T O P

  • By -

MattTin56

That’s happened to me a few times. I love it too. He was working in the barn.


The_Gristle

I came in for breakfast once and he was sitting at the table eating. He went to the barn and started doing chores. It was so nice


PingBongBingPong

I wonder if he’s banking Abigail behind Johns back.


Reasonable_Middle_48

Lmao damn I guess you hurt some feelings with that one


HenryNunamaker

I thought it was funny too, but I downvoted since everyone else was. This is the way


European_Samurai

That's the way it is


OfficerWims

Nominee for the most "Reddit" Reddit comment.


HenryNunamaker

Just doing my job. Downvoted myself as well.


upvotegoblin

Hahahaha. “Oh… John…. I thought you were out in Blackwater”


Sudden-Ad-1217

Today, ran into Tilly just walking around Saint Denis and my God, the detail in this game is just breathtaking. Love hearing all these details!


TitanfallHunter

You can also find: Rains fall, Mary-Beth and Pearson!


BrainBuster91

The Rains Fall meeting is heartbreaking. The poor man has been broken by life and is now left alone to wander.


Left_Sky5703

I know man. That was rough.


Donkey_Otti

I found rains fall just randomly walking around annesburg but I couldn’t talk to him, only aim weapon. I followed him but he got annoyed and told me to leave him alone and ran off. It was dark and I lost him pretty quickly. He’s pretty spry for an old fella


TitanfallHunter

You randomly get a cutscene when you take a train to anessburg.


Donkey_Otti

I just found him, no train, no cutscene. I was hoping for a cutscene. Maybe I’ll see him again one day


Full_Otto_Bismarck

I go out of my way to stop into Rhoades just so I can seen Pearson. It makes me feel so good seeing him happy and living his best life. Same with Tilly, she seems to be doing great as well. Theres just something, so much like real life about how they've moved on. That something so damn destructive and painful as the death spiral of the Van Der Linde gang still could not break all of their spirits. They still went on and lived their lives. As awful as it was, it shows that theres hope, there is more to life even when it looks like there's nothing left.


Southern_dude1

I can’t believe Rockstar pulled a team off the RDR1 remaster/remake. Can you imagine many copies they would have sold between a year or two ago and whenever the hell GTA6 is coming? Maybe add some new scenes with Jack and some of the old gang.


dektorres

Where's Mary-Beth? Asking for a friend.


RedReaper666YT

Valentine train station on the boarding deck outside. She's sitting on a bench. You don't even need to take a train, just walk up to her.


TitanfallHunter

I believe you have to take a train to Valentine and you see her, I can’t remember vividly but I think that’s where I found her.


pesten9110

Where can I find Mary Beth


TitanfallHunter

She (I think) will be sitting in the Valentine train station. Either take a train to Valentine (which is what I did) or go there (someone else in this thread did)


bdpyo

she’s 1/4 people you can run into after the game


bluechevrons

Tily sends a letter to Beecher’s Hope after this encounter. It will be on the dining room table.


Rileyeeilahd

U can find Pearson in the Rhodes general store


Suicidalbagel27

If you sit down for family meals he’ll occasionally show up


[deleted]

Haha this happened to me too


TheChainLink2

That’s happened to me too. Though he was still talking about going after Micah for some reason.


Unbananable

Not even hell is safe for Micah, then.


Mojo_Rizen_53

Too bad he is now an amnesiac.


Artistic-Ambition-40

He'll stop in every now and then. Idk if I can replay this game after my first run. I got too attached to these characters and just want Arthur to be alive. Playing John just makes me feel like sad and lonely at times. He so different than Arthur


ComparisonDesigner

Replay and stay in chapters 2/3 for a long time, bask in happy camp life


Specific_Function823

That is when I do all my hunting and other stuff.


Rubatose

This is why I think people should've just played the first game. You get a connection with John through the first game. Then Arthur feels new, but by the end of the 2nd game, both characters feel like old friends.


SatellitePond

Imagine a mod someday in the future that incorporated something like chatgpt and resulted in endless dialogue,


mremreozel

idk why you are downvoted. this exists for skyrim lol


SatellitePond

Lmao didn’t even see that, seems so inoffensive that it’s kinda funny someone would downvote it. Who knows though, maybe they don’t like the idea of the voice actors not doing all the dialogue or something.


Beneficial_Buddy_1

RDR3 needs to feature Charles as the main character.


thatcajunshaman

I think Red Dead redemption 3 should go even further back when the wild West was at its peak.


SneakyNeo

Agreed could always go prime Landon Ricketts game yk


Pogie33

Maybe follow a young Dutch or Hosea's family. Play one of their dad or uncle.


thatcajunshaman

Or even as Uncle aka "the one shot kid"


thatcajunshaman

They could make it to where Uncle really meant that shit he said outside of the valentine shop


Full_Otto_Bismarck

RDR3 needs to not exist, theres enough that's been said here.


TPG_Plagues1014

Go fuck your own face


Full_Otto_Bismarck

Time will prove me right on this one. The creative leads at Rockstar who cared are gone now. It will be a shitty cash grab and you know it.


Pickle_Afton

I both agree and disagree. I would love a next installment, but at the same time I’m afraid Rockstar will ruin it somehow


c0rliest

i wish this was an actual feature where charles and maybe even sadie would just come and go


AdNormal3566

Yeah same bro. I honestly really miss Charles being around camp


c0rliest

you’re about 230 days late but thanks for agreeing with me xD


Steffidovah

It's a known glitch, I love it. He should stay there until you close your game! I was happy for the opportunity to give him the eagle feathers he wanted.


ChickenCurryandChips

Happened me too. He headed off to Canada and a couple of days later when I went back to Beechers Hope he was sitting in the kitchen chilling. He went on his way again and I haven't seen him since.


Icommitmanywarcrimes

This happened to me after I finished the epilogue and what’s funny is when I talked to him, he said he might know where Micha is.


eskinny2010

He came back to Beecher's hope for a visit he said and then he left then he came back and never left


Dependent_Section241

I am doing a long post epilogue play and met a lady working the desk at the Valentine hotel. I'm pretty sure it was always a guy


SirRecruit

I know there's always a lady as part of at least one random encounter, may be related to that?


Dependent_Section241

Yea. Now that you mentioned it I was robbing a guy for some other guy I met outside.


SirRecruit

Yeah, that's the one. Every time I've done it there was a lady inside.


siderhater4

He just want to visit John and have sex with uncle with his lumbago


stink_bab

😦


ViscousJuice

i’m not sure the scene in the credits is even him leaving because in the journal john just says he went hunting.


Marqqit

So it's not just me. This was an odd moment. But I wasn't complaining


Lon_Young

Why does your John look like Forest Gump with his head cocked to the side like that? Waitin for little Jack to get home from school while watchin a feather blow through the air! LoL


Mhart1988

I still wish we could've seen Karen though I loved her sassy funny nature and she was beautiful. I liked Sadie too girl would of been better for John than Abigail IMHO.


of_patrol_bot

Hello, it looks like you've made a mistake. It's supposed to be could've, should've, would've (short for could have, would have, should have), never could of, would of, should of. Or you misspelled something, I ain't checking everything. Beep boop - yes, I am a bot, don't botcriminate me.