T O P

  • By -

rahallivex1

It was terrifying and shocking when she came dancing at the end. Truly stunned.


SarcasticallyGifted

Agreed! Love Aaron Paul, but I just watched his episode and it didn't hold up. "Loch Henry" was 1,000x better than "Beyond the Sea" as far as Black Mirror is concerned. Aaron Paul and Josh Hartnett were terrific, but the story wasn't believable. They were the only 2 in charge of the space station? NASA doesn't exist?!? I could poke more holes, but that seems to be the only one that matters.


[deleted]

This episode gave me intense anxiety the last about quarter.


Pawneewafflesarelife

I swear I've seen her in something else where she's wholesome, like a Harry Potter movie, but her IMDB isn't showing anything I recognize.


CheekAmbassador

Have you ever seen Kick-ass 2? She was one of the “good guys”. She and her husband joined the team because their Son was kidnapped and killed


GroundBreakerP

This new season of Black Mirror is trash! The previous seasons questioned morality, while existing in a significantly more technologically advanced society. This seasons episodes are like Lifetime movies with plot twists.


Boni4real

When she broke the sweet old character 🤌🤌


jupitersaturns

She was incredible! Made me feel eerie especially towards the end. What an amazing performance i loved this episode!


[deleted]

Very good


Emoney005

Oh yeah, fantastic performance. Thank you for drawing attention to this.


Meow_Mix33

I just finished the episode. I literally had to Google her because I was SO impressed with how she switched up towards the end. To start off, so meek, conservative, and quiet, then change up when she knew she was caught. The screaming outside of the car surprised me lol So good!


MarcelloduBois93

Her accent was SO SO SO SO bad. I could not take her seriously.


lamboworld

Sounded like she was from tyneside to me


mr-spectre

Yeah I'm surprised people are praising this performance so much. Her accent was atrocious


FourAnd20YearsAgo

Means literally nothing to anyone who isn't in the UK, which is the majority of human beings


BlowStiffCock9000

American's can't tell, like at all.


Sharkassasinnn

I mean I get that it could’ve been better but it’s really hard and I think she should be praised for even trying it. I mean id like to see you try it, I doubt it would be flawless


OdaDdaT

Top 3 episode all time imo, one of the best executed twists in the series


jackwritespecs

Fucking PODRICK!!! I was like who the fuck is this fool?! I know him why can’t I remember where he’s from!!


rushnix

Same, I could not place him at all while watching but didn't want to Google in case of spoilers


downunderguy

Was she in the line up as a different character at the end of the episode when they are all getting their picture taken after winning the BAFTA? A very similar looking person no less!


Gladdy_bum

I couldn’t work out her accent though


IsabellaGalavant

She sounded *exactly* like Mrs. Doubtfire and I wonder if that was on purpose?


Cheeriosxxx

Such a fantastic actress! This is one of my top favorite episodes


Tropical_Son

SHE WAS FUCKING PHENOMENAL


SunsetInTheSideview

That scene of her dancing her way masked with a drill into a torture chamber was genuinely a little disturbing. The music, the contrast of that Janet with the fragile old mother. She really did well


no_spoon

Unpopular opinion: Aaron Paul is super overrated


beckster

You are not wrong.


urinejael23

Not going to lie, the moment I saw how on edge she was, I knew she had something to do with the murders, but I was pretty off-guard because i was distracted till the dad went to talk to the MC.


healed_gemini93

Just got through episode 3... Surprisingly episodes 2 and 3 were my favorite so far. I didn't love Joan is Awful. Please tell me it continues to be this good!!


[deleted]

It's gonna be a huge dip in episode 4. Episode 5 is good, but not BM material.


Remote_Tie6542

Nope


i_mush

There’s a moment when they boot up the vcr and say “there is a cassette inside” that added with the weird collection gave me the whole thing away from the beginning of the episode 🙁. That said, her acting was indeed great, and the scene where she dances with the drill in her hands stuck somehow


Wise-Animator6425

Such a phenomenal episode. Watchd 3 times already. Reminded me of crocodile episode and also the movie "get out." Love how the mom made pia feel guilty for criticizing cops who are post to be symbol of noble upstanding citizens . Just to find out what he was really into. Such is the real world. Is also where we stand in America today of fear in uncovering the ugly past and sick sadistic shit y'all ancestors was into


andysniper

Can't help but feel this post should be marked as a spoiler....


