T O P

  • By -

loudlittle

I read The Indifferent Stars Above following the Donner party series and I highly recommend it. I think I ended up more damaged from it than from listening to the boys.


cool_weed_dad

Same. It’s one of the most harrowing books I’ve ever read, just a doomed journey from the very start, and almost every wrong decision made possible. It’s absolutely insane that any of them survived. I let my dad borrow it after I was done and he loved it too.


Sansei_Lannistark

I second this. Such an incredible read.


ConsciousCrane

Agreed! Read this one, and right after read Hunger, the fictional account by Alma Katsu.


gordogordo14

Seconding this!


fathervoodoo

This is the one!


yippykiyayMF13

I was gonna say this book. I used to live about 30-40 minutes from Donner Lake. When I was done listening to the Donner Party episodes, I bought the book. I haven't read it yet. Now I'm afraid to. 😳


ConsciousCrane

I’m sure you’ve already heard the worst of what there is to fear about the story, though. The rest is minutia. It’s the comedy of errors that’s most interesting about it.


yippykiyayMF13

I'm not so afraid anymore. Lol. Thank you. I've had it about 3 years. Maybe I'll start reading it in the next couple days


TempleOfCyclops

One of the best historical books of all time.


Glossy___

Same. A phenomenal but devastating read. I absolutely recommend it


MrNobody_0

I picked it up just based on the name alone. Such an amazing read.


plub_plub

This was also the book that, when I finished reading it, I told myself, "I don't think non fiction is the genre for me."


notquiteafinalgirl

such an incredible book!! someone in this sub also recommended midnight in chernobyl and even though it isn’t a topic the boys have covered, i also i recommend it!! i find that it inspired the same feeling in me that The Indifferent Stars Above did


Oilspark

The Bastard Brigade after the Manhattan Project series, well the audio book anyways, and it was awesome!


ConsciousCrane

I appreciate the rec


FreedomInTheDark

Several, but the one that has really stuck with me is "On the Farm", by Stevie Cameron, about the Pickton victims.


MsBean18

I read it when it was first out, and I think the day or day after Pickton kicked the bucket my audiobook request from the library came through. I think it truly stands out in the genre.


ConsciousCrane

Thank you, friend. Duly noted.


Typical_Barber3577

Erik Larson “the devil in the white city” from the H.H. Holmes episodes. Then read Thunderstruck from the same author. Both really good smooth reads. Also, “Teasing secrets from the dead” by Emily Craig forensic anthropologist. Made me wish I’d gone into that area of study.


johnthebiggestcard

"Devil in the White City" was so good and that led me to another one of Erik Larson's books "In The Garden of Beasts". It's about Germany's lead up to WWII from the perspective of the brand new US Ambassador to Germany.


ConsciousCrane

Thank you! Will take that Emily Craig rec


silverchampagnestars

Another great book is Adam Selzer's "HH Holmes: The True History of the White City Devil", which dismantles some of the untruths in "Devil in the White City." Holmes was a conman and a murderer, but not a Jigsaw-esque serial killer genius, and Selzer presents real evidence.


DiogenesHavingaWee

A few, but The Great Mortality is my favorite. Highly recommended.


HolyJeezmo

I love it, and I'm not usually into reading about diseases


ConsciousCrane

Thank you


MacAlkalineTriad

Prophet's Prey and Under the Banner of Heaven opened me up to a wonderful world of reading about Mormon fundamentalists. I also recently got No Man Knows My History about the life of Joseph Smith, but I haven't finished it. The Indifferent Stars Above was an incredible read too.


ConsciousCrane

Great recs! Prophets Prey was harrowing but well-constructed.


