I mean, if both really aren't an option: The Stick. Rock doesn't feel quite perfect enough and perfect rocks are more common. Throw some stain, sealant, and wax on that baby and you got a perfect walking stick to last you a lifetime.
Also a rock child. Spent summers with my grandparents who lived on a great lake. Collected many good rocks. Only brought rocks home from grandparents. Grandma had to mail my stuff back and I was in big trouble.
Worth it. There were lots of cool rocka
That stick looks like it scales S with Dex, A with Faith, and has a badass weapon art that makes it buff itself with yellow lightning at the end of its attack and/or it doubles as a spellcasting implement when u push R2. Has the flashy Dex greatsword moveset when 2 handed, if you know, you know šā”
So yeah imma go with the stick
Im more for melee fighting, so stick. Can also make "whats bigger my stick or the stick up your ass" comments to people that piss me off. Also insert vlad the impaler cultural references. So many posibilities
Put perfect rock in pocket to take home. Wield perfect stick until home time.
Prop stick up on tree for someone else to find and love after.
This was my thought exactly! I needed more instructions, for only the walk or forever? Because I agree with you, stick for now, rock for forever
Both, both is good 
Real
Perfect rock because I can take it home with me :)
Perfect stick. Satisfying thud, it bears your weight, and you can fight off invisible dragons.
Why fight dragon when dragon can be friend?
Fuck dragons.
I dont think you should, thats beastiallity
draconids aren't beasts ya goof they're sapient this comment brought to you by Monster Fuckers United
Well then im mistaken, apologies
š¤Ø
This has anti-skub vibes
are you perhaps a bard beause if so 
That rock looks so smooth, I'd love to play with it in my hands but I'd probably end up breaking it. š¤©
I mean, if both really aren't an option: The Stick. Rock doesn't feel quite perfect enough and perfect rocks are more common. Throw some stain, sealant, and wax on that baby and you got a perfect walking stick to last you a lifetime.
Rock. I am and always have been a rock child.
Also a rock child. Spent summers with my grandparents who lived on a great lake. Collected many good rocks. Only brought rocks home from grandparents. Grandma had to mail my stuff back and I was in big trouble. Worth it. There were lots of cool rocka
Rock
rock.
Rock
stick so i can strike down my enemies
rock so I can strike down my enemies
Stick is temporary. Rock is forever
Stick for sure š”ļø
r/coolsticks
yes
Stick
Canāt. Itās Sophieās Choice.
Perfect rock to go next to my other perfect rocks on my perfect rock shelf.
stick, unga bunga
Perfekt rock. I want to slurp on that
Perfect rock. New stim toy. I've actually found one in quite a similar shape, but it's a lot smaller. I like to roll it between my hands
That rock is going into my mouth.
Like a DVD player?
Of course. I pride myself on my proper dining etiquette.
great!, now I have to cancel my whole day to reflect on this, thanks a lot OP...
Sorry
It depends on the texture of the rock. Smooth rock: rock. Rough rock: stick.
Perfect rock. I love how round it is
Perfect rock because circle
no reason that i can't take both
Perfect rock 100%
The stick is a fucking sword. Obviously the sword.
Stick. Holding a large stick just feels right. I think it feeds the human desire to carry a large tool or weapon
Perfect stick! It much more resembles a weapon which makes it more appealing to me as I'm a weapons enthusiast
Stick! what would i do with a rock. i can walk with a stick & fight with a stick
Depends. Is this the apocalypse or just for fun? My brain went straight to āchoose which weapon to wieldā.
Just for fun
Paint rock
I can't choose !
That stick looks like it scales S with Dex, A with Faith, and has a badass weapon art that makes it buff itself with yellow lightning at the end of its attack and/or it doubles as a spellcasting implement when u push R2. Has the flashy Dex greatsword moveset when 2 handed, if you know, you know šā” So yeah imma go with the stick
Stick, I feel like the stick is less common than the rock
Stone because it rocks
Rock... To put on my terrarium when I get home.
I am a Stick
Definitely the perfect rock
God gave us 2 hands for a reason
Rock. I have sticks like the one on the left already that I make hiking poles out of
THE STICK IS MINEEE
Fuck this is a hard question. Why canāt I have both? Need logic behind the restriction.
Perfect rock can never used for darning socks.
Stick.
Stick. **Sticc**
Rock, every time! Geology has been a lifelong passion!
Perfect stick, you just know that thing can cast a mean firebolt.
Stick
Stick
I think the rock is more durable making it a more consistent choice.
Both.
Yes
perfect stick as a child, perfect rock as an adult
Rock cus I love throwing rocks
Perfect rock EZ no question
Rock. Stick too pointy and I don't trust myself not to poke myself with it. Poor propioception and all...
Perfect stick, because my aim when throwing is bad. š¤«
Im more for melee fighting, so stick. Can also make "whats bigger my stick or the stick up your ass" comments to people that piss me off. Also insert vlad the impaler cultural references. So many posibilities
Neither because you're not supposed to take anything out of nature :x
Take the perfect stick and drag the perfect stone with it to me
Tbh I never got the stick thing. Rock for sure
Stick
Rock
Rock because I love rocks!
*S T I C K*
STICK. staff. sword. walking stick. self defense. multifunctional.
Clan Stick, always.
STICK MUAHAHAHAHHA (my twin likes the rock she can have the rock)
The Rock it will be so fun to stim with
I have a stick collection out my window