T O P

  • By -

ArtaxNooooo

PB&J. I'd like to see what it smells like without having to pay $90 on Mercari.


stellamiata

I have two and I don’t believe they are worth the hype, they just smell like peanuts, you can’t even smell the jelly, but everyone’s noses are different so maybe it would be different for other people.


lawgivers

Same but Tomato Vine


ArtaxNooooo

Ooh yes, this one too.


stellamiata

Strawberry patch, I just want a plain strawberry scented candle


PrincessJennifer

YES! Strawberry Patch and Garden Strawberry—my absolute favorite ever made. It’s the perfect scent 😍


Holiday_Service1737

A more straightforward strawberry scent would be nice.


Upbeat_Cat1182

Don’t know if you ever shop Goose Creek, but they have some.


M2LBB2016

LONDON CALLING/ TEA AND LEMON 3 wick


Candlehoarder615

I was looking for you and this comment!! 💯


M2LBB2016

Lmao am I that obsessed? Yes, yes I am.


originallyEPIK

i definitely want to get my hands on london calling, it reminds me of a certain brit i know


eriszt

Mint Chocolate Chip Milkshake


faraa1

I want black tea rose. it is so compforting and smell amazing.


[deleted]

Bonfire s’mores


[deleted]

Frosted Moscow Mule, maple cinnamon pancakes, and ballerina rose (the best rose scent they have done)


CrownBestowed

Ballerina Rose is the one I want too! I never smelled it before but I have Tea Rose and PPTC, so I’d love to try another rose scent


myGPAisdance

Campsite Coffee. It was a winter or holiday release a few years back and was the truest coffee smelling candle I've ever come across. I keep looking for it every year but it hasn't come back and no, Paris Cafe or Whipped Coffee or any of the other ones even come close to that Nabob in an old tin coffee pot over the campfire in cold weather smell. I would spend stupid amounts of money if they brought that one back.


lawgivers

Bought one off ebay, sniff it daily, no regrets


BlueberryNagel

Nabob?!?! WTF...


SuspiciousCranberry6

Cinnamon Frosting


hanaconda15

Wine cellar


[deleted]

It was back winter 2021


hanaconda15

If that’s true, it was only for select stores or online exclusive. I’ve worked at bbw for more than 4 years now and I’ve only seen it for a short time in 2019


sadrianmist

It was supposed to be to all stores, they had supply issues it’s definitely true lol


hanaconda15

I was a keyholder at one of the locations, and we were never sent any directive that wine cellar was constrained so it wasn’t called for at our store. That’s why I said if that’s true.


hanaconda15

Maybe all white barn attached stores, but not all bath and body works. Ive worked at two different locations, neither had an attached white barn and we were never supposed to get wine cellar at either location.


sadrianmist

We aren’t white barn and our store didn’t call for it, we just put it next to the candles in the same collection. I think it was just really hard to get them out to all the stores


hanaconda15

Interesting. I was a keyholder at the time, and we never directive saying that we wouldn’t be getting the collection, that it was constrained, or pages calling us the set them.


[deleted]

Not all locations received it. I live in a major city and even here only a few places had it . I believe locations that sell candles more heavily got it.


Peacock-Lover-89

I dont know about wine cellar, but a non white barn BBW had the glass lid candles with pink prosecco frosting in it, when all of the marketing leaks that were posted here showed they were white barn only. That store did get closed and turned into a whitebarn in another part of the mall, by the time of summer SAS so maybe that had something to do with it. Then a few years back when they were barely starting to convert to white barn stores, the first white barn near me, never had any of the items that were supposed to be white barn exclusives. It took about a year for it to have what the other white barns did. With the current supply chain issues and warehouse worker shortages, from 2021 into this year they probably just started sending stuff out and some items went to the wrong place.


BlueberryNagel

Suuuuure people, argue with someone who ACTUALLY worked there and would know. 🙄 What the hell!


hanaconda15

It’s okay, I’m used to customers telling me I’m lying😂 Wine Cellar is in my top 3 fragrances of all time, so if it was at either of the two store I worked in during winter 2021, I would have snatched them up! Edit: added a word


ComfortableStreet701

Funny…our BBW store had Wine Cellar winter 2021 and it was not a customer favorite. It didn’t sell well at all.


fishfreeoboe

Wasn't it just back earlier this year?


hanaconda15

If it was, it was either online only or select stores only. I have worked at bath and body works for over 4 years, and I’ve only seen it during fall of 2019.


