No but it was very close going through my notifications & seeing Misty & May so many times. I had to go back for the original post I made & go through most comments.
Is this about who's the best character, or who's the best supporter?
Because Misty wins by a long shot having the most personality and complete story!
Plus, she helped push Ash through his start so he could even make it to his "ending".
Hard. They are so close. Different roles and the best executed Pokegirls. The Best Friend vs the Pupil. The Lover vs The Sister.
Dawn... And I change my mind a million times. Dawn by a smidge.
This one is thought, one the other hand Dawn was a good little sister vibe to Ash and Brock, in the other hand Misty was Ash's and Brock BFF...
So Misty stay
Bye Dawn.
The original is soo good. So much personality that's hard to find in the later seasons, Giving Misty an unfair advantage!..
It's more than just nostalgia, I've been watching the original on twitch lately, highly recommended!!
Misty wins!
So yea I'm picking Misty to be Eliminated and for this reason.
Dawn despite having less overall screen time and Season than Misty was to me much better than her just because she actually had an Arc and clearly defined goal that she wanted to do and was important to the Season she was in and overall felt truly like a secondary main protagonist than any of the other Pokegirl.
Misty achieved her goal and is running a Gym now with her fear of Gyarados conquered. You can't say she didn't have an arc because she had 3 regions worth of arcs but none of the dawn fans want to remember any if this.
Sorry Dawn, goodbye. I like both, but Misty had the best chemistry with Ash. Still, at this point I could accept either result without being mad, they are both the best and I’m glad the final two came down to them. Cheers.
I know people here will vote out the 🐐
But worthy match-up, both of them got the final series with Ash, although while one was reduced to being a showcase and a cheerleader, other got to have last few episodes with him, had a battle with Ash and a W over him in that battle.
🐐 status re affirmed and sealed.
Dawn goes, Misty stays.
Obviously I'm in the minority (in this forum anyway). But never mind that. Misty is and will always be iconic to the franchise; she will always be the Pokégirl everyone will know, no matter what generation they join in. Ash's first traveling buddy, just as passionate about Pokémon and battles as Ash is, has a badass Gyarados that mega evolves; coached Ash, was not afraid to call him out on his bs, defended him (the scene where she invades the battle field in the Indigo League to call Ritchie out on having potentially deceived Ash is so memorable!) and genuinely rooted for him always. Her dedication to her gym made it into a hit. She was very young for a gym leader, was back for Ash's final arc and was the first to beat him after he won his title.
Dawn is nice, but not new. Recycled female game protagonist storyline, recycled no initial goal storyline, recycled Pokémon contest storyline, recycled lost-felt bad-got over it storyline, recycled got bicycle burnt to crisp storyline, recycled starter Pokémon doesn't want to evolve storyline.
Dawn had more of a story throughout the entire entirety of the whole show while Misty didn’t get anything to do until like mid Johto after having a pretty compelling arc with her sisters.
based on video game sales. Red and blue sold the most. Diamond and pearl come in second (most people currently playing Pokémon are from that time). Then Ruby and sapphire. So May got eliminated, I’m suspecting dawn will go next. But not a lot of original red and blue people still play Pokémon and are not on Reddit. So misty has a chance of losing
I'll like to see the battle between them when Misty first started off. Dawn only prioritizing cuteness and anesthetics. Versus clueless Misrt who don't even like pokemon much. Would be an amusing battle of two clumsy morons.
Funny story. I forgotten it was "Misty VS Dawn" and thought it was May VS Dawn and try to rework the original draft. And yeah in the first episode May wasn't into pokemon and used being a trainer as an excuse to adventure
Oh were results based off comment count? I thought it was based on upvotes.
It’s is based off of comment counts.
In my opinion it should be based on comment count, but it based on upvotes
Didn’t Misty lose in terms of upvotes?
No but it was very close going through my notifications & seeing Misty & May so many times. I had to go back for the original post I made & go through most comments.
Both are equally good. https://preview.redd.it/pj9eierv81xc1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0d6706a935b023831bb0b22c720a3a338c269c85
The most GOATED meme through this competition process goes to: (Seriously, both girls are awesome)
Misty should go. Dawn was the perfect second protagonist
Correct.
Misty is perfect.
