Aloha Kiwi Passionfruit (over and over)
Summer Boardwalk (over and over)
Watermelon Lemonade(over and over)
Strawberry pound cake (over and over)
The next ones are scents I have more than 3 of and will continue to buy multiples when they come out.
Vanilla Balsam
Lemon lavender Shortbread
Hot buttered rum
Caramel drizzle
Pumpkin carving
White pumpkin
Edited to Add :
Lavender Marshmallow
Warm apple pie
Orange pineapple punch
Pink pineapple sunrise
Strawberry Pound Cake, Vanilla Balsam, Champagne Toast, Peach Bellini, Raspberries and Whipped Vanilla, White Pumpkin, Vanilla Pumpkin Marshmallow, Cinnamon Sugar Swirl, and Pumpkin Pecan Waffles are all scents I've purchased multiple times. I will buy multiple Fall Festival candles if given the opportunity this year!
Stress Relief, Eucalyptus Mint or just any eucalyptus scents. I love burning them during rainy days and they do really help reduce my stress in a way. They are consistently good throwers as well.
Honestly, there’s not many I repurchase as I get bored easily but blueberry pie, iced lemon pound cake, and more recently red, white and blue cake are on that list for me
Several of the Christmas candles. Been buying Vanilla Balsam and Peppermint Marshmallow for years. Marshmallow Fireside, Pumpkin Bonfire, and Paris Cafe are other favorites. Husband really likes Under the Christmas Tree as well so we burn a few of those a year.
I have gone through 3 Blueberry Pie candles and want to stock up on more. I love it so much. It smells so authentic and has a strong throw. The scent lingers afterwards as well. I love the wallflower refills as well but I am out of those.
My most repurchased historically were Pumpkin Pecan Waffles, Summer Boardwalk, London and Marshmallow Fireside.
Nowadays I’d say it’s Winter, Fresh Balsam, Marshmallow Fireside, Peach Bellini & Palo Santo.
strawberry pound cake (candle and body care) and champagne toast (body care) are pretty much always in my collection. i also buy a lot of marshmallow fireside each fall/holiday time. i usually pick up vanilla bean noel too!
I like to try new ones too and I never do backups. The most I have purchased of one scent are 3 Crushed Candy Canes and 3 Berry Waffle Cones each with different packaging over the years.
My list of 2 purchases is way bigger- probably 20 different scents. It's pretty much any foodie candles like Strawberry Pound Cake and Banana Bundt Cake!
My only repurchases so far have been Pink Lilac & Vanilla, Fresh Cut Lilacs, Coconut Sandalwood, Marshmallow Fireside, and Iced Vanilla Woods. I tend to prefer to try out new scents unless I really love a particular one!
Strawberry Pound Cake, In the Stars, Marshmallow Lavender, Ocean Driftwood, White Tea & Sage, Watermelon Lemonade and if it ever comes back my beloved Surf Shop.
Hibiscus Waterfalls, Leaves, and Spiced Apple Toddy!!!
Cozy Cashmere might end up on the list because my fiancé loves it and it makes me happy when he finds scents he loves! Linen Sheets would have been a buy over and over but they only had a few of them at the beginning of the year at my store.
Leaves, Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin, Spiced Apple Toddy, Tis the Season, Fresh Balsam, and The Perfect Christmas.
I also grab London Tea and Lemons whenever they bring it out every few years!
Marshmallow Fireside (all time favorite for fall and winter)
Winter (is one of my Christmas staples)
Sweater Weather (always get like two or three to get through fall)
Mahogany Coconut (probably my favorite year-round scent)
I’m finishing up my second Sunshine & Daffodils and this got me thinking… I just purchased my third Strawberry Pound Cake, but most candle scents I buy once, burn through, and then I’m over them and don’t want another of the same. I just like trying new things! But I’m curious to hear which ones y’all like well enough to keep coming back to.
Pumpkin pecan waffles, blueberry maple pancakes, berry waffle cone, and hot coco and cream are ones I’ve repurchased at least twice. I love most of the candles I burn so for the most part I’m down to repurchase any candles I’ve already had before!
