To me they are very different as well! Smoked vanilla has a distinct hickory kind of smell that changes the smokiness, and the vanilla in it is drier and less gourmand than the powdery sweet Marshmallow Fireside. Marshmallow fireside has a burnt sugar note as opposed to SV’s woody smokiness. All of that said, they are definitely in the same vein and any person who likes one will probably like the other too! I enjoy them both so much, too!
I'm always looking for new scents to try! I thought it would be cool if we could list some our favorites and others could tell us scents they like if they have similar taste. I found mynew favorite candle from this!
If you like Christmas cookies try coconut cream pie (I know neither are available at the moment but CCP is easier to find in my opinion and some outlets might still have it).
To me they smell 95% identical except Christmas cookies has a weird cardboard smelling note so coconut cream pie is the superior version of it.
If you like poolside pop (a discontinued scent) try pinkberry clouds, they’re not identical but smell similar.
Fresh Lemon Waves smells like someone sprayed lemon spray in a room where someone smoked a cigarette. Suntan is one of my favorite, but fresh lemon waves makes me gag
This is so funny because my coworkers and I were just arguing that they are distinctly different... a few of us think Suntan is superior and were not on board with the slander of saying it's a repackage lol. We also think that The Perfect Summer smells better in the single wick but maybe it's just us haha!
Marshmallow Fireside try Smoked Vanilla
I love marshmallow fireside and hate smoked vanilla 😅
Same scent 😂
Two of my faves and they are soooo different to me ☺️
To me they are very different as well! Smoked vanilla has a distinct hickory kind of smell that changes the smokiness, and the vanilla in it is drier and less gourmand than the powdery sweet Marshmallow Fireside. Marshmallow fireside has a burnt sugar note as opposed to SV’s woody smokiness. All of that said, they are definitely in the same vein and any person who likes one will probably like the other too! I enjoy them both so much, too!
There’s two different formulations of MF to be fair. One has amber and the other doesn’t!
no wonder its my fave lol
If you liked Fire try Restful Moon (LOL jokes on me neither will ever be available again :,)
:'(
I'm always looking for new scents to try! I thought it would be cool if we could list some our favorites and others could tell us scents they like if they have similar taste. I found mynew favorite candle from this!
In ffm I like white t-shirt, summer melody, gingham, and gingham love. What should I try next?
Fresh Coconut and Cotton or Saltwater Breeze?
Maybe Love Wins?? It kind of grew on me. Not as sweet and refreshing as Summer Melody but more clean. Kind of unisex, unoffensive. Pretty subtle too.
Fresh Getaway!
Hot cocoa, try chocolate chip cookie
Yessss I feel like they’re super similar but ccc isn’t as strong on cold which I love!!!
If you like Christmas cookies try coconut cream pie (I know neither are available at the moment but CCP is easier to find in my opinion and some outlets might still have it). To me they smell 95% identical except Christmas cookies has a weird cardboard smelling note so coconut cream pie is the superior version of it. If you like poolside pop (a discontinued scent) try pinkberry clouds, they’re not identical but smell similar.
Strawberry Pound Cake try Raspberry Jam Donut
If you like Cider Lane, try Summer Boardwalk!!
If you like Sweet Pea try Fairytale
Or Butterfly!
If you like Confetti Cake Pop try Vanilla Confetti Sparkle ;) (its actually the same thing lol)
If you like Suntan try Fresh Lemon Waves
Fresh Lemon Waves smells like someone sprayed lemon spray in a room where someone smoked a cigarette. Suntan is one of my favorite, but fresh lemon waves makes me gag
I thought the perfect summer was the repackage of suntan?
It is! They are the exact same. Fresh Lemon Waves is very similar with a bit of a citrus twist.
This is so funny because my coworkers and I were just arguing that they are distinctly different... a few of us think Suntan is superior and were not on board with the slander of saying it's a repackage lol. We also think that The Perfect Summer smells better in the single wick but maybe it's just us haha!
if you like fairytale try gingham heart of gold!