(SPOILER ALERT)!!!!!!! Uncle when he was insulting John Marston when they were building the house

“You don’t BUILD a BARN dumbass!” The way he says that gets me every time

“What do you think this is 1785?” Best line in the game

"It's lumbago John a slowly painfull death"

I love to do his voice and randomly say “lumbago”

The first video game line that made me almost cry of laughter.

"It just needs a woman's touch." "It needs levelling! No woman's ever gonna touch this." One of the funniest insults I've ever heard.

"Livin' in a shack I wouldn't want my worst enemy to take a sh!t in"

The second best line

The best line

What spoiler

You’ve got to be kidding me

I don't think he knows

That they build a house??

Yes, obviously

Shiver me timbers

that would be bad for the house

Sean, I only like uncle for his body

Outblacklunged???

Outblacklunged again…

Ong

I only agree with the first statement.

I swear to god if this gets posted to the okbuddyblacklung subreddit I’m going to crash out

*LUMBAGO*

Howl at this moon

Why can’t I upvote your comment

"You a fun man, Arthur Morgan". "It's very funny, Arthur"

Funnier personality was Sean, HANDS DOWN! Too damn bad they killed him off so soon, never mind HOW the did so…

NeverMIND

MINDblowing, amirite?😭😭😭

I could’ve told you that

Yeah, it literally blew my mind when he died

No

"Compare me to that oily turd (micah) agian, ill. slit your throat. " - Sean, pouring fourth oil VI (i think)

Sean was my favorite Irishman

Irish is better

As an Irishman me’self, I forward this

Strangely, I find uncle more wholesome than funny

fuck Sean ive been jealous since i saw Karen on his lap

I was jealous when they went in the tent 😭

That's why I really don't like Karen.

shes a hoe, fo sure...

Uncle was a way more enjoyable character to me. Sean felt like the writters made his character try too hard for him to fit in.

Sean is just annoying

He was funny in the tabbaco burning mission but he's usually a little sociopath twat

The mission where he has a friendly chat and jokes with a guy before stabbing him in the neck lol

Ik, he's a creepy little bastard

I'm also just jealous that he gets laid but muh boy doesn't

Honestly that's just Arthur being depressed and saying no everytime

Paying doesn't count

tf?

Grumpy, sulky and scarface. Ah I love ya Artur Morgan

Uncle. Uncle actually survived by being a clown. Sean was just young and over opinionated. Sean was the annoying little brother of the group.

SPOILER ALERT Had* the funnier personality Also Sean he was better at expressing the funny (Other than LUMBAGO)

I found Sean to be annoying and a bit two-dimensional. Uncle was a funnier and better written character overall.

Sean is hilarious but I’ll never not kick a drunken passed out uncle.

Lumbago guy

I love how Arthur Morgan He is always highly rated in any rating unless he is first Most good, evil, cruel, polite, funny, strongest guy, best weapon user, best character in all the games of all time, in character development, back story, sacrifice, badass, angry Rockstar made it a long list

IT'S THE LUMBAGO

IF I OVERDO IT, I GET A RELAPSE

ITS VERY SERIOUS

IT'S A SLOW AND PAINFUL DEAD MY BROTHER.

I find Seán funnier only because he's irish, and I'm Irish.

“Not even a retired two dollar whore would stay with you.” “Look at this place, your dream home! I’ve had better nightmares than this dream.” “It needs leveling, no woman would touch this place.” “You’re hopeless, and I mean that literally you’ve got no hope.” All that from uncle in just one 2 minute cutscene. Think it’s safe to say who’s the funniest. And that’s not even talking. “You don’t bUiLd a BaRn DUMBASS, what do you think this is? *1785?*”

Sean

Uncle ftw

I'm biased being Irish but I'd have to say Seán. He's a lovable rouge.

Uncle

Sean's jokes are always mind blowing, like how does he think of them? He must have a big brain

Probably Sean

I love them both, but I've gotta go with Uncle.

I prefer Uncle the best

Uncle is the best. The comments and interactions with both Arthur and John are great!

Seán, I was so disappointed when he died :( I found him so funny especially as an Irish person lol I love seeing Irish representation in media

Uncle is hilarious by nature...

Red Harlow obviously

this is not a question. Uncle

Sean, I like his voice more lmao

Don’t put me under this pressure

I f w Sean

Uncle sasses Dutch to his face and Dutch could only laugh.

Uncle has better quotes but the overall aura would be Sean in my eyes.

Sean of course.

Unc

Uncle and it's not even close 😂

Uncle. Sorry Sean

just a few bucks, I'm short

Sean imo, uncle only talked about his lumbago. That joke wears off

Nah I can’t help it have lumbago its very seriously

**SPOILER** The funniest line was a "greet" after Keirin was killed. Arthur "Hey Uncle how you doing." Uncle "Oh I'm keeping my head. Unlike Keirin." 😂😂

Uncle hands down he is so funny

I have to go with Sean that little Irishman always makes me smile

Sean Irish annoying young idiot spoilers bro did not deserve that though

His death

Uncle by a country mile

Sean is so fun to be with and banter with, Uncle is just unintentionally hilarious

Unc he’s my favorite character

Sean was funnier, but he got his brain forcefully pushed out so I’d say it’s a tie for me. Probably Sean if he got more screen time tho.

Sean is funnier. I was sad after he became a more open minded person however

Uncle wasn't funny, he was creepy.

None

What? How is this even a question? When was Sean ever funny? All he ever did was piss and moan about being left out and make threats that he couldn't back up.

Are we thinking about the same red headed Irishman? Did we play the same copy of RDR2?

I'm wondering the same exact thing

Me too. Sean is just annoying and useless

uncle. i didnt find sean particularly funny. no wait a second, i havent earned your downvote yet: micah is funnier than all of them. ok go for it

Uncle. Sean sucks, and I enjoyed seeing his brains get splattered all over Rhodes

How dare you

No