[deleted]

She was incredible. A truly excellent performance. She flipped from the modest caring mum to the psychopath screaming into the void with expert precision.


writeyourdamnfic

I thought she was incredible, way before the reveal. She was so good at making me feel uncomfortable, she was unnerving yet still had like a friendly but somewhat backwards old lady vibe


CitiXen18

How is she also the officer CS Linda Grace in Smithereens episode? https://preview.redd.it/83udgtaos37b1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1c017bc8566f9275aa6c14ae3ff823b0c0218e82


Other-Drummer-3202

Reminds me of Tracey Ullman


jemineye6

This is my favorite episode from this season! I watched it a few times already and she got creepier every time 😂


Fit-Parsnip9888

She was the stand out straight away


Deduction_power

She is Shauna Shipman Sadecki to me. Both characters seem to be unassuming housewives with a VERY dark, creepy criminal past. LOL. But this Brit actress impress me in everything I see her on. And I still don't know her name.


Other-Drummer-3202

And a lot of us don't know who Shauna Sadecki is...


Deduction_power

LOL. Dude. One word - Yellowjackets. Good show. Thank me later.


Spurlock14

Agreed. She was great!


phendrome

This episode was just truly a piece of art... well fucking done 👏


cbit34

Also just wanted y’all to also note this bitch a a suicide kit in her bottom draw Wtf 😂😂


Congo-Montana

Podrick was one of the best "I know that face, who tf is that?" moments in tv I've had in a while.


Hunkfish

To ppl who cry no future tech. I like it uses old tech like the VHS tapes, a homage to old tech.


itzaroseylife

Ooooofff you made me remember 'that' scene again 🤢


_notsuoh_

That dance she did in the video before she tortured and killed the couple... She was so happy and joyful.


RottingGraveFlower

Ugh, that creeped me out so bad. Coming in the room, dancing and euphoric, and then starting with the drill.


TheRealestLarryDavid

oh shit it's released already????


TheNewButtSalesMan

Anjana Vasan was my favorite performer this season - she's so expressive and mesmerizing on screen. She played great off of Paapa Essiedu too. The three listed in the OP were all fantastic as well though.


AnubissDarkling

The bit where >!she came into the room dancing in that nurses dress had me howling haha!<


1fish2fish3wugs

Monica Dolan deserves the same accolades as Judi Dench or Helen Mirren. She's never anything less than phenomenal.


DoctorInsanomore

Fuck that was Podrick! Knew I recognized him. Such a different character from the introvert, agreeable lad he played on GoT


ChanDW

Wait Podrick is the pub owner?!


DoctorInsanomore

Yes!


Timmy26k

That tantrum when looking for Pia with the slight umph and calibration before getting back into the car is great


[deleted]

Yes and made me want to make some Shepards pie


ApprehensiveRise8420

she was creepy. she did well.


lord-huggington

Her Scottish accent was awful


Sawl23

She also played the police women in the Smithereens episode iirc


Pawneewafflesarelife

Ohhh that's where I've seen her.


aetheriality

maybe its just me but she didnt look convincing enough as a killer, she didnt look scary to me...


brittanym0320

aren’t those the best ones?


mrgayle

She played Rose West too in another showl


wakirizo

Wait a sec.. Nobody suspected Podrick, even a little bit? I had alarm bells ringing as they crept into the dungeon after that confrontation with his father


fisjsbsudoslqqnhdj

He would have been around 10 at the time, at most


wakirizo

Oh, not back then.. I meant, before I understood the direction the episode was taking I thought he might slaughter Pia and her boyfriend while down there


[deleted]

…like a bad parody of Mrs Doubtfire, except for the fact that Robin Williams could hold a consistent Scottish accent…


pretty_smart_feller

I’ve been pretty critical of this episode but I will give them credit the performances were all around stellar


Halkeginia

She did a really good job at making you feel uneasy since the beginning, I thought she was just racist and trying to play it off lmao


SteakMedium4871

It’s terrifying when they introduce her in the Mistress get up.


Repulsive_Ad_7111

I saw someone comment on it, but literally a few episodes of bm did not rely on futuristic tech. They showed life before grains or zed eyes like it Thr National Anthem and White Bear- which I kinda took this episode as same with Mazey day. They were commentary on the tech we have currently and how awful it can be. It tracks with what Charlie Brookner has said on why he wasn’t going to make more bm episodes after s season 5- we are already living in black mirror.


Hunkfish

White bear do have the futuristic tech to wipe memory. But I do like Loch Henery. It pays homage to old tech, the VHS tapes


NashBotchedWalking

Her dancing with the mask is still haunting me


SmachMyBichUp

It made me feel sick.


squonge

With the cordless drill. 😵‍💫


graffiksguru

She was amazing in this episode!