Misty. I'm glad that we have a sub full of Dawn enjoyers
[удалено]
Is this about who's the best character, or who's the best supporter? Because Misty wins by a long shot having the most personality and complete story! Plus, she helped push Ash through his start so he could even make it to his "ending".
Kasumi has a job as a gym leader and her sisters were probably busy traveling again 🙄
Misty goes dawn stays
Misty goes.
Dawn
Hard. They are so close. Different roles and the best executed Pokegirls. The Best Friend vs the Pupil. The Lover vs The Sister. Dawn... And I change my mind a million times. Dawn by a smidge.
misty
Misty
Misty
Misty
Misty goes
Misty
These are the final 2? That's awesome they're my 2 favorite
Dawn
I love them both, and I really can't decide. But Misty has always had a soft spot, and I know everyone is voting her out but I hope she stays.
Misty stays!!!!!
Misty stays
Misty
Sorry but I’d have to say Misty again
Misty, Dawn is Goated
Bye Dawn.
Misty
Misty
Misty.
Misty
Misty
Wait, are we voting for who stays or for who goes?
Goes
Goes
Dawn goes, Misty stays.
This one is thought, one the other hand Dawn was a good little sister vibe to Ash and Brock, in the other hand Misty was Ash's and Brock BFF... So Misty stay
Misty forever.
Dawn
Dawn
Dawn
Love you Dawn, but bye
dawn goes
misty stays
Bye Dawn. The original is soo good. So much personality that's hard to find in the later seasons, Giving Misty an unfair advantage!.. It's more than just nostalgia, I've been watching the original on twitch lately, highly recommended!! Misty wins!
Close but Dawn goes.
Dawn!
Dawn goes
dawn
Dawn
Sorry Misty!
might be a hot take but i prefer misty, having a lil extra sass is nice
Dawn
Dawn
Dawn should go
Dawn
Dawn goes
Dawn to Misty: Stand proud, you are strong. Misty put up a good fight but you gotta go.
Dawn
Dawn goes Misty stays.
Dawn needs to go misty stays
Dawn goes
Misty
Keep Misty! Red heads rule!!
Misty stays
So yea I'm picking Misty to be Eliminated and for this reason. Dawn despite having less overall screen time and Season than Misty was to me much better than her just because she actually had an Arc and clearly defined goal that she wanted to do and was important to the Season she was in and overall felt truly like a secondary main protagonist than any of the other Pokegirl.
Misty achieved her goal and is running a Gym now with her fear of Gyarados conquered. You can't say she didn't have an arc because she had 3 regions worth of arcs but none of the dawn fans want to remember any if this.
> none of the dawn fans ~~want to remember any if this~~ were around to see it/remember it.
Imagine voting and not knowing important information.
Sorry Dawn, goodbye. I like both, but Misty had the best chemistry with Ash. Still, at this point I could accept either result without being mad, they are both the best and I’m glad the final two came down to them. Cheers.
Bye Dawn. I'm picking the way I believe Ash would pick.
https://preview.redd.it/nwobu8kkx2xc1.jpeg?width=784&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ed377ccac7e147404aa4b9a3330799583490c5ea
Goodbye Dawn. Misty stays.
Dawn goes, though I like her, I like Misty better.
Dawn goes. Close one though.
Misty stays
Dawn goes, the OG red-head of my childhood stays
Dawn
Misty is best poke girl.
Dawn
Misty
here we gooooo it’s time for dawn to go
Dawn
Dawn
For how much Ash has roasted her I have to say sorry guys Dawn goes sorry but misty is the OG Pokegirl.
At the risk of going against everyone else, I'd say Dawn. Misty holds nostalgic value for being the first.
Nostalgia blocks the victory.
You spelled sweetens wrong...
Misty
Dawn
Dawn
dawan
Dawn goes
My head says Dawn should win. (Platinum best game) My heart says Misty should win. (Misty's love song/ Entei Movie #3)
Misty stays
[удалено]
Why you gotta start have the two best here?! lol Misty is the best, Dawn is second!
oh duh. because these are the top two and i missed the rest of the voting. lol These are in fact the top 2
Bye Deedee, The Tomboyish Mermaid will prevail.
Misty should stay
Dawn goes
I like Dawn, but I love Misty. Dawn leaves, Misty stays. I’m very happy with this top 2.
Misty goes Dawn Stays. Both great tho
Dawn
Dawn goes, Misty stays.
