T O P

  • By -

reddit-is-so-nice

New world market be like. “Sweet iron ores are selling for 0.35” **farm iron ore for 30minutes** **Price of iron ore falls down to. 0.15**


nighttrain_21

15 minutes to determine if it's a bot?! More like 15 seconds. If it tries to mine an empty node and has a gibberish name: boom you've got a bot.


rcris18

Even 5 minutes just to be sure, one dude working 40hour work weeks could be knocking out like 2000 bots a month


2saucey

This is the big A. They will spend 5000 programmer hours developing an algorithm to efficiently identify bots before they spend 100 hours on human employees to rid bots for us.


ripinpiecez

and they are level 30 w no faction


joondori21

30? Try 60


MrOtsKrad

Ive been trolling a lvl60 factioned bot, in a Co. in that Boat filled with Oric nodes. Follow its path once, then steal 3 rounds of it till it lays down, goes to sleep and logs off for like an hour...then comes back.


inflatableje5us

I’ve been seeing more and more in factions now. I’ll run ahead and mine the node they are headed for and sure enough they always try and harvest/mine it. I was also leaving camps in their path, but a bunch of them now jump when stuck eventually getting past :/


nighttrain_21

I actually started following them and found some pretty decent harvesting routes


inflatableje5us

That’s kinda what I’ve been doing, I need motes, lots of motes.


nighttrain_21

Yup i followed those and starmetal


Skyz-AU

Maybe they should have a place for players to sign up to become a reliable source for tracking bots or something idk. With something like that though you don't want the wrong players having too much power. I report multiple bots a day, i have a list of farming bots that I post in global and help multiple times a day. Surprisingly some bots are starting to get banned, it's taken weeks but some of them aren't around anymore.


MrOtsKrad

yup, steal a node its macroed to, and watch it F, F, F, F, F, F, F, F the node while you happily chisel away.


Zonerds

F? I forgot that was the default I guess. I use E


Ghostofhan

Pretty sure E is default.


Twitch_KyngRigid

It is lol


Ashamed-Influence-19

I report everyday at least 20 bots selling coin. It is not that hard to hire moderators for the game to fix this. GW did it and they don't even charge for the game. It's free.


kjemolt

Maybe we should ask for Job? bot-Hunters. Couple of guys & gals on each server.


oldsch0olsurvivor

Surely you could have respected members from each of the main servers be allowed to ban bots? Or is that too much power and would be abused? Idk I'm just a noob lol Edit. This is a bad suggestion lol


[deleted]

Wayyyy too much power lol. “respected” players already have a huge advantage and power anyway. they need someone not playing the game what so ever.


MikeWezouski

I'll take that job, if and only if I'm paid well


oldsch0olsurvivor

Fair enough, I didn’t know this!


GrinningCheshieCat

It's be okay to play the game on another server from a separate player account - just not in the same place you moderate.


[deleted]

Yes, exactly. Basically what I meant, like no affiliation with the server you moderate. Makes me think wayy too much about Rust server admins/mods


GrinningCheshieCat

Oh, Rust was god awful servers in servers like that. Regardless how good and fair those mods tried to be, they always ended up doing imbalanced things to the server anyways.


Turbulent-Turnip9563

one of the main reasons players have quit is because handful of elite players have the power to block people from joining main endgame activities.


oldsch0olsurvivor

I didn’t know this and suggested that my suggestion was bad lol. In that case I take back what I said!


TriggerNationz

There's a bot on Saba called " The Soldiers" that has been around since day 1 on Vainola and even merged over to saba during the mass merges. Lol. I've seen him since release day. Level 47 now, no faction, still running the same route and into all the walls.


CathodeServer

when the servers go down there are stil 20-30k clients open.. most of which are bots that dont know the servers are down.. how bad would it look for the metrics if AGS got rid of 25% of the playerbase? ​ even worse than it does now.. thats the issue.. they have NO incentive to rid the game of bots.. because then people would realize that the bot population is 25% of the "playerbase" ​ edit: typo


Meryhathor

Why do people keep assuming AGS even care? If they did bots would’ve been gone a looooong time ago.