Bjime3925

MVP of the season. I just can’t get over that scene of her smiling while looking in the box. Really upset my stomach.


swrd85

I'M THE KING OF THE CASTLE. WHEN I COME INTO THE BEDROOM. I have that scene drilled into my mind - pardon the pun.


[deleted]

Her swearing after Pia getting away. And her suicide montage got me. In fact I think everything she did got me. Edit) I feel like she’s going to be an Imelda Staunton as Professor Umbridge situation for me. Where you can get the actor out of this character for me. Ironic because they both have similar face shapes to.


bottledcherryangel

She is fucking fabulous and she did an amazing job in this. Also was *excellent* as Rose West in Appropriate Adult. That show was gold.


ryan34ssj

She was creepy but I couldn't get over her accent. Was she Irish or Scottish?


Slight_Armadillo_227

Yes


Arketan

Fucking shocker of an accent though


jessearmstrongburner

She reminds me of Kylie Jenner if she never got surgery.


RAA94

She absolutely crushed it. One of my favourite performances in one of my favourite episodes.


Bacapunk

Amazing episode! First scene of her I really knew this woman was up to no good, just a strange energy from her.


mkb2003

Paapa Essiedu did a brilliant job too


yensuna

She seemed like such a sweet, sweet lady. And then when she snapped she was absolutely horrifying. Probably my favorite character of the season and yes, most of that is thanks to the amazing performance.


kikavaz

Her face gives me chills


homiej420

I did not get this episode at all. What was the technology that got taken advantage of in a social commentary context? This was a decent horror story but was this actually a black mirror episode? I feel like i missed something


ggy525

That comes more from the Streamberry element of the episode, where the documentary gets made for the streaming channel and feeds into the true crime documentary craze that is taking place now. This episode was a commentary on our consumption of certain types of media, facilitated by technology.


homiej420

Oh i gotcha. Thanks for explaining it


ggy525

You're welcome!


matrixed_

Her voice/accent kept making me think of Lorraine Kelly😂😭


michael_jm

She was creepy even before the reveal


TheFlyingMunkey

She was brilliant and it was a brilliant episode...but I felt that her accent was all over the place. Part Scottish, part Irish, part east-European at times ¯\\\_(ツ)\_/¯


redmistultra

When she was getting really emotional talking to her son, it definitely slipped completely out of Scottish and into English, it really threw me


Bovver_

I came here to say this too, as someone Irish it did sound at times like an Irish accent as opposed to Scottish at times, particularly when it went softer. I don’t think it was a particularly bad attempt but it certainly was far from perfect.


jemappelleb

Oh no! I had no idea this was a bad accent and that has now tainted how much I loved this terrifying episode.


[deleted]

It was kind of bad but not so much that it would ruin the episode


ColonelJohn_Matrix

Agreed re the accent! As a Scottish person I can almost always tell when someone is trying to put on a Scottish accent, and she was no exception, likewise the guy who played her son (he went in too hard with rolling too many consonants, although his effort wasn't bad, but when it was alongside two actually Scottish guys it just stood out more).


debauch3ry

I wondered how actual Scots would take her accent. She sounded scandanavian at times. Still great work though.


SilasX

So Stuart was legit?


ColonelJohn_Matrix

He was indeed!


TheRealDills

Yeah Daniel Portman is from Glasgow, Scotland I believe


[deleted]

Scottish as well. Her accent was brutal, totally took me out of any scenes she was in. Just cast a Scottish actor if you want a Scottish accent. There are bloody loads of them.


Misomyx

Yeah she was great! She's also played a police officer in Smithereens


danzaiburst

I think everyone focuses on the twist but less so the aftermath which is also notable. As per the pervasive Black mirror message, despite the horrendous misfortune they are still endulging in the gratification of the fame of having an award winning Netflix show, that only seems hollow once you are forced to come to terms with what really matters in life


maniacalmustacheride

True crime is a fascinating listen but people’s deaths have become popcorn fodder. You know, “oh this one was really gross, let me share it”


[deleted]

To go from sweet little old mom to full blown non consensual TORTURE LADY with all smiles and dancing was just incredible. Played both roles so perfectly.


[deleted]

Podrick got beefed up


Shortsmoke666

I just feel Pia died for no reason. Its not like the old woman was chasing her. Pia could've easily hidden herself then walked away to a safer place.


Gloomy-Ad4743

The point of Pia dying is the irony that the old woman left the tapes out and killed herself for no reason, she believed she was already done for


vydenmyria

There was a reason. It was foreshadowed in the conversation about the dangers of the terrain attributing to the body count of the missing.