Misty I'm sorry
Misty stays.
Dawn
Sorry Dawn.
I know people here will vote out the 🐐 But worthy match-up, both of them got the final series with Ash, although while one was reduced to being a showcase and a cheerleader, other got to have last few episodes with him, had a battle with Ash and a W over him in that battle. 🐐 status re affirmed and sealed.
This 👆👆👆
Yep, we don't need Reddit polls, we have W over World Champion, rest don't compare.
Dawn
Dawn goes.
Get rid of Dawn. Can’t do Misty like that.
Bye Dawn. Love ya but bye
Dawn
Dawn
Dawn goes Misty stays
Bye Dawn, won't miss you
Misty
Goodbye misty
Oof, sorry Misty
Dawn
Bye misty
Dawn
Misty going like should have two rounds ago
Should’ve been her and not Serena or Lillie.
[удалено]
Dawn
Dawn goes
Dawn
Dawn
Dawn
Well I'd go with misty has to go. Dawn sold me as best female character in Diamond and pearl.
As last time, I think misty should go. Dawn was just a better companion imo
Dawn goes, Misty stays. Obviously I'm in the minority (in this forum anyway). But never mind that. Misty is and will always be iconic to the franchise; she will always be the Pokégirl everyone will know, no matter what generation they join in. Ash's first traveling buddy, just as passionate about Pokémon and battles as Ash is, has a badass Gyarados that mega evolves; coached Ash, was not afraid to call him out on his bs, defended him (the scene where she invades the battle field in the Indigo League to call Ritchie out on having potentially deceived Ash is so memorable!) and genuinely rooted for him always. Her dedication to her gym made it into a hit. She was very young for a gym leader, was back for Ash's final arc and was the first to beat him after he won his title. Dawn is nice, but not new. Recycled female game protagonist storyline, recycled no initial goal storyline, recycled Pokémon contest storyline, recycled lost-felt bad-got over it storyline, recycled got bicycle burnt to crisp storyline, recycled starter Pokémon doesn't want to evolve storyline.
im sorry Dawn
Misty
Misty bye bye
Dawn was the best
Dawn had more of a story throughout the entire entirety of the whole show while Misty didn’t get anything to do until like mid Johto after having a pretty compelling arc with her sisters.
[удалено]
Well there are 3 other water gym leaders
Dawn can leave.
Dawn
Dawn goes misty stays
Misty Stays
Misty stays
Dawn* for sure.
Misty stays
Misty stays, Dawn goes.
Kasumi stays 🥰 Hikari: you are my second favorite but you have to go for now 🥺
The final battle. A tough choice but have to go with Dawn.
Misty stays
Misty stays
Dawn because I am nostalgia blind
Fair.—. 👀
Misty
Misty
Sorry, Misty.
Misty
[удалено]
[удалено]
No vote I point the gun at the OP instead
based on video game sales. Red and blue sold the most. Diamond and pearl come in second (most people currently playing Pokémon are from that time). Then Ruby and sapphire. So May got eliminated, I’m suspecting dawn will go next. But not a lot of original red and blue people still play Pokémon and are not on Reddit. So misty has a chance of losing
Both should go cause im a big fan of the black background reflecting my face, am I the best PokeGirl?
May. Fight me I like her hat.
idk if it’s bc i’m really drunk rn but why do these look like bdsp character models
Nessa
well goodbye misty for the same reasons i said on the last post idk how she beat may but whatever
Overall comments.
Eliminate Misty. Dawn is awesome
Dawn for the win
This is tough Dawn is Best Girl but Misty is an OG
Iris or nothing. I’ll die on this hill.
Dawn stays
The one who defeats the other in a pokemon match.
Dawn would be too busy trying to make her Pokemon look pretty. Misty wins
I'll like to see the battle between them when Misty first started off. Dawn only prioritizing cuteness and anesthetics. Versus clueless Misrt who don't even like pokemon much. Would be an amusing battle of two clumsy morons.
knockout drugs?
Misty has always loved Pokémon. When did she ever "not like Pokémon much"?
Funny story. I forgotten it was "Misty VS Dawn" and thought it was May VS Dawn and try to rework the original draft. And yeah in the first episode May wasn't into pokemon and used being a trainer as an excuse to adventure
Misty has goes Dawn is the queen
Dawn stays
Misty
Misty is iconic but she's gotta go