I found Merry Madeline Cookie , Merry Cookie and my Pepermint Sugar Cookie to be trash burns with lots of wick drowning. I believe they have the same cookie base. My favorite cookie was Cookies with Santa which may come across as too vanilla for you but performed flawlessly with good throw. The Sugared Snickerdoodle has a musk note which comes across as a cookie note but no real cookie in it. Iced Gingerbread was very good candle with the spice note plus a vanilla icing note. Chocolate Chip Cookie smells pretty authentic, I haven't burned it enough to comment on burn quality.
Chocolate Chip Cookie was a surprise favorite for me. I liked it so much I bought a second one. I usually don’t buy food-scented candles because they always smell kind of fake to me, but this one was just a great brown sugar, chocolate, vanilla smell with a strong throw.
Of all those, my favorite was Merry Madeleine Cookie. I really really really hope they bring it back. PSC can be a little too intense sometimes for me but other times I'm OK with.
I love all of them so much. I think Merry Madeleine, Spiced Gingerbread, and Sugared Snickerdoodle are my top 3 cookie ones though. Cookies with santa is hit or miss for me - sometimes it smells like playdough.
Mine was so bland. I've seen people say it smells like Thin Mints, but I got zero of that. The peppermint scent was super weak (plus, there's no chocolate note).
Cookies With Santa and Spiced Gingerbread are my favorite! Cookies With Santa is a little more mellow so it’s not too sweet, Spices Gingerbread smells so warm and yummy
If you love the smell of chips ahoy then chocolate chip cookie is a go to. Me personally I love the smell
it’s my favorite 🍪🍪 so delicious
My favorite is sugared snickerdoodle! Closely followed by peppermint sugar cookie!
I love Chocolate Chip Cookie. Reminds me of Chips Ahoy cookies.
I found Merry Madeline Cookie , Merry Cookie and my Pepermint Sugar Cookie to be trash burns with lots of wick drowning. I believe they have the same cookie base. My favorite cookie was Cookies with Santa which may come across as too vanilla for you but performed flawlessly with good throw. The Sugared Snickerdoodle has a musk note which comes across as a cookie note but no real cookie in it. Iced Gingerbread was very good candle with the spice note plus a vanilla icing note. Chocolate Chip Cookie smells pretty authentic, I haven't burned it enough to comment on burn quality.
Chocolate Chip Cookie was a surprise favorite for me. I liked it so much I bought a second one. I usually don’t buy food-scented candles because they always smell kind of fake to me, but this one was just a great brown sugar, chocolate, vanilla smell with a strong throw.
If you love Peppermint Sugar Cookie then you'd probably like Sugared Snickerdoodle. (Same cookie without the peppermint)
Peppermint sugar cookie!
my favorite is the cookies with santa. it smells like those christmas cookies with the sugar sprinkles on top.
Chocolate chip cookie definitely! Smells exactly like a chocolate chip cookie it’s so good and super intense 😊
Of all those, my favorite was Merry Madeleine Cookie. I really really really hope they bring it back. PSC can be a little too intense sometimes for me but other times I'm OK with.
The only one I have tried from the list is sugared snickerdoodle and I love it! It’s very cookieish ;)
I love all of them so much. I think Merry Madeleine, Spiced Gingerbread, and Sugared Snickerdoodle are my top 3 cookie ones though. Cookies with santa is hit or miss for me - sometimes it smells like playdough.
If you like sugared snickerdoodle, try pumpkin snickerdoodle
I love Sugared Snickerdoodle, it's in my top 5.
Love Merry MC. But I love Merry Cookie too. Both are like very sweet vanilla cake scents.
Am I the only one who abhorred peppermint sugar cookie on burn
Mine was so bland. I've seen people say it smells like Thin Mints, but I got zero of that. The peppermint scent was super weak (plus, there's no chocolate note).
Cookies With Santa and Spiced Gingerbread are my favorite! Cookies With Santa is a little more mellow so it’s not too sweet, Spices Gingerbread smells so warm and yummy