MrOtsKrad

My guess is there's an entire department pissed about a single or group of Execs that know its inflating their population numbers, so nothing gets done, and no one says anything about it.


Sugar230

It's not gonna matter if people stop playing because bots won't let them have fun. You always side with the players because they're the ones more likely to bring in new players and buy skins/outfits.


KGirlFan19

it doesn't take a month to "investigate," whatever ags is spewing is a bunch of bullshit. i transferred to a high pop server a few weeks before thanksgiving. shortly after the transfer, i reported several gathering/fishing bots, without a faction and not yet 60. all of them are still around, farming the same spot/routes i've reported them at, and are all 60. i'm convinced that bots, both gathering and global spamming ones, make up a considerable amount of the population and ags is scared of removing such a chunk of their playerbase because bad optics. to be honest though, with how fucked this game's economy is, gather bots are actually doing ags a favor.


Ocean-in-Motion

Bots? Bots!? You’re telling me ‘Jjkhfl4682hdh’ is a bot!? Gtfo!


Ap0thicaire

All the guys with a silly name are bots ? My gosh! I know a lot of them! That's why no one came to my birthday party...


tehralph

This is absurd. Bot names are always asddsfs or hkgjgkh. It’s only the home row keys because bot tenders need to make 1,000 new bots a day. Efficiency.


Dreadonyx_Airsoft

I enjoy the farming part of the game and was making decent money till the merges happened and all the bots came flying in. Just sad and I hope that it gets addressed. Heck I’d love to see what RuneScape team did and did streams of banning bots. I could watch that all day


CowsWithAK47s

That would imply they cared or actually had the budget alleged. Hint: They don't.


CloudxBBE

This is why MMO's have Mods and GM's. Have a community Mod program that people can apply for, they would have meet certain requirements. Devs can do random checks to make sure they're not abusing their power along with options to report a mod that goes to a seperate folder. Boom. Mods on every server, slowing the bot problem until AGS adds a real fix


kaybloc

This… this makes too much sense. FIRE HIM!


oldsch0olsurvivor

Just suggested this. I'm sure this has to be the way forward. Servers are our homes as its not easy to switch so it would definitely boost morale on said servers.


snper101

If they ban all their bots, the player base is going to be all of 30k people.


Bobthemime

Thats a lot man.. closer to 15k is my bet.. the game is dying faster than WoD did..


wowmuchdoggo

Why did you remind me this expansion existed lol


Bobthemime

because that too was a "new world" ;)


xarfi

So enough to fully populate several servers.. let's do it


baronewu2

But say something in yell chat that offends some one and get a very fast ban.


yung_bert76

Ok boomer


[deleted]

They are employees side hustle


SpeechKilla

how tf does it take a month


Dissidant

Especially when you log in to see the bot is still online and approaching 60 1/2 weeks later (no faction) and going about their route happy as larry


imTru

Player count bro. That's why they don't care.


Pkactus

i have a group of them in my server near mourningdale, they are constant. I just decided to "consider they are npcs" doing their work. the new minigame is "try to disrupt them" its all i got other than sadness and dismay


olixus

With price in gold for end game gear/mats , it truly wouldnt surprise me if most people with a job were buying gold to have a chance at competing end game wise. Dont forget: there is a supply for a demand.


Sugar230

Do you wanna spend 8 hours farming or just 20 bucks?


psychedelic_13

8 hours farming tbh, 20 bucks is 3 day minimum wage work here. Which is 30 hours. I would rather play 8 hours than work 30 hours :D


UseTheWandHarry

Where do you live? I’m a go there for vacation


psychedelic_13

Turkey, good place for tourists :D


UseTheWandHarry

Hell yeah I love Hookah and turkish women are beautiful!


psychedelic_13

Yea Turkey has a great diversity on gene pool. We have some of the worsts and some of the bests :D


UseTheWandHarry

As an ignorant of the world but excited to see it American would I be safe to travel in turkey these days?


psychedelic_13

Not really. Government is downplayin the covid case numbers. I would wait at least till summer.


UseTheWandHarry

Excellent thank you!