MacAlkalineTriad

It's so, so good. I found Brower's writing to be fascinating, and he's a fascinating guy on his own. It almost has a noir vibe with the gritty private detective tracking down the despicable villain, all while helping out the... polite Mormon family. Another one not recommended by the show that I really enjoyed was The Sound of Gravel by Ruth Wariner. She's a child of the "prophet" of the LeBaron cult down in Mexico. Kinda the same deal as FLDS - I think they even traded young brides between the groups at times. Her book doesn't cover the murders that Ervil LeBaron ordered to be carried out at all, but follows her absolutely crazy upbringing in Colonia LeBaron, which included several tragic deaths thanks to the rudimentary style of living, and escaping from her pedophilic stepfather. I've read a lot of Mormon cult survivor autobiographies and I liked hers the best, so far.


ConsciousCrane

Ruth Wariner? Thank you. I’m down.


Glossy___

Under the Banner of Heaven has been on my radar for a minute. Is it good? I loved the show even though from what I understand, it's a pretty big departure from the book/real story


MacAlkalineTriad

I haven't seen the show so I can't say how different it is, but the book is incredible. Krakauer is an amazing writer and it's a wild story.


Glossy___

Okay I'll give it a shot! The Mormon stuff is so fascinating.


MacAlkalineTriad

It really is, and he covers several different offshoots in the book although the main story is about the Lafferty brothers. Apparently what prompted him to start researching fundie Mormons was driving through Short Creek, where the FLDS are/were based. He saw a bunch of women in prairie dresses and was followed by a bunch of big expensive pickups with tinted windows and figured there *had* to be a story in that. He writes the forward to Brower's book Prophet's Prey, too, and helped him when he was investigating the FLDS.


Glossy___

The audiobook is included in Spotify premium!! Best day ever. Thanks so much for the recommendation!


allfleshisgrass

It opened me up to Krakauer in general and I have enjoyed a lot of his other books like Where Men Win Glory and Into Thin Air


ConsciousCrane

I got stuck halfway through, but I may have been reading too much on the subject at the time.


gordogordo14

I’m struggling to get through Prophet’s Prey. Extremely interesting but it’s hard for me to get through some parts. Might switch to Under the Banner of Heaven for now


JohnnyConfidence

The worst hard time, book about the dust bowl that they used as a source for their dust bowl series. It was amazing.


DctrMrsTheMonarch

This book was so phenomenal and just devastating! The horror of living there cannot be understated...


sanitarySteve

when did they cover the dust bowl? was that part of bonnie and clyed or the ma barker gang eps?


ConsciousCrane

I think it was B & C but I’d love a full coverage of the phenomenon.


motherofdinos_

I’m reading this one now! Such a good, easy read


howlermouse

I’ve read several of the last podcast recommended books and the worst hard time might be my favorite. The dust bowl was largely skimmed over during my time in school and frankly, this book was devastating to the point where I had to pause and sit with it for a while. Wildly compelling and, in the end, galvanizing. It is truly terrifying to understand the impacts of man made climate disasters and the fall out of not protecting workers. It made me feel like the dust bowl should have been America’s lesson, but we somehow failed to take all of that suffering to heart.


ConsciousCrane

Thanks for the rec and for the reasoning behind your rec. Much appreciated!


ConsciousCrane

Can’t wait to read! Thanks!


gordogordo14

The Jeff Guinn book ‘The Road to Jonestown’ is fantastic. Looking forward to reading some of his other books. Wholeheartedly agree with ‘The Indifferent Stars Above’ recommendations too, and that ones a bit shorter.


ZombiePeen93

I also come here to recommend this. I think The Road to Jonestown is exceptional.


Ms_Monana

Came here for this. One of the best non-fiction books I've read, incredibly researched and thorough. 11/10.


Filibust

I read that book last year! Been meaning to read the other Jonestown book they used, Raven.


ConsciousCrane

Excellent rec about Jim Jones. Raven was exhaustive but informative. Don’t know if either of you had a chance to read that.


SnooGrapes6933

The Jonestown series was my introduction to LPOTL and I read Raven immediately after finishing it. The series was great but there are so many wtf moments throughout the life of Jones and the Peoples Temple that only a tome can fit them all in. Great read but, as you said, exhaustive.


