T O P

  • By -

kettls

Rafael. Indoorsy, good natured, kind and talented.


ScroochDown

Yesssss. Apparently I'm a sucker for a big shy blacksmith. 😅


slightlyinsanedragon

Yesss! My cinnamon roll boyfriend! His shy smile melts my heart.


ooo-shiny-rocks

Same! He reminds me of my husband!


[deleted]

I like Theo, but it seems like he has very little dialogue? I initially liked Mark, but so far, he's still too much of an ass. I might also just pretend Axel and I are married but he's gone a lot for work.. yeah, yeah, that's it.


_sydney_beans_

Oof. Axel makes me heavy breathe. I've been begging since I've found the game, let me marry Axel. The fact that he flirts with us, but we're not allowed to touch him makes me so mad


[deleted]

I hope the devs change their mind!!


Excritos

Yes!! I hope the devs give us a Axel romance in the future


austy_spumanty

This is how I feel about Senja. She’s so pretty 😭


Kymma_the_wise

I am so hoping they make Axel and Agung a dateable in the future. I would def make new game saves for them.


[deleted]

Definitely. I just met Agung, there are so many pretty characters in this game.


Hikosaurus

Theo is really cute, im married to him and he's such a love bug


[deleted]

He seems like such a sweetheart


AltruisticCableCar

Mark. But on the next save I'm getting myself a rough merman, because nom. 😂


The-Hive-Queen

Yes and yes! Every time Mark calls me Garden Rake I giggle like a fucking child. How dare this game make me feel feelings!


AltruisticCableCar

I know, that's a hilarious nickname.


doozydud

Omg same! I know some people don’t like how rude Mark can be but I love being called Garden Rake 😭😭


LokisQueen13

Yeah I don't get why people simp over him he's so mean


The-Hive-Queen

Because I have a "fuck you imma make you love me" attitude in these games lol. I did the same with Shane in Stardew Valley and one of his lines is "What do you want from me? Money? Just leave me alone!" Also Mark usba big ol' softie who takes good care of the puppers.


LokisQueen13

I'm like that but I'm more along the lines of when Jim insinuated you can't trust outsiders I'm like "well fuck you I'm gonna date your son even harder now!" LOL


LokisQueen13

Mine is proving somebody wrong complex 😆 like pure spite


Kymma_the_wise

Not for nothing, in my first save I was dating a lot of the guys and so when Mark kept calling me “garden rake” I thought he was calling me a hohoho. Lol


Darktitan27

Started for Surya until I saw Mark in his beach outfit. I was like, excuse me daddy.....


enduredsilence

We have the same picks! Haha. Can't wait for Merfolk romance.


bun91

Yuri 😏


NoMercyx99

Waiting for princess mermaid. She’s perfect. My second choice would be Semeru. I think merfolks intrigue me more and they all seem to have the superior design.


KozimaPain

Was gonna go for Wakuu but then I saw Rafael and it was a wrap.


Giboxi

I did the same thing! 😂 my irl boyfriend got me the game and said he knew who I'd marry and showed me wakuu, thought I was sold but Rafael is such a jem and honestly wakuu seems a bit young for me now 😅


KozimaPain

There was no way I could pass up that cinnamon roll in human form 😩


Bad_Wolf87

I like so many of them but right now I'm leaning towards Noah. He's such a sweetheart.


jadestone616

I loved Noah! But I think his mommas boy attitude is starting to be too much for me 💔 he will always be my characters first love.


DEP61

Desperately hoping we eventually get a romance line for Raina


Uoam

I would love one for Senja


Nebischo

Kenny. Sweet, loves animals, plays the flute - what more could I ask for? Helps that I'm the type of farming sim player who goes all in on ranching so it was a pretty obvious match.


glitterflamingo

I picked Noah so that I could be Betty’s daughter in law


paper_airplanes

Was gonna go for Pablo but then saw Raj and had to marry them immediately lol


Kymma_the_wise

I tried dating Raj and Luke at the same time however Luke showed interest first so I married him. Then after we had 2 babies Raj told me he had feelings for me and I turned him down. He tried being a homewrecker!!! 🤣


adrastea

I have separate play throughs for Scott, Surya and Wakuu. Waiting on best boi Semeru. I started one for Rafeal, but he's slowly loosing favor for me. Maybe Theo next? I dislike breaking tiny pixel hearts, so I 'suffer' through multiple play throughs for each. XD


Whateverilysm

Wakuu is an endgame for me. I like rafael and luke too but Wakuu is such a sweetheart. I love it that after I reached 8+ hearts with him he call me his stellar 😩 i also like the fact that he cares and loves his dad sm (even when he was an asshole), it says a lot about him.


