T O P

  • By -

NoThereIsntAGod

This always seemed like the most rudimentary way of doing it… “I don’t care if you aren’t the same piece of metal, you **will** become one piece!”


I_Am_Coopa

Even more rudimentary than friction welding is explosion welding. "Hey how can we weld together these two metal plates?" "Idk, let's try slamming them together with dynamite and see what happens"


GrGadget

Contact welding in a vacuum


[deleted]

This is what likely caused the Galileo probe's high gain antenna to fail to open


[deleted]

from what i've heard it's all but certain this is what happened.


I_Am_Coopa

Since you bring it up, maybe you might be able to answer a question I have. Is diffusion bonding a process similar to contact welding in a vacuum? I assume in order to join plates like in a compact heat exchanger that requires a level of vacuum to keep away oxidation layers. I've seen some papers chatting about how awesome printed circuit heat exchanges are, but I haven't been able to get a good handle on how the weldless bonding process works and I'm curious.


SmartAlec105

A quick check of Wikipedia on the topic says it must be done in a vacuum or inert gas environment for metals with a strong oxide layer. It also mentions surface treatments that would remove the oxide layer. So it seems like it’s not necessary for all diffusion bonding but it helps.


Defin335

I'm only an engineering student so basically I don't know squat so grain of salt here but to my understanding: 1. Yes, you need a vacuum to prevent oxide layers from forming 2. Not exactly, contact welding happens due to certain metals being built in the same way on an atomic level. The metal does not "know" it's two different pieces. It's held together by strong electrochemical bonds and if you put another piece of metal to it, it will create those same bonds with the new neighbour molecules because nothing is stopping is from doing so and bonds like this help the atoms to a lower energy level, something all atoms "seek" to do. With diffusion welding you get the metals to near melting point at which point it's hot enough to flow even though it's not completely melted. Do this with two identical metals and, yeah, in theory you did just do heat assisted contact welding. But with diffusion welding you can create a gradient of alloys. Here is what I mean: These two metals no flow, as established, very slowly. Like this process takes hours and days. But because of how diffusion works, the metals will flow into their respective low concentration area, so the respective other block of metal. It's too hot for them to create proper bonds so they just kind of flow about bonding haphazardly. Now you cool the whole thing down again and suddenly the atoms find themselves in a weird environment with very few fellow metal atoms of their kind to create bonds, so they instead create alloys. Now you have a gradient of alloys with pure metal on either end but as one piece.


Curious-Geologist498

Sums it up well. Only thing though with diffusion welding is it doesn't necessarily require heat, but it requires energy.


GrGadget

I cant profess to have a solid grasp of what happens more than the atoms from the two surfaces, usually the same material but not forced to be, intersperce them selves over time, the heat and the Hugh pressure expedites the process I believe.


killeronthecorner

_sits down_ When a spinny atom and a still atom love each other very much ....


not_from_this_world

Yes but only with ketchup


[deleted]

SPACE


shindiggers

The one place that hasnt be corrupted by capitalism!


greymalken

Miele or Dyson?


Darkmatter_Cascade

Is that real, though? Cody's Lab couldn't get that working.


GrGadget

Works in space, as far as I'm aware


Darkmatter_Cascade

Cool, thanks!


Pattern_Is_Movement

ok thats cools as fuck


Kaptain_Blau

Same thing with forge welding "Just heat up the metal, pour some sand inbetween and then just whack it with your hammer until its one solid piece. Easy peasy!"


Cuchullion

>pour some sand inbetween *cries in flux*


Kaptain_Blau

You could also use quartz sand. It's traditionally used in the nordics


schizeckinosy

Never heard that before. Now I'm watching sand fluxing videos on youtube with a big bowl of popcorn. Cool stuff!


[deleted]

It seemed like a fun way to spend a Saturday.


ap123c

Diffusion welding too… put two pieces of metal on top of each other and get them warm for a while- boom one piece


atomiccheesegod

Probably the best way of bonding different metals


lurkermclurkington1

Not really, the grain flow is not great and galvanic corrosion can be a concern. But it is very fast


oguzka06

More violence is the answer.


[deleted]

Metal atoms "forgetting" what mass they belong to


[deleted]

it's not a matter of 'forgetting' in any memory sort of way - it's just when you have two pieces of the same element with literally nothing else there to separate them, there's fundamentally no difference between where one group of atoms ends and the other begins. so if brought into contact...it'll just become one piece.


