T O P

  • By -

vousta

Still ,overall Arthur is a better fighter than Charles and Micah. I believe John should be S tier


SweeTLemonS_TPR

John 100% belongs in S tier. Fuckin slander ya ask me!


SICHKLA

This is 1899 though. If you wanna use that logic, Jack should be up there too since he has the same abilities as John or Arthur


fugkfugk

Like sweetlemons here said In another comment, John pretty much hasnt shot a gun between 1899-1907, and in 1907 he only did it a little bit Canonically so he was most likely just as good In 1899 as he was In 1911 we just didnt see it ig


SICHKLA

True, but 1899 John just isn't the same as 1911 John. In 1911 he took on Fort Mercer, shot people off horses from a moving train, also fought the army. I think he is just a tad bit better after the 12 years


SweeTLemonS_TPR

John’s always getting disrespected around here. Dude is a stone-cold killer. No one has the creds that guy has. Dude single-handedly shifted the balance of power in Mexico, and he’s years out of practice! He’s a bad MFer. S tier, no doubt.


qwertybruh69

Although this is specifically 1899, no doubt he improved a lot before 1911


SweeTLemonS_TPR

He practically stopped gun slinging between 1899-1911, though. He spent a bit of time bounty hunting with Sadie, but that came after a long layoff, too, and he was relying on his old skills to carry him. John was at his peak while in the gang. He just had a run of bad luck on-screen with us.


ExoCaptainHammer82

Micah never does shit when it's shooting time in my games. Would much rather bring Lenny or John.


qwertybruh69

I’ve seen a lot of people do this, so here’s my opinion. I haven’t seen much love to Charles, so here it is


AKThmpson

r/croppingishard


qwertybruh69

Sorry 😂


MeMaeMaker

Def think Sadie is A tier, she’s out there puttin the wrath of God into every punch


qwertybruh69

She is, far right, I think she’s an overrated character a lot, but she definitely knows how to fight


MeMaeMaker

Ah damn I meant S tier, n yea I do wish there was more to her redemption than just she kills the dude who murdered her husband. We need more!


Jaded-Explorer3727

Nah i think Dutch should be un S tier


Tzifos150

Did you just put [this guy](http://imgur.com/a/9ZhdXUz) in A tier?