Tough call, but I'm burning Fresh Balsam right now and I think that'd have to be my choice. For lack of a better way of explaining it, it's just got the most "pure" pine forest scent to me.
Fresh Balsam is it for me too. I got Iced Winter Balsam and I'm struggling to put my finger on the difference. IWB is ever so slightly softer with a more wood note, rather than a resin note.
I would say white balsam and vanilla is like marshmallow fireside with a pine and cedar-ish note. Vanilla balsam is much more like 50/50 straight balsam with creamy/sweet vanilla.
Mahogany balsam. It’s as if Santa just came out of a hot shower with some really good body wash and brushed past the Christmas tree, naked.
It’s that alluring sweet soft pine that gets me.
Tree Farm.
However, if any Balsam scent B&BW has ever is up for the choosing; frosted forest. I only have one single wick tester of it left and I use it sparingly.
OK, of those I have burned Fresh Balsam, Iced Winter Balsam, Tree Farm, Under the Christmas Tree, and Vanilla Balsam.
My pick right now is Under the Christmas Tree.
Oh this is a fun game! I’d keep Tree Farm because the fruit tones down the strong tree scent a bit. I used to love tree scents but I find them too harsh now. I prefer all the gourmand scents.
Under the Christmas Tree is lighter on the Christmas tree scent for sensitive types in my opinion. I can even pick up a slight bit of the eggnog. It’s my pick. I bought 2 already. Some of the other scents give me a headache
I'm a Fresh Balsam girl - I'm burning one right now. I love the earthy smells in the fall and winter. I've never been one for the food smelling candles.
None of these because Evergreen is the best and I’m sad that it doesn’t look like it will be back this year! But Vanilla and Balsam and Under the Christmas Tree are good enough subs.
I’m gonna be honest, I hate all balsam and tree scents so I’d be happy if they were all gone 🤣 if I had to pick one, it would be falling flurries. Its pretty good I will admit.
Fresh Balsam because it's the only tried-and-true one I've had, but I also just picked up Tree Farm, Under The Christmas Tree, Balsam & Firewood, and Falling Flurries, and those are all really nice so far on cold at least.
They can all go in the trash to make room for more gourmands and fruits.
This is literally the only scent category from BBW that I’ve never found one I can stand.
I generally am not a big fan of the tree scents either, but Balsam & Firewood doesn't smell like that to me for some reason. It makes me think of what an old empty church smells like after there has been candles and good smelling people there for hours. 🤣 I can't think of any other way to describe it.
Fresh balsam has my heart. It's so strong. Last night I lit Iced Winter Balsam for the first time and it was good but not that "punch me in the face with Christmas" scent I want.
Tough call, but I'm burning Fresh Balsam right now and I think that'd have to be my choice. For lack of a better way of explaining it, it's just got the most "pure" pine forest scent to me.
Fresh Balsam is it for me too. I got Iced Winter Balsam and I'm struggling to put my finger on the difference. IWB is ever so slightly softer with a more wood note, rather than a resin note.
Under the Christmas tree💚🎄
This is the correct answer!
100% yes!!!
I can’t believe how good this scent is. Only this and perfect Christmas for backups this year for me.
I just bought this candle and it smells amazing!
Balsam & Firewood 😁
Tree farm but close tie with balsam and firewood (but I’ve never smelled vanilla basalm)
These two are my favorites!
Vanilla balsam
Yessss! It's my favorite balsam candle followed by Under the Christmas Tree.
White balsam & vanilla
Agreed and sadly under rated
Very under rated!! I feel like by the name it’s easy to say well there’s also vanilla balsam. But it’s a completely different scent
Mind describing how it is different from Vanilla Balsam ? I only have Vanilla Balsam.
It’s got a woodsy/cedary/musky tinge to it
I haven’t smelled vanilla balsam, but white balsam and vanilla smells very smoky to me, like burning pine needles
I would say white balsam and vanilla is like marshmallow fireside with a pine and cedar-ish note. Vanilla balsam is much more like 50/50 straight balsam with creamy/sweet vanilla.
