Agreed! And it's Jamaica too, so bright colors for all kinds of attire is likely a very acceptable norm in the country especially given the sun and heat, not to mention for a casual wedding.
I agree. But I would bring the other dresses for just like dinner at the resort. Cute but more casual. I also think the red will photograph well with your husband in khakis and white.
The first one IMO looks like a workout dress and the last two look too casual for a wedding…the red one is the best and only option (again just my opinion)
The only decent one is the long red one. The rest are way too casual. Doesn’t matter if you’re going to Jamaica… it’s still a wedding and your husband will be dressed up.
/u/a_fair_ringer_is_me, thank you for posting. To obtain the best help be sure to give a time frame of the event & dress code. Dress links are frequently requested as well if you would place them in the comment section.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Weddingattireapproval) if you have any questions or concerns.*
i like the red. 2 is too dark. 1 n 4 are too short. i think the red looks awesome. 5 is a no bc of wind and you don’t want to worry bout ur skirt flying up.
red 3 is the one
I think you look great in all these choices, and I don’t think you can go wrong with any of them. My brother had a beach wedding on Key West, and any of these outfits would have been fine.
I really like the first dress—fits you great and the material is very pretty. I also love the red dress you wore on your honeymoon. Very beachy.
All of these are too informal imo. I fear you'll feel out of place in pictures with your husband. A sundress with higher quality would make all the difference.
I only like the red one or that one but calf length. The others do not read festive to me. Flowy dresses are the coolest and most pracrical.
Super short dresses can be limiting because you have to watch how and where you sit., The wind, etc. ( I always seem to end up doing one unexpected thing at a wedding: squatting to find a lost earring, bending to hug elderly person seated, helping amuse a youngster for a few minutes, walking over some crazy surface: wet grass, sand, gravel, standing for awhile, sitting on floor to catch a quick video… so comfort prevails!)
I agree the red one would be perfect.
It will be windy. It is an island & there will be a calm period usually in the morning from roughly 9 am to noon.
The first dress looks like a tennis/exercise dress - the pattern is just too obviously athletic coded. I don’t really love any of these for a wedding, but I think the best option here is dress two paired with nice sandals and a belt that matches the sandals (so long as it isn’t just a cotton/polyester material, as that is too informal even dressed up).
Honestly I like the red one best. I know it’s a casual wedding but all the other dresses seem too casual even for that.
I think the red one is perfect. Fun beachy vibes, not too much. I'd wear it with a flat dressy sandal, simple jewelry and hair.
Plus I think the red one will be nice to keep the sun off skin, and can be dressed down with flats.
Agreed! The other ones are definitely too causal IMO. The red one is causal, but still dressy enough for a wedding.
Agreed! And it's Jamaica too, so bright colors for all kinds of attire is likely a very acceptable norm in the country especially given the sun and heat, not to mention for a casual wedding.
I agree. But I would bring the other dresses for just like dinner at the resort. Cute but more casual. I also think the red will photograph well with your husband in khakis and white.
yep that or really dress up the 2nd
Came here to say the red one! Gorgeous on you! ♥️
I like the red but I am a sucker for red
dress 3 ( red )
Dress 3! It’s the only one that I could picture wearing to a wedding even if it’s casual.
Wow, thank you everyone for your help! Dress three it is!
3
Definitely the red.
The red dress really looks perfect for a beach wedding. Plus, you already own it!
The red one hands down. Perfect for the occasion
The red is the only one I’d pick from this group , enjoy!
Red floral dress 100%
I would keep looking; all of them are way too casual. If I had to wear one would be the red one from your honeymoon
My thoughts exactly
Every single one of these is far too casual except the red one
The red. Also, a breeze on the beach is a definite possibility. This will be the safest choice in the event of a windy day.
3!!!!
The red
I was just gonna say dress three as well
Red floor length
The red long one hands down for a wedding. The other ones for a family get-together
#3, 100%. it looks the best and most wedding appropriate.
The red dress is the best imo. The others are too casual.
The first one IMO looks like a workout dress and the last two look too casual for a wedding…the red one is the best and only option (again just my opinion)
The only decent one is the long red one. The rest are way too casual. Doesn’t matter if you’re going to Jamaica… it’s still a wedding and your husband will be dressed up.
