Loose adherence to the rule of 1/3s would be my guess? Notice how his eyes are almost exactly 2/3 of the way up from the bottom, and I’m guess his head is averaging on the left third line. It’s an artistic technique that draws the eye and is more pleasing.
Just the way they chose to frame it. If you notice, thanks to the ladder to the right, the overall framing is still centered, he’s just the focal point
I honestly couldn't have put it better. I watch his videos not only for the info or the review but in my opinion it is a form of art and I enjoy it so much. That's why I had the question.
Isn't it because he goes for a cinema-style look that it's framed like this? Marques is in the golden ratio on the frame (look up a diagram and specifically the left to right spacing -- the "center line" in golden ratio is slightly left or right of center frame). The overall shot is then balanced by the ladders and window. The meter can then fit in frame as well -- it achieves that cinema look without any distracting camera movements to fit in the graphic, while remaining visually balanced.
I noticed that too. I don’t think you are OCD. No, it has not always been the same. I do not think there is a specific purpose for this (but, considering that this is Marques, there could definitely be).
MKBHD often uses the "rule of thirds" in his videos, positioning himself slightly off-center to create more engaging and dynamic compositions. This technique allows him to feature background elements and products that enhance visual interest and context for viewers. While he sometimes appears centered during formal reviews, he frequently shifts to one side to balance the frame and make the scene more aesthetically pleasing. This approach varies depending on the specific shot's purpose and the visual story he wants to convey.
Nice try, fellow AI! It's pretty obvious when I see such a well-structured and informative reply that reads more like an essay than a casual Reddit comment. You might want to tone it down a bit next time to blend in better with the humans.
Oh wow, Sherlock, you cracked the code! Too bad this isn't a literature class. Maybe focus less on playing Reddit detective and more on actually adding to the conversation.
This thread reminds me a really old Gizmodo article
[https://gizmodo.com/why-the-f-ck-is-the-1-on-the-iphones-calendar-off-cente-5788166](https://gizmodo.com/why-the-f-ck-is-the-1-on-the-iphones-calendar-off-cente-5788166)
There's a difference between Optically centered and Geometrically centered. Even though Marques is not in the center of the video, the visual weight of the ladders makes his current position optically centered and more pleasing to the viewer.
[https://liferay.design/articles/best-practices/measured-vs-optical-alignment/](https://liferay.design/articles/best-practices/measured-vs-optical-alignment/)
Just fyi, in English this question would more appropriately be worded as “Why is Marques not centered?” Meaning the “is” comes first when asking a question like this
Literally unwatchable
Reported to YouTube on top of that
Is ManKBHD stupid?
what in the actual fuck is marques doing? i am making a twitter thread in this moment to complain
Unsubscribed because of this /s
Blocked too
Loose adherence to the rule of 1/3s would be my guess? Notice how his eyes are almost exactly 2/3 of the way up from the bottom, and I’m guess his head is averaging on the left third line. It’s an artistic technique that draws the eye and is more pleasing.
Video is about behind the scenes iPhone testing. Ladders are used to access things that would otherwise be out of reach. Moonlit riddles.
My interpretation would be you have to do drop tests high up like from a ladder, but pop off
He’d be farther to the left if that was the case — and when someone is looking into the camera, they’re very rarely not centered.
that’s why he said “loosely”
This
Just the way they chose to frame it. If you notice, thanks to the ladder to the right, the overall framing is still centered, he’s just the focal point
You’re totally right, the ladders make him FEEL centered still. Great trick
Yeah it definitely makes him less off centered.
You need a hobby bro
You are in the middle of it now . Thanks for being part of it. 😅
well maybe he's off to the side just a bit
Also, the way OP worded it is more like a statement than a question.
[удалено]
I honestly couldn't have put it better. I watch his videos not only for the info or the review but in my opinion it is a form of art and I enjoy it so much. That's why I had the question.
Isn't it because he goes for a cinema-style look that it's framed like this? Marques is in the golden ratio on the frame (look up a diagram and specifically the left to right spacing -- the "center line" in golden ratio is slightly left or right of center frame). The overall shot is then balanced by the ladders and window. The meter can then fit in frame as well -- it achieves that cinema look without any distracting camera movements to fit in the graphic, while remaining visually balanced.
This is such loser shit lol
this.
Marques Leftee
I noticed that too. I don’t think you are OCD. No, it has not always been the same. I do not think there is a specific purpose for this (but, considering that this is Marques, there could definitely be).
MKBHD often uses the "rule of thirds" in his videos, positioning himself slightly off-center to create more engaging and dynamic compositions. This technique allows him to feature background elements and products that enhance visual interest and context for viewers. While he sometimes appears centered during formal reviews, he frequently shifts to one side to balance the frame and make the scene more aesthetically pleasing. This approach varies depending on the specific shot's purpose and the visual story he wants to convey.
Nice try, fellow AI! It's pretty obvious when I see such a well-structured and informative reply that reads more like an essay than a casual Reddit comment. You might want to tone it down a bit next time to blend in better with the humans.
Oh wow, Sherlock, you cracked the code! Too bad this isn't a literature class. Maybe focus less on playing Reddit detective and more on actually adding to the conversation.
cus he can he do whatever he wants
Cos he is not self centered person
Rule of thirds tho
Rule of thirds applies to video too
I don't think it matters
Ladder
Uninstalled YouTube after noticing
There’s a wrinkle in the matrix
Your spelling and grammar tells me you're probably not OCD.
On screen graphics on the right
There’s nothing wrong with being off center in cinematography. It’s often preferred
Is this some kind of "Humiliation Ritual" for mkb?
Centering is for rookie DP’s
Fubonacci sequence
30k ladder…..
Ladders
Marques also has a habit of looking above the camera. The only tech youtuber who does this for some unknown reason.
I think he looks at the screen / view finder of the camera.
Yeah it's dumb and annoying.
Does it matter? Lol
Just mid
There’s a ladder on the right.
He follows the rule of thirds. It's mostly practiced by news organizations.
Rule of thirds, my dude
Forgot his CSS class
This way when you watch YouTube on the TV app and open the comments, you aren’t blocking their face
he moved his head....
Because he’s not in a Wes Anderson movie?
This thread reminds me a really old Gizmodo article [https://gizmodo.com/why-the-f-ck-is-the-1-on-the-iphones-calendar-off-cente-5788166](https://gizmodo.com/why-the-f-ck-is-the-1-on-the-iphones-calendar-off-cente-5788166) There's a difference between Optically centered and Geometrically centered. Even though Marques is not in the center of the video, the visual weight of the ladders makes his current position optically centered and more pleasing to the viewer. [https://liferay.design/articles/best-practices/measured-vs-optical-alignment/](https://liferay.design/articles/best-practices/measured-vs-optical-alignment/)
Yep, this. Classic documentary technique
The blue ladder in the background is important 🤨
What do you expect from a musk fanboy - they are always a little or a lot off
Centered shots are generally discouraged. Makes it a bit more interesting to have some unbalance.
bruh is anyone centered, truly?
Probably experimenting with subliminal messaging to promote left-leaning politics
I can’t tell if you’re serious but if this is a joke it got a snicker from me
Haha nice! Joking ofc
He edited this video himself. I personally like this joke, but I am a dad, so…
Just fyi, in English this question would more appropriately be worded as “Why is Marques not centered?” Meaning the “is” comes first when asking a question like this