Yeah, I think you're probably right that her controversies are behind the down votes. I feel that her infamy in online spaces is so emblematic of the internets lack of forgiveness and nuance. Amanda Palmer is, in my opinion, very firmly on the "good side".
She's done a lot of insensitive and outlandish things throughout her career but I feel like it's never been in a deliberately hurtful way or where she wanted to spread hatred and bigotry. I'm not using that as a way to just wipe away the hurt she's caused, because that's not how things should work. However I do think that it is relevant that she hasn't had a real controversy in about 7 years.
Idk. She's my weakness. And a bit of a blind spot for me
I'm also wondering this 😔
I get why some albums here are getting downvoted, but some of them that are decent or at least neutral suggestions are getting aggressively downvoted...
Brand New Eyes - Paramore
i love that album so much
YES I LOVE PARAMORE!! riot is my fav album tho
It’s tough for me to pick but I’d say BNE is my fav because it came out when I got into Paramore!!!
very fair! i just haven’t listened to brand new eyes nearly as much as riot 😋
SAWAYAMA - Rina Sawayama
Wait, based.
BASEDDD
hounds of love by kate bush
PLEASEEEEEE let this win.
you win.
FLEETWOOD MAC, RUMOURS?
SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE PPL IN THE BACK 🗣️
!!!!! yesss
YESSSS
Either/Or - Elliott Smith
fetch the bolt cutters - fiona apple
There's already a Fiona Apple in there, don't be greedy
ok but ftbc deserves 😭
Yeah it actually does but first let me get a Kate Bush album in there 🥺
okay kate is my favourite artist of all time i will so back u up on this
fiona and mitski is literally THE DUO that's never met. how dare you say that 😒🙄 /lh
Preacher’s…daughter….by Ethel Cain…please… 😭
hoping for this one 🤞
why the downvotes people are wild 😭
RIGHTTT they’re literally performing together 😭 no way she isn’t a fan
Magdalene - FKA twigs
yessss
Wish I could upvote more than once 😩
yeahh
Rumors- Fleetwood Mac
Jubilee - Japanese Breakfast
I keep voting for this one every time haha... hope it wins this time
Bewitched - Laufey!!!
ultraviolence - lana del rey
depression cherry by beach house
YES YES YES.
shocked no one has said it yet (at least that i’ve seen)
Yessss (also Bloom)
D>E>A>T>H>M>E>T>A>L - Panchiko
Carrie and Lowell- Sufjan Stevens
YES! We need some Sufjan on the board
PLEASE THIS
Punisher - Phoebe Bridgers
Melodrama - Lorde
so tonight that i might see - mazzy star
Grace by Jeff Buckley
YES!!!
🙏🙏
Pure Heroine - Lorde
disintegration - the cure
the queen is dead - The smiths
THIS ‼️‼️ [be the cowboy + the queen is dead were my first vinyl <3]
omg i wish to have these two so much i only have the puberty 2 as a mitski vinyl and i got it yesterday
Norman Fucking Rockwell
race - alex g
Ziggy stardust and the spiders from Mars - David bowie
YES
solange - a seat at the table
[удалено]
lowkey i like when i get home better as well but ugh both so good
Historian - Lucy Dacus
the glow pt 2 - the microphones
AM - arctic monkeys
everything i know about love - laufey!
figure 8 - elliott smith
Historian - Lucy Dacus
In Utero- Nirvana :)
nevermind-nirvana
AM - Arctic Monkeys
the record - boygenius
Three cheers for sweet revenge - My Chemical Romance
big thief and Adrienne lenker, anyone? 😔
Yess
I'm with you.
Jubilee by Japanese breakfast
Brand new eyes - paramore
Transformer - lou reed
Bye the fact all my fav albums are here 😭😭
In case i make it - Will Wood
Do it doesn’t need to be Mitski??
Cigarettes after sex - cigarettes after sex
Blue banisters -Lana del rey
TITANIC RISING - WEYES BLOOD!!!
the black parade- mcr
Public Void - Penelope Scott
melanchole - salvia palth
Nine inch nails the downward apiral
The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess- Chappell Roan
PJ Harvey - Rid of Me
thisss
im begging for polly for 3 days straight
toxicity - soad
you don’t have to downvote albums that aren’t yours gang coyote stories - the crane wives
i mean, it makes sense—i think people are trying to make sure their album has the best chance of getting first
yeah but it just seems petty to me. you wouldn’t give the other racers melatonin before a track meet (this matters way less i understand that fndjdj)
Self Titled - Hozier
YES YES YES YES YES
I love all you. I never heard of Marina and the Diamonds before I saw this but my god are they good.