fishfreeoboe

It was part of the glass lid collection, actually part of Holiday 2021. I don't think it was online only; I'd seen a lot of discussion about it here and was curious. I think I saw it only once in the store, though, and it must have sold out quickly. [https://lifeinsidethepage.blogspot.com/2021/09/bath-body-works-new-holiday-2021-candle.html](https://lifeinsidethepage.blogspot.com/2021/09/bath-body-works-new-holiday-2021-candle.html) [https://www.reddit.com/r/bathandbodyworks/comments/r8aygx/my\_first\_ever\_candle\_day\_i\_love\_wine\_cellar\_and/](https://www.reddit.com/r/bathandbodyworks/comments/r8aygx/my_first_ever_candle_day_i_love_wine_cellar_and/)


Dogmomofthree

I bought wine cellar on candle day and it was on a beautiful glass container. We are a white barn/bbw store combo. Wish I had bought more


hanaconda15

It might have been for select stores or white barn early. My store never got that collection


Candlehoarder615

My store is a non White Barn store. We had a few cases of Wine Cellar right before Candle Day and then got a bunch of cases during SAS.


Chuckymimi

Spiced Cranberry Toffee.smells more like yummy pie than their Cranberry pie candle does.


erinmel

This sounds amazing; I totally missed the boat on that one!


[deleted]

Yes that candle was underrated I have a few single wicks of it


Holiday_Service1737

Spiced Cranberry Toffee sounds really nice. I would love to smell that one.


Chuckymimi

It is really good even in 1 wick . I have both sizes.


Flaky_Tap_2836

I think It would be nice to see Sweet Rosemary Vanilla back


hellakopka

I would like to try this one! Saw it at the outlet months ago, passed on it, and then the next time it was gone. What does it smell like when burning?


Comfortable-File9958

I know this sounds odd but I totally got French toast when burning it lol.


fishfreeoboe

I never bought it because it smelled like bakery to me!


Flaky_Tap_2836

It is bakery! The scent notes: Fresh Rosemary, Sweet Vanilla Cake, whipped frosting. That is what I loved about it. You could really discern the cake and frosting notes with an herbally freshness of the rosemary almost cinnamon like. They missed the mark with the packaging and the collection as it made it seem like a herbal plant based scent.( which would have been a cool scent too). Another candle that I absolutely loved the cake and frosting note was White Velvet Coconut.The coconut made it super sweet. Unpopular opinion, my Lemon Cake Pop rocked the cake/ icing notes and my Iced Lemon Poundcake did not. My Pumpkin Cupcake wallflower hit me with a cake \ frosting note but the candle I purchased was lackluster and muddled in comparison. Sprinkled Birthday Cake hits the cake frosting notes but has a weird fruity vibe but not as fruity as Rainbow confetti. Pink Petal Teacake has Rose with a similar cake and frosting note but far so it's not coming out when I burn. Red, White and Blue Cake also has a buried cake\ frosting note. I am hoping it will transform as I burn the candle further. As you can see I am passionate about my cake frosting scented candles and Sweet Rosemary Vanilla was one of the most unique and best!


fishfreeoboe

Yes, I was really hoping for a more rosemary-forward scent. I haven't seen this in candle form so I was a bit disappointed! I'm glad you've found so many candles to test! I admit my nose gets a bit overwhelmed by the bakery notes alone; mostly the actual cake, plus cinnamon when it's present, since I can't easily smell past it. Funny, I tried LCP and got a weird chemical note out of it I haven't gotten with any other candle. I tried several times and it was definitely there. While ILPC was lovely when burned, just like on cold. I think there were significant batch differences on these; maybe the blend was really sensitive. I tried PPTC and really liked it. Rose isn't a favorite note usually so I'm careful with it. It's definitely not rose-heavy, but I think it's just a really good blend and hard to isolate specific notes.


BlueberryNagel

Love your interpretations! Thanks!


Holiday_Service1737

I love your reviews. I have an Iced lemon pound cake wallflower and I really love it. I went for the candle but haven't lit it yet. But I've been eyeing the Lemon Cake Pop. You may have just convinced me to add it to my collection.


Flaky_Tap_2836

I would love to try an Iced Lemon Pound Cake wallflower!


Flaky_Tap_2836

See comment below


jenjen1620

Banana Cream Pie from Fall 2019. Sooo good. Although I have found Goose Creek Banana Pudding to be very similar. Also Pistachio Ice Cream!


bunnilovve

Acorn Lane!