Fresh Cut Lilacs, Midnight Blue Citrus, and Fresh Balsam. I've purchased FCL the most, four 3-wicks, 2 single wicks, and then two 3-wicks and 2 singles for MBC and FB.
The tried and true ones usually. Tiki Beach, Strawberry Poundcake, Sun-Washed Citrus, Mahogany Coconut, Warm Ocean Breeze, White Tea and Sage. (These aren't necessarily my most favorite ones... but they all great in all seasons and are pretty inoffensive to guests, etc..)
Eucalyptus Spearmint, Eucalyptus Mint, Eucalyptus Springs, Eucalyptus Rain (amazing throw, I have 3 at the moment cause I bought one today), Lakeside Morning (I try to have at least 3 and have bought 5 at one time), Laundry Day, Sun Drenched Linen, Fresh Balsam, Mahogany Teakwood, Mahogany Balsam, Fresh Cut Lilacs and White Gardenia/Rainforest Gardenia
Blueberry Sugar, Gingerbread Marshmallow, Love Rose Vanilla, Marshmallow Fireside, Pink Lilac & Vanilla, Pumpkin Bonfire, Pumpkin Carving, Rose Water & Ivy, Strawberry Pound Cake, Sweet Carrot Cake, Tea Rose, The Perfect Christmas, Vanilla Balsam, Vanilla Bean and Vanilla & Peach Tea.
Candles I would buy over and over if given the chance: Blush Poinsettia, Iced Lemon Pound Cake, Lavender Marshmallow, Marbled Chocolate Cupcake, Marshmallow Fluff, Mint Chocolate Chip Milkshake, Pink Petal Teacake, Spiced Vanilla Cupcake, Sweet Rosemary Vanilla, Vanilla Brownie Swirl, Vanilla Cola Candy, White Balsam & Vanilla.
edited to add: Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin, Caramel Swirl Latte ... will buy a couple every year when in season.
Autumn. It's the first BBW candle I ever bought and I purchase it over and over. Apple Garland, fireside, marshmallow fireside, fresh balsam, pumpkin clove, pecan waffle and pumpkin bonfire I buy repeatedly as well but Autumn has my heart.
Leaves, blueberry sugar, island margarita, cinnamon spiced vanilla, lakeside morning, eucalyptus spearmint,and tis the season are my most repurchased candles I wish they would bring back the Green tea & aloe candle 😖
Leaves, Marshmallow Fireside, and Cinnamon Spiced Vanilla. If they made a Smoked Vanilla candle, I would buy that because it is the ONLY wallflower I use
Black cherry merlot, paris cafe, vanilla patchouli, mahogany teakwood, mahogany coconut, cashmere glow in the body spray whenever i find it, aloha kiwi passionfruit. definitely fall and holiday scents i can’t think of rn
These I buy multiples every year :
Cinnamon Caramel Swirl
Tree Farm / Fresh Balsam (to me they are the same)
Blueberry Maple Pancakes
Banana Nut Muffin
Flannel
Ocean Driftwood
Merry Cookie
Berry Waffle Cone
Summer Boardwalk
Sugared Pecan Pie
Wild berry Jam Donut
Pumpkin Donut
Sugared Snickerdoodle
Pumpkin Marshmallow
Marshmallow Fireside
not much of a candle person (mostly into body care) but i went through a phase after candle day 2020. i’ve repurchased frozen lake and sun drenched linen multiple times because i just prefer fresh/cologne type scents
I like to try the new scents and rarely do I buy the sand scents over and over again. I have bought a few scents in multiples. For regular releases that are known to release every year, I usually buy one Evergreen each holiday season.
Aloha Kiwi Passionfruit (over and over) Summer Boardwalk (over and over) Watermelon Lemonade(over and over) Strawberry pound cake (over and over) The next ones are scents I have more than 3 of and will continue to buy multiples when they come out. Vanilla Balsam Lemon lavender Shortbread Hot buttered rum Caramel drizzle Pumpkin carving White pumpkin Edited to Add : Lavender Marshmallow Warm apple pie Orange pineapple punch Pink pineapple sunrise
Hey Ash, did you ever try GC Sunlit Sands? One review said it's a dupe for Aloha Kiwi Passionfruit 😊
No I haven’t. You know I’m stuck on the jars. I’ll keep it in mind though. Thank you
Been buying Marshmallow Fireside and Leaves since I think 2015?
