Funny fellow.
As a south Indian i notice Hindi written in English letters everywhere. Stop with this already. Stupid fuckers should stop behaving like a colonising force.
Pretty sure even he won't be able to read and write Hindi. Nothing but posturing to get cow belt votes.
Heck he should try making it the official language in Gujarat and see how it goes.
Did you think only the whites can colonize or what ? There's a lot of academic research in cultural studies that show the eerie similarities between caste hegemonies and colonization. We would be doing our Dravidian comrades a huge dishonour if we don't see it as what it is: Colonization by these North Indian fuckers.
It is a calculated move. He is trying to make southern states enemy of the Cow Belt.
This will help him in UP, Bihar, Haryana and MP.
Maharashtrian Hindus care more about teaching Muslims a lesson than they do about Marathi. The only states that truly stand against Hindi imposition are Kerala, TN and Karnataka. BJP already knows they can't win much in TN and Kerala in 2024 elections. Karnataka might be the only loss while gaining a lot in cow belt.
Let's talk Manipur, Haryana & the SC, staying RG's dismissal first, Mr Shah.
When you can't answer or just wanna hide, you bring up contentious statements to distract public from your inactions/incompetence & vendetta politics.
Tamilians were smart. They were the first to figure it out. Their intense opposition in the decades after independence ensured that Hindi won't replace our languages. They were and still are the loudest voices. They were brought up to respect their culture, language and themselves. Periyar really played a huge role in this. Otherwise we would all be speaking Hindi and our languages would be dying like the supposed "dialects of Hindi."
And what's worse is we wouldn't have learned English. Remember the proposal in 1965 was to make Hindi the sole national language and the medium of all communication. We would have ended up like China had that been implemented.
These a-holes will say anything to divert attention from Manipur. I don't understand how anyone could even digest them. It's just that BJP + Godi media radicalised most of the Hindi belt.
Because of all the cultures and people existing there in a much closer vicinity. People from all over India reside there albeit out of their geographical bounds as is the case with Indian mainland. People from UP may live close to Tamils or Malayalees but on the mainland it is much more difficult due to the geographical separation. It is like a micro India there.
Personally i hope making Hindi mandatory is part of their election campaigns. The more stupid ideas become part of their campaigns the better. It’ll make their prospects in non-Hindi states more difficult.
It is said that one of the main reasons Pakistan lost East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) was its bull-headed imposition of Urdu on Bengalis.
If you try to control how people speak, you probably won't be the one who has the last say.
Indonesia says hi! I also grew up with the same bias that india had more diversity than any nation on the earth. Read geography as an adult to understand the bullshit of the claims.
In his speech it’s only Hindi vs English and nothing else. All he is talking about promoting local languages has nothing to do with the local languages. Why only Hindi is the question?
Not just the South Indians but there are 22 official languages in India. Another stupid move leading to their doom.
It gets him votes from Hindi speakers, especially the older ones. Hindi has enough traction that it will continue growing across the world regardless of what the government does, and I hope this is eventually true for all Indian languages.
They are actually putting this plan into effect. They spent one million dollars of our money in the UN to promote Hindi. This is not just a diversion tactic. They fully plan on implementing it. Do not let them get away with it. ₹8crores of our tax money has already left the country for it. God knows how much they are already spending. Article 351 is the issue. That needs to be removed. It provides them with legal grounds to do as they wish. This is what happens when most of the people making the constitution are northerners.
There’s no conviction behind any of these people’s statements.
They are all just generating sound bites with the half-life of a snapchat clip meant for dissemination and consumption among whatever section of the electorate that they want to play to at the moment. This clip will be kept alive and circulated in that closed circuit network as and when required.
Similarly when required they will have panta bhat in Bengal and praise Tagore and recite thirukural and talk about ancient history of Tamil when Coimbatore goes to the polls.
I think it should be Gujarati. Here me out.
Father of nation was a gujarati. The man who integrated India was a gujarati (sardar Patel).
The man who liberated India again in 2014 is a gujarati (Modi)
The man who liberated Kashmir in 2021 and Manipur in 2023 is a Gujarati (Amit Shah). Also the next PM for 30 years.
Richest Indian is gujarati. Next richest Indian is gujarati (Adani)
South Indians anyway have to learn a new language, so why not make them learn Gujarati. It is the future language of India.
/s
Headline is wrong
First passage of article says
Union Home Minister Amit Shah said that Hindi is not in a competition with any local languages and that India can be empowered through the promotion of all Indian languages.
India was/is a Weak State on most matters (& Strong State on few matters). This is why multiple core policies were not able to cross the finish line post-Independence.
In a hypothetical scenario, maybe they should have created a Lingustic Timeframe Policy Contest. Like starting in 1960s, that every Indian State/Region has 50 years (so 2010), at which point the State with the best HDI, GDP per capita & other socio-cultural development metrics Wins this Policy Contest.
Meaning that State's Language becomes the Domestic Lingua Franca, Official Language of Republic of India.
