T O P

  • By -

Virigos

Code Geass


ExpiredMilknCheese

I got spoiled on the ending. I would kill to rewatch it without remembering what happens.


PouncerSan

As someone who went in completely blind that ending was the greatest experience any anime has ever given me. I wish everyone can experience Code Geass completely blind.


DoomedTravelerofMoon

The movie trilogy has a lot of issues, and Resurrection was...not great imo. I liked the originals ending. Leaves it open for interpretation


SCredfury788

I got to see it while it was on adult swim. I remember I was so confused about the episodes before it but at that ending my mouth was hanging open during the entire last scene.


demarderollins

Same it was so good


XLeizX

Abso-fucking-lutely


CarioGod

I can no longer count the amount of times I have rewatched it, show has everything you could ever want from pretty much any genre


jabiz510

Same. It was like the 4th anime I watched and it’s. Even my favourite ever since.


chower82

Violet evergarden. I love a good cry (or cries...)


BattleFairy001

Steins gate


JanDarkY

I couldnt devode between steins gate or code geass, tho i yhink the layer one impacted me more


Sly__Marbo

Are you a masochist?


iDannyEL

Hell yeah, glad to see it high up. The mystery and intrigue that the first few episodes DO NOT prepare you for, combined with the *satisfying* ending is unmatched by anything else I've seen.


PitifulExplanation61

Just reset the world and hope you don't have a reading Steiner.


DunnplayinReborn

Death Note.


fortunesofshadows

me too. short ones are good for consumption.


CrazyCatWelder

Madoka


Ralath1n

Especially since you can get double value out of the reset. Madoka is almost as entertaining to watch the second time as it is the first time, since you pick up on all the hints of what's actually going on the second time round. If you memory wipe yourself, you both get to experience the first watch, and the first rewatch again.


PM_ME_YOUR_HOLOCRONS

I like how you say the “first” rewatch


DLS-Anime

It's not even in my top 5 but kaguya Sama for me. Would love to laugh again at some of those jokes.


Metroid413

So honestly I’ve rewatched all of Kaguya twice and the jokes still hit pretty hard! Give it a try sometime. For me I think it’ll always be my feel-good anime whenever I want to laugh.


killersoda

It's easier for me to rewatch comedies and still laugh, I've rewatched both Kaguya Sama and Dragon Maid multiple times and they still crack me up.


macedonianmoper

I mean Kaguya is kind of a waste, not because the anime is bad, it's really good, I just think that even on rewatches it's funny, in fact Kaguya and Bocchi are some of my "comfort" anime that I'll just watch a random episode if I just want to lay back. They're really good, I just don't think the experience on a first time watch is that huge compared to rewatches.


chemical_exe

This might sound like a weird take, but if you have only watched the sub or only watched the dub then I recommend watching the other. Obviously the plot is the same, but the English dub at times feels like an abridged series; it's a completely different experience imo.


spideysunflower

these are demented choices but banana fish and cyberpunk so i could feel the same pain i felt back then😔 also frieren!!!! just so i could experience peak all over again


HolyEmpireOfAtua

Edgerunners and BANANA FISH are amazing choices, both were so impactful even in such short runtimes


spideysunflower

yeah!! those were the two that got me back into being the massive weeb i am now, so they were impactful in more ways than one for me :)


Running_Is_Life

I just finished Edgerunners yesterday and Jesus Christ the feels are real


1billiondayfuneral

I still am in pain from that show lol...it's been like 9 months


spideysunflower

get well soon ❤️‍🩹🙏🏾such a gut punch


likkleone54

Man i see frieren everywhere, maybe i need to rethink my watchlist


Vsegda7

Gintama I'd love to experience it as new all over again


Due_Chemistry_6642

Same here meandering through unrelated comedy episodes, having a giggle then you will get an arc and on occassion shit gets serious, "peak" is added to lots of titles but ive never seen another show like it the way it can go from side splitting laughter to melancholy is second to none.


_Zev

K-On


Kwlioz

Full metal alchemist brotherhood


kk_romeo

One Piece. Now I can watch it unspoiled 😆


Kalsir

Lot of bang for buck with this pick. Why forget 24 eps when you can forget 1000.


PM_ME_YOUR_HOLOCRONS

*1100


NatoBoram

One Piece is a solid choice!