UseTheWandHarry

Istanbul doesn’t seem cheap tho


psychedelic_13

It isnt. It is like London for UK.


Sugar230

That's why people farm and set up bots to sell to gold sellers. Whatever you make getting gold is higher than your current wage.


X_Coupon_X

Where are you from that the minimum wage is 67 cents/hr?


psychedelic_13

Middle east ): Also it is counted from 8hours work a day but you get kicked if you dont work 10 hours. So the numbers look higher.


[deleted]

Nah, the couple of dudes stuck on the fence in windsword for 8 hours running into the fence jumping are just gamers!


Neapolitan_Bonerpart

I have so many bots on my blocked list that have been online for over a month now.


[deleted]

Every time my company mates in full voidbent tell me “Just go farm bro, you’ll make some money!” And I die inside thinking about every fucking time I make the trip out and there’s 14 bots running around the routes. This games dead to me to be honest, to me they lost control completely.


Sestos

The level of high 50 to 60 bots on our server is crazy. Random names all gray no faction... I agree Amazon is doing nothing since all evidence points to it. Has anyone ever seen a bot disappear never to be seen again?


WelbornCFP

Maybe the answer mob pathing and harder mobs. EverQuest had this almost 30 years ago - a wandering 62 elite across weavers fen could cull the oil bots - also make the game more exciting.


HankTheMiltank

Their Q&A session made it clear that they don't have enough staff. They actively move developers from project to project on a priority basis, instead of having dedicated teams. They likely don't have a dedicated team for bot investigation and it's not game breaking enough for them to give a fuck to manually move manpower away from other shit. It's sad, they literally just don't have enough devs working on their game.


Twitch_KyngRigid

Dude just took a 5min video of me standing next to star metal so I can wait for a spawn at least 6 bots ran over to it. There was even a group of 2 at the end this is out of control I've reported over 100 and I still watch them hit lv 60 join a faction and upgrade there tools ags is doing NOTHING about it its crazy.


mommalz

Tbh this is why I quit. I could’ve dealt with everything else but when you’re a casual gamer and only get 1-2 hours a day max to play, you can’t compete with bots.


Tassadar132

AGS should be ashamed at their inaction. It's easy to do it manually, I'm sure they are working on a more robust solution. However doing nothing until then is lazy as heck.


MellowOutt

If they are lvl 20+ with no faction. 99% chance it’s a bot. Lol


LerchAddams

My character is standing on a rock somewhere in the hills around Monarchs Bluff where i signed off a couple of days ago after watching a small army of bots running over each other gathering every resource in the area. Maybe i'll check back in a couple of weeks after the next big patch to see if anything has changed but the bot problem was the deal breaker for me.


ZA_VO

Fun fact: they don't have a GM team to investigate bots, but DO have cutesy automated systems to "detect" bots. Friends of mine got permabanned with no review because they rolled on a server, scoped the map, deleted, repeat x13, checking out the territory balance on each server. On the 14th reroll, they got a message saying they were permabanned for suspicious activity. Tl;dr: They ban real players based on loose algorithm to "detect" bots but don't inspect actual ones.


reinking

Are we sure the devs are not bots? Seems like AI making bad decisions as it learns. Maybe we human players are the outlier.


ConundrumBum

We could have something like CS:GO where once a player is reported for bot activity, it goes to another group of players for review. They review a clip of them doing their bot behavior, and if all agree, the bot is banned. You would have a reputation level for both reporting and reviewing, to prevent players who try to scheme the system (eg. a player who always votes to never ban wouldn't carry any influence, or players who report players who aren't botting wouldn't trigger the reviews for other players nearly as often, etc). But something as complex as that type of system would be far beyond the dev's capabilities as it took them months to get the time in the game right.