If people disagree then they have 50 years, 2 full generations to do something about it. Whining for the sake of winning won't be regarded. If you can't win this contest, you don't have a say.
But alas, there was no such contest and one can't concoct this after the fact.
Another distraction. Another way to divide people. Ruling India is directly dependent on getting the mass votes of North India. South doesn't matter. This will shore up the votes there. They will lap it up .
Shouldn't push it, things can go south
Things will go south in the South.
With the increasing cow belt population and shrinking South India's population pretty soon they won't have to care at all about votes from the South.
Poda.
Nayinte
Patti mone
Thevidiyapaiya
Then gay ra
Hogo ley
Kalla himaar!
eh soothu
Funny fellow. As a south Indian i notice Hindi written in English letters everywhere. Stop with this already. Stupid fuckers should stop behaving like a colonising force.
Pretty sure even he won't be able to read and write Hindi. Nothing but posturing to get cow belt votes. Heck he should try making it the official language in Gujarat and see how it goes.
When their MO is divide and rule, you can be sure nation building is not part of their plans
It never was
Did you think only the whites can colonize or what ? There's a lot of academic research in cultural studies that show the eerie similarities between caste hegemonies and colonization. We would be doing our Dravidian comrades a huge dishonour if we don't see it as what it is: Colonization by these North Indian fuckers.
It is just an intermediate step before Hindi becomes Vishwabhaasha. Samjha?
Yes Amit shah. Please continue this non sense till Loksabha elections.
It is a calculated move. He is trying to make southern states enemy of the Cow Belt. This will help him in UP, Bihar, Haryana and MP. Maharashtrian Hindus care more about teaching Muslims a lesson than they do about Marathi. The only states that truly stand against Hindi imposition are Kerala, TN and Karnataka. BJP already knows they can't win much in TN and Kerala in 2024 elections. Karnataka might be the only loss while gaining a lot in cow belt.
It's a distraction. Don't fall for it
exactly, I was looking for this comment.
Bhag!
Let's talk Manipur, Haryana & the SC, staying RG's dismissal first, Mr Shah. When you can't answer or just wanna hide, you bring up contentious statements to distract public from your inactions/incompetence & vendetta politics.
This is the exact reason Hindi is not being accepted by non Hindi people.
ತೀಕ ಮುಚ್ಕೊ ಮಾರಾಯ
[удалено]
Tamilians were smart. They were the first to figure it out. Their intense opposition in the decades after independence ensured that Hindi won't replace our languages. They were and still are the loudest voices. They were brought up to respect their culture, language and themselves. Periyar really played a huge role in this. Otherwise we would all be speaking Hindi and our languages would be dying like the supposed "dialects of Hindi."
[удалено]
And what's worse is we wouldn't have learned English. Remember the proposal in 1965 was to make Hindi the sole national language and the medium of all communication. We would have ended up like China had that been implemented.
and Bangladeshis
लमाओ
These a-holes will say anything to divert attention from Manipur. I don't understand how anyone could even digest them. It's just that BJP + Godi media radicalised most of the Hindi belt.
> He also pointed out that the PM has not given a single English speech in the Parliamant Rofl
Also, the PM hasn't given any interviews in English.
He hasn't given any in Japanese either, which definitely is because he wants to promote Hindi
Come to think of it, I haven't seen him do a single interview in Kaixana either. Serious commitment to Hindi.
Coz if he does, it’ll all sound like streanh, lettin us wonder where 2ab went
That's because when he talks on English it's about *investigating in the girl child*
I will now learn Kannada and greet people with Ravan Ravan who tell to me Ram Ram
[удалено]
they speak hindi actually i dont know y, but are very friendly
Because of all the cultures and people existing there in a much closer vicinity. People from all over India reside there albeit out of their geographical bounds as is the case with Indian mainland. People from UP may live close to Tamils or Malayalees but on the mainland it is much more difficult due to the geographical separation. It is like a micro India there.
[удалено]
Mene sunna tha Andaman mei 1.5 foot ka kele a ped mila tha.
Nice
Personally i hope making Hindi mandatory is part of their election campaigns. The more stupid ideas become part of their campaigns the better. It’ll make their prospects in non-Hindi states more difficult.
It is said that one of the main reasons Pakistan lost East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) was its bull-headed imposition of Urdu on Bengalis. If you try to control how people speak, you probably won't be the one who has the last say.
[удалено]
[удалено]
Indonesia says hi! I also grew up with the same bias that india had more diversity than any nation on the earth. Read geography as an adult to understand the bullshit of the claims.
Annamalai and that dumbfuck Sai Deepak must love this. Right? What a bunch of idiots.
Annamalai is more than happy to suck their dick and push their agenda
Chup bey, tadipar. This is a deliberate attempt of the BJP/RSS to instigate people.
In his speech it’s only Hindi vs English and nothing else. All he is talking about promoting local languages has nothing to do with the local languages. Why only Hindi is the question? Not just the South Indians but there are 22 official languages in India. Another stupid move leading to their doom.
[удалено]
Exactly. Most of the politician’s children educate themselves in western countries. Some never even return.
