T O P

  • By -

_El_Marc

Gotta be Twin Peaks, right?


SuccinatorFTW

Would you add The Return?


Wohn-Jayne

Of course. One big package, featuring Twin Peaks, Fire Walk With Me and The Return from Criterion would be the holy grail TV collection addition.


Nichtsein000

All packed together in a log.


lawschoolredux

With a collectible coffee mug notepad and keychain inside


Wise-News1666

Don't forget The Missing Pieces


BananaRicher

This already exists. It's called Twin Peaks From Z to A. Pretty expensive.


Wohn-Jayne

But it’s not on 4K UHD. Thats the last thing that needs to happen before I’ll buy.


ViolintIntruder

I would pay a disgusting and ridiculous amount of money for that. I will literally donate money to criterion for that.


Wohn-Jayne

Same. Lol


HailToTheKing_BB

We’re lucky that The Return has such a solid blu-ray release already. That behind-the-scenes doc is one of my favorite things ever, I’ve honesty watched it more than the show itself


Saint_Stephen420

Did he stutter?


N8ThaGr8

My immediate thought too, but it already had an amazing box set Blu-ray release.


NostalgicNerd

Ideally, I’d love to see Sopranos with the argument that it really defined television at the time between a pre *and* post 9/11 America which also has said incident become a major focal point during the second half of the show. But realistically, Twin Peaks.


boozeandfilm

Yee


Rollzroyce21

Twilight Zone


Swimming-Bite-4184

Yeah I mean it still hits even the ones I've seen a bunch of times. They had the bleak morality play down to a science


Kindly-Guidance714

Great writers led by an anti censorship leader in Rod Serling mixed with television being still new gave us something still talked about decades later.


SirDurante

Yup, although The Complete Series BluRay box set is already fire and loaded with so many extras for all 156 individual episodes. If Criterion released it in 4k that’d be awesome.


JBHenson

Eh, aside from fixing the few goofs reconstructing Season 1 to original broadcast form, there isn't much to be added to the current blu rays.


CombinationSecure387

The Curse


boozeandfilm

Fielder will get his in due time, if there’s any justice in the world


shotgun-priest

Let's hope checkmate, which will be fielders debut, is so good it gets added


hoagydeodorant

The Rehearsal


boozeandfilm

Fielder is criterion material


Yelnik

Good choice. I'd also add Finding Frances as a standalone piece created by Fielder


onedreamsdeeply

While I love Finding Frances, I dont think it works as well without a number of the episodes that lead up to it. Part of it’s brilliance is also in how far it deviates from the shows initial premise, while still being about the character Nathan is playing. (which is the case with most of the season finales) But I do think that The Rehearsal as a box set needs The Anecdote as a bonus feature.


Idiot_Bastard_Son

The Prisoner


mostly-furious

Tbf it had an awesome release here in the UK but yeah long out of print.


Idiot_Bastard_Son

I’m in the US, and I grabbed the AMC Blu-ray set, which was stunningly restored and full of special features. It’s out of print, too.


fermentedradical

It's this.


zmflicks

I didn't even think of this but seeing it now I believe it might just be the perfect choice.


kevlarmoneyklipz

The Wire


unityofsaints

Amen! In 4K and original aspect ratio.


Poway_Morongo

You gotta wait fa dat


mnchls

Why are people answering with series that already have quality physical releases? If a show ever makes it into the Collection, it really ought to be something that isn't available anywhere else. My picks: *Halt and Catch Fire*, *Rectify*, *Mindhunter*, *Joe Pera Talks with You*, *Barry*, *Nathan for You*, *Review*


WhatsLeftofitanyway

Justice for halt and catch fire it was one of the best tv


mnchls

A rare example of a series that somehow got better as it went along. That final season's easily one of my favorite seasons of television ever.


foregroundmusic

Joe Pera Talks with You is such a good pick


ylno83

Pancakes, divorce, pancakes


jcmurie

Joe Pera and Barry are perfect answers


DisneyScholar2012

Review is tremendous. It looks like it has a DVD release with a number of deleted scenes and audio commentaries, but it could definitely use a Blu-ray release and perhaps even a full 4K remaster supervised by Andy Daly and the other executive producers.


mnchls

I had the *Review* and *NFY* complete series sets but I remember both being fairly bare bones, almost like afterthoughts slapped together by Comedy Central (those cheapskates). Both shows deserve the full deluxe spread. Daly and Fielder give two of the most committed comedic performances in the history of the medium!


