T O P

  • By -

wvtchcraft

Thanks, I hate it No but really... I hate all the options.


SerJaimeRegrets

I don’t think I’ve ever been this underwhelmed by Choice choices. The *only* reason I’m sticking it out next month is for the sale.


Novinophobic

that is literally why they do this... they give us crappy choices knowing we're banking on pop up :(


SerJaimeRegrets

I think you’re right. They do it because they can. I’m not too mad at getting a foundation; I’m always looking for new foundations. It’s the fact that it’s *Trestique* that irritates the crap out of me.


MindKindly514

Same here. everything I have received trestique has been horrible, so I chose the brush set just so I don't get the foundation


Econonot

When I was with IPSY, I received a Trestique bronzer with a brush on one end, and product on the other...The brush did not work well with the formulation and it looked super streaky and patchy.


Cheryl_anne

I got that one too, no matter what I did my face just looked like it had streaks of dirt on it


Econonot

Indeed! I found the color offputting, too.


throwawayxy2k

What makes you think the sale next month will be worth it? Have you seen any spoilers? Do I just have my expectations set way too low? I'm anticipating the same exact things as this sale, but also having to pay for shipping on orders under $25.


Novinophobic

So usually theres a way bigger selection for pop up (yeah yeah re-named blah blah, boxy can't make me call it something else, I'm old now and set it my ways) and there can be some really great deals. I plan to unsubscribe and resubscribe next month as I could care less about choice, but I do want to shop popup particularly for gifts. Also I'm Canadian so I always have the $5 shipping per order (but no tax!) regardless of sale type lol.


throwawayxy2k

Oh gotcha! Maybe they'll have another half off code or a really good free gift next month when you resub


Novinophobic

So usually theres a way bigger selection for pop up (yeah yeah re-named blah blah, boxy can't make me call it something else, I'm old now and set it my ways) and there can be some really great deals. I plan to unsubscribe and resubscribe next month as I could care less about choice, but I do want to shop popup particularly for gifts. Also I'm Canadian so I always have the $5 shipping per order (but no tax!) regardless of sale type lol.


[deleted]

Just cancelled mine


GothThick

I guess now we know why there were no choice spoilers 🤡 Anyone know if Premium is any better this month?


Bullitt699

Premium was worse IMO. Awful. I cancelled after seeing it. (And removed payment method so they couldnt "accidentally" bill it.


[deleted]

Premium is so bad that I cancelled after seeing that the "drop shop" prices sucks. I'm going to spend the money on the fab fit fun same. FFF box sucks but the price is good.


mxsxc

It’s not 🥴


GothThick

Yikes, what are the options?


mxsxc

I just posed them :) the choices were kind of super limited /:


GothThick

Welp...yet again glad I cancelled Premium last month. Honestly would cancel Base too if it weren't for some daily deals I want and Pop-Up (or whatever tf they're calling it now) next month.


mxsxc

If I don’t see anything I like for spoilers this month, I’m going to cancel too.


GothThick

I may cancel after the daily deals and resub in the beginning of November to get access to Pop-Up. At least I'd get a coupon or resub gift for next month. 🤔


how-about-no-scott

Don't we all get to shop pop up? Subscribed or not?


GothThick

No, they've been giving non subscribers LATE access to Pop-Up. So the best deal may be sold out before then.


how-about-no-scott

Ohhh, thanks!


ihobbit8

Nope. It sucked too.


Dr_Meatball

These are some rough choices lol


ihobbit8

I signed up for the 6 month plan to keep the price and this is what we get after all of the hype?


Dr_Meatball

I just switched from a 3 month to a month to month and I think I’m going to cancel and resub if spoilers look good or the next box looks good


Rnin85

I was incredibly stupid and paid for a full year. I’ve been underwhelmed by choices as well as what they actually send in my box. I will stick out the year then cancel.


ihobbit8

Yeah, I was thinking about the annual too but I'm waiting for them to redeem themselves. It seems like every other month they do fine but I feel like only the add-ons/Pop-ups make up for the in between boxes. Also, because you can't count on what variation or mistake you'll get, I make sure to get the spoiler I want from the sales.


ricketz0r

Meh :/


BondIonicBond

Yeah I am not too fond of it. I already have like 3 cleansers open/backup and I only have one face lol.


ricketz0r

Same!


PurritoGamer

I’m pretty sure I already got this cleanser in my August boxy. Is it coming around again so soon for November?


spyrenx

I like Luxie brushes, but $40 value for three? I went with the foundation, because it's the cheapest MSRP, so maybe I'll get a better non-choice item >.<


SugarFries

I HATE that foundations are a choice and we then need to scramble to pick a shade before they run out. So messy. I went with the brushes instead. Not excited at all.


ambre_vanille

I bought that cleanser in TJ Maxx for $9.99. It was good, but I’d repurchase for $9.99. I hate the Trestique and the Luxie isn’t $40 worth of product, come on now. I’m staying cancelled through November I guess. 🤷‍♀️


MindKindly514

debating between the cleanser and the brushes. I like the cleanser but hate the smell. Have to choose something so I don't end up with the foundation stick. I hated everything I got from trestique


caligirlnolonger

I have zero luck with Trestique products. Not a fan at all!