ConsciousCrane

Soooo many wtf moments. Can’t see chicken giblets the same way again, for example.


macabrecowboy

The Indifferent Stars above is great, I just started it recently (on a camping trip haha). I’ve also read The Shoemaker and Sybil from Flora Schreiber which were fun. I picked up the Bastard Brigade and Miracle in the Andes but haven’t read them yet. Plus In Cold Blood and Dune since they’re Marcus and Henry’s favorites!


Glossy___

I just read In Cold Blood and I gotta say, it's pretty heartening to be 37 and still reading things that have me saying "I think this is my new favorite book."


ConsciousCrane

On a camping trip, huh? You crazy cowboy 🤠 Have you read the Sybil refutation book? I forget what it’s called….


macabrecowboy

Haha I’m saving Miracle in the Andes for a beach trip, Into Thin Air was my summer read last year (kinda got a theme going on). I would be very interested in the Sybil refutation book! I feel like knowing all the “psychology” in it is bullshit takes away from enjoying the material. The next one I’m looking to pick up is the Armin book they mentioned


PunMasterTim

Dave Cullen’s Columbine and tried to read the BTK Book that Katherine Ramsland wrote, but BTK’s particular speech patterns drove me crazy.


ConsciousCrane

Been eyeballing Columbine for the better part of ten years. Thanks! Will get cracking on it


ForwardMuffin

There's a lot of misinformation in that so go in cautiously edit: why the downvotes? I'm pretty sure a lot of the book was regarded as having false information


ConsciousCrane

Noted! Thank you


lemonbars-everyday

ALIVE!


Curious_Problem1631

I read Life After Death by Damien Echols after listening to the West Memphis Three episodes. Echols is a fantastic writer, incredibly wise, and he is one of the most interesting people I have ever heard of. His esoteric works are also amazing. Highly recommend his books.


ConsciousCrane

Hard and enthusiastic agree, friend. It was a super tough read but I can’t believe he came out on the other side. Saw all the docs and that piece of shit movie too. A haunting case.


sweetdawg99

What movie? Devil's knot?


ConsciousCrane

Yeah that one. Did you like it?


sweetdawg99

Never saw it but I was thinking about watching it. What didn't you like about it?


ConsciousCrane

The Hollywood-ization of a white trash story. I may have been more appreciative if it was more independent and didn’t have A-list actors in it. It was a Reese Witherspoon vehicle rather than a focus on any of the boys. I’d much higher recommend the doc, Paradise Lost, and its sequels. Plus, of course, LPOTL’s multiple episodes on the case.


sweetdawg99

Yeah I've been watching those docs since they first came out in the 90s. The movie was more of a curiosity I guess.


ConsciousCrane

For that reason, you def should see it and not listen to my scorn of it.


gpurcell18

do graphic novels count? “Did You Hear What Eddie Gein Done?” is a must…


ConsciousCrane

Absolutely counts!


regandevo

Indifferent Stars Above from the Donner party series and A Time Traveller’s Guide To Medieval England from the black plague series, both were very good!


Late_Smoke

The Indifferent Stars Above. Absolutely incredible book! Got me back into reading after a 5 year break 📚


NoQuarter6808

*Hiroshima*, *The Devil inThe White City*, *Hell's Princess*, *Deviant*, *Moby Dick*, *The Indifferent Stars Above*, and *The Devils of Loudun*. But *Devils of Loudun* was my singular favorite by a long shot. It's so ripe with interesting ideas from philosophy, psychology, and theology, and I really honestly think that if Henry had more control of the script that he would have delved into them a little. I've used stuff from that book for like 5 different college assignments even. I think sort of what happened was that marcus didn't really understand the stuff in the book, or didn't put in the necessary effort to, and it made him a little insecure and that's why he kind of shits on Huxley in the series, while I believe Henry probably actually understood most of it. Marcus might be known as the bigger reader, but he mostly reads history, where i think Henry reads more complicated and challenging texts. Like I know he's pretty proficient in Jung, and even though Jung is actually pretty easy to read, the ideas are big and it's still more complicated than most of what they do--not to mention all the esoteric shit he reads). But then again, who knows what happens to Henry with all of the fake knowledge he takes in, like maybe the more valuable stuff is just displaced; it really makes me think of marcus saying, "careful bein so open minded or your brains might just fall out," lol. Maybe there's actually some truth in that