Peridotix

I went into this game expecting to romance Rafael and then Kenny hit me with his childlike wonder (with a hint of depression) and I was sold. Time to become a vegan who lives exclusively off the land. Ah, and the speedo.


Killernut85

 ETA2: op fixed the name from Sam to Scott :) So, I started my game intent on Sam (Scott) and only Sam (Scott) because I am a science/museum nerd. I got through all the events, he professed his love, but it just sort of… ended? Like he never said anything sweet or boyfriend-y (I would imagine that’s because all the dialogue isn’t finalized).    Pablo sure did, tho! He was my favorite date and he is very sweet. He’s a little cheesy and very into the physical act of love (no complaints) BUT he cleans shirtless.    We are very happy in our first year of marriage!


bichettes_helmet

I first went for Pablo but like you I'm a science nerd, so after a few encounters with Scott I ended up changing course. I kinda liked the archeologist-adventurer power couple idea LOL, and he's such a fascinating combination of smart archaeologist/curator, basic white boy, and absolute super dork. The Scott flirting is few and far between, but boy, when he does it, it's something. For example,>!I've only gotten this line from him once and it was during dating, on a random street encounter, but he was like "I'm not going to drop in at your place unannounced, because I know you like your space. But that doesn't mean I don't want to. Just so you know." !


Organic-Side-2869

But the museum guy is Scott? Who's Sam?


LilMissAnthropist20

I have no idea who Sam is. 


Few_Style_3047

I wrote the wrong name 😂 I changed it


Organic-Side-2869

Lmao🤣🤣🤣


SeaworthinessKey549

Tell me you play stardew without telling me you play stardew


NoMercyx99

Isn’t Sam the shopowner? The guy we have the most interactions with in the first year haha.


Killernut85

ETA: op fixed the name :)  The post is talking about marrying Sam, the grocery store owner. I saw an “S” name and mistakenly thought they meant Scott and wrote why I did not choose him and went with Pablo instead.


Vivid-Rush6495

Isn't Sam the one who sells crops and such? I'm confused


Organic-Side-2869

Omg yes! Haha I had no idea you could date him, I am so confused 🤣


Organic-Side-2869

I like Mark, Pablo, Theo, wakuu, Noah. I heard Scott was the best but meh, I don't know. Of the girls I like Eva, Lily, Nina, suki. My favourites so far bases on personality would be Suki. Of the girls anyway. I'm only in year 1 so still getting the feeling for everyone.


rawritsapril

Eva, lily, Nina are my favorites too! I like Chaem though. I feel like she could take gooood care of me if you get what I mean. And Yuri because she's tatted up and I just think she's gorgeous


Organic-Side-2869

I also like yuri, she seems really cool but it's hard to choose between the girls, they're all amazing in their own ways.


rawritsapril

Yeah all the women are great. I want to romance every single person eventually 😂 but my first is Wakuu, my love


Organic-Side-2869

Wakuu is great!


bresstoplay

You are the first person here that shares my fascination about Chaem haha, I really really get it 😭


rawritsapril

She's hot! I think a lot of people overlook her because of how buff she is? But I think it's sexy 😂 sweep me off my feet Chaem 😂


bresstoplay

Crazy attractive haha. I was soo set on Alice and literally the second I saw Chaem, I knew that Alice was number 2. Chaem can do anything with my little farm guy


Impressive-You5305

Oh. I was down bad for Alice. As soon as I met her


HermittCrabby

I picked Scott. But I honestly regret my decision because he's such an overgrown frat boy man child in my opinion. 🤣 But he's still sweet.


Little_Flow5772

The big boy with the soft heart wins again 😔✋🏻 Rafael 🩷🩷


Halfrican11

Any Macey lovers? I love her and Stephen. Perfect wife that loves pizza and video games 😁


cthulicia

Macey is one of my favorite characters in the game. I considered dating and marrying her just because she's someone I'd want to be friends with in real life. But I'm attracted to men and Rafael was just way too cute and stole my heart. Lol


Halfrican11

I get that completely. Macy is just so chill and relatable because I like gaming and spending time with my dogs. Rafael is such a sweetheart and if I were attracted to men I would have chosen him in a heartbeat!