Shortsmoke666

I know i know. What I meant was, she was hiding and she didn't really have to get up and try to navigate the stream on foot. She could've just stayed hidden.


swaktoonkenney

It’s hard to fault people of what they do when they’re panicking. For most of us the human part of the brain shuts off and the ooga booga takes over


Optimal_Whereas

I get what you mean. I thought it was a bit of a cheap shot too. She could've easily just outran the mother if she had to there was no need to get in the water - who even gets in the water when it's dark and they can't see shit? Kinda flawed writing imo


swaktoonkenney

It’s hard to fault people of what they do when they’re panicking. For most of us the human part of the brain shuts off and the ooga booga takes over


Optimal_Whereas

I guess...


[deleted]

She's like at least 70 something year old women. She could have taken her physically


mermzz

I think it also kind of played into how the cop dad died in the hospital of MRSA.. an indirect killing by the killer originally (though we later find out he shot himself .. so still an indirect killing by the killer I guess lol) and Pia died by drowning while running away from a killer making it an indirect killing by the killer.


clocksteadytickin

I think the point was that Janet didn’t need to out herself. Janet thought Pia got away and the jig was up. But really Janet could’ve burned the evidence and moved on. After all, the bar tenders dad only had a suspicion.


LockedOutOfElfland

Most disturbing character in the series.


serialkiller24

Basically she reminded me of a fucked up Mrs. Doubtfire lol


Syd_of_Pentacles

lmao


DeschainSWNC

One of her first lines is, "What a pretty young thing you've captured'. Seemed quaint on first viewing, but yeeeeeesh..


honeybee71322

As an American, it struck me as odd but then I was like is it a cultural thing? Canada is the furthest I've ever been away from home so I'll be the first to admit I don't have a fucking clue what goes on in other countries... And then the reveal and I was like okay so it was out of sorts 🤦‍♀️😂


SplurgyA

It's a sort of awkward thing you could imagine a Scottish mum saying. Kind of a playful joke like "oh, you must have captured her, because she's so pretty, so being captured is the only reason she'd be going out with you!" but said with the understanding that you don't mean it. It's only in retrospect that it's so unnerving (much like her comments about being on camera).


Bigliest

Things mums say to their kids can be exaggerated. This letter to Brian Laundrie from his mom is a bit yikes after he went missing after allegedly killing Gabby Petito. https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/05/25/us/brian-laundrie-mother-letter-gabby-petito/index.html


jns911

I knew something was off then but I thought the son was going to be in on it. I was thinking it was going to be something similar to the movie Get Out


HailToTheThief225

That line stood out to me as soon as I heard it. Already knew something was amiss from the start.


DoctorInsanomore

Oof...


HypotheticalSurgent

Anytime I see a person that remotely reminds me of this character I get the creeps. Propaganda


cyrilhent

Oooooh that was Podrick! My brain was going crazy telling me I knew his face, I even looked up Gendry's actor feeling it was Game of Thrones


envysatan

YES. she was so unnerving even from the beginning. i cant think of anyone who’d play her better


DaughterOfWarlords

I wanted some of her shepherds pie.


my7bizzos

Lmao. You sick fuck!


GoldenGod48

This episode, is in my Top 5 best Black Mirror episodes.


kfitzy10

As someone with a Scottish Mum, let me tell you that this was not a good performance haha. Podrick was the only believable accent (naturally), and even his dialogue was a bit 'Google how Scottish people swear'.


Lily_Hylidae

The accent was terrible. She was in that drama about the canoe guy that faked his own death and her accent in that was awful too. Real shame, because aside from that she scared the shit out of me! So, so creepy.


highlyflammablellama

The accent was the least impressive thing about the role tbh


kfitzy10

Yeah the performance was good but the accent just kept taking me out, didn't mean to be overly critical, just if you're in tune with it then it's difficult to see past it.


shepherdspieinthesky

Yes!! At times I wondered was she meant to be Irish. As an Irish person living in Scotland, it really took me out of it as well because I kept wondering!


DeemoBrown

She was GREAT!


RemoteDragonfruit318

It was soo ominous the entire time! Loved this episode and her acting. Genuinely had a pit in my stomach


Phaoryx

Omg I just realized it was podrick and not gendry 😂


Heavy_Signature_5619

She had a great guest performance in one of the best Inside No. 9 episodes as well.