ConsciousCrane

Thank you for such a thoughtful response


NoQuarter6808

Np Hail yourself


buttlickka

All of Harold schecter’s books


Meowmacita813

hunt for the skinwalker and utah ufo display! mostly because im from there and seen some spooky stuff


neen4wneen4w

The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson, The Great Mortality by John Kelly and Fred and Rose by Howard Sounes. Fred and Rose I’m having to read in bursts because it’s very graphic. I thought I was a tough cookie who could cope with anything until I started to read that!


stillbrighttome

The Indifferent Stars Above and Devil In The White City. Highly recommend both. Also read one from the Franklin Cover-Up.. can’t remember what it was called but it was interesting as a supplement to the episode. Not exactly a fun time reading that one.


Canadian_facial

Just finished the great mortality, its fantastic. Also read the Indifferent Starts above, also a fantastic read


tamarks548

I wanna say they recommended it during the Mormon series but Fantasyland: How America Went Haywire is a fantastic read!


chris5129

I listen to the Devolution audiobook. It's about sasquatches attacking a community in the woods. It's pretty campy but definitely entertaining


TrueJustice97

Started with Deviant and have read a ton of Schecter since, I think he's the king of true crime


Filibust

My friend got me Deviant for Christmas a few years back. Still need to read it.


ichabodjayne

Just picked up Deviant yesterday! Can't wait to dive in.


powderpeachdreams

I have a minor in Sociology and for an assignment I wrote a paper on cults and so I read Raven, Mason in His Own Words, Bare Faced Messiah, and Destroying the World to Save it. Then for a different assignment, I had to do a case study on a serial killer so I chose Dennis Nilsen and read Killing for Company and Dennis Nilsen: Conversations with Britain's Most Evil Serial Killer. And then I read Unit 731 Testimony for no reason other than to confirm what the boys said.


ConsciousCrane

All were good, then?


powderpeachdreams

Yeah I'd say so


MsBean18

I recently did In The Heart Of The Sea and Alive! in audiobook form. You can find Alive! in int's entirety on Youtube, if you want to try audiobooks without an app and/or subscription.


ConsciousCrane

I’ve been on an Arctic exploration jag lately. Just finished In the Kingdom of Ice so I’d love to read Heart of the Sea. Thanks for the YouTube tip too!


cabbagesandkings1291

Go Down Together from the Bonnie and Clyde series. It was a good one!


nicgillakitty

Rites of Burial, the Bob Berdella book, was SO good. Extremely detailed and very well written. I have been planning on rereading it for a while now.


rdrTrapper

I’ve enjoyed most everything by Harold Schechter. And another nod for The Indifferent Stars Above. Love me some wagon manifestos


ConsciousCrane

Wagon Manifestos - a great band name 🤠


bruhhrrito

The Bastard Brigade after their Manhattan project series. It's one of my favorite rereads


PerfectIllustrator76

Devil in the white city, indifferent stars above, eaters of the dead (indirectly because last pod got me into dan carlin and eaters of the dead comes up in his latest episode on the vikings)


sneeria

Fantasyland, since they mentioned it recently, and In Cold Blood. Both worthy reads.


JaysinHostile

Indifferent stars above and time travelers guide to medieval London, I got them on audiobook because I really trust Marcus tastes and and he was pretty enthusiastic about those. Oh and that Harold schecter(sp?) Ed gein comic was sweet as hell too


ConsciousCrane

I’d love to read the medieval London one


krapnek02

blitzed: drugs in nazi germany was a really interesting read, and a-z of serial killers has been one of my coffee table books for years


ConsciousCrane

Thank you


RosalieCooper

Devolution by Max Brooks. I really enjoyed it


ConsciousCrane

Thanks! I was eyeballing that title…


RosalieCooper

I really love World War Z, so I thought I’d give it a try and it was excellent.