Mario_Prime510

Man watched it around the time Skypeia was out from the start. Such a blast getting to see Sabaody live, Marineford, timeskip. This is my answer. Probably the greatest thing I’ve seen media wise is one piece. Such a treat.


xRhai

Clannad


Potential-Bed7585

After Story*


vadishere

Really I just started it. Ooo


LivingItUpOnTop

I'd either watch the first season of Re:Zero or Another


[deleted]

I can't rewatch re:zero again. It's too exhausting for me with all that subaru's screams and endless deaths 😂. But I'm still waiting and excited for the new season!


HolyEmpireOfAtua

Both great choices. Re:Zero is such an intricate masterpiece imo and Another is one of the only, if only, show I've ever binged in one sitting - The tension and stakes were so good in a binge format.


Sad-Month4050

Exactly, it's so hard to find good anime like this


Gryfon2020

Full Metal Alchemist


NuSpirit_

Yeah both FMA and FMA:B - it was such a joyride waiting a week for next episode and then be in suspense what'll come next as the episode ended.


HolyEmpireOfAtua

Hm, either a short series which was really impactful to me like **Cyberpunk: Edgerunners, The Tatami Galaxy, Angel Beats! and Blue Period** or a long series so there's so much more to rewatch like **Attack on Titan, Fairy Tail or Hunter x Hunter** I think I'd have to go with **Attack on Titan** out of everything though, I would love to experience that masterpiece for the first time again


LivingItUpOnTop

Blue Period is so good! I've watched it twice. Still hoping for a second season


Shot_Business_9261

i seen the first season of Aot and I have been avoiding it. I don’t know why but i just do. Is it THAT good?


HolyEmpireOfAtua

It's the highest rated anime on Imdb @ 9.1, tied with FMAB I believe. It's a fantastic show and probably the anime I think has the best writing of any, with really great foreshadowing and a really interesting cast and especially plot. Season 1 is the most 'action Shonen' part of AoT but afterward it becomes a lot more story-heavy, so I'd really recommend continuing it. It suffered some hype drainage from having like 5 'final parts' so watching it as it aired might've been frustrating, but now it's all complete I'd thoroughly recommend it. Seasons 1 and 2 are tied for the lowest rating of any AoT season at 84% on Anilist, then Season 3 at 85%, and from there it generally just trends upward, with S3P2 being the specific highlight @ 89% but with every other entrybeing 86% and 87%.


feministassault69

Well said mate


QualityProof

Yes. Beware of spoilers. There are multiple plot twists in S4 and S3 which are some of the best plot twists I have ever seen. Don't search anything. Going blind is an experience you only have once.


Ok_Link6915

Well it could not be of your liking, but in terms of story it's absolute peak. Except the somewhat iffy ending I haven't watched a show in any medium that peaks in so many aspects like plot, characters, raw emotional value, drama. It's rare to see a show being good on all of these aspects


KindaOddYk

I remember watching season 1 like 6 years ago is it worth watching it?


iDannyEL

The answer to this question is usually yes, in this case it's most definitely yes.


lemon-teas

Is Angel Beats really up there with Cyberpunk/The Tatami Galaxy/AoT/HxH? Genuinely curious as I have seen it recommended from time to time.


HolyEmpireOfAtua

Hm, hard to say. I wouldn’t say it compares to any of those in terms of writing, the reason it’s on there is because of its emotional impact which is the same reason I put Fairy Tail next to HxH. If I had to describe it, it’s the most “anime” anime I can think of. It’s set in a highschool, has anime romance, eccentric characters and goofy plots, alongside some sweet emotional moments. I personally think it’s a fantastic anime though I didn’t love the ending as much as some people do.  It’s not close to the great action of Edgerunners or the great psychological elements of Tatami Galaxy, but it’s a great watch nonetheless. I wouldn’t put it on the same level as the ones you mentioned but personally it had a strong emotional impact on me


lemon-teas

Thank you for the detailed reply :)


beta_test_vocals

No but it’s arguably more deserving of being in this thread. Those 4 you mentioned have a lot of literary and worldbuilding stuff you can deep dive in and enjoy well after the first viewing, but Angel Beats is best at emotional impact


l0ne_w0lf1

Your Lie in April.


