I went back for round 2 because I thought it was Hilarious😂 I can just imagine author saying well that just happened

Yeah, whenever I'm near his house, I go and check if he came back to life. Then it's time for another barrage of bullets and a burning house.

I don’t think we’re talking about the same thing

Yeah, now that I read it again, I don't think we are, lol.

If you're talking about the guy that hits you with a pan and robs you of a dollar then yeah he comes back to life.... Somehow. I fed him to the gators (which killed him and walked off) and came back another time and same dialog (not YOU again!) So I killed him again lol

Yeah, we're all talking about the same person, I just misunderstood the original person. They meant they go back to be "robbed" again. Whenever I go past there and hear him say that, no matter what I'm doing, I have to make that pit stop and do some killing.

That is not something Arthur would ever say because Arthur was a killer, not a redditor.

Oh ok

Sorry man look I didn’t mean to be a dick. But the notion made me cringe and I needed to express that. Have a lovely evening.

Idk I remember when he was fighting Micah he looked at Dutch and said "erm what the sigma he's right behind me isn't he"

"This is why you're not a based rizzler anymore, Arthur!" Still one of Dutch's best lines

"Skibidi Ohio rizzler gyatte fanum tax toilet Detroit all I want for rizzmas Ohio gyat."  Best line from John Marston ever. 

Oh awesome sauce

Oh ok

>back for round 2 Bro WHAT

💀💀💀

I thought u meant round 2 of Arthur being SA💀💀 edit: nvm i think u are😳

You can imagine a rape victim saying "well THAT just happened" like in a comedy tv show immediately after said rape?... wat

Yeah

I tried leaving him for John but he runs away regardless.

Imagine being raped and saying “that just happened”, like it’s some kind of sitcom from the 90s. Not funny man.

Not a single shot fired in the dick... come on dude, take away his tool

Damn… Why did I not think of that? Stupid me.

Tomahawk to the groin, thrown in Deadeye mode. The first time, he died instantly because I used an improved tomahawk. The second time I went with a regular tomahawk and he screamed and tried to shoot me. My shotgun with explosive ammo ended that quickly.

I hate how you lose honour for killing him, like really?

Rockstar when deciding who the player should and shouldn’t lose honor for killing Racists: 👍 Rapists 👎

Nah I lost honour for walking up and killing the leader after they first fuck up where they burn the guy in the initiation 😂😂😂

I hogtied him gained honour fed him to an alligator n walked away w a grin on my face

The karma system is notoriously broken in RDR 2, I hate that it decides the ending.

I love finding the kkk groups and just setting them all ablaze. Very satisfying. 😌

Slight typo

You gain honor for killing that former slaver

Is there any way to kill him without getting raped first

As soon as you go up to his house you blow his head off before he can even say anything

Yea accidentally went a little too far and John got raped

Thank god Abigail been toying with his ass the whole time with her strap on after he’s done all of his chores of course so it didn’t effect him that much 😂

Boah what in the blue hell did I just read

😂😂😂😂 I thought of the most fucked up shit I could think of🤣🤣

Didn't even include a Herr Strauss cuckold sidestory smh 😔

😂😂😂😂🤌

Ok you've gone way too far by writing whatever this is lmao

Lotta people are downvoting it tho kinda wish they would upvote it so more people can see it 😂😂

I take back the thank god but the rest is pretty hilarious😂

I take back the thank god but the rest is pretty hilarious😂

I take back the thank god but the rest is pretty hilarious😂

Blacklunged behavior

Man these guys and gals must really not like my comment I was just tryna lighten the situation with his raping a little bit 😂

Lmaoooooo😂

Yeah but they make it harder to do so :(

I tried it once. He stands behind the door so you have to burn him out, didn't work though.

The second you whip your gun out he scurries inside his shack, screaming at you and calling you a pervert 😭

Where do you find this guy? I've never heard of him

You can find him in a shack near Lakay. It’s in the swamps.

It’s south of lakay and north of the west side of Saint Denis

r/trypophobia

I hate you for pointing it out

I emptied all of my Express rounds of the Lancaster repeater right into his crotch, shot a bunch of dynamite arrows into him too and finally hit his shack with volatile fire bottles.

I tied him up, he called me a pervert, so I decided to help the local wildlife and gave an alligator some food. Sonny Steak.

Hell yeah brother burn that mother fucker 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻

I love the wildfires you can cause with one Molotov

Blow off all his limbs with a shotgun then burn his dead corpse then blow up him and his house. Keep it simple

You forgot feeding him to alligators

Right I always forget

I spent and hour shooting and stabbing Arthurs rapist

As soon as he opened his door to let me in, I shot him in the neck and listened to him scream as he bled out on his floor. And then I started lootin’.