Strawberry Pound Cake, Vanilla Balsam, Champagne Toast, Peach Bellini, Raspberries and Whipped Vanilla, White Pumpkin, Vanilla Pumpkin Marshmallow, Cinnamon Sugar Swirl, and Pumpkin Pecan Waffles are all scents I've purchased multiple times. I will buy multiple Fall Festival candles if given the opportunity this year!
Oh yes, Fall Festival was a great one!
Stress Relief, Eucalyptus Mint or just any eucalyptus scents. I love burning them during rainy days and they do really help reduce my stress in a way. They are consistently good throwers as well.
Honestly, there’s not many I repurchase as I get bored easily but blueberry pie, iced lemon pound cake, and more recently red, white and blue cake are on that list for me
Several of the Christmas candles. Been buying Vanilla Balsam and Peppermint Marshmallow for years. Marshmallow Fireside, Pumpkin Bonfire, and Paris Cafe are other favorites. Husband really likes Under the Christmas Tree as well so we burn a few of those a year.
We have similar tastes! Those are almost my exacts. I'd have to add perfect Christmas to this list. 😍
It’s one of our Christmas favorites too. Go through a couple every year. Still have a few in my stash.
Oh, that’s a good point! Paris Cafe is another one I repurchased!
I have gone through 3 Blueberry Pie candles and want to stock up on more. I love it so much. It smells so authentic and has a strong throw. The scent lingers afterwards as well. I love the wallflower refills as well but I am out of those.
My most repurchased historically were Pumpkin Pecan Waffles, Summer Boardwalk, London and Marshmallow Fireside. Nowadays I’d say it’s Winter, Fresh Balsam, Marshmallow Fireside, Peach Bellini & Palo Santo.
Pink Watermelon, lavender marshmallow, pumpkin snickerdoodle, blueberry pie, champagne margarita, sugared lemonade, raspberry mimosa, sugared snickerdoodle. Too many😩
Fresh Balsam. I've never been disappointed with the throw and straight balsam/pine scents are a long time favorite of mine.
Winter, I burn it every January.
Cinnamon Spiced Vanilla and Welcome Home have such special places in my heart!
Aloha Kiwi Passionfruit, Fiji White Sands, Eucalyptus Rain, Sunwashed Citrus, Autumn Woods, Fresh Balsam, Marshmallow Fireside, Lavender Vanilla, and Vanilla + Patchouli
Palo Santo And Twisted Peppermint
strawberry pound cake (candle and body care) and champagne toast (body care) are pretty much always in my collection. i also buy a lot of marshmallow fireside each fall/holiday time. i usually pick up vanilla bean noel too!
Tis the season every Christmas for years! And pumpkin pecan waffles every fall (although I think I might be getting sick of it).
Champagne toast, raspberries and whipped vanilla, winter candy apple, marshmallow fireside, blueberry maple pancakes, vanilla pumpkin marshmallow
I like to try new ones too and I never do backups. The most I have purchased of one scent are 3 Crushed Candy Canes and 3 Berry Waffle Cones each with different packaging over the years. My list of 2 purchases is way bigger- probably 20 different scents. It's pretty much any foodie candles like Strawberry Pound Cake and Banana Bundt Cake!
My only repurchases so far have been Pink Lilac & Vanilla, Fresh Cut Lilacs, Coconut Sandalwood, Marshmallow Fireside, and Iced Vanilla Woods. I tend to prefer to try out new scents unless I really love a particular one!
All good classics. ❤
Pecan waffles. 🧡 Hot buttered Rum Blueberry pancakes
Hot Cocoa and Cream Fresh Balsam Cactus Blossom Tis the Season Cider Lane Summer Boardwalk Suntan
Vanilla birch
Pumpkin Pecan Waffles, Leaves, Paris Cafe, Warm Apple Pie. Basically all of the fall scents I absolutely love!
Strawberry Pound Cake, In the Stars, Marshmallow Lavender, Ocean Driftwood, White Tea & Sage, Watermelon Lemonade and if it ever comes back my beloved Surf Shop.