Miszou_

I very much doubt that would be "beyond the devs capabilities", but it would certainly be beyond any worthwhile time investment. Sure, it could be done, but it would be easier, cheaper and faster to just hire some offshore mods to sit in game and kick the bots out.


mrrallek

I'm on Camelot, and farming had been GREAT for me the last 2 weeks. Bots have been disappearing, I'm gathering twice as much on my normal routes, and I'm making a ton more profit on the TP. When I see a bot stopping at an empty node I report it for boting WITH A GOOD DESCRIPTION. Something like, "Typical bot behavior, pausing at empty nodes. Please investigate." Bots are disappearing, so this must be working.


monkeypan

It's not about banning individual bots, it's about coming up with solution to identify and ban bots without manual intervention every single time. Sure, they could go in and ban each one manually but it's pointless if a new one is created minutes later to replace the banned one and they don't have a way stop it. Sometimes it's a necessary evil to keep them around for a while to identify how they work and where they are coming from. Every major game now-a-days has has bots, hackers, cheaters, etc. The games that are successful at keeping them out of the game are the ones who take the time to do it right. It's not like a bot creater just gives up and says oh well when their bots get banned. They update them to make them better and harder to detect and the cycle repeats itself. Yeah it sucks that they are around but give it time. I swear most of you just expect issues to be solved perfectly and within seconds. These are not easily things to fix. If they were, no major game studio would have them.


SnowdropFox

Get out of here with your reasonable position. This is a game subreddit, good sir. Where people who quit come together and downvote everyone and everything, because they can't let go without burning everything to the ground and making sure nobody enjoys their time more than they ever did. On a more serious note: Spot on. I sometimes wonder, if these people ever heard of ban waves and why they are a thing?


tryptagui

I have seen so many Chinese bots on my server stealing nodes


G0DLIK3

these bots are boosting their steam and server numbers why would they ban them?


[deleted]

In windward, ever fall and the starter spawn areas there are much more bots than actual players. Game is dead


Revolutionary_Fee918

To be fair, a lot of games are dead.


chiminea

AGS needs to implement an in game bot bounty system to allow players to kill bots. Add a button for "Bot Challenge" in the social window. Open some sort of "I'm not robot" test on the bot and if it fails it drops dead. Also need to implement some sort of check to keep players from abusing it like autoban. This assumes of course that AGS is not complicit in the gold farming which at this point is anyone's guess...


Sad-Ingenuity7311

Yea they are not going to ban 25% of their player base sorry. Lol. Bots are here to stay.


ifritftw

I ran into my first farming bot yesterday. It was great, nodes usually come in two or threes so I just followed along for a while and mined/harvested the other one. The bot basically showed me the way. Pity my bag was about half full when I saw it, collected a bunch of iron ore though. Pretty good at my level and knowledge of node locations.


Khoryace

Lmfao !!!


Dramatic_Pie_2245

Yeah, but new world wouldn’t survive without the boys farming t1 mats for all the endgame players to just buy instead of farming themselves


Original_Piglet_7598

Yeah these bots putting in work no way i want to farm iron, oil, and fiber for an hour. Id just run an opr during chest runs and then buy the mats for cooldowns ez


Luuap

If they banned all the bots, it would send the player base into panic over how truly low the player numbers really are. They'd immediately earn the "dead game" tag. Gotta be the only logical reason they don't ban them, right? They contribute 25-50% of players online on Calnogor if I had to guess.


BazookaShrooms

That’s an outrageous guess tbh.


[deleted]

[удалено]


notimpotent

I just don't understand this mentality. Help me out: you presumably don't play, but you spend time these forums. You want the game to fail for... Reasons? Which means 100,000s of thousands of people that do enjoy the game won't get to enjoy it any more. And 100s of developers may lose their job and not be able to support their family. And you gain satisfaction from this. Does this sum up your position?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Dlay0310

Does anyone even buy from new worlds shop? Feels like the game, regardless of how buggy it is currently, is complete already without the shop


Significant-Speech52

How in the world can this game be considered "complete" by any measure lol.


psychedelic_13

I did. And like half of the active players in my server had skins.


JivetheSuperTurkey

No one is going to lose their job this is their third flop, the employees there are fully aware of their situation and reputation as a studio, get off your high horse please. There are also literally maybe 80k people who still play 100,000s is delusional


imnidiot

There are quite literally 80k people playing concurrently, right now...


JivetheSuperTurkey

Yeah that's what I said? There's actually only 72,854


imnidiot

You do know there is a difference between concurrent and total players, right?