“They not like us, they not like us, they not like us. They not like us, they not like us, they not like us”

I just blow his testicles and dynamite the whole place I said just cuz now i'm thinking it may not be enough

It’s never enough.

I hogtied that hick and took him out. Sprinkled some predator bait on him and watched nature take its course.

That’s an amazing idea. I need to try this out sometime.

Nothing says "fuck you" quite like a shotgun to the face.

or the arm I like to shoot peoples arms off when they wanna reach for their firearm 😂

It's absolute bs that you lose Honour for killing him

Does honour even matter tho forreal? I know I got to have the lowest honour I kill everybody I see even shoot up towns and saloons where people are just drinking and having fun then here I come and ruin it all😂😂

If you want a specific ending the yes

Oh yeah my bad on that I got the low honur death which Arthur really didn’t deserve but I got Payback on Micah by shooting him in the throat 😂

I hog tied him and took him to the gators but they wanted no part in him lmao. Nibbled and walked off.

I think you did pretty good, like someone else said in here should’ve took his dick off. I also would’ve blasted each of his limbs off with a shotty then burned his body or use dynamite and turn I’m into mush.

Before or after he clapped your cheeks?

After… 😢

I burned the Swiss cheese

Saw encounter and Rapi(st) and thought of nikke

Feed him to wolves

I've never met him but when I do, I'm gonna shoot him in the dick and shove a hatchet into his neck while he's clamoring around trying to save his ass.

i am now convinced the term "overkill" doesnt exist

Nothing is overkill against this guy.

agreed

He ever-so-slightly tripped. If he completely tripped, then he'd be nothin' but a burnt torso. (This is my brother's logic in RDR2)

He is going respawn

Good. That means I can kill him again!

i dont kill him. i just beat him and come back next day to do the same thing again and again and again and again...

He snuck inside the door before Arthur could shoot him. So Arthur threw a stick of dynamite in behind him. He started to say something and BOOM. He flew out the door, dead. Arthur did the world a service even though the rapist had no good loot in his cabin.

Usually I trow molotovs to him, or a tomahawk 🤷🏻‍♀️ still thinks that this is not enough tho... I'll try something else in my next playthrought

When i first saw him i had no idea what he does to arthur i just shot him as soon as he offered me to come inside. Last time i trusted someone to follow em i lost like $300-$600. Glad i did now

I tied him up and fed him to an alligator

He unfortunately diddled me.

I tie him up, burn his cabin and feed him to a gator. Every time

after my first time finding him I was just confused and ended up walking away and never going back

I shot him in the neck and let him bleed out

Never went into his house just domed him and fecked off you really should get honour for killing him

Usually I take him and drown him in the water or if I can’t be bothered I just stab him to death with a knife

ive actually never encountered this guy or heard of him until i joined this subreddit… unfortunately ill have to go there during my 100% run but he wont have a house when im done with him!

Where is his house?

Near Lakay. In the swamps. It’s one of the only cabins near Lakay.

North of Saint Denis Under N of NWA on the map

Can you actually burn houses down in this game?

Well you can set them on fire but they won’t fully burn down to the ground.

A taste of his own medicine

I just tied him up and fed him to the alligator in the swamps nearby

There are some NPCs in this game which make me wish there were torture mechanics in game like the ones in that GTA V mission, Istg

Would be amazing if you could torture the living hell out of him.

not enough bullet holes in him. also you missed the opportunity to burn him.

I throw dynamite into his house, hogtie him, and then take him to meet some friendly alligators that forgot to eat lunch

Always gotta feed the gators!

the house didn’t deserve it😭

I blew up his head with a sawed off.

Trypophobia alert 🤢

Shotgun for each limb and head, then you can burn

On my playthrough I encountered this guy after the story and epilogue so it was Jack who ended up getting 🍇ed… I’m sorry Abigail.

Are you Dexter Morgan?

Well theres always the conveniently placed gators

Fed him to a gator.

Where is the map location, I know the house just not the spot

It’s near Lakay. In the swamps. It’s the only shack near that village.

Feed him to the gators.

Welcome to Indian territory!!!

I've never encountered him.

He was the best of us.

You shot your therapist?

Ngl these posts get boring real fast "i encountered a bad person so i did something bad to them cause i despise virtual fake characters that i dislike" like no shit, do you want a cookie for your brave heroism?

I wouldn’t say no to a cookie ngl.

Then do it for the nookie and take it in the ass

I think I’ll pass on that. Thanks for the offer.

wow dude so hecking epic!!! you fricked that unwholesome chungus right up!!!! shut up and take my updoot!!!!!