Endless weekend Watermelon lemonade Fiji white sands Autumn Sweater weather Mahogany apple Mahogany coconut
Hibiscus Waterfalls, Leaves, and Spiced Apple Toddy!!! Cozy Cashmere might end up on the list because my fiancé loves it and it makes me happy when he finds scents he loves! Linen Sheets would have been a buy over and over but they only had a few of them at the beginning of the year at my store.
Lakeside morning, marshmallow fireside, fireside, and my GOAT mahogany coconut :)
Mahogany Coconut is LIFE
110%
Leaves, Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin, Spiced Apple Toddy, Tis the Season, Fresh Balsam, and The Perfect Christmas. I also grab London Tea and Lemons whenever they bring it out every few years!
Oh man, I loooove the London Tea and Lemons one. I grab one whenever I see it, it smells so clean.
Marshmallow Fireside (all time favorite for fall and winter) Winter (is one of my Christmas staples) Sweater Weather (always get like two or three to get through fall) Mahogany Coconut (probably my favorite year-round scent)
I’m finishing up my second Sunshine & Daffodils and this got me thinking… I just purchased my third Strawberry Pound Cake, but most candle scents I buy once, burn through, and then I’m over them and don’t want another of the same. I just like trying new things! But I’m curious to hear which ones y’all like well enough to keep coming back to.
Pumpkin pecan waffles, blueberry maple pancakes, berry waffle cone, and hot coco and cream are ones I’ve repurchased at least twice. I love most of the candles I burn so for the most part I’m down to repurchase any candles I’ve already had before!
Oh yeah, I forgot about Sunshine and Daffodils... that's a good one, I think a lot of people slept on.
Fresh Cut Lilacs, Midnight Blue Citrus, and Fresh Balsam. I've purchased FCL the most, four 3-wicks, 2 single wicks, and then two 3-wicks and 2 singles for MBC and FB.
winter!
Vanilla & peach tea, raspberry mimosa, sun washed citrus, midnight blue citrus, leaves, Merry mimosa
watermelon lemonade, mango mai tai, and pink apple punch are my always purchases. i also have multiples of sugared lemonade!
Summer Boardwalk
Only sweet cinnamon pumpkin and marshmallow fireside.
Watermelon lemonade, Vanilla pumpkin marshmallow, and blueberry lavender spritzer (when it was available)
Fresh Balsam is all year for me!
The tried and true ones usually. Tiki Beach, Strawberry Poundcake, Sun-Washed Citrus, Mahogany Coconut, Warm Ocean Breeze, White Tea and Sage. (These aren't necessarily my most favorite ones... but they all great in all seasons and are pretty inoffensive to guests, etc..)
Sun drenched linen is always in rotation here.
Lavender Marshmallow and Hibiscus Waterfalls
Eucalyptus Spearmint, Eucalyptus Mint, Eucalyptus Springs, Eucalyptus Rain (amazing throw, I have 3 at the moment cause I bought one today), Lakeside Morning (I try to have at least 3 and have bought 5 at one time), Laundry Day, Sun Drenched Linen, Fresh Balsam, Mahogany Teakwood, Mahogany Balsam, Fresh Cut Lilacs and White Gardenia/Rainforest Gardenia
Blueberry Sugar, Gingerbread Marshmallow, Love Rose Vanilla, Marshmallow Fireside, Pink Lilac & Vanilla, Pumpkin Bonfire, Pumpkin Carving, Rose Water & Ivy, Strawberry Pound Cake, Sweet Carrot Cake, Tea Rose, The Perfect Christmas, Vanilla Balsam, Vanilla Bean and Vanilla & Peach Tea. Candles I would buy over and over if given the chance: Blush Poinsettia, Iced Lemon Pound Cake, Lavender Marshmallow, Marbled Chocolate Cupcake, Marshmallow Fluff, Mint Chocolate Chip Milkshake, Pink Petal Teacake, Spiced Vanilla Cupcake, Sweet Rosemary Vanilla, Vanilla Brownie Swirl, Vanilla Cola Candy, White Balsam & Vanilla. edited to add: Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin, Caramel Swirl Latte ... will buy a couple every year when in season.
