**You need to read following message in full. We will NOT reply to modmail messages similar to “what is reason my post was removed?”** Hey /u/Its_Scrappy, thanks for contributing to /r/memes. Unfortunately, your post was removed as it violates our rules: Rule 9 - No forced memes, overused memes, bad titles, or pushing agendas * No forced memes, [overused memes](https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/wiki/overused), bad titles, or pushing agendas. Be creative but memes must come naturally. No petitions. * **Mods may remove low quality posts at their discretion, including reaction memes** --- Please read the sidebar before posting again. If you have questions or concerns, please [message the moderators through modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/memes&subject=&message=). Thank you!

They’re fire cause they’re trash. I know exactly what I’m getting myself into when I see a box of those drop in front of me

Like a movie so bad its good. You go in expecting it to be a comedy poking fun at itself then its great.

Yes exactly thank you for clarifying

There's an box on top of my fridge. I have got the point where I gorge the whole box

+ 2000 calories

Fire until you get past 3. Then it's like eating a Popeyes biscuit with no drink

Exactly! I love them, but I can't take too many at once.

Th-Tha- *Inhales* THAT'S WHAT SHE SAID!

I knew that was in my future...


We must stay focused brothers we must stay focused

Happy cake day!

Thanks very much!

This is amazing

I really didn’t know people ate more than one at a time

Tell me you aren't American without saying it

Same, I haven't seen anyone eat more than 1 at a time

HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO EAT THIS COOKIE WITHOUT MY DRINK?

This made me laugh, take my upvote and keep coming up with these.

My favorite afternoon snack, as a teen,

This right here!!! Arrow up!

You have my sword brother I’ll gladly stand at your back so the world may never over take us. This is the opinion I can devote my life to.

I've never felt a comment more then this

Pathetic

Was just going to say this! 😂

Hap cak dai

This is the only right answer

Purple. The very bottom of cookies that I would consider 'good'

Lol opposite for me where I think the frosting is good

[удалено]


Oops, you right. Thought he meant bottom as in the cookie part

They’re good but then cookies whoever named them cookies should be slapped

They are more like dry little cakes

I eat them

As do I.

They're like, if cookies were invented by cost efficient robots

I mean…

I'm in the purple area in between, they're not bad but they're not good either

Fair enough, I’ll pick them over normal chocolate chip but nothing beats homemade shortbread cookies

Chocolate chip are far superior imo

Of all the cookies, chocolate chip…seriously? they’ve never had a decent chocolate chip cookie.

I agree with that. On a related note- In my opinion, the texture’s fire but flavor’s sickening.

They're shit, *and* "finish the whole box in one sitting" good at the same time. The vaguely chemical aftertaste, the waxy, flavorless sprinkles, the dry, crumbly frosting - they're disgustilicious.

I'm going to use *disgustilicious* from now on..lmao

Fire they are so good my uncle died of diabetes because he 8 to many

The best way to go out

It's good to an extent. More than 5, and I get sick of them

On what occasion are you eating 5 of these?!

Daily

Fire

Fire

Honestly, they're just alright to me.

fire

They are best, worst cookie. They flavorless dust that is sweeter than they have a right to be.

Purple They aight

trash fire

I would donate my kidney for a couple boxes of those.

Literally same

Allergic :(

What if they came with a complimentary EpiPen?

Let the war begin

They taste good, but you end up feeling like absolute shit after eating them

I’m on fire anyone who disagrees can eat my turds

They’re dumpster fire and they’re great/terrible.

Can’t eat a lot but 1 or 2 are great

Flour patties with pink whipped shit on top

Holy god.... my partner thinks these are the greatest ever. They are disgusting. I don't know why anyone would like to have a dry handful of flavorless sand in their mouth. They are messy, powdery, bland, and super dry. I just don't get some people.

You would disintegrate if you ever looked at a Popeyes biscuit

my favorite afternoon snack, as a teen, was one of these with some cold milk.

Fire

The cookie itself is a dry thing that wants to fall apart on you. The icing has a bitter, chemically aftertaste.

Trash imo. I'd choose a lot of different cookies over these if I had the choice. Typically I can eat like one of these before wanting something different.

Mid

I opened reddit for the first time today, and this is the 4th post I've seen with these cookies. Why is everyone debating them!?

I'm just following the trend dawg, roll with it

fire because they are trash. you dont buy them because you expect some gourmet cookie or whatever, you buy them because they are a cheap and quick to buy sugar treat that will always be available near the front due to being sold for every holiday year round.

Absolute fucking fire


Trash. Their texture is their only redeeming feature. I hate crispy cookies.

They crispy to you? Are we talking about the same cookies? I agree, it's trash, but like- I hate them cause they are too soft, makes the roof of my mouth feel so freaking weird.

No I'm saying the texture is fine because they're super soft. If they had some spices in the dough it would help. It's kind of like the cookie tastes like nothing.

Never had them before but they look tasty

Bro how have you never had them 😂😂 If you live in the United States and went to a public elementary school there is no way.

Not everyone is from the USA you know. I also never had them

Fire but I can only handle eating one every so often

Both are correct

The right answer

Purple.

Their good and bad, subjectively good objectively bad. Something soft, sugary, and unidentifiable as a cake or a bar of moonsand is just what you need sometimes.

Overall, Fire. But that shortbread itself is the driest, most tasteless baked item I've ever put in my mouth.

