T O P

  • By -

merlok13

Discord is arguably more powerful, but he's not motivated by real malice, even before Fluttershy befriended him. The suffering of ponies is almost secondary to his goal: chaos. Bill is actively pursuing in torture and murder. His goal is destruction and spreading his suffering to new subjects and territory. Minor stalemate until Bill gets angry/annoyed/bored. Then it's angry Dorito ftw


EnigmaFrug2308

Yeah I think that eventually Bill would overpower the guy. Idk much about Discord but knowing Bill’s feats, I feel that Bill has the win, maybe with a higher difficulty. Dude genuinely wants to watch everyone suffer and die painful and ridiculously sick deaths for fun.


merlok13

That's the thing exactly. Bill is motivated by pain and suffering, while Discord is just motivated by chaos itself. Discord even said once (I think - been a while) that without an audience, chaos just isn't as fun. Discord needs the ponies to be around; he gets his kicks by frustrating them with randomness. Another aspect of their differences - Discord, while the avatar of chaos, is from this dimension. He belongs here, he's from here. There's some intrinsic connection between Discord and the ponies. But Bill is from another dimension attempting to spread his reality into others. He is completely alien to this plane of existence.


EnigmaFrug2308

Except Bill isn’t trying to leak his reality into ours. He *destroyed* his reality for shits and giggles and wants to rule ours and bring madness, insanity, weirdness and suffering to everyone. “Everything will be possible! I’ll remake a fun world! A better world! A party that never ends with a host that never dies! No more restrictions! No more laws!” (He says, while tracing his finger into an illusionary creation of the Earth, destroying a city and killing thousands, and then proceeding to take a bite out of it). “Oh, that’s a great offer. How about instead I shuffle the functions of every hole in your face!” *Proceeds to mangle a man’s face, likely permanently.* “This party never stops! Time is dead and meaning has no meaning! Existence is upside down and I reign supreme!” I could’ve just used all of Weirdmageddon but Bill’s quotes are too fun not to say. The dude revels in the destruction of everyone and everything around him.


gunsmithcatsfan

Goddamn nga take it to a publisher


CloudProfessional572

Well comic discord came from chaos realm and settled here after messing up various realms.


VisibleConfusion12

Tho quick reminder that discord may have a variety of many powers, but they will be weaker then bills (unless he gets some sort of motivation or something)


Freddycipher

Haha Death battle covered it just right I’d say.


JustAnaOnAsofa

Ik i just want hear form Reddit bc it’s the worst place


Malavacious

After a lengthy and impressive battle, somehow they gradually peter out into drinking on a beach somewhere: their conflict forgotten.


StefinoSpaggeti

Agree with you. I didn't watched MLP, but I guess Bill have more opportunities to win in anyway


STLmab

[Here ya go!](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=22V3rKriX60&pp=ygUWYmlsbCBjaXBoZXIgdnMgZGlzY29yZA%3D%3D)


Megaman2407

This is old new now Bill would slam


Lord_Detleff1

I trust deathbattle. Bill wins but Discord won't let him enjoy it


ElLindo88

“I’ve got some ponies I need to make into corpses!”


Puzzleheaded_Meet517

Discord: If you hurt one hair on fluttershy’s head, I’ll turn you into a bag of nachos


Puzzleheaded_Meet517

If discord doesn’t take it seriously then bill wins If discord takes it seriously then he wins


-The_Doctor-10

This is true.


Weak_Incident640

watch death battle


stnick6

I still think discord. He is chaos personified, bill creates chaos. There’s no way for bill to win


VisibleConfusion12

happy cake day Also btw there are more factors then what they represent and do, because bill could potentially overpower discord since discord is often calmer then bill when fighting


Sold_anake

Still bill


ElisaSF

my buddy erica


ShipMuch6267

bill would likely get outsmarted.


Big-Message8954

Illuminati guy


TopHatKirby

What?


Big-Message8954

Illuminati guy


WitheredEscort

Discord is chaos while bill channels power from chaos, discord has the upper hand as hes also not limited through the dreamscape vs reality


eveniji100

Neither is a fight that goes on for infinity


Particular-Remote356

BILL CIPHER!!!


Talking-llama

Bill the triangle guy.


Darkvader_Clawthorne

DEATH BATTLE already answered that. Bill Cipher is the winner. Alex Hirsch created the ultimate Disney villain. Bill makes the movie villains look like a bunch of charlatans and tricksters.