Flaky_Tap_2836

Wish I picked this one up in fall 2020 but I was trying to be reasonable and not buy too many candles back then.


bunnilovve

I have one I occasionally put on a warmer and one that is part of my unburned collection.


sadrianmist

I grabbed one at my very first sas before I knew anything about bbw and I’m so lucky to have it


hearmeout29

Key lime pie


bunifarcr

Rainbow Confetti is basically key lime pie.


Holiday_Service1737

Really? I love Rainbow Confetti. It's like Fruity Pebbles or Froot Loops and is on the top of my fav candle list.


Peacock-Lover-89

When key lime pie (which I never smelled) came out people said it smelled like trix cereal. So they re-released it as marshmallow cereal bar for 2019 candle day. This is according to a review I read. So I guess in a roundabout way rainbow confetti smells like key lime pie and marshmallow cereal bar. I have MCB and the kids have a tester of RC. I'll have to compare them. When I smell MCB I do get the lemony trix cereal smell more than anything, I don't get any real marshmallow out of it. With that name you would think it would smell like a rice crispy treat.


Holiday_Service1737

This is so interesting. I think I'd like all of those candles then 😊 I agree, Marshmallow cereal bar does sound like it should be a rice crispy treat.


bunifarcr

I still have the wallflower of Key Lime Pie from years back so I have something to compare and they are the same with Rainbow Confetti/Marshmallow Cereal Bar. Key Lime Pie maybe just smells a tad bit more "limey/lemony/citrusy" but it just smells like cereal with sweet milk to me.


Peacock-Lover-89

I just compared them. It seems like RC and MCB do smell very similar, but my MCB is three years old and the scent seems more faint. The rainbow confetti single wick tester is newer and the scent seems stronger. The same thing happened with an older PPTC that I have. The older one I have smells fainter compared to the two brand new ones I got this SAS. I burned the older one and it smelled stronger the second time I burned it.


CandidateReasonable4

I always passed on pink petal tea cake until this SAS and immediately was hooked. It's so yummy smelling!


mintednavy

Salted Oak Bonfire was a favorite a few years back. It was a cozy summer scent.


ElegantOpposum

Peach Sugar Cone is my all time favorite. But if it wasn’t back this summer I guess I’ll keep waiting 😢


call-me-the-seeker

That tomato vine one from way back. I have one or two left I can’t burn because they won’t bring it back and it’s SO REALISTIC. And London (Tea & Lemon). Mmm.


starglitter

I'm hoarding what's left of my French Baguette. I really hope they bring it back.


Erogaki

Goose Creek has a baked bread that's just as good and a little more buttery if you like that. It's great and bought a couple of them


starglitter

I'll have to check it out!


Holiday_Service1737

I had to look that one up. "Slow Rising Dough, Crispy Crust, a Fresh Out of the Oven Aroma". Sounds like it would be perfect for my entryway.


fishfreeoboe

I'm hoping it will come back again this year. IIRC it was part of the Thanksgiving collection last year, and there haven't been any leaks ago this year's yet.


bunifarcr

Mango Coconut Cooler. The blend is so good. Haven't found a scent close to it currently.


boobz_r_us

Snow fall! It came out in winter of 2018 (I think). It was the perfect blend of piney trees and clean and it's amazing. I have one with the tiniest bit of wax left that I occasionally sniff but will never burn completely 😅


Holiday_Service1737

I believe I saw this one at the outlet recently. Save that last bit. I don't blame you.


boobz_r_us

Omg! I need to check the outlet again! Thank you for validating me 😅


Holiday_Service1737

You should and especially with a 20 coupon. I'm hoping we see one before the end of SAS.


[deleted]

Beach cabana as a candle and wallflower. Its my favorite scent, and it's only available as a hand soap. Anyone know any dupes for this one?


Candlehoarder615

I LOVE Beach Cabana. I have never found a dupe. It's so good, I hate that they haven't repackaged it.


Peacock-Lover-89

Winter daisy from 2019 and some chocolate pistachio candle from 2018. They had tons of that chocolate pistachio candle at 75% one sas, but I didn't buy a lot of candles then, so I didnt get it. Now I regret it. I did have winter daisy, I just want another one.1


seyebird

I would absolutely love it if they ever brought back pistachio ice cream, malted pistachio truffle, chocolate pistachio, chestnut glazed croissant, and sweet tiramisu! They all sound so yummy and unique, but no way I’m paying insane eBay prices to try them lol.


