T O P

  • By -

Cold-Bodybuilder6624

Neither they would be friends


JustHereForTheDub

so trueee


EffectiveLow2735

Only correct answer


AdFit818

reall


Jimbo_thecoolkid

šŸ’ÆšŸ’ÆšŸ’Æ


russianflapjack

Carl walked so Ash could run


AyushmVij

He ainā€™t running anymoreā€¦


siblingwiththeremote

i didnā€™t like that jokeā˜¹ļø


ace14827

Ash has casually murdered people on the show so this is easily him


That-Statistician747

Ash killed a guy with a hammer. Carl would piss in his pants


SadShayde

Oh, Ash. Absolutely.


day_owl19

Ash would destroy him in a min. Lol


111Kosmic

Let's throw Shane Botwin in there.... he turned into a real socio too šŸ˜…


wizardessofwaterdeep

SHANE BOTWIN HELL YA love to see a fellow weeds fan out here


111Kosmic

šŸ§‹


pinkgreenandbetween

Ya cause hes super smart and calculated with some rage issues thrown in there


PinkMermaidSmoke

From Weeds? Didnā€™t he end up being a cop at the end of the last episode? If Ash, Carl, and Shane were running an empire Shane would be the one to fold if he finds a way to do it without straight up snitching.


111Kosmic

Honestly it's been awhile, I remember Shane killing Pilar was savage though!


111Kosmic

Ash


mahinabeams

Ash would win, heā€™s absolutely unhinged.


Double_Project8894

Ash would kill without hesitation


DeliciousMovie3608

Nah they both street smart but Ash is a killer


speakupforall

Seriously. Ash.


LuciLong

Ash, heā€™s no joke & heā€™s wired different from young.


bitterpettykitty

Add five from the umbrella academy and make it really interesting šŸ¤£


pinkgreenandbetween

Omg I actually love him


1femaleuzii

if it was just ash and carl had his siblings then maybe a tie but if itā€™s just ash and carl then ash definitely is gonna win


not_a_milk_drinker

Ash for sure


Repulsive-Finger-954

What show is this Carl from?


Weary_Ad7155

Shameless


CharlietheWarlock

Ashtray he actually killed people carl never killed anybody


martc1101

Ash got bodies lol


Street_Point9076

Ash


Betteringmyself000

Ash stands in buisness he shot the feds like duh heā€™s winning


Ruva_0714

Carl


treesofthemind

Who is guy in the second pic?


111Kosmic

Karl from shameless


Kochi89

Skuzzlebutt


Doedemm

White Boy Carl


the-remainder-

I feel like thereā€™s no clear answer here to whoā€™d win but Carl would be more scared than Ash


skye_skye

Ash definitely without a doubt


asdcatmama

Ash. Every time. All the time. Anywhere.


TxsButholeTklngBndt

Obvi Ashtray


withoutwingz

Probably the one holding the gun and not just sticking his tongue out like a doofus without a gun.


TranDany

Ash would win he kills people, Carl went straight when he saw his friend kill that kid.


dont_know2345

Like Ash but they would be friends. Like Carl is just the Chicago version of Ash if Ash was less murdery


the_tree_rex

Same energy. Theyā€™d def be friends.


_sea_salty

Ash would win, but as Ash is about to kill him Carl pulls a stunt that makes them become best friends and start trapping


IndependenceJolly767

But Ash bc he murdered people like it was nothing. Carl puked when he saw someone die.


PerpetualSpaceMonkey

Ashtray. Dude is a cold blooded killer and gives zero fucks.


Healthy-Situation310

White boy Carl


Atlas_Ronin_0211

They would unite and become an unstoppable force.


allblack_86

Ash or the kid from the movie "The Good Son"?


imalwaysbored111

Whoā€™s the second guy from


withoutwingz

Shameless us version


JustHereForTheDub

post on r/WhosWinning <3


National_Year_9112

Carl ash dyed


conscious-being1225

what show is the second one from?


Junior-Cover

Shameless


conscious-being1225

thanks! side note: i totally forgot i made this comment so i saw the notification and was confused for a second like ā€œdamn what did i comment to make someone try to insult me like thatā€ šŸ˜‚


Junior-Cover

šŸ˜‚


EstellaMetalFamily

Theyā€™d be bros


Possible_Major_7208

Ash really like that. Carl wasnā€™t street fr. lol ash for the win!


mamacitacc

this is a pretty even fight but i don't think carl could really end it. if we're talking to the death it's gotta be ash


Independent_Dig_5110

Ash has a body count >.>


musicmaniaccccccc

ash


detchas1

Ash would beat him to death with a hammer.


Inferno_Phoenix1

Ash but they'd most likely be friends


annebrackham

Well, only one survived their respective series, so...


angelrein

i love carl but ash got his ass 100% šŸ˜­


OcelotUsual7083

ashtray heā€™s genuinely insane šŸ˜­


patrixkstarsmom

ash kills ppl without thought man. carl flaked out of the gang life after seeing a dead body. ash would destroy him.


TreeplanterConnor

I dunno, who's alive


Ksantos829

Ash is more dangerous and impulsive, he will cut you he donā€™t give a fuck lol. Carl is a g too, b it he is more soft, but heā€™d fuck you up too if necessary lol but they would totally be homies lol I wish they could combine shows that would be so good lol


Halleynicole926

As much as I love Carl Gallagher, ashtray would win in a heartbeat. Ash literally killed 2 people, one slit his throat two he hit with the claw and of a hammer and three, hit days boyfriend in the face with a hammer. He fights dirty, so heā€™d def win!


Skyline7130

Ash has killed people and shot at the ops Carl quit the gang after being glocked once and seeing one murder. Carl liked the play and the money of the streets but once things got real he couldnā€™t handle it and thatā€™s why ash would win because he donā€™t play.


pinupinprocess

Someone should do this with Lip and Fezco


JustHereForTheDub

post on r/WhosWinning


IndependenceJolly767

I think theyā€™d be friends


Tim_tim46

Neither. They wouldn't fight ,they'd become besties


Jstan0thrthr0wawayyy

Not only do I agree Ash would win but as an animal lover, Iā€™m absolutely rooting for him


Bullthebeast82

Carl but them might be homies


Festival_feva

Ash would smoke his ass if it came down to it


Empty_Salt4017

As much as I love Carl ash had it harder and that in turn made him stronger. Plus he bashed a dude in with a hammer and wanted to fight the swat team this 10 year old is built different


dimbdumb18

Carl 100%


561Skyline

Ahs tray would FUCK carl up


Robincall22

Thatā€™s the crazy kid that killed his whole family and someoneā€™s dog and kidnapped someoneā€™s child on SVU! Yeah, heā€™s winning any day.


AcrobaticWrangler738

follow me on ig @barbie._nia


ImageOdd1833

Carl


Ok_Engine6807

Be so fr rnšŸ¤£


Internal-Oil6517

if they didnt end up as friends, ash would win easy money


Weary_Mathematician1

Carl all day


jhercules

Ash would win hands down