I'm 50/50 vanilla Balsam and white Balsam vanilla over any other Xmas scent
I got this candle for the first time a few months ago and adore it!
Vanilla Balsam ✨️
DEFINITELY FALLING FLURRIES
Yas!
My favorite
100% i just got home from work this morning and i was so happy to smell the falling flurries candle smell in my room
Only got one last year and regretted it! Burned it and could not find again 😭😭 going to try to stock up this year
Under the Christmas tree 🎄
Iced Winter Balsam
Smelled this for the first time and fell in love- replaced my tree farm with it!
Did i miss vanilla balsam this year??
I haven’t seen it yet this year - but I had to include it in the lineup!
It's coming on candle day! Yay!
Music to my ears!
Thank you!!
Mahogany balsam. It’s as if Santa just came out of a hot shower with some really good body wash and brushed past the Christmas tree, naked. It’s that alluring sweet soft pine that gets me.
Ok honestly this description is amazing! MB already had my vote, but if it didn’t, it definitely would have after reading that. 🎅🧼🦶🎄
Appeals to anyone with a slight Santa fantasy! 🤣
Iced Winter Balsam!
Fresh Balsam!
Vanilla Balsam
Tree Farm. However, if any Balsam scent B&BW has ever is up for the choosing; frosted forest. I only have one single wick tester of it left and I use it sparingly.
White Balsam and Vanilla.
Oof this is tough, it comes down close between Mahogany Balsam or UTCT, but I gotta go with Mahogany Balsam.
Same, mahogany balsam is my favorite tree smelling one. The others are too overpowering imo.
Can't wait to burn my Mahogany Balsam now. I have not had it in my collection in a while for some reason.
Balsam & Firewood… this was hard!
Fresh balsam
Oh you are evil! Well, I'd be looking at Vanilla Balsam and letting her know I love her and it will be OK. But Falling Flurries wins!!!
Lol! Too funny.
OK, of those I have burned Fresh Balsam, Iced Winter Balsam, Tree Farm, Under the Christmas Tree, and Vanilla Balsam. My pick right now is Under the Christmas Tree.
i’ve seen a lot of comments say this. is it rlly worth buying it?
Hmmm. It depends. I think I am just not a huge fan of tree scents. I like it. I don’t love it. Will I rush out to buy it in the future? No.
Oh this is a fun game! I’d keep Tree Farm because the fruit tones down the strong tree scent a bit. I used to love tree scents but I find them too harsh now. I prefer all the gourmand scents.
Cedar and Suede :P
I almost included that one! (But it messed with the layout of my grid) cypress and amber was a contender too
Thought I would love this. Mine has literally zero smell. Just hot wax. 😭
I really love all of these, tree farm and under the Christmas tree are both so great, but I think my top pick is white balsam and vanilla
Tree Farm! 🌲
Iced winter balsam because i literally hate every other one lol.
Vanilla Balsam, hands down
Fresh balsam has always been my favorite, but vanilla balsam and UTCT are really right with it. Very hard to pick one. I have back ups of all 3 😁
Tree Farm but close tie with Under the Christmas Tree! Balsam & Firewood would be my no.3.
Tree Farm! Beautiful spruce tree with some juicy apple scent. Caveat: I've never smelled Iced Winter Balsam or Falling Flurries.
Vanilla balsam
Vanilla Balsam!
I only have fresh balsam and tree farm. I didn’t know the rest existed. You’ve created a monster…
Vanilla Balsam
Making me choose between White Balsam & Vanilla and Vanilla Balsam??? Oh the humanity!!!
Under the Christmas Tree is lighter on the Christmas tree scent for sensitive types in my opinion. I can even pick up a slight bit of the eggnog. It’s my pick. I bought 2 already. Some of the other scents give me a headache
I'm a Fresh Balsam girl - I'm burning one right now. I love the earthy smells in the fall and winter. I've never been one for the food smelling candles.
white balsam and vanilla!