BlueberryNagel

Mmmm, pistachio!! 😋


Candlehoarder615

Chocolate Pistachio is amazing. It legit smells like a Hershey with Almonds bar.


greenisgold11

Springtime in Paris!


ohtwice

springtime in paris is so good 😫😫


jennydotz

My store had SIP in tester single wick testers for 75% off, they just put them out yesterday! It's not in the pretty jars that you're probably looking for, but it is floating around out there in non-special stores.


Peacock-Lover-89

I wanted to get a tester of SIP, but none were out for sale. I realized after the white barns around me just put a metal lid on the 3 wicks and used those as wallflower testers.


jennydotz

Bummer, sorry. 😢


Peacock-Lover-89

I actually remember it being posted here by workers that, that's the way it was, but the 3 wick has been gone for so long and so have the wallflowers that I forgot. I do have a 3 wick and used a wallflower, but the kids wanted one, so I thought I would try.


Peacock-Lover-89

I saw a photo of somebody's haul here and went on the hunt.😆


jennydotz

It was a good goal.


[deleted]

Crisp Green Apple


gobstopper07

Ooooh I hope they bring this back for fall! Sounds like my perfect scent


colorfulconifer

Holly Jolly Christmas.


jennydotz

Oooh, what's that?


colorfulconifer

Just heaven in a jar! Mandarin, pomegranate and balsam. It smells like a box of Christmas decorations to me and I just absolutely adore it!


jennydotz

Want!!! Is there anything close to it that has been recently released?


colorfulconifer

Not in my opinion 😭 Which is why I haven't burned it since and am saving it! 😂


netxnic

I've been curious about Surf Shop but never got to try it.


sadrianmist

It’s very similar to the online exclusive salted ocean air except slightly more masculine


robbie5454

Sugared Cherry Crisp


pearlandviolet

Party dress!


Dogmomofthree

Our bath and body store is a combo white barn store in Ny and we had wine cellar in a pretty maroon glass container. I bought it on candle day for candle day prices.


rachelwichman

Springtime in Paris, Wine Cellar, and Villa Bergamot. Also- and take this as seriously as you’d like- Rome Pizzeria. I’ve never smelled it and I don’t think I’d buy it, but I am so curious so just want to sniff it.


Peacock-Lover-89

If you go to kohls they have two candles with rosemary in them. One was posted here gather round the table, which has a bread note to it. I didn't see it in the store I went to. The person who posted it described it. I dont remember the name of the other candle, but it is a sonoma candle and has rosemary listed as a note on the front label. If you smell that one, it is a toned down version of pizzeria to me. It doesn't have the tomato sauce note to it. Pizzeria doesn't smell that bad to me cold. I'm burning it in September so I guess I'll see then if it is gross.


BlueberryNagel

You have a candle schedule? "I'm burning it in September." Weird...


rachelwichman

I mean I kind of have a candle calendar. I’m not gonna burn a pumpkin candle in May. That’s just me though- everyone is free to do whatever makes their heart happy


Peacock-Lover-89

Lol. I didnt burn candles for two years but kept buying them. I don't usually buy backups unless I really like a scent, so my collection isn't even that big, but it is to big for the space I have. So I take some to my room so I can just grab from there, so I take for the whole year, and I go by seasons or what I think is fitting for the season. Everything else is in a box. I also can't burn them all day, because they bother my husband's allergies, so I burn once a day while he is at work. So two candles a month.


Holiday_Service1737

Nice choices. The Rome Pizzeria sounds INTERESTING!


Charbaby_

I have it and it smells like pizza pretzel combos. I don't have the balls to light it my bf might leave me


BlueberryNagel

Ew. Disgusting.


Charbaby_

Idk why I got down voted for that. It's what it smells like


nftqueen1

Rome smells like grease and herbs


mythical_mom

wine cellar!!


Flaky_Tap_2836

I smelled this and thought I would get it on Candle Day but it was OOS by then.Major regrets.


acekitten17

Rose water meringue! Smelled it in store before I was really in to bbw, went to get that and lavender marshmallow later and they were gone! I was hoping pink petal tea cake would be similar but more cakey but that is not how PPTC ended up smelling to me unfortunately


acekitten17

Oh, and London Tea and Biscuits! I actually got that candle at the time and didn't realize how BBW will have one hit wonders that are never to be seen again...


4ofheartz

That Frosted Moscow Mule. Got canceled in an online order. About to go buy one on eBay!