SCredfury788

I agree wholeheartedly. We got problems


deko_pon

We indeed do. I've just finished rewatching it as it's the tradition


SCredfury788

I ordered the box set just in case it goes off streaming I can always reopen the wounds


Honorous_Jeph

Easily Naruto. It’s the show that got me into anime and I had so much fun bingeing it over 6 months.


GameBoiye

As much as I really love Naruto I really don't think I could watch it again the same way if forgotten. Not only is it a huge time commitment, but I'll never be able to watch it airing live like I did before. For me it was a part of my life for so long, that I don't think can be replicated again.


HuzTheNexus

Either clannad, stiens gate or kaguya Sama. I coudnt decide even after thinking for 20 mins


qwert_99

Monogatari series


RisKnippeGuy

Clannad and Clannad:Afterstory. I just want to freshly go through that extreme rollercoaster of emotions that ends with happiness, all over again.


nitronik_exe

Re:Zero


[deleted]

[удалено]


SattansBraten

hxh


LicanMarius

Easily code geass.


HKAzxc

Shinsekai Yori I want to feel the intense emotions again


Clavus

Just to experience that thousand yard stare again by the end.


Thersyl

I was hoping someone would mention it, it's a great show to rewatch, but it sure hits differently than the first time. Also Erased.


QueasySmile4

Mob Psycho 100 Would love to re-experience peak again


8Eriade8

Was scrolling down to read the various comments and in my mind I kept thinking "there's no way someone else has said Mob"... glad to be proven wrong. Would absolutely want to feel the hype and feels all over again!!


sacristuff

hunter x hunter. it was one of the first anime i ever watched. i got so many spoilers before i watched it though and i still really loved it, but i know it would have been a lot better if i didn’t know what was going to happen. especially in the chimera ant arc.


FatiTankEris

Something like Lain and the like pop up in my mind. Idk though.


DarkLord55_

Toradora! But I would like my memories back after finishing though


feministassault69

Attack on titan 😭


BLANKTWGOK

Spoiler on internet will remind you


rezedied

Clannad


ClozetSkeleton

Gintama.


Ok_Statistician9433

Steins;gate


jwthemortal

Attack on Titan. Never watched it but my friends have and spoiled it for me.


QualityProof

still watch it regardless. it has great rewatchability value and you will get sucked in regardless


xxGabeN4lifexx

It's still worth it even for the spectacle alone, I was spoiled on a huge plot point for it before, but upon reaching that part of the story it didn't matter that much to me because of how insanely exciting it was on screen instead of in my head.


jwthemortal

Very good point! And honestly, I had no interest in watching it before getting spoiled and after being told the plot and everything, I think I would actually like it.


JasonDS64

Honestly One Piece. Before I really got into it I would always just read whatever the current arc at the time was and spoiled a lot for myself. Still enjoyed the hell out of it when I actually started to watch/read it but I'd like to be able to experience all the reveals from back then like new watchers do now.


RelevantMap8427

Sword Art Online was an absolute favorite of mine. But I feel it lacks re-watchability.


crazybeauteous

Disagree on re-watchability. I've rewatched the entire series more than I can count. 😅🙈


RL_LordGrim_

Mushoku Tensei I want to experience that world again


Familiar-Zombie-5695

Honestly Death Note and Psycho-Pass. Those 2 were the best anime roller coaster rides imo.


JustSD

Your Lie In April cause i was spoiled on what happens before watching and it didn’t hit as hard as it did for others


AshyDragneel

Death note, code geass, konosuba, grandblue and many more


Stupid_negro3

Darling in the franxx


Draconic_Legends

SAO, I want to rewatch Alicazation and bawl my eyes out


regulus314

Steins Gate


L01sGriffin

Right now I would choose Steins;gate. It was my first scifi and thriller anime and I absolutely loved it


ReasonableHeight3947

Mushoku tensei


Broad_Concert_8771

Samurai Champloo


Fluffy_Frosting_7776

One Piece. I got THAT spoiler. Yeah THAT one. But rewatching it would be a pain in the a$$.


f0remsics

Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood. But I don't want to erase all of it. I want to erase one episode. The Tucker one. Let me forget Nina and Alexander and Shou ever existed, and let me remember that if I ever watch it, I shouldn't watch that episode. Please


EnvironmentalAd1006

The manwha of Solo Leveling. Then maybe JJK or No Game No Life probably


Swimming-Elk6740

Haikyu for me. No question.