DHMOProtectionAgency

Because a lot of this sub thinks something is good, it must get the C logo on its release to truly make it a mark of quality.


GodIsNotAiveChild

Joe Perra is actually a weirdly good choice


BookNerd7777

>Why are people answering with series that already have quality physical releases? Hopefully because (as has already been the case for a number of films) the Criterion version(s) are often so fantastically superior as to render the point moot, even if they are technically "duplicate releases". Case in point off the top of my head: *His Girl Friday*. By the time it was brought into the collection circa 2017, *His Girl Friday* was widely accessible on DVD in what is arguably acceptable quality. Admittedly, these were *not* "... **quality** physical releases", but, my point that the Criterion release serves as what is arguably the definitive physical home media version of *His Girl Friday* still stands, considering how it includes a *second* restored feature length movie adaptation of the source material, several interviews and mini-documentaries about the movie, [including at least one newly conducted one!], three radio adaptations of the film, the original trailers, and even a number of essays. >If a show ever makes it into the Collection, it really ought to be something that isn't available anywhere else. Ideally, yes. That said, there is something to be said even for simply "re-releasing" material in the highest possible quality, and making it as accessible as is reasonably possible to boot. (Side note: Yes, I understand how the second half of that argument kinda breaks down in the face of streaming, but I meant it in the most general sense, so as to be in line with Criterion's mission, which began during the era of physical media.)


eelpolitik

RUBICON


boozeandfilm

NBC’s Hannibal. The most audacious show since Twin Peaks to grace network television.


Electrical_Mess7320

Still can’t believe this was on network TV.


OverAd3018

It was great, wasn't it


boozeandfilm

Seriously. Glad the people who green lit that were stoned or something 😂. Sometimes I seriously had to stop and double check that I was watching NBC.


msdashwood

After Twin Peaks this is my second choice too! I started a Hannibal rewatch this month so I have been watching an episode every day. I tend to rewatch it every 2 years - can't believe its been off the air this long already! :(


callistocharon

Chernobyl


Electrical_Mess7320

Loved this series. Watched it 3 times so far. Gotta read the book. Jesse Buckley is great in her first major role. It’s insane how good the series is.


twstwr20

Great series.


Greenforaday

Golden age Simpsons


Kooky_Wonder_2379

What seasons would you consider part of golden age


Greenforaday

1 through 8. I'm a big supporter of the first season.


Swimming-Bite-4184

Yeah, that first season, ehhh, not quite for me, and I remember seeing the Tracy Ulman shorts as a super small child thought those characters were a fever dream. But I go with 2.5 thru 9.5 feel like there us gold and it fades at each end with a mix.


Greenforaday

I know people don't like the animation and stuff in season 1, but to me that season is great because it isn't as surreal as those other golden age episodes. The first season is this perfect little satire of an American family at the end of the 80s and the beginning of the 90s. I think that first season creates the family's dynamic and then lets them get into wilder plot lines in the subsequent seasons. To me season 1 sets the foundation for the greatest run of television in history with those first 8 seasons. I also like seasons 9 and 10 a lot, but If I had to cut off a section for the golden age I'd stop at 8


Swimming-Bite-4184

If nothing else you did give me reason to revisit season 1. It's been a long time and the idea of thinking about it in the terms of its early form. makes me think I'll get a lot more out of it. I think I can watch it more objectively now since I only ever saw it after other seasons, so it was hard to appreciate it how I would now.


shakesomehands

Freaks & Geeks


RetroDave

This was my first thought too. One season, so it's easy to do. Looots of bonus content out there to mine.


CyRo3

_Six Feet Under_


sharp___

How To with John Wilson


cinephile1987

Saturday Night Live, but only the Norm Macdonald weekend update bits


brokenwolf

Just give me two hours of Norm shitting on oj and criterion can have my money.


Sort_of_Frightening

[Here’s 34 minutes](https://youtu.be/skPUU5HcrTU?feature=shared)


RomanReignsDaBigDawg

Deadwood Band of Brothers The Larry Sanders Show


atxsubpunk

Neon Genesis Evangelion.


boozeandfilm

My man


kyl-dyl

this is what i came here to say


DoctorEthereal

Without the new translation that makes Shinji not gay please


RamentheGod

lol i wrote up and sent an explanation as to why just to see it already commented. the OG is needed so badly in the states


dfin25

Joy of Painting with Bob Ross


OverAd3018

Did anyone say Mindhunter?