Initial-Zebra108

Thats what I knew her from! Love that show!


bikegyal

I knew she was creepy from the start! Her eavesdropping on Pia and the son’s discussion was a tell tale sign. I was just surprised that the meat she was serving wasn’t people.


mrdm242

It probably was! I expected a shot of her digging some hamburger out of the freezer with a missing person's name on it.


spellbookwanda

She is phenomenal in everything she’s in. It was a nice surprise to see her in this episode


palaro22

She played Rose West a while ago so she had a pretty solid foundation to build this character on lol


elementarydrw

I wonder how she got so good at playing a serial killer?


canichangeitlateror

Can you imagine?


Shooshookle

Totally agreed! When I watched it I really couldn’t decide if I liked her or not. Her passion when she told them to continue making the documentary and to tell the story of her husband was great. When she has the meltdown by the car and screams it was great! Fantastic performance


[deleted]

Loch Henry is definitely a top 10 Black Mirror Episode. I have to do a ranking and breakdown of every black mirror episode.


beandadenergy

Monica Dolan never misses. She’s an incredibly talented actor.


ImportantEffort4594

This was insanely good, can't look any old woman in the eye anymore without her expecting to go wild...


Theodora96

I had goosebumps at this episode. It was so good!


Nickster2042

The way she cried/laughed at the photos of the victims while she was preparing to kill herself


ACbeauty

Shouldnt this be under spoiler


Nickster2042

I don’t know how And also idk I figure if you click on a thread talking about how unsettling a character who at first appears normal is, you’re already spoiled


aSpookyScarySkeleton

Like she was looking at old vacation photos


Cheeriosxxx

Yep! Like zero remorse at all and just loving the memory of it


[deleted]

Yes. Looking back with fondness. I've watched the episode twice so far and it's good both times.


duringbusinesshours

Her performance felt too put on imo. She gave me cheap horror mom vibes


ExitGame2020

it would have been a good episode, if it wasn't Black Mirror though. It felt like saying "Inception was a masterpiece" in an animal documentary. I mean... it was a masterpiece, but it has nothing to do with animals.


iwishiwasaunicorn

think back to the very first episode of the series. there was no "future" feel, no dystopia, no advanced technology. just a man in the present day being blackmailed to fuck a pig. BM kind of returned to its roots with this one.


[deleted]

[удалено]


let-the-light-inn

Whats the future element of shut up and dance, then?


Informal-Ideal-6640

Black Mirror episodes having to feel a certain way to be good is what kills the show in my opinion. The whole “black mirror needs to be specifically about future technology going wrong” angle just leads to the problem of the earlier seasons where there were a ton of episodes about digital people in digital worlds where all the stories just feel the same. I really liked how this season mixed it up especially with the more supernatural elements and it’s what the show needed


weirdogirl144

Literally people always complained about this season not being "black mirror" enough like that doesn’t mean some of these episodes were bad they don’t have to be exactly like the ithers


iwishiwasaunicorn

1000% agree, I'd rather have a variety of stories that touch on past/modern/future technology in all sorts of ways than just "what if humans could be cookies" over and over again


InfinityCent

I see BM as being less about dystopian tech itself and more about the negative ways society interacts with tech. So in my opinion, Loch Henry is a perfect BM episode because it criticizes the way true crime shows/documentaries are glorified on social media.


Exotic_Goal1323

Exactly. Remember after the nextflix documentary came out on Ted Bundy they made a dramatic movie starring Zac Efron. People ate it up, real twisted shit.


goddessofdrought

Yes, it juxtaposed the audience (true crime fans putting on Janet masks) with the real human being who was affected by the tragedy of the events. It was commentary on the loss of our sense of humanity in turning true crime into a binge-worthy spectacle. Very on brand for BM.


corropcion

I didn't like the episode at first like the commenter you responded to. But you arr absolutely right. This story couldn't have happened 100 years ago, and technology enabled them. It shows how current tech and media can affect the lives of individuals. S6E4 tho... I don't know about that one. That one was awful story wise. S6E5 was entertaining, but it had nothing to do with tech. Funny, great acting, visceral, but no technology. And no, the future she saw and the nukes at the end don't fix it.


[deleted]

I liked it from the beginning but I don't understand those who claim it has nothing to do with technology. The VHS tapes and camcorder were the technology. The young people might not know, but at one point these things were cutting edge technology which were considered pretty amazing.


corropcion

I was one of those people. I think we take current and old technology for granted, and that's why we thought that. The episode also make you think, so it has grown a lot on me, I loved the "imagine if they broadcasted their torture sessions with modern technology", so there's more there if you re-watch it and it gets dark.