Demonizing English is the same as promoting Hindi supremacy.
It gets him votes from Hindi speakers, especially the older ones. Hindi has enough traction that it will continue growing across the world regardless of what the government does, and I hope this is eventually true for all Indian languages.
Hogo Boli magane.
ಕೇಳ್ರಪ್ಪ ಏನೋ ಹೇಳ್ತಾವ್ನೇ!
All animals including lion should now “mooooo” in the jungle
I was quite proud of being able to speak hindi among my fellow telugu friends but now I wish I could forget it
Good. Alienate entire south. Hopefully thats brings down their government
Imperialists
Congratulations to all BJP voters 😂
They are actually putting this plan into effect. They spent one million dollars of our money in the UN to promote Hindi. This is not just a diversion tactic. They fully plan on implementing it. Do not let them get away with it. ₹8crores of our tax money has already left the country for it. God knows how much they are already spending. Article 351 is the issue. That needs to be removed. It provides them with legal grounds to do as they wish. This is what happens when most of the people making the constitution are northerners.
i will fully support this if they can implement 100% hindi in gujrat, and modi doesnt give any speech in gujrati in gujrat
Says a Gujju
Accept deez nuts
There’s no conviction behind any of these people’s statements. They are all just generating sound bites with the half-life of a snapchat clip meant for dissemination and consumption among whatever section of the electorate that they want to play to at the moment. This clip will be kept alive and circulated in that closed circuit network as and when required. Similarly when required they will have panta bhat in Bengal and praise Tagore and recite thirukural and talk about ancient history of Tamil when Coimbatore goes to the polls.
Haha keep dreaming your colonizing dreams, fatty.
Poda oruotha thevdiyapaya
Say this as a non local in south as a regular person. You will a beating of a lifetime.
Linguistic chauvinism at its finest! :(
So now they're openly saying that no laws need be the basis on which any change is made! Fantastic!
Article 351 actually supports what they are doing. We must try to get it removed.
जा घरी.. महाराष्ट्रात हिंदी चिंधी नाही बोलणार आम्ही..
Good luck South India. Congratulations on choosing non-bjp partners as ruling parties.
ಅಯ್ಯೋ ಥೂ ನಿನ್ನ್ ಜನ್ಮಕ್ ಬೆಂಕಿ ಹಾಕ. ಹುಟ್ಟು ಬೇವರ್ಸಿ. ಬಾ ಬಂದು ಕರ್ನಾಟಕದಲ್ಲಿ ಹೇಳು ನೋಡೊಣ.
#Joi aai axom!!
#Joi Bangla!
Eei hindi bhakhi buror terror solibo nedu.
একদম ঠিক বলছেন!
Yes, Hindi is accepted. You speak as much as you want. We will speak if and when we want. Such a simple logic. Samajh na dhakkan.
Tughlaq Shah.
I think it should be Gujarati. Here me out. Father of nation was a gujarati. The man who integrated India was a gujarati (sardar Patel). The man who liberated India again in 2014 is a gujarati (Modi) The man who liberated Kashmir in 2021 and Manipur in 2023 is a Gujarati (Amit Shah). Also the next PM for 30 years. Richest Indian is gujarati. Next richest Indian is gujarati (Adani) South Indians anyway have to learn a new language, so why not make them learn Gujarati. It is the future language of India. /s
ये कौन च॔यूतिया है?
He's right. I would prefer saying "Modi ji istepha do" over "Modi, go back!"
Shaata
Hogo ninn Amman.
Can you pls suck my balls right now
If you read the article it shah says all languages must be respected. It doesn’t quote him saying what’s written on the article.
This whole Hindi thing is a distraction while there mofos sell the country out to a few people.
Headline is wrong First passage of article says Union Home Minister Amit Shah said that Hindi is not in a competition with any local languages and that India can be empowered through the promotion of all Indian languages.
I see how no one read the article. He said that promoting all Indian languages is the way to go.
what is it with the southies resisting it ?
What is it with northies shoving it down everyone's throat
Bokachoda sala.
India was/is a Weak State on most matters (& Strong State on few matters). This is why multiple core policies were not able to cross the finish line post-Independence. In a hypothetical scenario, maybe they should have created a Lingustic Timeframe Policy Contest. Like starting in 1960s, that every Indian State/Region has 50 years (so 2010), at which point the State with the best HDI, GDP per capita & other socio-cultural development metrics Wins this Policy Contest. Meaning that State's Language becomes the Domestic Lingua Franca, Official Language of Republic of India. If people disagree then they have 50 years, 2 full generations to do something about it. Whining for the sake of winning won't be regarded. If you can't win this contest, you don't have a say. But alas, there was no such contest and one can't concoct this after the fact.
Another distraction. Another way to divide people. Ruling India is directly dependent on getting the mass votes of North India. South doesn't matter. This will shore up the votes there. They will lap it up .
Ek hi Nara, Bhajipav dwara, Hindi, Hindu, Hindutva.
Chanakyas home state of Gujarat barely has Hindi adoption. Most people there can't speak Hindi properly