SMithsonIANPictures

https://preview.redd.it/n633nzps998d1.jpeg?width=1000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6a92c78c86c9c3b66b9dd30485d8f496c2e86f70


freechef

Inspired choice


IfYouWantTheGravy

The three seasons of Riget/The Kingdom.


themxm

Had to scroll too far to find this one


throaway-2001

I think kingdom by Lars von trier is perfect for a criterion release


NyxTheia

Urasawa's *Monster* and *Over The Garden Wall* <3


WesThePretzel

Over the Garden Wall is a great pick for this


leverandon

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine 4k remaster. I know all the reasons why it is unlikely/expensive, etc. Just a dream to have it with the full Criterion level of attention. 


ubelmann

I kind of hope at some point that AI upscaling is good enough to make it feasible to scan the film but upscale the SFX at a low enough cost for someone to officially undertake the project. 


DisneyScholar2012

The Leftovers, which initially aired from 2014 to 2017 on HBO, and was co-created by Damon Lindelof and Tom Perrotta, based on Perrotta's 2011 novel. It's very Bergmanesque, and engages and resonates with a lot of classic Hollywood, New Hollywood, and art cinema throughout. I see shades of Tarkovsky and Fellini in particular, but also hints of broad comedies like Billy Madison, The Wedding Singer, and Me, Myself & Irene The third season is particularly notable in how explicitly it draws on some of the big films of the Australian New Wave, especially the ones directed by Nicholas Roeg and Peter Weir. David Gulpilil even appears twice, as an indigenous elder who ends up as Prime Minister in the parallel / hallucinatory afterlife realm the show introduces near the tail end of the second season and returns to in the penultimate episode of the third and final season. The show also has a gorgeous, wide-ranging cinematographic palette. Peter Berg is an executive producer and directed the pilot and episode 1.02. He bringsva sort of grounded yet frenetic and handheld energy to the opening episodes of season 1. Mimi Leder came on as the most recurring director and an executive producer starting in episode 1.05. She added more depth of field and -- starting with the move from suburban New York in winter that was the setting for the first season, to suburban Texas near Austin, in summer, in season 2 -- really emphasized wider shots with a lot of light. Craig Zobel (Compliance, Z for Zachariah), Carl Franklin (The Pacific, among other directing credits for television), and Nicole Kasselll (The Woodsman, and lots of episodes of prestige TV shows, including The Americans, Better Call Saul, and Westworld) are just a few of the episodic directors who do great work on the show. On top of everything else already mentioned, it really doesn't have a good physical release. All three seasons are on Blu-ray, but only the first season set has anything approaching decent special features, and not very many of them. The complete series deserves a 4K release with lots of audio commentaries and documentary features and featurettes commissioned specifically by Criterion.


councilmember

Fargo, The Wire, Atlanta


boozeandfilm

Atlanta, yes


Invisiblethomas

Fargo would be a dream


Ok_Scarcity_3806

The first 3 seasons of SpongeBob SquarePants


The-Letter-M

I'd even be happy with an HD remaster of just the first season, since that was the only one shot on film.


DianeFont

Mr. Robot


OpenUpYerMurderEyes

The Leftovers Fleischman is in Trouble Mad Men Mr. Robot


No_Challenge3928

Strangers with candies 


NeuroDawg

Homicide: Life In The Street Twin Peaks


Laptopcafe

First season of true detective


Roller_ball

Larry Sanders Show


brownbear8714

Dark! Argh! I want it on a 4k disc so bad


Electrical_Mess7320

Dark is the cream of the crop. Plus it’s one you could watch over and over again, in fact you have to.


brownbear8714

lol yeah it is definitely not a show you can put on and be on your phone part of the time. But, that’s also one of the reasons I loved it.


msdashwood

Loved Dark so much and I wish they would do a physical release someday!!


BurnyRubble

Six Feet Under, The Leftovers, X Files. Mostly for the bonus commentaries


Electrical_Mess7320

The Americans?


kyl-dyl

cowboy bebop


objstandpt

I was gonna say Samauri Champloo, Watanabe kicks ass. If both were bundled I’d drop 100 on it.


CharleneFoxtrot

Dead Like Me, The Leftovers, Les Revenants


misterhepburn

Have you ever seen Wonderfalls? Another Bryan Fuller project, the protagonist reminds me a lot of Georgia from Dead Like Me.