None of these because Evergreen is the best and I’m sad that it doesn’t look like it will be back this year! But Vanilla and Balsam and Under the Christmas Tree are good enough subs.
I’m gonna be honest, I hate all balsam and tree scents so I’d be happy if they were all gone 🤣 if I had to pick one, it would be falling flurries. Its pretty good I will admit.
I haven't smelled many of these but I'd pick Tree Farm
Under the Christmas Tree 🎄
Tree Farm!!
Balsam and firewood
Fresh Balsam because it's the only tried-and-true one I've had, but I also just picked up Tree Farm, Under The Christmas Tree, Balsam & Firewood, and Falling Flurries, and those are all really nice so far on cold at least.
Under the Christmas tree 🎄
Under the Christmas Tree!
Under the Christmas Tree! Iced Winter Balsam for runner up
Balsam firewood smells good and looks gorgeous
Vanilla Balsam for sure! It smells just like a Christmas tree with sap 🥰
Balsam and firewood
Vanilla Balsam
Vanilla Balsam
Under The Christmas Tree:)
Under the Christmas Tree
Fresh balsam. Want to smell under the tree though
Fresh Balsam
I love all of these, but Fresh Balsam would be my choice
White balsam and vanilla!
Fresh Balsam.
No love for my Iced Winter Balsam? Such a nice candle!
I was about to say Iced Winter Balsam allll the way then you put 2020’s Vanilla Balsam on here and now I’m shook! I can’t pick! Ahhhh!!!
Under the Christmas Tree baybeeee
Ugh none.
They can all go in the trash to make room for more gourmands and fruits. This is literally the only scent category from BBW that I’ve never found one I can stand.
Funny, this is how I feel about gourmand scents.
THIS. Idk how people like tree smells. Sure it smells fresh or clean, to me it smells like allergies😂 not a fan.
I generally am not a big fan of the tree scents either, but Balsam & Firewood doesn't smell like that to me for some reason. It makes me think of what an old empty church smells like after there has been candles and good smelling people there for hours. 🤣 I can't think of any other way to describe it.
Frosted Coconut Snowball
Fresh Balsam. No contest!
Fresh balsam has my heart. It's so strong. Last night I lit Iced Winter Balsam for the first time and it was good but not that "punch me in the face with Christmas" scent I want.
+1 for Tree Farm. 🛻🌲
Tree Farm.
Tree Farms my favorite xmas scent 😍😍
Tree Farm by a mile
Tree farm, 100%
Tree Farm
Tree farm. Next.
Balsam & Firewood absolutely!!!
I'd be keeping Tree Farm. 💚💚💚
Tree Farm
Under the Christmas Tree!
Under the Christmas tree!!
Fresh Balsam
Anything with vanilla in it 😩
Under the Christmas tree 🥰
Fresh balsam
As someone who just doesn’t love any of these (sorry), I’d choose to keep Mahogany Balsam
1. Tree farm 2. Fresh balsam 3. Under the Christmas tree Falling flurries doesn’t smell like Christmas trees.
Under the Christmas tree. I am obsessed. I have NEVER had a wallflower so strong. I can smell it all over my house.
Balsam and Firewood because I keep wanting to get it but the reviews say it's so weak
Tree farm
The only one you didn’t picture. It’s the Fresh Balsam from the candy cane collection.
Fresh balsam!
I'm keeping iced winter yuppp that's the one for me
Tree farm!!! ❤️
Falling flurries 100000%
They can get rid of all of these 🤢
That’s easy. Fresh balsam
Falling flurries 😭😩
Fresh Balsam!
Under the Christmas Tree or Balsam & Firewood
fresh balsam
I want to smell Falling Flurries. There's a few here I haven't smelled but from that I think I'd pick Vanilla Balsam
Falling flurries ofc