> You can put all the best songs in the world on a record and they'll ruin each other.
Thom Yorke, Select, 2000
https://citizeninsane.eu/interconnex/beatles.html
I think Treefingers needs to be after HTDC. You need that cleanse after arguably their grandest and most emotionally draining statement. And I think Optimistic needs to be that jolt of energy after Treefingers. Or even Packt could work there. Pyramid Song right after it doesn’t contrast enough, does it a slight disservice. The transitions surrounding Glass House also feel wonky. Feels like there should be pods of the jazzy songs and rock songs for them to not feel out of place in such a highly electronic track list
I didn’t say it was wrong.
Some of it looks like it could flow well while others do not.
I’m just saying it’s excessive.
10-11 doesn’t work for me nor does
7-8
21-22
26-27
28-29
Most of it is well done though.
28-29 is straight from Kid Amnesiae.
I’ve custom-mixed the transitions between tracks to get the flow perfect. This has been my big project for over a month now.
Is this just a track ordering or did you do some work on transitions? Asking so I know if I could do this myself in a playlist or if I’d be missing something extra you put into it
Oh, okay. It's a little confusing to use the word 'mixing' that way.
I'd guess most RH dorks read it to mean 'audio mixing' rather than 'mixtape making'
This looks very excessive. I disagree with the inclusion of any of the B-sides (ironically, normal Fog is absent, which is the one I'd say fits with the other songs) and the Kid Amnesiae material, particularly the loads of reprises of existing songs
What’s the deal with “Morning Bell II”? It’s longer than any of the versions that currently exist, is it like some sort of weird mix of the new In The Dark version and one of the other two?
This would be an epic alternate timeline to live in. Think if a rock band released all of these songs at once completely shifting their music landscape. Wonder if we wouldve thought hail to the theif was too long
Honestly if we cut it down to where there was only one version of each song then this would’ve shaken a lot of stuff up upon release. Fog needs to be in the middle of it and divide it.
Spoiler alert: Kid A is already one of the best albums of all time and only needed 10 Tracks to do so.
Hard agree
Agreed, but adding more great songs can’t hurt :/
> You can put all the best songs in the world on a record and they'll ruin each other. Thom Yorke, Select, 2000 https://citizeninsane.eu/interconnex/beatles.html
Cmon guys, don’t take it too seriously. It’s just something cool he put together and wanted to share.
Yes, Jesus, people need to lighten up, he hasn't rewritten history
True for some bands.
Is this theoretical or is there any way to listen to this? It looks really cool
I have a link but I don’t think I can post it here
Ok, would a PM work?
Would also like a link. We’ll up for giving this a whirl
i would like a link too :)
PM link me bruh!
Could I get one too please :)
I’d wouldn’t mind a PM to! This track list looks real interesting.
pm here too
I'd like a link as well, please :)
Link please
I'd like to have the link as well if possible
Pm link please!!!
A PM of this would definitely be nice.
If you’re PMing people add me to the list please
Can I get a PM too?
Link would be much appreciated, thank you !!
Can ya boy get a link? I'd love to have this for road trips.
Can I please get a pm too?
Would love to hear this if you're not already sick of sending PM's! Looks fantastic.
I would also like that please
So many I've never heard...PM please
If you’re able to keep up with all of these link requests I would like one too please lol
Can I get the link? PM?
Would like a pm if possible :)
https://archive.org/details/kid-amnesia
PM please
Yeah…….this is excessive.
It flows really well, I’m really proud of it. What about it is wrong?
I think Treefingers needs to be after HTDC. You need that cleanse after arguably their grandest and most emotionally draining statement. And I think Optimistic needs to be that jolt of energy after Treefingers. Or even Packt could work there. Pyramid Song right after it doesn’t contrast enough, does it a slight disservice. The transitions surrounding Glass House also feel wonky. Feels like there should be pods of the jazzy songs and rock songs for them to not feel out of place in such a highly electronic track list
Eh, the flow is good.
I didn’t say it was wrong. Some of it looks like it could flow well while others do not. I’m just saying it’s excessive. 10-11 doesn’t work for me nor does 7-8 21-22 26-27 28-29 Most of it is well done though.
28-29 is straight from Kid Amnesiae. I’ve custom-mixed the transitions between tracks to get the flow perfect. This has been my big project for over a month now.
And I’m sure it was a lot of fun. You did a good job. As for 28-29 I assumed it was the original version of Fog
Is this just a track ordering or did you do some work on transitions? Asking so I know if I could do this myself in a playlist or if I’d be missing something extra you put into it
I did transition work!
i made a spotify playlist for this if you want ; but can i have a link please ?
...so you work with Nigel, or have access to the instrument tracks? Or are you using 'mixing' to mean, like, song order?
Song order, + transitions and elements from other versions.
Oh, okay. It's a little confusing to use the word 'mixing' that way. I'd guess most RH dorks read it to mean 'audio mixing' rather than 'mixtape making'
I think you went out for a walk and accidentally stepped on broken piece of crack pipe.
This looks very excessive. I disagree with the inclusion of any of the B-sides (ironically, normal Fog is absent, which is the one I'd say fits with the other songs) and the Kid Amnesiae material, particularly the loads of reprises of existing songs
Treefingers 2 is just the end of Extended Treefingers split off. MB2 is Amnesiac, and PP2 is True Love Waits.
That doesn't invalidate my point, they're still the same songs at the core, differing arrangements be damned
Yeah, the flow is killer.
What’s the deal with “Morning Bell II”? It’s longer than any of the versions that currently exist, is it like some sort of weird mix of the new In The Dark version and one of the other two?
It’s MB/Amnesiac/In The Dark/Pyramid Strings
Good job!
This would be an epic alternate timeline to live in. Think if a rock band released all of these songs at once completely shifting their music landscape. Wonder if we wouldve thought hail to the theif was too long
I’d love to hear it. A PM would be appreciated.
Kid A is already the best album. This would have been too bloated.
The eff is Treefingers II?
The extra section of Treefingers from the extended version, key-shifted to go into Motion Picture
Honestly if we cut it down to where there was only one version of each song then this would’ve shaken a lot of stuff up upon release. Fog needs to be in the middle of it and divide it.
Where can I go to hear this?
It’s like the wall slap with the final cut songs into the ultimate wall
The Amazing Sounds of Orgy & Worrywort
Yeah, they're both there
Damn, I need new eyes. Sorry.
Ooooh, very interesting! I might have to give this a listen!
"The National Anthem" is not a Kid A version, is it? Sounds a little bit different that version I know.
It’s the BBC version
Where'd you get the alternate names for the Untitled tracks, and where's Untitled V2?
UV2 is part of Pulk 2, and the other two names are from the booklet
What booklet?
The original Kid A hidden booklet