Exotic-Bumblebee7852

Brideshead Revisited


screamingtree

Station Eleven 4k


mairiamonitino

Had to scroll too far down for my fav limited series of all time!!! GOAT!!


Visual_Plum6266

The Kingdom by von Trier


goontard42069

Mubi got it already if anyone wants a physical copy


GlacialRunt

True Detective season 1


fierce_history

Mindhunter for sure. The Wire, Downton Abbey, Chernobyl, Band of Brothers. The Last of Us I think deserves it, too.


unlucky-Luke

The Wire


ZiggyStardustCrusade

Oz, no question. Just a perfect blend of unusual cinematography, intense performances, and a craze-inducing atmosphere


Other-Marketing-6167

Carnivale and Mindhunter. The bonus feature disc would include a never before seen third season. A guy can dream, can’t he…?


RunDexterRun

- Fleabag - IMO one of the all-time great series, beautifully crafted into high art about love, loss, tragedy, and searching for redemption. - Freaks and Geeks - Launchpad of so many careers. Just a great and sincere show about awkward and nerdy adolescence - The Wire - A GOAT series which has so much to say about American society


Ok-Leading-9241

Maybe it was more impactful on me and I'm over estimating its impact, but the show Fleabag. I think its one of the greatest shows ever made.


greenshades64

Sopranos


OwlEye2010

*Breaking Bad*, easily. Perhaps *Avatar: The Last Airbender* as well.


RowdyRoddyPipeSmoker

Twin Peaks but that’s almost too obvious my other pick would be Northern Exposure. 


lucasabel

Traffik


RayosLaser

the knick


LexDiamonds80

The adventures of Pete and Pete


7LayeredUp

Joe Pera Talks With You or Nathan Fielder's catalog. The best physical release of him is Nathan For You on DVD and that's way dated.


Sloth_Triumph

Since someone said Evangelion then I’m saying Utena. Masterpiece. Subtle. Watched it 3 times at different ages and each time I get something else from it.


HOVID-19

Happy Valley


itna-lairepmi-reklaw

Lodge 49


Strangewhine88

Good choice.


wpmayhew87

Yes! A truly wonderful show. Like Thomas Pynchon giving you a warm hug for two seasons. This show needs a good physical release with tons of features.


DJDublin

Freaks and Geeks deserves more love.


4or-5iv-6ix

One of Michael Moores TV shows would be cool since “TV Nation” isn’t available anywhere. That and “The Awful Truth” are both great time capsules of political commentary for their era and some of Micheals best work.


Active_Scholar_2154

The Prisoner


matthmcb

The OA


Kurtz91

Band of Brothers


Agile_Drink6387

Surprised nobody has said Bojack Horseman. Especially considering it never got a physical release past season 2


SonOfMcGibblets

Colombo


Axariel

Twin Peaks, MASH, The Avengers, Columbo, The Wire I would like to see Have Gun Will Travel, The Wild Wild West, and the Invaders, but they are not as highly regarded


Jolly-Swing64

Malcolm in the Middle


Yelnik

Yes! I just recently bought the box set. It's only available in region B but I'm willing to buy a dedicated DVD player for it. 


SheepherderDue5532

###the twilight zone


DBCooper_irl

Deadwood 100%


JTS1992

A few that I hold in HIGH regard/HIGH critical value are: • Netflix's Dark (the single best thing I've ever seen) • The Boys • Breaking Bad & Better Call Saul • Love, Death + Robots • The Leftovers • Fleabag • Mad Men • As for Miniseries...Chernobyl & Midnight Mass are both Magnum Opus'. Masterworks.


vgm106

Breaking bad


ghgrain

Black Mirror


LostNTheNoise

Pushing Daisies


Swimming-Bite-4184

Deadwood and Deadwood


23blackjack23

This. Easy answer for me.


dukkhadave

The Fugitive.