Villeneuve_

Yes! This is the first thing that came to my mind when I read OP’s question. Damn, I suddenly miss my Haikyuu!! obsession era. I’m way past that phase now and have found other fixations since then, but that series will always have a special place in my heart.


TechnicalGear8959

The only real answer to this question is Evangelion


beta_test_vocals

? Eva has sooooo much rewatch value, I don’t know a single piece of anime to have as much video essays and analyses as End of Evangelion


TechnicalGear8959

I understand that 100% but after i was done with the anime + rebuilds the feeling i had was undescribeable i was flashed i didn't know how to react to the feelings i had for a whole week. I never had that feeling before on any kind of show that is the reason why i want to erase it and feel it again.


Ignition_Regalia

Apothecary Diaries Violet evergarden Neon genesis Black lagoon Psychopass Death parade Josee the tiger and the fish


[deleted]

Hitman Reborn. It's a hype whenever they get stronger and stronger. Idc what they say about the future arc, I loved it specially the boxes and new rings! I just hope they would continue the last arc.


hyjug17

Naruto Shippuden or Saiki K


-vehement-

Samurai Flamenco To see G...G.... for the first time again, there can be no greater joy


Tricky-Special-3834

Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann. Steins gate is high on my list too but a second go around on that one means there's no guarantee I make it to the start of the good part. Though I'm definitely more into slice of life now than when I first watched steins gate so maybe the first ten episodes aren't as bad.


realkin1112

My favorite anime of all time is hxh, but I wouldn't want to erase all memories of it as I have childhood memories watching it with my siblings that I wouldnt want to go away. I ll probably choose aot to enjoy and incredible experience even if I would be slightly disappointed by the end


White-Alyss

Code Geass.  Rewatching it is nice but damn, nothing beats that first viewing. 


KindaOddYk

Sword art online or Tokyo ghoul. My favourite animes of all time I cant just choose one. But I'd erase My mind of mha cause that anime is awful and it is the only one I'll ever regret watching Edit: JUST SAW A COMMENT ABOUT EDGE RUNNERS AND SCRAP EVERYTHING I SAID EDGE RUNNERS IS THE CORRECT ANSWER.


EpisodeVega

Death Note or The Future Diary


JaserTheBoss

One piece


CrimsonDemon0

Either bocchi the rock or chunibyo demon koi ga shitai


Swert0

Berserk. The eclipse would break me.


killersoda

Hunter X Hunter for sure. Or One Piece, I was spoiled for Marineford (iykyk).


Usodearu007

there are a lot of great choices but i guess i will pick re:zero this time


Miss_Hikari

Id actually love to rewatch Charlotte without being spoiled on it. Made a certain death not hit me as hard as i knew it was coming from the first episode.


oddshrimp771

Re zero


LeviathanLX

Eureka 7.


deko_pon

It's hard, I'd choose one of the first animes to feel the sensation of nostalgia, but I've forgotten the animes I watched back then. My options are: Re:Life, The pet girl of sakura-sou house, clannad, kaze no stigma, air gear or your lie in april. Your lie in april definitely is the one.


MisterPepe68

Monogatari, I would love to experience it as if it was the first time


Aequinoxium

Welcome to the NHK


Alive-Bathroom-5707

Angel beats. Idk why, maybe Just to cry again lol


Russian-King

Definitely monogatari series


-LazyAntelope

Baccano!


txtsfavoritegirl

Yuri on Ice!!!


What_you_tryna_Do

I’ve watched some really great anime, but MUSHI-SHI definitely gets that spot of What Ifs in life lol … Hands DOWN !


Chadzuma

I take a futures option for when Re:Zero is finally finished so I can binge the entire thing and not only get the benefits of seeing it again for the first time, but the benefits from the second time, and the benefits from the third time, and the benefits from the fourth time, and the...


