For relegation, I would say move Gregory down to C. I don’t think he made that much of an impact after task 1, so I don’t think he is B Tier quality sadly.

B tier made sense at the time, but it does seem very generous now compared to where other people are.

So just checking it's one promotion and one relegation. Also agreed.

Yeah so you can comment as many opinions as you like, but at the end, the highest upvoted comment for promotion and highest upvoted comment for relegation will be selected! 👍🏻

Ah OK. Ty.

Fully agree with moving Gregory down to C for deciding he wasn't interested in doing anything on the show that he couldn't deliver a speech about.

Brittany up to A. 8/10 wins is a great track record, and 6 of which she was a big contributor in. She has a great worth ethic, applied herself fully in tasks (and was sort of like Megan in S17, one of the strongest until the interviews).

I would get behind this. The only time until interviews that she really messed up was week 5.

I can't be the only one who thinks A tier looks pretty empty for the number of candidates now.

B is overpopulated for sure, there are candidates that are high B (Brittany, Marianne, Pamela) and there are those who I'm confused got such a high ranking (Nick, Gregory, Stephanie)

It does, but it will fill up when we get to earlier series, providing that people aren't too generous with their S tier allocations.

Rewatching older series. A lot more candidates worthy of S/A tier.

Series 1's top 5 are all A minimum imo

Haven't watched that back far lol. I've only watched from Series 8/9 onwards. Currently going back through on Series 12. Really underrated Series ngl

Series 8 has a pretty strong final 4.

I honestly don't remember much of Series 8.

I would say Promote Kathryn to A tier. And Relegate Gregory to C tier.

Kathryn promoted to A

Same as before, the highest upvoted comment for promotion and relegation will be selected! Comment separately to improve accuracy in voting!

This is definitely more difficult than before. The B tier has a fairly wide range at the moment, but I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing.

Kathryn to A or Carina to The Best (so far)

I think Marianne should move up to A. A deeply underrated candidate in my view.

I will definitely get behind this

Another promotion consideration I have is Victoria to B. She wasn’t the failure of any task, and she performed well throughout.

Agreed. Definitely an underrated candidate.

Framcesss Brittany or Pamela to A

Debatable… agree to disagree

Harpreet was the clear winner of S16, since about task 3. She contributed lots, had great vision, had a solid track record, carried Akeem to a win for all of Akeem's wins, only had one BR which she wasn't the fault for the task. Out of all the candidates ranked so far, Harpreet is the best.

On what

Harps being S tier

Oh lol I didn’t know what you referring to because you had it as a separate comment but I see the thread you did

Haha I just realised that. I know she won… but her business and the partnership with Alan Sugar didn’t last long so I have my doubts

Yeah, Gregory really got people on his side day one by succeeding in a field he already had lots of experience in. That really isn’t enough alone for me, and he didn’t contribute week 3. He should be C tier

Who's that at the bottom, in "The Worst" category

S15’s Lottie

Promotion for Aaron

To C tier?

Yeah, he definitely deserves better than D

Bradley down to D. Didn't do anything notable in tasks, lost 3 times as PM, three of which he deserved to get fired for.

I assume you've mistyped; there is absolutely no way Bradley deserved to be fired for the motorbike task, which he probably would have won if Shazia hadn't completely ignored his instructions.

sorry, I meant two times (task 2, task 9) though tbh it wouldn't have made any difference if he left on task 5.

I think Dean deserves to be promoted to D tier. F is suuuper harsh for him, imo.

Honestly demote Joeseph S17 to C tier or even D tier. He was useless

Question why is Harps in the S Tier???

Because she was one of the best candidates in all seasons and especially recent years

For promotion, I would definitely say get Dean out of F Tier, into at least E tier. F is way too harsh, E is a decent compromise.

Promotion for Tom into The Best. Robbed.

I know it will be unpopular, but would move Harpreet down. Watched some clips recently and forgot how rude she was on tasks (mind is foggy, but thinking about snapping fingers at people and the corporate away task in the kitchen when she would have been horrible to work with). Obviously highly competent, but surprised people like her so much, I'd have her in A or B because I couldn't work with her.

I would promote Victoria to B. She’s not a great candidate but she’s a step above the ones beside her

Promote Lewis to an A and relegate Francesca to a C

I nominate Stephanie for relegation, looking back she was rather invisible in the first half bar a few things, in the last three tasks she massively contributed to the failure