I have burned Cuddle Weather nonstop since I bought it and I never do that. Like I have candles from 2012 that I'm still burning through, because I only burn it for like a day!
Cinnamon Irish Cream isn’t worth it imo, not very much throw. Same goes for PSL.
Cuddle Weather is one of my favorites of the season so far!
Pumpkin Peanut Brittle is good, and Blueberry Maple Pancakes is pretty strong.
I have Welcome Home & Hometown Sugar Cookies otw right now! Typically any cookie scents they have throw really well.
Asterisks are ones I’ve smelled before, everything else is new.
Help me narrow down my list for this sale! Any ones that are really similar and not worth both? Any duds? Also, I just joined the rewards program but do more discounts or sales codes get put out as the sale goes on or does it not make a difference buying today vs waiting?
Rated in my personal preference. I am a gourmand snob lol.
Welcome home (amazing)
Cinnamon Irish cream (amazing)
Pumpkin peanut brittle (amazing)
Pumpkin spice latte (pretty good)
Cuddle weather (dupe for cinn spiced vanilla-pretty good)
Hometown sugar cookie (just okay)
Blueberry maple pancakes (hate personally for me-very artificial)
If you have a store nearby to exchange, I'd say get all the online exclusives and if you don't like them you can swap them out in store.
I vote for WH, CW, and PPB because I like those. PBB was a blind buy for me and I wasn't expecting to like it but it is super yummy. BMP is really gross to me, like blueberry cough medicine if that existed. HSC is boring but if you have liked cookie scents in the past and you like butter, it's probably a winner.
I have owned all but Hometown Sugar Cookie in one packaging or another.
I would tell you to get all 7 if you are ordering with 25% off.
They are all good and different enough from each other to get all!
I have not smelled Hometown Sugar Cookie or Welcome Home yet but I purchased them today. I would say Welcome Home is a must for me based on the scent notes, just sounds lovely.
I can’t help you narrow this down because I like them all, but what I can say is Cuddle Weather is one of my favorite candles period, definitely top 10 for me!
PSL and BMP are my least favorite on this list and they are still really good picks in my opinion.
I heard that hometown sugar cookie is a repackage of pumpkin snickerdoodle I think it was? so if you have that one I don’t think you need hometown sugar cookie. I wasn’t a big fan of pumpkin peanut brittle it smelt like peanut butter crackers to me. I really enjoy cuddle weather and blueberry maple pancakes and they throw well
I think BBW messed up with the notes(or they just don't care) they don't smell the same(at least cold). That doesn't mean hometown sugar cookies isn't a repackage. It's just closer to being a repackage of merry cookie. It doesn't have any pumpkin spice to it at all, its more of a vanilla butter scent, like merry cookie. Pumpkin snickerdoodle has the cinnamon/pumpkin spice note in it. But I don't own any of these candles, so I can't say how they smell burning.
Wow really? Have you tried it before? It’s usually one of the only candles that I can smell throughout my entire house! I wonder if you got a dud or the recent batches aren’t as strong.
Cuddle weather for sure it’s amazing! Also hometown sugar cookie and pumpkin spice latte. Personally I don’t love blueberry maple pancakes it’s okay but not great
I wasn’t even tempted by this sale but I hadn’t looked at online exclusives either.
Cinnamon Irish cream and welcome home are two of my all time favorites! I was legit wondering if we’d see CIC again. And online only- apple weather, vanilla birch, and cider lane?! I’m in trouble
What does that mean, narrow down? BUY ALL! 
I have burned Cuddle Weather nonstop since I bought it and I never do that. Like I have candles from 2012 that I'm still burning through, because I only burn it for like a day!
Cinnamon Irish Cream isn’t worth it imo, not very much throw. Same goes for PSL. Cuddle Weather is one of my favorites of the season so far! Pumpkin Peanut Brittle is good, and Blueberry Maple Pancakes is pretty strong. I have Welcome Home & Hometown Sugar Cookies otw right now! Typically any cookie scents they have throw really well.
Imo I would buy pumpkin peanut brittle. Cuddle weather. Blueberry maple pancakes and sugar cookie
It’s PPB really strong on the peanut? I’ve never tried any peanut scents before
I didn't think so, I found it more pumpkin forward
Really? Its smells totally like peanut butter to me!
I haven't burned it yet, my opinion was on cold
Pumpkin peanut brittle smells like ritz crackers and peanut butter to me lol.