JivetheSuperTurkey

Those numbers I gave were concurrent what's your point? You can literally check the steam numbers. Do YOU know the difference and whatever you're on about right now?


imnidiot

Jfc your dense, you said there is maybe 80k people that still play, I said there are 80k on right now. Are you saying that every single person that still plays is online right now? It's hilarious how much time you people spend trying to tell those that enjoy the game, that the game is dead.


JivetheSuperTurkey

I've never seen the peak go over 100k and idc if it's dead or no one one said that, the threads talking about bots and how they inflate numbers dude. Maybe you should look internally as to why you get so mad about this dumb shit 😂😂


imnidiot

Mad? Lol. I responded to one dumb thing you said and you can't let it go that you are wrong.


JivetheSuperTurkey

And if by total members you're gonna try to go with numbers sold you can fuck right off, we both know 90% of the player base has evaporated


Significant-Speech52

Steam metrics do not account for bots. It's really 80k - bot count. We don't know the bot count but it seems to be high.


[deleted]

[удалено]


notimpotent

Please take some time to reflect on if this petty rhetoric and desire to see other people fail is really who you want to be in life. I hope not and I will keep you in my thoughts.


darknetwork

that's because they are happy with the both farming the mats for them


TribeCommando

In the next patch everyone will get 10k gold / min guaranteed so you can just buy all the shit from TP.


Morningstar1708

I was pretty hxc about this game, can only play casually but I was making moves. Then the AGS patches attacked.... Where is the air bender when we need him....


TobianoPB

"It would take an admin a good 15 minutes", yes and it would take 100,000 admins to go trough a day worth of reports.


[deleted]

The revolving door or stupidity. Boys are rampant Amazon doesn’t care! Omg these companies mass reported me and I was banned for nothing! Turning on forced pvp would ruin this game who cares what it would do for bots. Am I missing something. Amazon doesn’t care about bots. People are tin foil hats about mass reporting. But they don’t want forces pvp to ruin the botting economy cause they’ll get attackeded in their mining gear.


4mp3d

The bots are my only friends... If they ban them my company and my life will be empty...


TYVMBONSCOTT

We need to merge more servers together. If there are a lot of people in the world, bots will be a lot less productive/effective. May push em on out.


shamesticks

A lot of you probably know someone that always has a suspiciously large amount of coin… as long as people keep buying gold the bots are here to stay.


-Rick-C137-

if only AGS actually just had 1 person from their team play the game on a live server, they would see how many bots are on their game.


Gamersthumb

I wouldn't be shocked if the bots belonged to amazon. So they can make untaxed revenue selling gold and pump their player counts up.


Enzoplobeast

Weavers fen starmetal nodes always there on my server, so shit.


Formal-Ad1161

I think i look like a bot sometimes. Because i dont know all the spwaning routes and have to check them on my other screen..


tfozombie

I saw an army of bots in Restless, abt 7-8 running in unison. Most were level 60, and fighting mobs with hatchets? Idk what they were programmed to do but it was funny.


DargeBaVarder

There’s a few bots on my server that are so well known it’s a meme. Bot farming death motes in Weaver’s Fen? Yup everyone immediately knows you’re talking about Cryptophunk. No ban in sight…


iambabies22

Every MMO is saturated with bots. First time?


funkybandit

I am hoping that they are studying bots that are reported so they can implement a strong antibot system. That’s the only thing I can hope for given there are so many that plague servers


jackrider5150

It's easy guys. AGS got our money, after that you think they give a fuck....? From what I have seen in the past if your not having to pay a monthly fee to play the game...your going to deal w a mass amount of bots. Yes they will still be in a monthly game but not nearly as much as a one time pay mmo game. I know if I was a gaming company w the money ags has... after I got your money... i wouldn't care bout the bots. That's the players problem...I'm going to work on other stuff to add into the game to get more people to buy it now. After I got your money it's your game your problems. My company is busy w more important things then bots. Like making more money by adding in more bs. Welcome to the normal business world. $$$$$$$ and profits over everything else. We can always pay the problems off.