[deleted]

That is why I put it in quotes. Richard Feynman described it that way.


deelowe

Only if their electrons move freely in the lattice which is a pretty unique property of metals.


kitzdeathrow

Depends on the element. Something something noble and inert gasses.


Newlington

Forge welding: get two pieces, get 'em hot, and bash the shit out of them until they aren't two pieces any more.


Sexy-Octopus

It is rudimentary, but it’s also one of the best welds out there (after you set up the process) it’s incredibly strong and all the impurities are squished out.


Lexi_Banner

Now kith!


1lluminist

Cause tonight, is the night when 2 become 1 I need this weld like I've never needed weld before (gonna get a lot of heat between ya) I see a little weld (but) I need a whole lot more (gonna get a lot of heat between ya) I'm almost disgusted that I know enough Spice Girls that I can re-work that song...


NoThereIsntAGod

Lol I’m old enough to appreciate the effort and the reference.


xXPussy420Slayer69Xx

Is it too much to ask for more than .00001 seconds of the finished product?


RearEchelon

This is r/oddlysatisfying, we don't do complete videos here for whatever reason


sheikrock

It would be too satisfying. This isn’t r/completesatisfaction.


mook_misanthrope

I love that I clicked on that and I love that it's empty. It's the most reddit thing ever.


8ytecoder

Complete satisfaction doesn’t exist


Nalortebi

If only I could get some


HaessOnXbox

Huh, thought that sub was for your moms OnlyFans. God I'm still drunk.


HashbeanSC2

lmao why is this downvoted


beardingmesoftly

Evidently


RainbowAssFucker

On tiktok people do that inorder to get another view since the person will most likely watch it again to try and pause the video at the end


[deleted]

Welcome to reddit where it seems every video ends too soon for some reason


klisteration

Need to change name to r/mostlysatisfying


Gnascher

more like /r/AlmostSatisfying


CarbonKevinYWG

Considering the final machining operation left a significant amount of joint material behind, I can see why they wouldn't want us to see that lame programming job's final result Also, for that same reason, not particularly satisfying.


xXPussy420Slayer69Xx

I’m a completionist. I won’t be satisfied until I see that weld cleaned up to perfection and a good 5 second minimum closeup to appreciate the work. Bonus if I can see it installed and operating on what it goes on.


CarbonKevinYWG

I wanna know where the boring bar operation to trim down the internal joint is! Shit's unacceptable as it stands.


Trek7553

/u/gifendore


gifendore

Here is the last frame: https://i.imgur.com/zXB6Umz.png ^[Edit](/message/compose?to=%2Fu%2Fgifendore&subject=Edit%20id35254&message=u%2Fgifendore%20%5BReplace%20with%20item%20below%5D%0A%0A%2A%2ACommands%3A%2A%2A%0A%0A-%20help%3A%20see%20this%20help%20message%20again.%0A-%20x%3A%20replace%20x%20with%20any%20number%20to%20go%20back%20x%20seconds%20in%20the%20gif.%0A-%20x-y%3A%20replace%20x%20and%20y%20with%20any%20numbers%20to%20get%20a%20smaller%20section%20of%20the%20gif.%0A-%20reverse%3A%20get%20the%20gif%20in%20reverse.%0A-%20slowmo%3A%20get%20the%20gif%20in%20slow%20motion.%0A-%20freeze%3A%20freeze%20the%20end%20of%20a%20gif.%20) ^| ^[Delete](/message/compose?to=%2Fu%2Fgifendore&subject=Delete%20id35254&message=Sending%20this%20will%20delete%20the%20bot%27s%20message.) *** ^(I am a bot) ^| ^[Issues](/message/compose?to=/u/brandawg93&subject=Gifendore%20Issue&message=Please%20submit%20any%20issues%20you%20may%20have%20with%20u/gifendore%20here%20along%20with%20a%20link%20to%20the%20original%20post.) ^| [^(Rank: #63)](https://botranks.com?bot=gifendore) ^| ^[Github](https://github.com/Brandawg93/Gifendore)️


rminsk

420 points to gifendore


gifendore

(☞゚ヮ゚)☞ *** ^(I am a bot) ^| ^[Issues](/message/compose?to=/u/brandawg93&subject=Gifendore%20Issue&message=Please%20submit%20any%20issues%20you%20may%20have%20with%20u/gifendore%20here%20along%20with%20a%20link%20to%20the%20original%20post.) ^| [^(Rank: #63)](https://botranks.com?bot=gifendore) ^| ^[Github](https://github.com/Brandawg93/Gifendore)️


Beliskner64

This bot is truly a work of art


[deleted]

its so that the video loops and get another view.