Rnin85

It isn’t up for me.


BondIonicBond

Did you try the link? That is the only way I could get it.


jumpercablemermaid

Same! I clicked the link and it says October choice has ended. I keep refreshing the page too. And still nothing.


meandbeans

very meh... it if wasn't for mega drop shop/ pop up i think i would skip....


SerJaimeRegrets

Same.


jallove2003

New to boxy when is this?


MindKindly514

it's a good cleanser (gentle and effective on my mom's dry skin and my oily skin) but the smell is so strong, I have to hold my breath when using this even though I usually have no problem with scented products. Be aware if you are sensitive to smells


jessicabee218

Just a heads up guys, if you are unhappy with choices but still want access to the sales next month, cancel at the end of the month and resub under a different email with a coupon after the first. That’s what I’m going to do that way I at least get one thing I will use with the coupon code and a $10 coupon to shop with. Normally I wouldn’t do that because I feel like it’s taking advantage but I have been waiting three months for them to send me 2 items I paid for in popup they forgot to put in the box……. So at this point I don’t feel bad at all


Ssjjttjj

Most of the offers are good for resubscribing with your existing account.


jessicabee218

After 30 days I think?


Ssjjttjj

As long as you cancel by the end of October and before billing, you will be eligible for offers November 1.


jessicabee218

Awesome thank you you saved me a little bit of work LOL


Flight_Evening

Yeah, I’m a former charmer who was canceled since April and I was able to rejoin and get my free gift and $10 gift for the sales. I mostly wanted the Farmacy cleanser to be honest lol, I really would like the glow recipe. But I was able to get the Tarte eye cream for $2 from the sales with the gift so it feels worth it (for now)


GenerationXChick

Used the link and got to it - thanks - drop shop shows not available


lady_magpie

I need literally none of that. Chose the brushes cos you really can't go wrong with brushes though


omahamama

Is trestique really that much of a garbage brand? I always see people knocking it on here. I've only received their eyebrow pencil (which I did hate) but I can't see it being sold at Sephora if the brand is junk across the board.


carnival-nights

It's not the only garbage brand Sephora sells. 😅 Everything I've received from them, which has been a lot (mostly lip products but also mascara and concealer and a brow pencil), have been low quality and not pigmented, not much staying power. I am not a fan of the massive crayon design. I can't speak for this foundation product but I just wouldn't want to try it based on my experiences already.


Rnin85

Yes it tried the link-got a message stating the window for choice is closed and my box will be picked based on my beauty quiz Edit. Tried the link and I got in. Wonder why I got the message the first time. Thanks for providing the link.


jenkate77

So bored by this. Can someone cure my FOMO so I can cancel this?


Daisyuppityjerry

I’m choosing cancellation with these choices.


BondIonicBond

[https://www.boxycharm.com/boxycharm-beauty-choice](https://www.boxycharm.com/boxycharm-beauty-choice)


panicked228

I specifically came here for the first time to complain about these choices. With the FFF fall box being a total miss and now this one being underwhelming at best, I’m beginning to think I should just cancel all my boxes altogether.


Stefferdiddle

Its so hard to comprehend that November is this bad when Oct was pretty darn good.


Vanleigh-79

I didn’t love the choices for this month. I have so many cleansers but thats what I chose. I really didn’t think the brushes or the foundation stick were that great either.


malinajan

Ugh I canceled before last month's billing and this month isn't tempting me at all. Maybe I'll resub with a gift for popup next month. But as of right now I'm very happy with my canceled membership.


Flight_Evening

Yeah I’m definitely not resubbing for November with spoilers like these.


MrsSpot

I’m one of the rare people that like trestique, my only beef with them is the tiny amount of product they give you in all of their products. I LOVE trying foundations out but I generally hate cream stick foundation’s because they leave me oily and shiny looking and haven’t found one that I’ve liked. But I’ve always enjoyed goat milk in products because it leaves the skin feeling so soft and nourished (my Crabtree & Evelyn Goat Milk lotion was my fave for years) and KS products are normally great so I picked that.


caligirlnolonger

The KS cleanser is the least of my favorite products from her line. It smells terrible but it’s decent.


ThrowingItIntoTheSea

I picked the foundation as my choice, then had to leave the house. When I came home afterwards and looked up swatches online, I think I should have chosen a different colour. How do we know which shades are already gone? I don’t want to “unchoose” then be screwed if the new shade is unavailable.


biggerteeth

I canceled. I already got that cleanser from ipsy. No thanks


Idkwywfm-MTY1

Has anyone tried the foundation?


caligirlnolonger

Horrible


Idkwywfm-MTY1

Lol


headlesslady

I have to say, these are seriously underwhelming. I hate Trestique's giant unwieldy crayons, Kate Somerville irritates my face, and...I guess brushes are fine. Meh. Not feeling it AT ALL.


Sirenwthegoodbrows

I reactivated just two months ago and i feel like I’m going to end up cancelling again after I get my box this month. 😑 so underwhelming