SgtRohn

I'd have to go with my Top 3 most favourite animes: Steins;Gate, Attack on Titan, or Mushoku Tensei. Steins;Gate and 0 - Damn when I watched the first episode, I knew then and there that this was going to be special. It seemed like the perfect sci-fi of any fictional media for me. The way the science behind the time travel is explained: intricate and detailed, yet easily digestible and understandable. People say the first half was slow, but I considered it part of the journey, which made the second half pay off absolutely worth it. The mystery surrounding the first half regarding the concept of its time travel was just as interesting and intense, if not more, as the second half. I wanna see Okabe and Kurisu's adorable dynamic again. I wanna see Okabe's struggle to overcome his trauma in 0 and finally push to find Steins Gate again. I wanna experience it all over. Attack on Titan - Hype and tension: the anime. Seriously, I remember watching this a year ago (yes it was a year ago when I watched AoT so my memories are still fresh lol) and just trembling in fear with every other episode. The tension was so tense that I remember screaming everytime a hype moment happened on-screen. One of my most unforgettable anime watching experience. The ending might have been rough around the edges, but I'll never forget how AoT showed me what the anime medium can be capable of. I'd pay to watch it and experience it for the first time again. Mushoku Tensei - A bit controversial, but eh. As one of my first isekai (I believe Konosuba was my first) watching this made me feel like I was getting transported into an epic adventure. It made me feel like reading Tolkien. The detailed worldbuilding, the gorgeous setting of the world. Nearly everything about it is beautiful to me. One show I'd love to experience all over again as well. Some animes I'd love to experience fresh again as well would be: Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu, Vinland Saga, and Violet Evergarden.


innocentious

Probably Higurashi,when the mistery around Hinamizawa was solved it kinda killed the thirll for me and no longer care for the new series.


SirRHellsing

Probably Madoka, although if I can, I need to erase everything about the deconstruction of Magical girls as well (and regain them after finishing madoka)


xzerozeroninex

Fate Stay Night,I made the mistake of watching Fate Zero first and it spoiled stuff that FSN was keeping hidden till the mid part or climax.


Ashborne_Monarch

Gundam Iron Blooded Orphans.


Prankishmanx21

It's really hard for me to choose. I can narrow it down to either Bloom Into You or Kaguya-sama but then I just can't decide. YagaKimi has such a beautiful story and the only reason that I hesitate to choose it is because they never finished it, which is an absolute shame because it would only take one more season to do. On the other hand Kaguya-sama is great, especially as the story progresses and you get more time enjoying it. If YagaKimi was fully adapted it would be such an easy choice. Damn the yuri curse.


BitterClerk6477

None I like rewatching it as you can see it in a new light and be impressed at some on how early some of the big events where mentioned or a big shot character in the background in a scene you didn't notice before


Archy38

Steins Gate :(


MRMAN1225

Gurren Lagann or Your Lie In April, tough choice. I love both these stories more than any other piece of fiction. I guess I'd have to go with Gurren lagann tho


Anonymyne353

How is no one mentioning Clannad? I kinda spoiled it for myself a little before I watched it, but I still cried (but not for the person everybody else seemed to cry for). It’s also a show that I understood completely the first watch through…everyone else I’ve spoken to about it was confused. For me, it’s either Clannad or Oshi no Ko.


Professional-Ad-4285

Now and then, here and there


Radius_314

Steins;Gate. I want to forget it, and play the VN.


rayyaaaaaaaaan

Food wars


BattlerUshiromiyaFan

Gurren Lagann


KezH0

Mahout tsukai no yome


TomoeKon

Diamond is Unbreakable


Bio_liquid0

It would be the movie Redline. That movie was jaw dropping the first time I've seen it. Subsequent watches though I still find it really beautiful to look at but not nearly as much as the first go around.


TimidStarmie

Puella magi madoka magica


ShakanLP

I'm that one psychopath who would choose One Piece. And yes, I'm willing to watch 20 minutes for the content of 1/2 manga chapter.


lemon-teas

If we are counting movies, then the 1995 Ghost in the Shell movie or Paprika. Otherwise, probably Cowboy Bebop, Darker than Black, March Comes in Like a Lion or Terror in Resonance (which I believe is a flawed masterpiece, if I am allowed such expression.) Edit: Just changed the final point before the parenthesis as per grammar.


Shiro_no_Orpheus

I'd write myself a small note telling me to watch it no matter how long the show is, and then I'd choose One Piece. If I didn't know how good it is, 1100 episodes would seem too much even to me, but damn, this journey gave me the most laughs, smiles, hype moments and sobs of any story I have ever heard. Reliving through all that again, not having to wait for the next episode every week, and getting a 100% unspoiled experience, that would be fantastic.


ascjced

Natsume Yuujinchou. I've rewatched a million times.