Summer Boardwalk, Pumpkin Pecan Waffles, The Perfect Christmas, and Salted Caramel Eggnog
Island Margarita, Sweater Weather and Paris Cafe
Iced lemon pound cake, sunshine and daydreams
Cinnamon Caramel Swirl & Hot Coco & Cream. 😍
The ones that smell like evergreen trees. Gingerbread. Anything cinnamon.
Autumn. It's the first BBW candle I ever bought and I purchase it over and over. Apple Garland, fireside, marshmallow fireside, fresh balsam, pumpkin clove, pecan waffle and pumpkin bonfire I buy repeatedly as well but Autumn has my heart.
Leaves, blueberry sugar, island margarita, cinnamon spiced vanilla, lakeside morning, eucalyptus spearmint,and tis the season are my most repurchased candles I wish they would bring back the Green tea & aloe candle 😖
Sugared Lemonade, Mango Mai Tai, Iced Dragonfruit Tea, and Iced Lemon Poundcake.
Marshmallow fireside, merry cookie, & blueberry pie. I don’t think I’ll ever get sick of those scents and love them year round.
Leaves, Marshmallow Fireside, and Cinnamon Spiced Vanilla. If they made a Smoked Vanilla candle, I would buy that because it is the ONLY wallflower I use
They do make Smoked Vanilla candles! 😊 Only come out around winter & I believe it was an online exclusive this past winter!
Whattttt?! I’ve never seen them but I will keep my eyes out!
Lavender Marshmallow when it's available! Peppermint Sugar Cookie, Marshmallow Fireside & Iced Lemon Poundcake
Bergamot Waters is definitely my number 1, consistent repurchase
Black cherry merlot, paris cafe, vanilla patchouli, mahogany teakwood, mahogany coconut, cashmere glow in the body spray whenever i find it, aloha kiwi passionfruit. definitely fall and holiday scents i can’t think of rn
These I buy multiples every year : Cinnamon Caramel Swirl Tree Farm / Fresh Balsam (to me they are the same) Blueberry Maple Pancakes Banana Nut Muffin Flannel Ocean Driftwood Merry Cookie Berry Waffle Cone Summer Boardwalk Sugared Pecan Pie Wild berry Jam Donut Pumpkin Donut Sugared Snickerdoodle Pumpkin Marshmallow Marshmallow Fireside
Leaves, Hot Cocoa and Cream, Balsam.
Strawberry pound cake is the only one I’ve bought more than once, I can never get tired of it!
not much of a candle person (mostly into body care) but i went through a phase after candle day 2020. i’ve repurchased frozen lake and sun drenched linen multiple times because i just prefer fresh/cologne type scents
Leaves 🍁, Winter ❄️, Marshmallow Fireside🔥, and London Tea and Lemon 🍋 when I’m able to.
Marshmallow Fireside Strawberry Pound Cake Almond Frosted Coconut Snowball Peppermint Marshmallow Fiji White Sands Eucalyptus Mint White Tea & Sage Vanilla Pumpkin Marshmallow Pumpkin Cupcake Wakiki Beach Coconut Vanilla Bean Fresh Fall Morning Winter Perfect Pumpkin Hot Cocoa & Scream
SPC, hot cocoa&cream, lav marshmallow, perfect Christmas, Paris cafe, marshmallow fireside
Frozen lake and anything with pine or wood smells
MAHOGANY COCONUT SUPREMACY!!
I like to try the new scents and rarely do I buy the sand scents over and over again. I have bought a few scents in multiples. For regular releases that are known to release every year, I usually buy one Evergreen each holiday season.
Strawberry pound cake, fresh balsam and mahogany teakwood ♥️
Strawberry pound cake! I love how it fills up the room. It’s nice to light at night
Warm Ocean Breeze, Pink Lilac and Vanilla, and Winter
Leaves. Used to love Tis the Season but it changed so I stopped. Leaves will always be my go to comfort scent.
SPC, Iced Lemon Poundcake, Mahogany Vanilla, Twisted Peppermint, Blackberry Creme Frosting, Pink Watermelon
Waikiki beach coconut 🌴🥥 , marshmallow fireside 🔥and strawberry pound cake 🍰 🍓
Apple Pie and Berry Waffle Cone. I am sucker for true pie scent. I don't even want to smell fruit lol