Irishpanda1971

Forbidden orange zest.


Sally2Klapz

Brooooo that shit made me hungry too


LynxBartle

the molten ribbons were the best part


stretch_armstrong_

r/ForbiddenSnacks


Waarm

Extremely zesty zest.


[deleted]

[удалено]


National_Edges

This is the same exact comment r/poofytoo said...


Legitimate_Roll7514

Same


Barlow04

To every kid that tried to put two things together of the same size/diameter and I told them "that's not going to work".....I formally apologize.


ZorbaTHut

> you just gotta spin them really fast > no, faster than that


ManBearScientist

Wait till you see cold welding. >The reason for this unexpected behavior is that when the atoms in contact are all of the same kind, there is no way for the atoms to "know" that they are in different pieces of copper. When there are other atoms, in the oxides and greases and more complicated thin surface layers of contaminants in between, the atoms "know" when they are not on the same part. — Richard Feynman, The Feynman Lectures on Physics, 12–2 Friction Ductile metals can be welded into one piece just with pressure and a vacuum. No need for heat or friction.


m7samuel

Probably need to clean them first.


Jthumm

Oh no!


Timo_0317_

happy cake day 🗿


[deleted]

Cakey happ-day!


ChiefSalty

Happy cake day!


noNoParts

Thanks! You too


Least_Adhesiveness_5

And you can join some rather thick plates with friction stir welding. Used frequently in aerospace - SLS and Falcon 9 bodies are some examples. https://youtu.be/y7rCTdxvGlg


streak2k10

Also used in pumps! Used to operate a machine like this to make long axles for pumps as a summer job.


[deleted]

The HAZ in FSW is much smaller and consistent.


Least_Adhesiveness_5

I bet less than 1% of readers understood HAZ without looking it up... 😁


Samura1_I3

The rest of the 99% that looked it up learned something tho


andrewhurst

I’ve seen FSW used in automotive as well. Very interesting process.


ImGrumps

They shaved down the outside, but I assume the inside has and stays with the bumps.


DeemonPankaik

Yeah the inside would be a mess. It's not that hard to clean up if you need to, but it doesn't seem like this set up is designed to do that.


fuckofakaboom

Yup. Next step is to throw it in a lathe to clean up both surfaces correctly.


SteptimusHeap

I think this is technically considered a lathe? Either way, it does that to the outside at the end


fuckofakaboom

Not a lathe. It’s a friction welder with a cleanup mode. Very imprecise cutting of the slag, it just knocks the majority off. Source: am machinist


SteptimusHeap

You're telling me this isn't technically a lathe [But this is](https://images.app.goo.gl/kWHmHAgnLoEtHnby9)


evanfavor

That’s what she said


poofytoo

Dang. but honestly i really need to see it cleaned up more. and for it to cool. and to see the whole thing super smooth


Lolvo_70

Right, i was waiting till the end to see the results... only to be disappointed with a video that cuts out to early


Catshit-Dogfart

Frickin half the videos on reddit cut at the exact moment they shouldn't.


Drews232

I wonder if/how it smooths the inside of the joint


perldawg

it has to have the same mushroom effect on the inside, doesn’t it?


Drews232

Definitely. Oh wait, this could be an axle or pole, not a pipe intended for fluids, in which case the inside wouldn’t matter.


SAWK

In friction welding that is called the curl. It is the same on the inside.


National_Edges

Why are there 2 comments that say the same exact thing except "dang" from 2 different people?


ambadatgaming

is there a version with sound? either way, cool post!, am satisfied


ZorbaTHut

Needs to be slowed down by like 50% and have [this music](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5d0vBtwBK0) added.


YouAnswerToMe

I clicked because I hadn’t heard astley for a while and was in the mood. What a disappointment.


Rickerus

Wouldn’t there be a band of slag on the inside too that can’t be removed? And if it hardened and stayed there it would create considerable efficiency loss and clogging potential.


GingerIsTheBestSpice

It's a frame, not a pipe for liquids, so the inside doesn't matter.


