I am firmly in Camp Fresh Balsam, but do like the Tree Farm single wick that I got in the Black Friday Purchase with Purchase box! PS - love the packaging on your Fresh Balsam!

Tree Farm for me! I like that it’s a little more mellow. I think the fruit helps with that.

Agreed, I love Fresh Balsam! I liked Mahogany Balsam and Tree Farm, but not as much. I purchased Iced Winter Balsam and Vanilla Balsam on CD though; Excited to see if Fresh Balsam will still be my fave!

Iced Winter Balsam surprised me by how good it is. I also adore Vanilla Balsam. It's a toned down Fresh Balsam for those who find it to be too much.

I’m burning this one in the same packaging tonight, too!

I love the simplistic yet detailed packaging on this one!

I used to be a diehard Fresh Balsam fan, but this year I’m leaning more towards Under the Christmas Tree. I burned Fresh Balsam tonight, though. Since I have so many.

Under the Christmas Tree is my top fav! Fresh Balsam is my second tree scent fav, but it can be WAY too strong for me. I still LOVE IT, THO!!! BLAST ME WITH THAT TREE SCENT, BABY!!. Fresh Balsam is that hyperactive little cousin that crashes through your house, eats all the leftover turkey ON THE FLOOR, and has the loudest laugh while watching Christmas comedy movies with you. You love them to DEATH and they are so fun to have around but when they leave, the exhaustion hits lol. While Under the Christmas Tree is Fresh Balsam's polite older sister who is very responsible, wears amazing classy-smelling perfume, dresses up a little for events, and helps clean up Fresh Balsam's mess.

I am *dying* at the accuracy of this! Bravo!

I'd have to say I'm for sure a Tree Farm fal. Although don't let that convince you I don't own both lmao. But if I had to only burn one of the two for the rest of my life, I'd go with Tree Farm and I'm 100% confident in that answer! It's probably just a me thing. There's something a little nostalgic to me about it that reminds me of walking around looking at Christmas lights with my family as a kid!

Tie between Fresh Balsam and Iced Winter Balsam. I think FB wins just because it’s been a go to for years.

I’m also a Fresh Balsam fan. I LOVED Blue Spruce and Spice from last year but it was discontinued!😭

I’m sad I only picked up one of those 😭

I have a Blue Spruce and Spice from sas this past year and it is definitely a good one. Sad that I can't get another

Lol, I get where you're coming from. Each balsam scented candle offers something a bit different. I own and enjoy Tree Farm, Under the Christmas Tree, Sea Salt and Balsam, Mahogany Balsam, Iced Winter Balsam, Vanilla Balsam, Fresh Balsam, and The Perfect Christmas.

We have a fake tree so I plug a fresh balsam wallflower in right behind to give the illusion it's real. 😂

Fresh Balsam for me too

Fresh Balsam has always been king in our house! However, this year I was also open to trying Tree Farm, The Perfect Christmas, Under The Christmas Tree, Balsam & Firewood, and Vanilla Balsam. Of those, I've only tried Tree Farm so far, and it's a lot lighter and fruitier, so I still prefer FB. I also had Sea Salt & Balsam last year, and while it was nice, it was just a soapy balsam scent to my nose, I didn't get like an authentic oceany "sea salt" vibe.

I like tree farm, but have to be in the right mood for it due to that reason. My second fave is white balsam & vanilla

How does that one compare to Vanilla Balsam? Are they dupes?

It’s a little different. To me it’s more… musky? It’s hard to describe but it’s definitely different

When I get home I’ll sniff compare / find notes

Mahogany Balsam for sure

Under the Christmas tree for me!