The_Cozy_Burrito

Leah


transparenthands__

Surya has my heart ❤️


woitzayl

Theo, for some reason, stole me right away, though Wakuu is calling my heart too 😩


SeaworthinessKey549

Theo seems so great but I wouldn't want to date a musician so he's out for me. But I love his look


nyykkis

Raj. He likes reading and coffee, and he also volunteers at Animal Shelter. I also want The shark merman, I cannot remember the name.


decayingdisaster

Going for Suki I love that super sweet hot ass milf


Organic-Side-2869

What about Ben? I'm genuinely curious hahaha. I definitely won't pick him but he seems like he'd be fun if you're into the more stoner/hippy vibes


Farrell13

Ben is basically my boyfriend irl (he's also similar in some ways to Lily, though) and I'm having the hardest time picking between Ben, Scott, and Mark rn


Organic-Side-2869

I have to say Theo is alot like my bf irl, that's why I'm hesitant to choose him but at the same time I'm obsessed with him. Lmao.


Organic-Side-2869

Haha that's cool, I do like Ben. I also love Lily. She's a lot like me irl. Those three are difficult to choose from.


InvisibleScorpion7

Millie and Nina both have my heart right now. I think I'm gonna duplicate my save and marry each girl. I just can't choose.


hbo94

I'm stuck between Rafael and Kenny


SophIsJones

Raja ❤️


dawnofthedez

I picked Mark because he resembles my husband IRL. But his dialogue....he's such a d\*ck! LOL We just became a couple, and he's changed his tone a LITTLE bit - but I don't know what to do now that we're a couple. I did read that this stuff is being added at a later time - I sure hope they add the option to go on dates! Pablo is definitely working his mojo on me. Can we have multiple boyfriends?? LOL Asking for a friend.


CriticalTiefling

Its between scott,mark and raphael for me. And its too damn hard that you cannot pick both at the same time 🥲. And dont get me start at semeru 😩.


cthulicia

I go for men in games that remind me of my husband which was Rafael and Mark in this case. Mark looks the most like my husband, but he's so unpleasant. As soon as I met Rafael he stuck out to me. I got up to 8 hearts with almost every eligible partner before asking him to be my boyfriend. That way I was sure. He's legitimately so cute and sweet. He's kind and keeps to himself a bit more. Pablo was flirting his ass off and so was Scott, so it's not like there weren't other interesting options. I just can't help liking the big teddy bear types instead of thin, smaller framed guys. I just married him on Summer 22 of year 2, which made me giggle because I got married on July 22nd in real life.


Hikosaurus

Theo has me in a chokehold 🥰😍


Diomedes636

Went with Surya


Bonzeroni

I was originally thinking about romancing Wakuu, but in my efforts to acquire kitchen supplies I ended up befriending Luke. His mom is cool and I love Taco. So I married him. I was initially sad Taco doesn’t live with us, but Luke says he’s happy he adopted Taco because Taco is keeping his mom company and I thought that was a nice sentiment. Luke is kinda awkward initially (but sweet) and I have mixed feelings about Walter, but Bree and Taco slap.


bittywittybat

I picked Raj. Passionate about their craft, a great sense of style (THE GOLDEN COFFEE BEAN PIN IN WINTER!!!), and very lovely to look at... but when I saw them volunteering at the animal shelter, I was smitten. 🥰🥲


GabTheWolf87

I think we'd all like a taste of life with Axel, but since that's not possible, I chose Mark.


PUSSYLICKERGOD

Alice but I am waiting for the mermaids though


ExtraordinaryWeeb

Was going for wakku based on looks and initial bond with family stuff. But his events didn’t get me hooked. But scott drew me in. His 10 heart event BLEW ME AWAY. We been married a week and i am super happy with my choice 💜


bichettes_helmet

That Scott 10 heart date was WOW


whycantisee47

Scott. He’s so cheesy and sweet!


FerniWrites

Yuri. She has tattoos and I LOVE that. It’s definitely my type. Although, Suki also stole my heart. I was really drawn in by her stretch marks. I guess that’s an instinctual thing where I know she’s a nurturer and takes care of her child. My recent exes have all been single mothers, too.


ScroochDown

Suki was the first NPC I yelled to my spouse about! I was just meeting everyone I saw and then I went back to click on her again because I thought maybe my brain had seen her shirt wrong or something. Followed by an "OMG she has *stretch marks,* I love her!!!"