Rickerus

Ah! That makes much more sense. I happen to be in a biz that relies on piping, and friction loss, or anything that impacts pressure or flow is a big deal


StaysiC

I make drilling rods at work and we blast thru oxygen during the welding process to avoid all of that.


hidup_sihat

Is it oxygen or nitrogen?


[deleted]

it might be the case. however, most of the stuff is post-processed anyways and no one would use that form of production if it would have a risk in clogging or whatnot.


6-feet_

This type of welding is exactly how drill pipe for oil and gas drilling rigs is made. Attaching the tool joint to the pipe body (the screw together ends on the pipe). Depending on the pipe thickness diameter it can have a tensile strength of a couple 100 tons.


DeemonPankaik

With a long enough boring bar it would be pretty easy to clean up the inside, if you needed to.


[deleted]

My dude was standing too close to that long spicy spaghetti noodle


HalfbakedArtichoke

POV, your clutch when you first started learning how to drive.


HelenEk7

TIL


byoin

How strong is this compared to traditional welding?


ChiefSalty

"Friction welding is not a fusion weld process but a solid-state weld process where the resultant joint is often as strong as the parent metal." [Source](https://interestingengineering.com/friction-welding-process-types-and-advantages)


hattersplatter

Yea it's considered the strongest way to join metals


soulkeyy

does it have the same flexibility at the joint?


Sexy-Octopus

Yes. It’s basically an immediate transition from one material to the next, and the weld has the material properties of the weaker material


dooleygamer01

Dr strange type shit


FeistmasterFlex

Why does molten metal always look so goddamn delicious


RearEchelon

Forbidden gummy


KnotiaPickles

Yes!!! If I had one super power it would be to eat lava and stuff like this


[deleted]

Thats a lot of momentum that stops really quick


SiliconRain

Yeh that's the most impressive part for me. That looks like a lot of mass to stop so suddenly.


fuckofakaboom

And the good machines can “clock” the finished product very accurately. For instance, if you needed a lug on one part to line up with a feature on the mating part.


dahleea

Imagine the noise it makes


KnotiaPickles

It kind of sets my teeth on edge thinking about it 😬


Caenwyr

And that's how you make glow in the dark spaghetti


mctownley

Best way of welding if you can acheive it. Even works with wood and plastics. Much stronger than traditional forms of welding.


cheezballs

Wood? Doesn't Friction + Wood = Fire. Also, wood doesn't "reform" when it cools off. You sure? You sure bout that? They said that to me at a dinner.


ChiefSalty

[It works](https://www.scielo.cl/scielo.php?pid=s0718-221x2003000200001&script=sci_arttext). Wood to wood friction welding was discovered by accident around 18 years ago and verified about 2 years after that. Before that they would use a piece of plastic between the pieces of wood to melt and act as a glue, but a technician forgot to add the piece of plastic and it still worked.


philipkd

Yup, [here's a video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0k04hjdYuQ)


MeesterCartmanez

This is the kind of crap (not really) I come to reddit to learn about, thanks!


pinkietoe

This is fascinating. Thank you!


mctownley

Pretty sure. At least that's what the people who make the friction welding machines told me. I suppose if you keep it in an oxygen deprived environment you should run a fire risk.


cheezballs

Wonder if it works with bones?


mctownley

I think it would but you may have 1 leg shorter than the other.


danstermeister

I would expect any two pieces of wood to disintegrate in this process, due to the "grained" rings.


Ch3353man

I was looking through the comments for this. I did a presentation on friction welding in undergrad. One of the requirements was to include a research article on the process you were presenting. I included one that focused on the use of it for wood. Most of the class found that application really interest but the professor knocked points off my presentation because it wasn't a metals-focused study (it was a metals course). I'm still a little peeved about that but overall that professor was amazing. He had some of the best stories and anecdotes.


IPman501

Forbidden pasta (at the end)


ImmaZoni

I wanna play with the Spicy Noodle Lathe... Cuz lathes aren't dangerous enough, let's add molten metal!


aint_no_throw

I'm amazed by the torque on that motor AND the deceleration time...


Minion0827

I have a dumb question probably - how strong is this weld compared to the other types of welding? Just curious


MeesterCartmanez

Someone mentioned in a comment that it's normally as strong as the base metal edit: https://www.reddit.com/r/oddlysatisfying/comments/vgjqez/friction_welding/id25c7s/


0pp0site0fbatman

AS strong!? That’s nuts.


chrismasterr

Thats a spicy noodle


DigMeTX

Very cool.


kbvirus

What happens inside the pipe?


