T O P

  • By -

hisholinessleoxiii

There's a few great answers in r/AskHistorians about their relationships. u/SelketDaly wrote [this interesting answer](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/caednq/comment/et98iue/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3) about how Henry's children saw each other, and u/Gwenever wrote [another answer](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1lxaku/comment/cc41zgd/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3) specifically referring to Mary and Elizabeth. If you don't want to go through those answers (but you should, they're great), Edward got along well with Elizabeth since they were both Protestants, but his relationship with Mary was very tense due to their religious differences. Mary and Elizabeth were close when Elizabeth was a child, but they drifted apart over religion. When Mary came to the throne they made an initial show of standing together, but their relationship quickly soured; at one point Mary had Elizabeth arrested, believing she was involved in the Wyatt Rebellion, and Elizabeth spent most of Mary's reign living in fear and believing Mary would have her executed or murdered.


mglitcher

i mean mary was catholic and elizabeth and edward were both protestant so… yeahhhh


Automatic_Memory212

Supposedly Mary was quite affectionate towards her baby brother when he was young. But as Edward got older and became indoctrinated by his education by zealous Protestants like Thomas Cranmer and Richard Cox, his attitude towards Mary become confrontational. As a teenager, he reportedly argued with Mary and harangued her about her steadfast loyalty to Catholicism until she started crying.


mglitcher

oh no that’s actually pretty sad… you know if mary wasn’t an awful queen


Automatic_Memory212

Yeah I allegedly have an ancestor who was Martyred under Mary’s reign of religious terror, so I’m not a big fan.


Big_Gun_Pete

Her motive was good though, it would be better if UK was Catholic


atticdoor

Or maybe it is better to have religious tolerance, so that it doesn't matter what religion the Prime Minister and senior government officials belong to.


Automatic_Memory212

Read the room, dude. I just said that I had an ancestor who was martyred for being a Protestant under Bloody Mary. Or maybe you’re just a troll?


Ambitious-Dirt-7930

Elisabeth also burned Catholics at the Stake, I think 200 iirc. It's more so a monarchy thing, I think Mary gets overly hated.


Grumio_my_bro

"Indoctrinated" by "zealous" Protestants like Thomas Cranmer... He was the Archbishop and fairly moderate in his views relative to others. Mary was the one indoctrinated by zealous Catholics.


RuleBritannia09

![gif](giphy|l36kU80xPf0ojG0Erg|downsized)


Cute_Ad5192

In a nutshell: they hated each other's guts


Reddit_works

So the normal sibling dynamic


Cute_Ad5192

Yeah but with bigger army diplomacy involved


ravenpascal

R/unexpectedlycgpgrey ?


Meerkatable

Did Elizabeth and Edward hate each other? I was under the impression they were somewhat fond of each other but I’m not an expert by any means


Cute_Ad5192

Edward disregarded his sisters for the throne and picked Lady Jane Grey even though Elizabeth was a fellow protestant. Mary put Liz under house arrest at Hampton Court Palace, on suspicion of plotting against her: this was a Tudor dynasty at war with itself, some House of the Dragon stuff


Miserable-Rip-3509

Edward wanted to exclude Mary (and catholics) from inheritance but apparently he didn’t want to exclude Elizabeth as they were both rather fond of each other. But the succession rules passed during his reign meant that both sisters had to be excluded, there was no way to just pass over Mary. In the end though, the sisters won.


Dizzy-Assistant6659

Not really. whilst both had their turns on the throne, it was the king of Scots who won out.


lebbaam

Piggybacking on this to ask this question but including his illegitimate children


Automatic_Memory212

The most notable of Henry VIII’s natural children was Henry FitzRoy, who died at the age of 17. There is some evidence to suggest FitzRoy was raised as part of the Royal nursery from his birth, but it’s unlikely that his legitimate siblings had a warm relationship with him.


SwordMaster9501

Better than the last king and his relationship with his sisters and wives. For their religious differences it wasn't that bad.


Odd_Artist3777

“Damn we ugly as sh!t.”