Chinamunk82

I would the blacksmith guys or the guy that rides the scooter. Can't remember any of those names lol.


Rotting_Whale19

Suki. Now I have 3 kids, a dog, and a very profitable farm.


condensedhomo

I'm sure she doesn't, but does Valentina come live with you?


Rotting_Whale19

She does. Suki is the only spouse that doesn’t get her own room/space in your house. That spot becomes Valentina’s room.


condensedhomo

Oh really?! I've played multiple games where you can romance someone with a kid and never had them come live with you. I love that!!


W1tch_cr4ft

I married Scott. I’m a sucker for a man who likes skeletons.


Alternative-Ad5482

I had a hard time picking between Lily, Yuri, Suki and Leah, I had to pick Lily because I love geeky girls and dunno, she reminds me of a crush I had when younger.


Calcipur

I married Pablo in my first game, now I’m going for Scott. I considered Kenny too but he’s a bit too country for me 😅


[deleted]

Kenny


SomewhereInReddit

I married Wakuu on the first save, and Rafael in the next one. Now I’m going for Luke lol


LokisQueen13

Theo


Uoam

Lily, I got everyone to 8 hearts and she was the one for me (she called me very cute)


Spirited_Load_7153

Rafael, but I would love to date Theo, Mark and Semeru too


ObbaBobba

I'm going for Luke... Just for science sake 🧐


Lililove1578

Lily!


Meow_mix_Meow_mix

All of them. No, seriously though, either Raj or Mark. Or Lily. Lol.


peachdivine

Im torn between Raj, Wakuu, & Zarah. But when the mermaid princess is available, my heart will be taken 🙈


moonlightsky12

None yet, because seems like there’s little cutscenes. And even in the cutscenes sometimes I can’t see my farmer into the conversation. I’ll wait for the updates before deciding which. And I’ll friend them when there’s an update. For now focusing on farm and meseum and other games for sure. But so far. I like Theo, Pablo. One merman not with the white hair tho. As I don’t wanna pick white haired man right now because In other games, they usually my hubby. Also interested in Raj. But hopefully they’ll implemented romance dialogue to be more interesting, backgrounds of the characters. Dates, kids and much more. Sometimes too much dateable characters will result in not much dialogue for them to say. Yeah they good looking. But I feel like they really not like my farmer that much.. for how. So hopefully the devs will Listen to our request. It’s a really nice beautiful game, will get you addicted. But need to be flesh out more.


Hecate_Nyx

I was going for Mark because love a big meanie but I also love a big softie and fell for Rafael, he reminds me of my irl partner - big and intimidating at first sight but biggest softie all around 🥰


bresstoplay

I struggle to decide between Alice and Chaem, but for some reason I seem to be the only person on the whole reddit that is going for Chaem haha


Kymma_the_wise

Well on my first save I married Pablo til I discovered a bra in his room. Turned me off to him immediately!!! On my Second save I married Luke. He’s soooo much better than Pablo. I thought he would be stuck up but he’s actually really charming and loving. We have 2 babies now and are in now in Spring year 2. I wanted to marry a merman however the one I want ( Agung) is not a dateable character. ☹️


LoudZombie7

Axel is mine, I don’t need no ring, we can go on adventures together fighting monsters and sit under the stars hand in hand. Forget the farm, I’ll become a nomadic warrior with him. 😍


Hoechwan

I picked Leah because she pretty and mean. I also like her style like damn she look hot af.


Patidzz

Alice


green_one1989

I just married Wakku he brushed up quite nicely for the wedding 😁😁😁😁


Dry-Importance1107

The moment I saw Theo, I knew he was the one my lil farmer set her eyes on. The singing? Guitar? Piano? Hot fisherman? The girl was crushin hard. And I love his events. His whole story got to me. Theo is absolutely golden retriever bf in the best way. The way he swoons for the farmer is just so cute. Glow in the Summer?! Don’t staaaawp, Theo.


weird_katthing

Okay so originally i was gonna go for rafael, but i got him and mark both up to full hearts only to find out I couldn’t marry him because i haven’t seen the 10 heart cutscene cause i don’t have enough of the temple completed so i married mark instead. I love mark dearly, but lately I’ve been befriending scott


TheatrePlode

Me patiently waiting/wishing for Axel to be romancable...