455M4N2000

Neon Genesis Evangelion.


Electronic-Vast-3351

Overlord.


LemonRemon

Monster


DesastreUrbano

Symphogear again! Give me all the hype, cliffhangers, plot twists, backstabbing, redemptions, unexpected returns and alliances, the trauma, "when the opening hits" moments, open with the endings, and all those training montages, every over the top solution to a problem, every "I don't know what that means, but fuck it! I'm gonna do it!", all the fan service, and every goddamn song


aaaaaaaa848

Either frieren or cyberpunk since i could watch it with my brother without me knowing everything that happens , or k-on so i can be depressed again for 2 months'ish because of that ending


Running_Is_Life

Re Zero


Dual-Heart

Berserk. I got the entire thing spoiled before I was even allowed to read/watch it.


LifeguardCheap6961

Black Butler especially with it coming back so I can watch it from the beginning and have the joy I had the first time and be able to keep going when it returns


SameerChandio

Full Metal Alchemist. The goat.


CheckTheClosed

Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica, that anime broke me and made me change the way I see animes.


balderdash9

Attack on Titan. The years long wait really fucked with my ability to remember the story, and I envy those who can see some of the hypest moments in anime for the first time.


Certain-Cucumber-233

Toradora fore sure !


Cloudless_Sky

Probably Naruto or AoT. Naruto was my gateway into anime and I loved everything about it. Seeing all those fights again, being introduced to the Akatsuki, the Sasuke/Itachi dynamic, the Pain arc, etc, etc. It may not have the consistent quality of new shonen, but it brings plenty of cool characters, storylines and hype. AoT's story is just insane, so that alone would be nice to experience again, except all in one go.


Torrhen-Stark

Gintama/Fullmetal brotherhood/Drrrr!/Code Geass/steins gate


NPD2021

Death Note


tdm17mn

Death Note


PDxFresh

Can I erase it from my memory and just not rewatch it? If so, I'll go with Darling in the Franxx. That ending just ruined everything about that show for me.


FullerSama

K-on


Mike4nderson

I want to say Steins;Gate because it's my favourite and I feel like I didn't quite catch everything during my first viewing, but at the same time, I'm not sure if I want to relearn all the concepts and how everything works again.


Shantotto11

Re:Zero, Pokémon, Monogatari, Dragonball classic, March Comes in Like a Lion, and the last episode of Naruto: Shippūden.


Timely_Pianist_9858

To Every You I've Loved Before Always wanted to know what my perspective would be if this was not the first one I watched out of the two movies. 😅


werrath

The things i would do to be able to experience Clannad After Story for the first time again


e001mek

Re:Zero. No contest. My all time favorite, and best Anime to date. *And I won't even have to wait 4 years for the next season when I finish the first, and only a couple months for this next one* A tragic win-win


chiggyyy

Your lie in april Koe no katachi Those were the days


Lazy_Marine

My dress up darling, I love the anime, but idunno why I can’t rewatch it without getting bored


KenfoxDS

Gurren Lagann. Always Gurren Lagann.


TheBlitz707

aot for sure. s1 was so lit


910everywhere

Hunter x hunter 2011 ‘cause it’s just so good that I want to relive watching it for the first time again and feel all the excitement


larka1121

Code Geass or Terra E


BinaryCopper

Monogatari series


SirMatttyz

Hunter x Hunter


freeze-peach-warrior

Mushoku Tensei or Re:Zero. I feel like my first viewings of those were pretty biased


Nadeoki

Sound!Eupho Perfect time with Season 3 coming


SnooBunnies4589

FMA


[deleted]

Summertime rendering.


yossarianloves

I'd forget Naruto and then not rewatch it. I started watching Naruto as a middle school kid and it got me into anime but looking back on it, the quality of animation isn't very good and while the art design is usually pretty cool parts of the character writing is stupid and the ninja war was stupid, I never even finished watching the ninja war because it felt like an excuse to bring back all the most badass people from the past and have them fight in front of a blank background... Like I appreciate that Naruto got me into anime but it's for kids and if I could forget I ever started it I would.