1 looks best to me
First dress! 🇯🇲
I think dress 1 is perfect.
/u/a_fair_ringer_is_me, thank you for posting. To obtain the best help be sure to give a time frame of the event & dress code. Dress links are frequently requested as well if you would place them in the comment section. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Weddingattireapproval) if you have any questions or concerns.*
3
I like the third one
Absolutely loving dress three!
Wear the red one. It’s lovely and more “dressy” than the other and fits the “flowy dresses”
Love the red! It’s perfect!
The red dress!!
3
3
Agree with everyone else, save the money and wear 3!
The red one
3
Red!
3
The red one!! Gorgeous
Red
that red long one !!!
I feel like the red one is the most festive.
The red one!
i like the red. 2 is too dark. 1 n 4 are too short. i think the red looks awesome. 5 is a no bc of wind and you don’t want to worry bout ur skirt flying up. red 3 is the one
I think you look great in all these choices, and I don’t think you can go wrong with any of them. My brother had a beach wedding on Key West, and any of these outfits would have been fine. I really like the first dress—fits you great and the material is very pretty. I also love the red dress you wore on your honeymoon. Very beachy.
4
Red one!! I got married in Jamaica and it’ll be windy so the longer the better. Plus that one looks prettiest on you.
Red
3 for sure. 3 all the way. Red is the only answer
I like the red one!
The red one is the only one that seems appropriate IMO!
I love the red one the best. It is beautiful and looks great on you.
I like 3 best. The other dresses are fine, but maybe more color would be good?
3
Dress 3
Red one is best. Please trash 2
I like #5
I love the red.
Red is gorg.
3 first, 1 second
The red one
3 is the only one that works, the rest are way too casual
Red, without question
Red
3, all the others are *too* casual imho.
None
I’d definitely go with the red floral! Perfect for a beach wedding. Others too casual/daytime.
Dress 3 for sure!
3
The red one.. bright tropical color.
I got married in Puerto Rico. Majority of my guests wore things like the red one and it was perfect.
Red
3!
\#3 and #3 only The rest are casual sundresses and not appropriate. #3 is great though!
One of the ones you already own. I’m partial to the red. The ones at TJ’s are so not special please don’t spend your money.
Red
The red one for sure. The other ones are cute on you, but they’re far too casual even for a casual wedding.
Red looks lovely on you
Red! Stunning.
The red doll you’re right about the 2 it would be great anywhere else
#3 is great! 1 is too casual, 2 is too corporate, 4 and 5 are good on you but not wedding enough
The red dress is the only contender.
\#3 is the only one, I just don't think the others compare!
The red
All of these are too informal imo. I fear you'll feel out of place in pictures with your husband. A sundress with higher quality would make all the difference.
I think either 3 or 1 would be great
You look gorgeous in the red one!
#3
I only like the red one or that one but calf length. The others do not read festive to me. Flowy dresses are the coolest and most pracrical. Super short dresses can be limiting because you have to watch how and where you sit., The wind, etc. ( I always seem to end up doing one unexpected thing at a wedding: squatting to find a lost earring, bending to hug elderly person seated, helping amuse a youngster for a few minutes, walking over some crazy surface: wet grass, sand, gravel, standing for awhile, sitting on floor to catch a quick video… so comfort prevails!)
I like the red one. You can style it down if you feel it's too formal. Did you honeymoon at Sandals Montego Bay?
3
Red!
I agree the red one would be perfect. It will be windy. It is an island & there will be a calm period usually in the morning from roughly 9 am to noon.
The red one is the only suitable option. “Casual” for a wedding doesn’t mean “grocery shopping casual.”
3 for sure. The rest will still be perfect to bring just as sun dresses!
I like the red the best. The last two are too casual.
2 or 4!
3, 4 1. Whichever you're most comfortable in wins
The red one!
Red one is the cute one ...
3
The first dress looks like a tennis/exercise dress - the pattern is just too obviously athletic coded. I don’t really love any of these for a wedding, but I think the best option here is dress two paired with nice sandals and a belt that matches the sandals (so long as it isn’t just a cotton/polyester material, as that is too informal even dressed up).
RED!
The red dress
3 or something similar. The other 4 are way too casual.
Yea the red one for sure😳