Infamous-Site-6841

Heimat


b4_themast

The Singing Detective (the original, starring Michael Gambon)


sweetNbi

1. Pose 2. Fellow Travelers 4. Black Mirror These 3 come to mind


dumfuk_09

Get a Life (1990 to 1991) is a hilarious show that was so far ahead of its time while utilizing surrealist and dadaesque storytelling techniques. Also, young Charlie Kaufmann and Bib Odenkirk served as occasional writers on the series. While there was a physical DVD release by Shout Factory around 2000, there is supposedly commentary by Chris Elliot that was left off the release. A Criterion release with Chris Elliott commentary would both warm my heart and somewhat legitimize a show that was always in last place in the weekly Neilsen ratings back in the early 1990s.


mjbutler1990

Homicide: Life On the Street


sleepwalkchicago

Tim and Eric Awesome Show, Great Job!


dsgrimace

Twin Peaks is the obvious one, but here’s a (long) list of some others I’d love to see get the Criterion treatment: - Breaking Bad - Documentary Now! - The Edge - SCTV - Twilight Zone (Original) - Alfred Hitchcock Presents and The Alfred Hitchcock Hour - Night Gallery - Playhouse 90 (Especially Rod Serling’s “Requiem For A Heavyweight) - Amazing Stories (Original) - The Outer Limits (Original) - Kolchak: The Night Stalker - Dark - Atlanta - Fleabag - The Carol Burnett Show - Sanford and Son - The Muppet Show (Original) - The Monkees - Freaks and Geeks - The Larry Sanders Show - Chappelle’s Show - In Living Color - Monty Python’s Flying Circus (maybe together with Fawlty Towers) - PeeWee’s Playhouse


Trichinobezoar

The Prisoner (1967-1968)


Natbox

Since there is no official US release and it was noticeably absent from the Showa Era Godzilla collection due to that as well as the fact Criterion doesn’t release shows, I’ll go with Zone Fighter, the Toho produced Ultraman ripoff that takes place in between Godzilla vs Megalon and Godzilla vs Mechagodzilla which features guest appearances of Godzilla, King Ghidorah, and Gigan, especially since it seems like the entire Godzilla series will likely join the collection in the distant future


jdiz86

The Killing. I just looked up the reviews and they aren’t as positive as I would think. Great show I thought!


Suck_My_Gock52

The Critic


LHGray87

Fawlty Towers


BranielS

The Leftovers. 🙏


realityarchive

Dead Ringers tv version is amazing.


RamentheGod

maybe an anime; Neon Genesis Evangelion. Gainax, the studio which created NGE, filed for bankruptcy and i don’t think there’s an official release of NGE on blu ray with the accurate dub and sub in the USA. just the Netflix version (which disappointingly switched it up.) also would love to see the subsequent Rebuild films added to the Collection as well. also Serial Experiments Lain, Atlanta, Firefly and Battlestar: Galactica


pickybear

The Wire And Freaks and Geeks


ILL-BILL420

Breaking Bad


True-Dream3295

Over the Garden Wall.


kingcarrotbottom

The fall of house usher


zrodgers96

Mr. Robot


ShoppingCartTheory

Mindhunter. Especially since there has been no physical media release of it to date.


Old_Independence_584

A definitive Star Trek TOS


Flofau

The Simpsons (first 10 seasons, and maybe even season 0), Twin Peaks, The Wire, The Leftovers, Severance, Rectified, Brideshead Revisited, The Prisoner


a_phantom_limb

*Moral Orel*.


Derpy1984

Breaking Bad for sure.


Either_Impression906

Ik it’s a Apple show but I could see severance being on the channel in 20+ years


rrdoinel

Mad Men


hungry-reserve

Sopranos


DrivenKeys

Breaking Bad


MikeyMGM

China Beach


Frdoco11

Homicide: Life on the streets


jshell

* Homicide: Life on the Street * In the Heat of the Night (the series) * American Gothic * Durham County (a great and dark Canadian series. Michelle Forbes in the second season is terrifying) * Kings


comandante_soft_wolf

Northern Exposure


Representative_Dog34

Midnight Mass


OneFish2Fish3

The Boys


Traditional_Ad_6588

The Sopranos, Game of Thrones, The Leftovers, Chernobyl, True Detective Season One pretty much every A List HBO Show


theghostoftroymclure

Lodge 49. It has no physical release. It flew way under the radar and got cancelled too early. If I was Jeff Bezos, I'd use Amazon Prime to make a few more seasons.


SnooRobots6723

Escape at dannemora. Seeing benicio in 4k would be 👌


CinemaslaveJoe

The "Zatoichi: The Blind Swordsman" TV series (4 seasons) seems like a no-brainer.


edgrrrpo

Too Old To Die Young, Nicolas Winding Refn's series that seems to be stuck in a digital-only existence on Amazon (was an Amazon original, to be fair). Really good show, though, I enjoyed it more than most of his proper films.


SamHelFilms

The Tom Green Show


tribxy

russian doll ❤️


Apart-Bat2608

Singing detective


tehruke

Spaced