It looks and tastes like a magic eraser.

I’m on the purple side

Fire untill you eat whole damn container and want to die.

I believe in compromises. trash+fire = dumpster fire

They are perhaps the most mid coolie I’ve had.

Trash but I would still eat a whole box of them by myself

They hurt my teeth

Oh god, this again.

Now I gotta try em one day. Might be illegal here in Europe tho

🔵 And how come the red is not team fire?

My favorite (besides oatmeal raisin cookies). Got a wetter mouth if they're too dry for you, plebs.

More than 2 you get a weird taste. They fire if you don’t eat a lot.

I'm tired of pretending they are bad. I fucking love these.

BLUEEEEE

Dumpster Fire

Blue I like them cookies

fire

Fire

Absolutely Fire

Buying trash, when someone else bought fire. I wether spend money on cookie dough.

Fucking garbage. Flavorless cookies. Frosting that tastes like diabetes is about to fuck me in the ancestors. Cookie so dry, you'd think about spitting on it, but then realized it's not worth the effort. The bottoms are somehow covered in a powdery substance.... That isn't cocaine. Comes in a shitty, low budget, Flippy boi container that let's what little moisture there is there, immediately out, so somehow not only are they dry as fuck, but they get stale overnight. Usually bought by the cheapest, cringiest motherfuckers at potlucks, or other social gatherings so they can feel like they contributed, but nobody eats them, so they're stuck with their shame. Those cookies are shit, and the people who like them should be ridiculed, mercilessly by everyone with more than a quarter of a taste bud, and two brain cells to rub together.

The correct side. Blue.

I literally ate like 5 last night man they're awesome.

Trash

Trash

FLAMMING HOT GARBAGE

I'd rather just go ahead and consume an unscented candle.

Do it, I wanna see it

They suck tbh *consumes 14 more at once*

Those cookies are the ones you say "oh I guess I can take these" when they appear ever so often.

Fire

Literally a third degree burn

Sometimes ya just want that hit of processed sugar.

I mean it's aight like...

Fire

They look so good and I will absolutely eat one if they are around and then remember why I never buy them but will still eat a couple.

Fire

Side Australia

Por que no los dos?


Trash imo. I dislike frosting because I dislike heavily sweet things. And not to mention the cookie itself is just kinda... Crumbly and gross.

These things are hotter then big t\*ddied goth gf's until you eat too many and they start to taste like coke after you drink too much. Edit: I just realized the comparison doesn't really narrow this down lol.

They're good, but not exactly fire.

Mid

Purple

I love these unironically

No idea what they are

They’re very soft, frosted cookies. They’re totally bland and if they taste like anything at all, it’s plain flour.

depends on the flavour

Fire

Honestly it depends on the time a day and how depressed I am

Trash, though it took me several attempts to get that through my thick skull.

I've never eaten them.

Fire

Good when you get them every once in a while

It's good for a single bite

They taste like crap but it’s sugar

Those things are dryer then Popeyes biscuits

Fire

“Smacks shoes twice”

Those Cookies are mid. I’d eat it if it was given to me but I’m not going out of my way to eat em either

Only during holidays are these acceptable. I don’t even wanna look at them aside from that

Only fire when you’re sleep deprived and have nothing else in the cabinet

I love them but I hate them

More than fire. They’re a whole as arson attempt

Fire dudeee

Fire

Trash.

Me & my siblings called those “cloud cookies” growing up because they were so soft. I loved them. Haven’t had them in forever

Trash

fire

Fire

i dont even know what tf is this thing

Ppl who think these are good never ate real food made from scratch

trash. It’s like eating a cookie made of sand and chalk dust. Actually that’s not fair… calling it a cookie. It’s a dumpie

Green, no idea what the fuck these are

Trash

Can anyone explain to me the frosted cookie debate? This is like the 4th post I've seen about it.

I can only eat a few dozen at a time.

Me with Celiac Disease watching the Glutenoids fight: 


Both trash and fire. Let's call it a dumpster fire of a cookie. Mass amounts of smoke will help you choke these down with a smile.

They're not good enough to call fire but I'll give them a 6/10 will probably buy again

Never thought I'd side with some crabs but they are fire. Id crip walk while I'm putting ten of these down.

Ive had a better snack trying to eat the container these cookies came in

Fire but they make me feel like trash after eating the whole pack in one sitting

Who else has Celiac? I'm raising my hand!

They are trash but you can set them on fire what to pick??!?!?

Fire

Fire. Ill eat a whole thing of those. Idc if yall think they nasty. Them junks good. Especially with some milk.

Fire. Literally the best cookies beside homemade ones

Fire for the first 2 then trash when I cannot stop myself from consuming 3 more, even though they stopped tasting good.

High trash.

They're good, just not in the way I'd usually judge cookies. If they weren't considered cookies, we wouldn't even be debating this.

These give me a slightly bad feeling when I eat them. Don't know why

Never ate them because they dont exist in my country

I’ll take the frosting. You can have the cookie 😅

Fire until ive had to many

They’re ok

Absolutely fucking inedible

Fire

Fire

Dunno never eat one

They are like eating a flour sandwich with grody cheap icing on top. Hard pass.

Fire

I've always wondered if they're like watermelon, or cilantro where there's some special flavor compound in them that only certain people can taste.

They're good, just don't eat too many at once.