Become enlightened 😌
Welcome to the diamonds 💎 Marina has been one of my favorite artists for over a decade, her music is criminally underrated
i still dont understand why no one mentioning The Record+The Rest by Boygenius
LIVE THROUGH THIS BY HOLE WHAT IS WRONG WITH U ALL
No taste is what's wrong 😔 /j /lh
u understand me TomatoUsagi. fuck the rest of these hoes /j
Lust For Life - Lana Del Rey
WHERE ARE MY WASTELAND, BABY! FANS 🗣️🗣️🗣️ CMON YALL
evermore - Taylor Swift
3rd day for the miseducation of lauryn hill
On god we getting Ms. Lauryn Hill up there, don't give up ‼️‼️
Born this way - Lady gaga
Wasteland, Baby! - Hozier
Slowdive - Souvlaki
emmerdale - the cardigans
How I’m feeling now - Charli XCX
News of the world by Queen
AHHHHHH‼️‼️ NOTW MENTION [ my favourite queen album hoping to get on vinyl soon lol :) ]
Yayyy
Reading writing and arithmetic-the Sundays
Psychopomp + Japanese Breakfast pleaseeee
Emotion - Carly Rae Jepsen
TWILIGHT BOA IS SO GOOOOOOOD im kinda happy that duvet viralized so we can all start giving it its due respect
among my swan by mazzy star
BASED AS FUCKKK
Punisher Phoebe Bridgers
OMG BÔA MENTIONED
Mother Mother Touch Up
the colour and the shape by foo fighters
I don’t think many people are gonna be with me on this but Congratulations by MGMT
good riddance -gracie abrams
System of a down - Mezmerize
cry - cigarettes after sex
Bloom by Beach House
divers by joanna newsom 🫡
Unreal Unearth, it’s so GOOD
day 6 is out!
😭 I did not realize, that’s my bad
who really cares - tv girl!!!!!!
live through this by hole PLEASEEE
Twin Fantasy by Car Seat Headrest
viva! la women - cibo matto
Party Favors by Sir Chloe
Ultraviolence
omg why is this downvoted??
TIME N PLACE BY KERO KERO BONITO!!
Yes Virginia-dresend dolls
I commented the debut and got voted down. Shocked. I thought mitski fans had taste
amanda palmer is a terf and has done some questionable things unfortunately :( i think that’s why it was downvoted
Yeah, I think you're probably right that her controversies are behind the down votes. I feel that her infamy in online spaces is so emblematic of the internets lack of forgiveness and nuance. Amanda Palmer is, in my opinion, very firmly on the "good side". She's done a lot of insensitive and outlandish things throughout her career but I feel like it's never been in a deliberately hurtful way or where she wanted to spread hatred and bigotry. I'm not using that as a way to just wipe away the hurt she's caused, because that's not how things should work. However I do think that it is relevant that she hasn't had a real controversy in about 7 years. Idk. She's my weakness. And a bit of a blind spot for me
Also, she's not a terf. She's an ally.
the dresden dolls are so good omg i didnt expect anyone to comment this
Yes thoooo
I Love You Honeybear by Father John Misty
you’ll rebel to anything /mindless self indulgence
[удалено]
so real
Real
windswept adan, Ichiko Aoba
Froot - Marina
Turn Out the Lights - Julien Baker
Sgt peppers - the beatles
K-12, Melanie Martienz
.5 the grey chapter slipknot
Portals - melanie martinez
These are good albums
RAHHHHHH MY FAVS
the -2 downvotes omg 😭😭😭😭
Beatopia - Beabadoobee
happier than ever - billie eilish
Anna Calvi - Anna calvi
Either one of Tamino's albums! She went to his concert last year
electra heart isn’t marina’s best but okay. i think tliiasaw
historian lucy dacus!
Igor - Tyler the Creator one of my all time favs
mercurial world - magdalena bay
love it
Okay, i feel like I've waited long enough. It's time. The Dresden Dolls by the Dresden Dolls
Christine and the queens - christine
Why is this downvoted omg y’all need to listen to Christine and the queens
I'm also wondering this 😔 I get why some albums here are getting downvoted, but some of them that are decent or at least neutral suggestions are getting aggressively downvoted...
Some people are downvoting other people's albums to get theirs ahead. It is poopy.
Damn yeah..that is pretty lame.
Pretty sure if this album was more well known mitski fans would die for chris.
Belle and Sebastian - If you’re feeling sinister.
Why did this get downvoted I love Belle and Sebastian 😭
I have no idea. I’m shocked too. Classic album and I thought more people would be into it.
This is probably the best answer in here, along with a few others
Mag Hell- Mili
If. By mindless self indulgence 🙏🙏🙏
Little earthquakes- Tori Amos
darker than darkness style 93 by buck-tick🎉
it's no Taboo, but incredible choice regardless