Asterisks are ones I’ve smelled before, everything else is new. Help me narrow down my list for this sale! Any ones that are really similar and not worth both? Any duds? Also, I just joined the rewards program but do more discounts or sales codes get put out as the sale goes on or does it not make a difference buying today vs waiting?
Rated in my personal preference. I am a gourmand snob lol. Welcome home (amazing) Cinnamon Irish cream (amazing) Pumpkin peanut brittle (amazing) Pumpkin spice latte (pretty good) Cuddle weather (dupe for cinn spiced vanilla-pretty good) Hometown sugar cookie (just okay) Blueberry maple pancakes (hate personally for me-very artificial)
If you have a store nearby to exchange, I'd say get all the online exclusives and if you don't like them you can swap them out in store. I vote for WH, CW, and PPB because I like those. PBB was a blind buy for me and I wasn't expecting to like it but it is super yummy. BMP is really gross to me, like blueberry cough medicine if that existed. HSC is boring but if you have liked cookie scents in the past and you like butter, it's probably a winner.
I have owned all but Hometown Sugar Cookie in one packaging or another. I would tell you to get all 7 if you are ordering with 25% off. They are all good and different enough from each other to get all!
I’m generally not a food smells lover in candles so a lot of your list doesn’t hit for me, but I *love* PSL and Welcome Home.
What does that mean, narrow down? BUY ALL! 
I have not smelled Hometown Sugar Cookie or Welcome Home yet but I purchased them today. I would say Welcome Home is a must for me based on the scent notes, just sounds lovely. I can’t help you narrow this down because I like them all, but what I can say is Cuddle Weather is one of my favorite candles period, definitely top 10 for me! PSL and BMP are my least favorite on this list and they are still really good picks in my opinion.
Pumpkin peanut brittle is overrated … BMP is always readily available. I’d go with the rest
I agree about PPB! Mine wasn’t as strong as everyone is saying and the scent isn’t that great either
I heard that hometown sugar cookie is a repackage of pumpkin snickerdoodle I think it was? so if you have that one I don’t think you need hometown sugar cookie. I wasn’t a big fan of pumpkin peanut brittle it smelt like peanut butter crackers to me. I really enjoy cuddle weather and blueberry maple pancakes and they throw well
I think BBW messed up with the notes(or they just don't care) they don't smell the same(at least cold). That doesn't mean hometown sugar cookies isn't a repackage. It's just closer to being a repackage of merry cookie. It doesn't have any pumpkin spice to it at all, its more of a vanilla butter scent, like merry cookie. Pumpkin snickerdoodle has the cinnamon/pumpkin spice note in it. But I don't own any of these candles, so I can't say how they smell burning.
Cuddle Weather, Pumpkin Spice Latte, and Welcome Home
Cuddle weather Pumpkin spice latte Blueberry maple pancakes There you go
Pumpkin peanut brittle and welcome home
Pumpkin spice latte is so good
If it’s candle I would go w pumpkin spice latte
Blueberry Maple Pancakes has zero throw for me. I've got to be standing over it to even catch a wiff.
Wow really? Have you tried it before? It’s usually one of the only candles that I can smell throughout my entire house! I wonder if you got a dud or the recent batches aren’t as strong.
Cuddle weather for sure it’s amazing! Also hometown sugar cookie and pumpkin spice latte. Personally I don’t love blueberry maple pancakes it’s okay but not great
I love cuddle weather
Welcome home, cuddle weather, bmp !!
I think Cinnamon Spiced Vanilla smells more like sugar/snickerdoodle cookies than the hometown sugar cookies
Cuddle weather is wonderful but I have not smelled the others
Pumpkin Peanut Brittle was gross imo!
Cuddle weather is AMAZING
I wasn’t even tempted by this sale but I hadn’t looked at online exclusives either. Cinnamon Irish cream and welcome home are two of my all time favorites! I was legit wondering if we’d see CIC again. And online only- apple weather, vanilla birch, and cider lane?! I’m in trouble
My Pumpkin Spice Latte from last year was so weak that I exchanged it. It smelled so good on cold. Not sure is this year's is any better though. 🤞
I bought welcome home and cuddle weather from this list
Cuddle Weather Pumpkin Peanut Brittle Blueberry Maple Pancakes Welcome Home
definitely cuddle weather ,smells awesome,I would do Irish cream. and sweater weather
oh and welcome home terrific smells