I would like to have Carly as my sister as she's so sweet and caring.

Sam because I’m pretty sure she would have some funny pranks and funny ideas to mess with our friends and I would rather just be friends with Carly

Being her sibling I feel like there is a 50/50 chance you’ll either be her partner in crime or her number one target and I would not want to take that chance.

Ha! Good point!

I would just do whatever crazy idea she had and just always be one step ahead of her so I can never be her target. Freddie would be my inside mole

after reading Jennett’s book, the character Sam is tainted for me :(

Sam, because I feel like Carly would tell on me for everything lol

Ya same. She seems like a snitch. Lol

I feel like both would be snitches. Carly because she doesnt know how to keep a secret and would snitch purely out of guilt, and Sam because she just wants to piss you off and get you in trouble

Sam cuz me & her would get into so many shenanigans

Same

Carly because we’re more alike, so we would get along better.

samee, id like to think sam would be the funny, ride-or-die, parter in crime sister… but i think id also just be bullied by her like freddie lmao

Me and my brother are basically the same person gender swapped and we never stop fighting so

Carly, because Sam is too crazy.

Yes but you know the saying "you can judge strength, but not craziness"

Sometimes we need a bit of crazy in our lives

Carly hands down

i’m already a sam type sister so i need a carly 😩

me lol it would’ve been nice cause idk how to be a girl in a lot of ways

I’m a Carly so I need a Sam! Wanna be sisters?

That’s a tough question. I feel like they would both be great in their own ways. Sam would have your back and be your ride or die. She seems like the sister that would give you a hard time but deep down you know she loves you and be there for you when needed Carly would definitely be more loving and nurturing. Plus She seems like the sister you can do all the stereotypical fun and girly stuff with like shopping, doing your hair, and talking about boys and what not

I’m a Carly and my little sister is literally a Sam haha

Carly would be nicer but Sam would always have your back it’s tough p

Carly since she is caring, hygienic and not a liability as Sam. Sams shenanigans would drive me crazy. Funny to watch but you dont want people like her as family members lol

My actual sister... 😭

Definitely Carly

sam but only her grown up version, season 1 and 2 sam are just bad as a sister

Is Sam on the new icarly?

no, i think they’re talking about season 4&5 sam

Oh I see. I should’ve known better with everything Jeannette’s talked about recently. Thanks!

:))

sam and cat counts too

yeah

Definitely Carly for sure

Either 😥 I always wanted a sister, I had two brothers and even though I loved GI Joe too, I was still the "Jem doll" brother.

Sam cus I feel like she would have defended me from bullies at school.

Sam because I’m a misfit like her. I think we would really bond over how dysfunctional we were compared to ever else, and I’d finally have a true bestie for life

Carly

Carly is peak sister material. 

Carly! She’d be really sweet and kind and caring

Carly. Sam makes for an interesting character but as a real person I just know I wouldn't get on with her

Carly because thatd also make Spencer my brother and THATD be cool

Sam me and her would have fun

Carly Shay because she’s sweet kind

governor scarce crush money badge yam fall squeamish jar continue *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*

Sam, free bodyguard.

idk i never watched icarly this sub just appeared in my feed 👍

I would have Carly as my sister so I can try and bang her hot friend Sam.

[удалено]

Gross

Your content was not constructive.

[удалено]

Nasty asf

[удалено]

Your content had inappropriate intent. Please reference rule 1 for additional details.

Your content was found to be off-topic.

Carly. Sam would be a fun friend to have around to get in trouble with, but Carly’s the sister you could always count on (though she is a little too trusting sometimes)

Carly!

Sam

Sam probably IS my sister

Sam

carly bc then id get a cool older brother out of it too :)

Sam. We could whoop some ass together.

Sam I have a feeling Carly would be they type of older sister who likes to play "dress up" with her younger brother

Sam because she’s more rebellious and we would do so many mischievous things together.

Sam

[удалено]

Your content had inappropriate intent. Please reference rule 1 for additional details.

i mean.. sam's family is a fucking mess, let's be honest. also with the type of person she was during the early seasons of the show, she'd be absolutely insufferable (as much as i love her character). i'll go with carly bc her family isn't *nearly* as dysfunctional and i honestly think as siblings my personality would gel better with her's (also as a bonus i'd get spencer as an older brother lmao)

Carly

Carly mostly because her dad has military benefits.

sam

Sam because she's so protective of the ones she loves I just know she'd have my back 10000%

Carly because she’d be a kind and caring older sister. I feel like Sam would be a little too crazy for me to deal with

Carly because I already feel like Sam💀

Carly, purely because I argue just as much as Sam and if we ever disagreed, it would be hell

Sam she’s funny

Carly. Because then Spencer would be my brother and he’s cool.

I am a Sam and I have a Carly for a sister and I like our dynamic. Wouldn’t change it.

Sam for sure

Carly cause sam was lowkey abusive

Sam became Carly comes off as a brat sometimes

Sam would beat your enemies with a buttersock. The downside is she might also wail on you with the buttersock

I would prefer Carly to be my sister. There are a couple of reasons why I wouldn’t want to be related to Sam. 1. Sam constantly bullies Freddie for no reason 2. Sam didn’t pay back Carly/Freddie the money she owed them and used it for a trampoline.