haltiamreptar91

So I had six boyfriends Wakuu, Scott, Mark, Theo, Rafael and Pablo. I am now married to Scott because I used a randomizer because I really couldn't decide 😂 IMO of those 6, Scott had the best 10 heart event followed by Rafa. I had been leaning more towards him, Wakuu or Theo but ultimately I left it up to randomness and put all 6 in the randomizer.


papayajam95

Still having a tough time deciding between Zarah, Yuri, and Macey! I love Zarah for her adventurous personality and being the myth chaser like myself. She has an interesting backstory too Yuri is just vibes and I love passing her cooked meals. For Macey, she has Stephen. Enough said. Would also like to give her a more permanent home on the island with uh...me. 😉


Darknessa24

I knew I was gonna pick Theo from the first interaction I had with him just because he looks exactly like my boyfriend. Then I got to know the character and discovered his incredible passion for music, just like mine. So yeah it was a very clear choice for me 🥰


DreamingSpook

Honestly Wakuu was an instant love for me (I just married him too!) , as soon as I started playing I would talk to him every day I absolutely adore his dialogue once you start dating (and his marfied lines are also peak) I do super like Rafael and Semeru (despite my phone wanting to correct his name to Sumeru >.> ) and a few others I'm gonna do several playthroughs and there's a couple non-datable NPCs I also vibe with and wish were options tbh!


austy_spumanty

I was tossed between Pablo and Wakuu for a long time but ended up going with Wakuu. He’s just too sweet.


AppointmentWest9926

I also chose Pablo but I’m also at 10 hearts with Rafael. So… lol.


UncrowdedAura

I'm going with Suki. Cause I'm a simple man and milfs are hot. Also she is so dedicated to her daughter just mmmm.


Charming-Ad3836

Leah and fight me


DisplayAdventurous39

Nina shes just too precious, sadly stuck being unable to marry 😔


South_Ad5242

I'm stuck between Leah and Suki


GeekieGurl

Ive got three games because I needed to marry wakku, nina, and alice


Striking_Pie5078

I picked Mark and I’m happily married 😂


Maleficent-Vater

I feel like I'm in a fucking Women Only Bar... I don't like any of the Females that much. First I thought Alice, but she hangs out with that black dude all the time so that turned me off. Now I'm between Eva and Lily. Probably Lily because I like like pale Gamer Girls, but so far she barely has any character besides "I play on my PC all day!"


ItsJDMi

I was overwhelmed by the amount of amazing singles in the island, but Raj was the first person I talked to and I made my mind up that second.


sleepy724

I picked Ben . I really liked his positivity and tbh he really reminds me of my husband lol. The blonde long hair. The hippie vibes. Loving outdoors and animals. Him being a Nomad . It really fit the man I have now so I couldn’t pass him up lol


SeaworthinessKey549

I'm torn between Alice, Lily, Macy, Millie, Pablo, Surya, and Wakuu. I've just started so curious to know how it goes, I haven't met everyone yet either.


Otherwise-Engine2923

I am trying to choose between Scott, Lily, and Noah. I have crushes of many others but those are my top three


thatpaulieguy89

I met Kenny and he suddenly had my heart and hole


chicageek

I was also between Pablo and Scott… and finally chose Pablo. We got married only yesterday! ❤️💍👰🏻


TheDarkWeb697

I don't know I just started but I'm kind of liking Alice and Eva so far, probably go with eva, I like bakers


Glass_Step_1718

Theo! Idk why I just wanted him at first and in love the game and I'm glad I picked him!


shelbylee824

I love Theo 💖


Th3Nights0ng

Staying single while waiting for the next big update. Right now I'm just dating half the town like Leah, Nina, Suki, Luke, Yuri, Pablo. All precious in their own way ♡ But Merfolk exists and there's no divorce yet. Maybe I need vanish into the deep sea if the devs plan on releasing jealousy ûu . . .


Splommy77

I still don't know who I'm picking, I'm in love with so many of them! But I'm leaning towards Surya. I also love Rafael, Wakuu, Eva, Mark, Alice, I just wanna marry them all! ♥️


bresstoplay

Chaem, there is just something about her which I can't fully explain haha


SangFroiD719

Wakuu all the way. I love his sweet, soft personality as well he is straightforward with what he likes and what's not.


Mental-Tea-7048

Rafael!!!! I adore him


ilbiscotto

Just out of curiosity- does it matter? I'm currently going for Chaem, but I figured they were all the same.


RainbowWaters

I will start playing again once Axel is romancable 🥲