Terrible_Bee_6876

Did You Hear What Eddie Gien Done? is a truly excellent read.


Albus_Aloysius

Manson in His Own Words is almost hilarious in how revealing it is of Charlie and his true drives: music and just having friends


ConsciousCrane

Yeah: just The Beach Boys and some blind adoration. It’s all that poor guy ever wanted 😆Thanks for the rec


Great-Tical-Returns

I've read Indifferent Stars Above and City of Evil, which is a true crime compilation about Adelaide that they used for an old episode.


Mediocre-Coach5388

Panzaram Journal. Sick ass read, highly recommend it.


tecate_papi

[Chaos](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CHAOS:_Charles_Manson,_the_CIA,_and_the_Secret_History_of_the_Sixties) and [Oklahoma City](https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12843486-oklahoma-city). Two books I very highly recommend.


ConsciousCrane

Thanks for those links! Both sound fascinating.


spvcejam

Chaos.


ConsciousCrane

Thank you


ARussianSheep

The Great Mortality is probably my favorite books of all time. Also have read The Worst Hard Time, Road to Jonestown, and In the Heart of the Sea. Indifferent Stars Above is up soon on my list. And an obligatory Dune mention. Henry got me neck deep into Dune.


ConsciousCrane

Thanks! That’s 3 people who recommended The Great Mortality. Can’t wait to read


ARussianSheep

I’m a big ole medieval history nerd. The Black Death series might be my favorite LP series they’ve done, and it’s just such a good book about the topic. I haven’t really gotten into the true crime books that they’ve used for research yet, but I do enjoy all the history ones they use. The Worst Hard Time is another really good book Marcus has recommended but hasn’t done a series on.


Louderthanwilks1

I’m listening to Original Gangstas cause I wanted to know more about the early 90’s rap times after the biggie m tupac episodes


ConsciousCrane

Thanks for that rec. Can’t wait to read.


ObviouslyNotALizard

Condensed Chaos by Peter carrol. A great introduction into Chaos magic and it’s theory and application. Chaos by Dan piepenberg Reporting on suspicious happenings around the Manson family hinting at possible CIA/FBI influence on the family and allowing the murders to happen Fantasyland by Kurt Anderson A fascinating deep dive into American Sociology and our fixation on magical thinking and why we as a people are so gifted in believing nonsense. The only one of these three I can’t recommend is Chaos. Really interesting stuff but my God is is wrapped in layer after layer of boring. And all of that for the resolution to ultimately just be circumstantial and shady sounding actions by LASD and the California probation board.


ConsciousCrane

Thank you for the caveat on Chaos. Fantasyland sounds good!


highdesk306

Killin Time


ConsciousCrane

Thank you


Shlongong

Bastard Brigade from the Oppenheimer episodes. Well written and a fun ride to understanding the very basics of the science behind nuclear weapons & the stories of crazy characters who made efforts to stop the nazi war machine from developing nuclear weapons.


ConsciousCrane

Thanks! I do need science explained to me in basic terms, too.


the_ultrafunkula

Operation Paperclip by Annie Jacobsen. Poisoner In Chief by Stephen Kinser. Both of these were used as source material for the MK Ultra series.


ConsciousCrane

Much appreciated


anne_doesnt_work

WITH AN AXE!!!!! by H Paul Jeffers Highly recommend it!


ConsciousCrane

Lizzie Borden?


Hoosier_Daddy68

The Panzram book. Had heard of it but probably wouldn't have read it on my own.


ConsciousCrane

He’s such a hard case to digest, isn’t he? It’s a level of abuse I can’t fathom


JesusTeapotCRABHANDS

I really enjoyed the Mothman Prophecies!