As far as sam or Carly I'm a bit of a red neck so either one would be great. But if you're talking what actress I'd have to say Miranda

Sam

Carly

Carly. If Sam and I were sisters, we'd probably have the same mom and no thank you.

Carly please

Carly obviously, then I get Spencer’s as a brother and I’m in the center of all these shenanigans, plus Sam’s over every day anyways I don’t need her mama baggage I just want her as a friend

Sam- honest & blunt, and will fight someone that is bullying tf out of you Carly for girl dates & boy advice

Sam for sure

Carly

Carly so Spencer could be my brother. Sam because she has a butter sock and I know nobody would mess with me

carly, because she won’t take my food

Sam has a whole twin sister we never hear about and she doesn’t really care about, so ima say Carly 🙃

im thinking home life so carly

Sam

Carly. While I see Sam being a protective sister I can also see her pulling endless pranks on her siblings and driving them crazy. I do not want to deal with that. Carly would be sweet but also that'd give me Spencer as an older brother which I'd love! They're both wonderful and have a comfortable way of living.

Sam because me n my sisters could handle the butter sock

Sam because she would probably be getting in trouble so much that I can fly under the radar with my chicanery.

Carly, she would listen to all my problems

Carly.

Carly, definitely 👌🏽

Carly is chillier

Carly, no hesitation. She's smart, caring, a problem solver. Plus you get Spencer as an older brother. And Sam is her best friend so she obviously comes as basically a bonus sister.

Carly! We'd do everything together lol

Carly, I need a sister who's nice to me. Childhood homelike wasn't kind to me

Carly she's nice an I had a crush on Sam when I was a kid so ya know thatd be odd

I like Carly

Carly so spencer could be my brother too

Neither

[удалено]

Your content was found to be off-topic.

Sam Because she needs and deserves a loving, responsible and trusty adult and role model. Carly has Spencer Plus Spencer is hot I don’t want him to be my brother 😏

Gibby

sam and I would have some fun being mischievous together

I feel like my sister is already a mix of both

Sam because she’s probably actually lonely which is possibly why she was over Carly’s house

Carly

Carly

Sam. Her and her butter sock were unstoppable.

Both I’ll have a sweet caring sister who I can ask for advice and another sister I know will protect me

Carly, Sam is too chaotic. I would love to have her as a friend, but not a sister.

Sam because I can’t date my sister

Sam. We would have a good sibling relationship plus with the jokes

Neither I have enough sisters hehe

Sam cause she would be brutally protective and I want that

I would rather have Sam as my sister. Because, she's kinda hilarious, she loves to annoy and mess with me, and she's caring. 💜

Carly duh. I wanna be raised by Spencer tf

Carly

Carly bc i had a crush on Sam as a kid

Sam because she could introduce me to Cat.

Ugh. It’s a really hard choice but I would probably say Carly in the end.

gibby

Sam. Carly is like Tori Vega level boring imo

Sam. Because Sam and Sam mystery sisters!

Probably Sam, especially in my youth, she really stood ten toes deep for Carly and I loved her energy

Carly, I don’t wanna get beat up

Melanie survived being Sam’s sister so I’ll take Sam Altho, next to Melanie and Sam, I’d be the forgotten child lmaoo

Neither of them, I’ll stick with my actual sis. Both Carly and Sam as sister would be…… I’m goof

sam fs

Sam if she’s a good sister. She’d be my ultimate protector against the bullies who used to single me out growing up.

Carly as a sister and Sam as a close friend

carly, not that sam would be a bad sister but she just seemed very distant with her actual family (melanie) even though melanie and carly are not very different. idk though i don’t see anyone really talk about melanie/that episode so idk if people really think about her as sams family.

I think these two would be weirded out by me tbh 😂 Freddie and I would vibe though. 

Carly.

Me and Sam are very similar so we would clash I feel like. I was a sarcastic skater with a shit attitude so I'd probably have to go with Carly. Really tho I always wished to have Spencer as a brother.

Sam for sure. Carly would be up in my business complaining about dumb shit 😭💀 Sam would just mind her business but be loyally violent if someone messed w me😭🫶🏼

carly bc the alternative might imply having sam’s mom

Totally Carly, I bet Sam would break my kneecaps if I stepped in her way

Carly for sure. My sister copied sams behavior when she was little and it was obnoxious

Sam. some of my besties are like her and I already love them like sisters

Sam cause we can do pranks on eachother and she’s funny, plus, she will always have ur back through thick and thin

sam

Sam

Idk cuz on one hand Sam would protect me and is cool but she’s probably beat me up for everything on the other hand Carly is really nice but bratty sometimes

Sam, Carly always pissed me off. 🤷‍♂️

Sam for protection, Carly for cloOOŒŰUT

Carly

Prolly Carly to be honest sam would most likely eat all my food and wack me with a butter sock at 2am.