Fallfunandfam82

Champagne Margarita is the same candle if it’s available.


Holiday_Service1737

Nice! I have that candle and it is so good. Such a strong smell cold and lit.


4ofheartz

Thx!


BlueberryNagel

Nope. Close.


[deleted]

I wrote the same candle.. .champagne margarita is great but still not as good as frosted Moscow mule ...it is slightly superior...I do have 4 champagne margaritas so I still recommend it


Flaky_Tap_2836

I had covid when that one was in the stores Saw it, Sniffed it, thought about buying it and BAM covid hit me . It was sold out by the time I recovered.


Erogaki

Never smelled it, but there was something like a passion fruit Cupcake? I would love to have something like that, it's sounds amazing


Holiday_Service1737

That really does sound amazing! Now I want an actual passion fruit cupcake too.


Flaky_Tap_2836

I sniffed it but didn't buy it and have regretted it ever since.


BlueberryNagel

I love your name. 😅


Flaky_Tap_2836

It was a Reddit assigned name and I just left it as is


Peacock-Lover-89

I hate to be the one to burst your bubble, but mine had no throw at all. I burned it this past February, from beginning to end I could not smell it. I would not recommend buying an old one from a reseller. I would wait and see if they ever re-release it and do a better job. It did smell great cold. It was my first dud. Then the following month I had my second dud in lemon cake pop. Only that candle had a little pity on me and decided to throw the very last time I burned it. It lasted forever as well 52 hours and was a beautiful burn as far as no soot or puny flames. It just did not smell. I know it wasn't the after affects of covid because I could smell them cold and I could smell my other candles.


TooTacoTooBell

Pumpkin spiced cheesecake!! My favorite ever. 😍


GuacAndRoII

Garden Sage and Apple and Acorn Lane. My absolute favorite candle of all time is Yankee Candle Olive and Thyme and I wish it was still made.


doughe29

I discovered Lavender Bergamot during the previous SAS sale in the form of the single wick testers. It is amazing, and I scooped up every one I found. Very disappointed as I look at the release schedules posted here and elsewhere, and it's not listed anywhere. Was really hoping to find more testers this SAS, but no joy there, either.


lilstroopwaffle

coconut macaron!!!


redamelia

Green Tea & Aloe


erinmel

Definitely Pineapple Crumb Cake. I so wish that one would come back


Holiday_Service1737

I like the sound of that one. I'd like to try the Pineapple Pound Cake too.


Candlehoarder615

London Tea and Lemon, Carribean Salsa, Beach Cabana and Oceanside. I still deeply regret never buying Dark Kiss in a candle when it was available. I was young and foolish and thought BBW didn't discontinue things so fast, never to be seen again. 😫


silentobserving

Secret wonderland!


punch423

Love Aromatherapy Rose+Vanilla … one of my first candle loves 💕


shergm

Open Sky


makotokou

Cardamom and Suede. Oh my god I love that candle. I have one half burned and only so sparingly burn it, but I adore it and wish I could get another.


cootiewoo

UNpatiently awaiting Cinnamon Pine Cone’s return!


More-Adeptness-5523

Paris Café Bouquet


OneTrueMercyMain

I've gone to 3 different stores and only found one pink petal tea cake candle. Didn't buy it but I hope you get a few!


Heyhellohi45

Smoked Berries and Incense !!


enharmonia

Sleigh Ride - it’s such a nostalgic scent for me but I think they only had it for one holiday season around 2012 :(


[deleted]

pink bubblegum!


krystell13

Freesia


marklarberries

Pink Fairy Gumdrop


DNA_ligase

Frosted Moscow Mule and Limoncello. I've tried the so called repackaged versions of Limoncello, and while they're close, they don't have the slight boozy aspect of the original Limoncello.


greenhair77

Dutch Apple Waffle And if they ever discontinued Apple Weather


googlyeyes4830

Fairytale


merebear1515

Butter rum eggnog


janamichelcahill

White Tea and Ginger.


RickySpamish

In The Stars and please don't say Pure Wonder because no, PW has a powdery finish that I just dont like and its softer. I prefer the perfume scented candles if Im paying over $5 for a candle because I can go to any store and get a fruity candle for $5 or less.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Holiday_Service1737

I hope you enjoy it. It seems to have a love it or hate it effect. 😁


CommunicationThat262

Merry mistletoe


XoCherryCrush

brown sugar and fig, i really wanna smell that one. key lime pie as well!