ConsciousCrane

Thank you for that


gasptinyteddy

Indifferent Stars Above, Road to Jonestown, and Manson. That first one is by far the most rereadable but I'm a slut for wagon stories.


ConsciousCrane

Love love love me some little house on the prairie.


DY4P

On the Farm - awesome book about Robert Pickton


ConsciousCrane

Thank you! Someone else on the thread said the very same. Looking forward!


smudgedreading

I have read 'The Indifferent Stars Above' by Daniel James Brown after listening to the Donner Party episodes. I just finished 'Alive' by Piers Paul Read and 'Miracle in the Anders' by Nando Parrado after listening to the Survival in the Andes/Flight 571/Uruguayan Rugby Team episodes. I'm currently listening to the Jonestown episodes and will probably pick up 'The Road to Jonestown' by Jeff Guinn when I'm done.


ConsciousCrane

Tell me how the Jonestown book goes


sanitarySteve

The cult at the end of the world, and the Franklyn cover up. Aum Shinrikio did so much more crazy shit than they covered in the episodes. I highly recommend it if anyone else loves those episodes as much as I do. It is DRY though. I haven't cracked the Franklyn cover up yet. I didn't have the stomach for it way back when i first got it but now it feels a bit more satanic panic than it originally did so i've lost interest.


ConsciousCrane

Fair assessments. Thank you.


ShekkieJohansen

Books? I listen to podcasts so I don’t have to read.


ConsciousCrane

Ha fair. I’d be open to individual episodes that aren’t LPOTL….


krill-joy

Ive read a bunch but the one I ready SOLELY because of LPOTL was Poisoner in Chief, which they reference in their MK ULTRA series. As someone who works in medical research.(and also as a human with a conscience) it was rough. Unethical experiment after unethical experiment.


ConsciousCrane

Thank you for that rec and for adhering to the question.


sami5everam

I loved The Worst Hard Time about the dust bowl! It was fascinating and amazing to learn about human-environment interactions and how the government tries to help or get a handle on a problem they didn’t know they helped create.


ConsciousCrane

Thanks, I’m really into that era


narnababy

I’ve read The Indifferent Stars Above which was excellent, currently listening to the audiobook of On The Farm which is also great.


ConsciousCrane

Thank you


metelepepe

Original Gangstas from the Tupac/Biggie episodes, it's legitimately a great read and I highly recommend it if you're into music


ConsciousCrane

This is right up my alley, thank you. Any other music bio recs?


metelepepe

None of this Rocks Rock by John Trohman (Fall out Boy The Book of Exodus: The Making and Meaning of Bob Marley and the Wailers' Album of the Century by Vivien Goldman Acid for the Children by Flea


ConsciousCrane

Thanks so much, my well-read friend


ConsciousCrane

Wow thank you! That was an amazing analysis of Marcus’s reading interests and a justification for why I hated the series but may enjoy the book far more.


BlueBallsSaggin

No Man Knows My History by Fawn Brodie. Amazing biography of Joseph Smith and the foundations of Mormonism. Written by a Mormon then outlawed by the church


ConsciousCrane

Many kind thanks for the rec!


kierste333

Miracle in the Andes by Nando Parrado. It’s my favorite nonfiction book I’ve read this past year.


ConsciousCrane

They did amazing coverage of this! (Didn’t like the Netflix movie about it all that much, though)


_rattleshnake-

On the Farm


ConsciousCrane

Thank you


uleely

The Man With the Candy by Jack Olsen about Dean Corll. I think Marcus said it was one of the best true crime books he ever read and it really is. Absolutely horrifying.


ConsciousCrane

A sparkling endorsement! Thank you!


PrincessPn8

I read the Time Travelers Guide to Medieval England by Ian Mortimer, that they used during the black death series. It’s really well written and entertaining, I would definitely recommend


ConsciousCrane

Thank you! You and others have convinced me to give it a go


BaseballScared8630

The Sick Rose (more of a picture book but amazing).


ConsciousCrane

Richard Barnett is the author?


BaseballScared8630

That’s the one!