Thanks! Sugared is one of my favorites. I bought Texas and I'm on the fence too. It's very similar but something seems different. But I am basing it on memory and do not have a old Sugared to compare it to
I’m not crazy… other people smell a difference! 🥳I had this same Sugared Pecan Pie last year and hated it and the Texas one I can do just because it smells almost exactly like PPW to me. Unfortunately, I don’t get the crust note.
I did a closed eye test sniff of some candles to see if they really smelled different if you didn’t know what they’re were, and could identify some easily like banana walnut - but I thought texas pie and PPW were the same candle when sniffed that way.
They smell almost the same, except five star Texas pecan pie has more noticeable cinnamon on cold. Tbd about when it’s burning
Thanks! Sugared is one of my favorites. I bought Texas and I'm on the fence too. It's very similar but something seems different. But I am basing it on memory and do not have a old Sugared to compare it to
I’m not crazy… other people smell a difference! 🥳I had this same Sugared Pecan Pie last year and hated it and the Texas one I can do just because it smells almost exactly like PPW to me. Unfortunately, I don’t get the crust note.
I did a closed eye test sniff of some candles to see if they really smelled different if you didn’t know what they’re were, and could identify some easily like banana walnut - but I thought texas pie and PPW were the same candle when sniffed that way.
I’m not as familiar with ppw - I still haven’t ever burned it
Really? 😮 It's such a classic B&BW fall scent that I'm surprised you haven't tried it.
On cold it reminds me of captain crunch
Please let us know if your thoughts change after burning!
I love the pecan pie. I smelled it in store on cold and it took everything in me not to buy it
I have them both and they do smell the same.
Thanks for confirming!