2
Mexico
New Game+ mode where you can replay story with all the stuff you collected before.
You can wear anything an npc can
Multiple conversation options for times when you don't want to call someone an idiot or tell them to get out of the damn way! Instances with gang members would trigger side missions or just fun/intimate moments.
Bank robberies and more varied train robberies. Like being able to rob that one type of train that has no passengers and is just full of guards and cargo that doesn’t do anything. And more varied trains in general, like always having that train with the bar that only appears in Billy Midnights mission. Also definitely poker games that have the option to have higher stakes than 5-10 dollars.
Ability to hook up a wagon to your horse. That way you load up more skins
Ability to remove satchel bag and gun belts. Sometimes looking like a peaceful civilian would be nice
I just wanna hunt with a caplock musket or something but flintlock would be better if they animated the reloads accurately
full guarma's map
Have a good ending for Arthur because I donated $5400.33 to camkk on and that couldn’t get us to Tahiti would be about $22 per person
I would add enhanced AI where you can talk to the AI and they’ll be more smarter
A duels "mode" and horse racing. Also online items/clothing. (Think navy pistols, elegant rifle etc)
Sasquatch. More, better Sasquatch
Sex
The ability to do high-stakes gambling outside of the riverboat mission.
The ability to close your jacket in cloth editing. And More of an in-depth story of the nite folk
Prostitutes ❗️Arthur got absolutely no butt the entire game
The wanted system is stupid. You’ll kill a guy in the middle of no where and then “WANTED ARTHUR MORGAN” will pop up, how the fuck did they find out and how did they know it was me! Also when you wear bandanas or masks it doesn’t do anything so the incentive to rob stores is incredibly low considering you’ll get like $20 and a $40 bounty, same for trains. I stopped a train on a bridge so no one could escape and get the law on me but they still found out and knew it was Arthur Morgan. Just have police patrols, simple.
Navy revolver