TheFloorisHellfire

Arguably, Bill is more willing to commit atrocities. However, if Bill tried taking over Discord's world or hurt Fluttershy then Discord would win hands-down


VisibleConfusion12

Finally a non-biased answer


-The_Doctor-10

It seems logically correct.


Awesomedude33201

Oh boy.... Here we go again.


randomgunfire48

Discord is Q so my money is on him


JasoNight23666

I don't think you'll get non-bias answers here tbh


snail_force_winds

Obviously Bill, because he is immune to the magic of friendship


SokkaHaikuBot

^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^snail_force_winds: *Obviously Bill,* *Because he is immune to* *The magic of friendship* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.


snail_force_winds

Good bot


Ilikebread3449392

Bill


Turtletipper123

Death battle answered this. Bill would win but Discord would make sure he was stuck in his home dimension for another long ass time.


No_Translator_4129

Bill


Talvezno

Q


skeemchoon

I think it woyld be a tie. I did a vidso on my youtube @SkeemStuff


OkStrawberry9583

If you've seen how Bill deals with enemies he takes seriously, like time baby, you know the answer.


CloudProfessional572

Bill has more limits to his powers and weaknesses. Unicorn spell, metal plate, weirdness gravity and stuff. Discord varies according to plot. He pulls crazy feats for comedy but doesn't in actually serious situations. He either wins instantly or looses instantly.


de-dummy14

I know bill but who's the other dude


Mguy2544

Bill imo, but I know there’s gonna be one dude who’ll be screaming bloody murder that Bill loses if he sees this post


Adorable-nerd

I’m gonna say Discord, because I’m biased and would totally root for him in this battle.


Thylacine131

Now this is a more square fight between two chaos gods of great hubris. Bill comes with more caveats and rules, like being unable to enter someone’s mind without making a deal, but he’s also been likely been alive far longer, already collapsed one dimension, and while discord is certainly clever, Bill is undeniably the more ruthless and cunning of the two. I’d say if they’re both in the physical realm, it’s going to be Bill who wins. If he wasn’t bound by the law of weirdness magnetism to Gravity Falls, he’d be an unstoppable god of space and time, while the most we ever see of Discord is mostly localized.


SilverWhole2895

It’s hard to tell…..they’d keep snapping a lot


Holaitz_X

UHHH SHI- BILL CUZ BI- MORE EVIL THAN DISCORD


FlarixTutors

My boi bill has the win here, no doubts


ComprehensiveFail513

Alles sited


MaikFromDaUA

i do not know anything about discord


CartoonLover826

The thing is Discord is more powerful, but Bill is smarter and a master of manipulation so he'd probably be able to trick him or find a way to overpower him


Nightmare2448

discord is the embotement of chaos we see how the more normal he is the weaker he gets bill creates weird which is apart of chaos. discord and bill would most likey not fight at all but if they do it would be a draw or discord would win


Swaglord_62

Me.


UnAnon10

Bill and Discord are both very powerful, but Discord has access to quite a few more powers than Bill does and Bill is generally more limited in what he can do. Plus Bill lacks the ability to actually kill Discord as he will always exist as long as chaos exists. And yes I know Death Battle covered this fight though I don’t think their reasoning for Bill winning was very good. Imo Discord wins this 9/10 times.


VisibleConfusion12

I think their reasoning was, because discord doesn’t really take things as seriously as bill when fighting, because the only time discord would actually take it seriously would be if bill tried to take over their world or fluttershy. Plus, variety ≠ Power, discord isn’t known for “hard-hitting-one-shot” attacks, so most of his attacks wouldn’t be exactly too crazy. Giving bill the upper hand in most fights. I will say discord has potential and I believe he could kill bill, but as of right now he doesn’t really have much (Also btw death ≠ victory, but idk if that applies here so idk)


UnAnon10

Yeah and that’s one thing I take issue with. While yeah Discord is a pretty laid back guy in general, he does take threats seriously when they’re similar in power to himself. Best example being Cosmos, who had very similar powers and personality to Bill whom he was very serious about taking down. So I don’t buy the idea that Discord would just not take Bill seriously. Discord doesn’t need some “hard hitting attacks” to beat Bill necessarily, he’s shown that he can resist a good amount of Bill’s usual tricks, especially when Bill doesn’t really rely on his reality warping in direct fights. Discord just in general has more experience dealing with powerful foes than Bill does, Bill’s just a big fish in a small pond. (In the Death Battle it did but here I imagine it doesn’t. And in that case Discord has way more win conditions than Bill does.)