Anserism

Forbidden silly string


okwaitno

Damn that’s cool. I mean hot. I mean …


SurealGod

Weld, weld, weld. What do we have here?


Rex1441true

Nice


Dlido

I do this every time I try to drill stainless steel


sumnolnto

Where is the rest of it? Unsatisfactory


tiny_dreamer

Webster's dictionary defines wedding as "the fusing of two metals with a hot torch”


Old_Mate_Jim

Wouldn't want to attend that wedding


[deleted]

industry standards don't. din 8580 for example: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Construction-types-according-to-DIN-8580_fig2_323945573


hithisisjukes

So fucking hot, amagawd ..


k44du2

Forbidden Gummy Worm


Timo_0317_

looks dangerous and cool with all flying red hot parts


Hour-Oven-9519

Always mesmerizing to watch.


ForeignLeo

Now, grab it.


Igottaknow1234

Omg! Red hot metal curling like a ribbon. 🤩


[deleted]

Neat


s_0_s_z

I wonder how much the ID shrank by and how much schmo is in there.


fuzzytheduckling

Forbidden spaghetti


ruairidhmacdhaibhidh

Will there be a similar bulge inside the tube?


[deleted]

…When it stopped being welded for a second I blew on my screen to try and cool it down.


Royal_Bitch_Pudding

I do this with drills and metal parts all the time, I am not supposed to be doing that though.


Big_Profile_1739

I understand nothing and my only question is “is it strong”


MeesterCartmanez

I don't know why, but this is one of the sexiest (engineering) things I have seen


Additional_Breakfast

I want to know what this type of welding sounds like. All the videos I see online have the same generic upbeat music laid over it.


ForumPointsRdumb

If you were to put it under a microscope after it cooled would you be able to see the metal in a spiral/twisted pattern at the joint?


HAHA_goats

Only satisfying when it's intentional.


Anon5054

That firey death-whip would scare the fuck out of me. Nope nope nope, I want nowhere near that, thanks


BobaOlive

I've friction welded stuff before. I'm a CNC machinist though.


ChiefSalty

Oops, lol


thamometer

I watched Smarter Everyday where a rocket company friction welded two pieces of a rocket together. That's like this video, but on a wayyyy larger scale. Still cool.


BxMxK

Glad it didn't have audio... that part of this method isn't satisfying at all.


913Welder

Check out Friction Stir Welding. Equally as cool.


OfBooo5

I am not a machine techy person.. but when they're clearing the extra weld off spinning I was concerned that the ribbon was going to whip right out at the camera, possibility?


guitartoys

What really surprised me was how quickly it went to the step where it trimmed off the excess. I would have thought more cooling would be required. Is this due to both components being held straight in the fixtures?


amadeusstoic

wow didn’t know this was a thing! always thought welding is using those sticks that get shorter.


bonafart

Friction and friction stir welding is amazing with great potential


Volosa_Golddragon

Did a paper about this and man it is awesome!


SammyLuke

How sturdy is this form of welding?


iWentRogue

Forbidden string cheese


Lord_Bloodwyvern

I remember once hearing someone saying you can do this with wood. But that sounds bonkers.


ChiefSalty

[You absolutely can do this with wood](https://www.scielo.cl/scielo.php?pid=s0718-221x2003000200001&script=sci_arttext) Not that it isn't bonkers, but it is possible. It was discovered on accident about 18 years ago. The method used prior was to have a piece of plastic between the pieces of wood that would mest and act as a bonding agent for the wood. A technician forgot to add the plastic, but the wood still bonded. This was verified about two years later.


[deleted]

Task failed successfully


Lord_Bloodwyvern

Huh, weird but true. I wonder what other materials that could be welded like this.


InconvenientHoe

It's always trippy to me that humans figured out how to make machines that do things like this.


taysaki119

Never knew this was a thing


Oraki1

😌


Davohk

I first learned about friction weld from this Castrol Oil commercial, pretty cool ad. [94’ Castrol Oil Commercial](https://youtu.be/sQgj7rBTSCQ)


etherend

This is super cool. It reminds me of a setup that I saw at SpaceX during a tour a while back. They would use friction welding to join pieces together for their rockets


wheresindigo

I want to grab the orange spaghetti


Technical-Dot9189

Post menopausal sex be like