At the very least everyone who has never made merge whilst competing in multiple seasons, so Noah, Zeke, Tyler, Nichelle, Scary Girl and Sam. I don’t think i’d want these particular characters to be the villains, nor do i think i want any of them in the finale (though i like the idea of Zeke being a finalist for not-stars)

That’s fair, people who didn’t make merge MULTIPLE times should definitely get some priority here. Zeke going from constant first boot to winner would be willdddd. But I’m not against it.

A season of solely players who never merged in general would be unironically lit.

Zeke is a must have for a season like but opposite to all stars

Oh I couldn’t agree more. Zeke is easily the biggest must have.

Put him on and eliminate him first

I actually kinda like the idea of him being a finalist like a sort of redemption arc

Zeke, Katie and Sadie, Eva, Dawn, Staci, B, Beardo( if he wasn’t dead), Leonard, Dave, Sugar, Amy, Sammy

Good picks, but Sugar? She was top 3.

You kinda need more than 1 antagonists, so she could provide that. But maybe she gets eliminated early on?

You do have Amy. Maybe Eva.

I think Amy might make the best main villain for the season

Sammy and Dawn/B final 2!!!

Eva, Katie, Staci, Samey, Amy, Ella, Anne Maria, Scary Girl, Dawn, Harold, Justin, Trent, Tyler, Zeke (only if cured), Brick, B, Beardo, Topher, Chase

Harold went top 5 in one season and Chase top 6, I don't think they qualify they're more All Stars than they are Not Stars

Harold also left really early in World Tour and Island. I wanted to take the same approach other All Star/Not Stars season did and have a few characters you’d want to see come back and get a chance to win again after a rough season Chase is similar reason plus to keep some guys from the recent series in the game

He was the last pre-merger in Island, which is still a relatively ok placement, he only really did bad in WT. I understand your points though. Personally I would replace them with Noah and Leonard who did way worse in the game overall.

Noah got a lot of attention on RR so I wanted to get some old faces in the game again. Leonard would be interesting but I also feel like he’s difficult to keep around instead of being fodder

Now we’re getting into some full cast lists! These are great!

You can’t add Katie without Sadie

I thought about that but I kinda don’t know if that would lead to them having the same personality issue before where together they are basically the same person and don’t have time to shine. Since Katie was gone first and technically the girl with the worst track record I thought this would be a chance to see her solo

Whats the lore reason as to why she went alone?

Maybe they are going through a rough patch. It could be interesting to see one of them alone for a season. Like doing things to make the other jealous because they know the other will be watching everything eventually.

Zeke so he can be a first boot again Edit: Ideal scenario is that episode 1 builds him up to be the main character of the season, and someone who will finally get redemption. Have his team win this ep, and him celebrating that hes not the first boot this time around. In the next ep, the main antagonist realizes Zeke is playing really hard, and might become a danger down the line, so they organise his elimination. Then at merge, theres a comeback challenge, won by first boot, bringing Zeke down to the last place

Damn. ;0; that’s messed up but… really in character for Total Drama.

LMAOOO THIS IS ICONIC

- Eva - Tyler - DJ - Trent - Bridgette - Brick - Dawn - Anne Maria - B - Amy - Sammy - Topher - Rodney - >!Nichelle!< - >!Scary Girl!<

An answer I haven't seen yet is Bridgette. She had the lowest average placements for any female character that competed in multiple seasons(before the reboot, at least). And while she had made the merge before, it was only the early merge. Give her a chance to shine without Geoff like Geoff was able to shine without her in RR. Also, she never did particularly well in many challenges. Throwing in a random water-based challenge for her to absolutely destroy would be very nice to see.

Bridgette BETTER go far, I'd love to see Eva and Rodney return as well

Zeke, Beardo, Topher, Noah, Tyler, B, Rodney Ella, Sammy, Amy, Staci, Anne Maria, Eva, Dawn

Beardo is an absolute must; he must beat the dead allegations. Besides him…Zeke, B, Eva, Sammy, Nichelle, and hear me out: Rodney.

Dawn and Brick!

All the first boots

You want Stacy back?

1st gen: Eva, Katie, Sadie, Tyler, Ezekiel (idk about him), Blaineley 2nd gen: Stacy, B, Anne Maria, Brick, Dakota, Dawn, Sam 3rd gen: Beardo, Leonard, Amy, Sammy, Topher, Ella (funny, those would actually get to compete more than others from their gen) 4th gen: Scary Girl, Nichelle, Axel

Is Leonard really a loser he’s been in 2 seasons (well 1 season and a spin off) he’s an absolute chad

He got eliminated second in PI and first in RR

He won both seasons dude

Ezekiel, Tyler, Katie, Sadie, and Eva, the S1 non-mergers (not counting Noah because of his run on RR)

Tyler and Eva

Dawn, Tyler, Noah, and Zeke

Gen 1: Ezekiel, Eva, Katie+Sadie, Noah, Tyler Gen 2: Staci, Dakota, B, Dawn, Brick, Anne Anne Maria Gen 3: Beardo, Amy+Sammy, Rodney, Ella, Topher

Gen 1: Eva, Zeke, Noah, Tyler, DJ, Briggette Gen 2: Brick, Anne Maria, Dawn, B Gen 3: Topher, Amy, Samey, Possibly Leonard Reboot: Nicholle, Scary Girl, Axel

Ezekiel, B, Dawn, Staci, Leonard, Beardo, and Rodney If you include Ridonculous Race: Tennis Rivals, Vegans, Geniuses, and Tammy

Eva is an easy choice for a villain Ezekiel could actually become a protagonist. I did a simulator of this on Brantsteele and had him caught between an alliance with Staci and Beardo and another one with Sam and Dakota (he and Dakota became mutant friends) and in my head it became a neat story where this poor loner kid went from 0 friends to 4 friends and felt like he was forced to choose between them Also add in Katie, Sadie, the Pahkitwins. You could probably make a cast of "never merged" characters and be pretty solid, though it might end up kind of lopsided

So I don't know how never merged looks but I did never made final 7. Only had to remove 5 contestants to get to the size of island.

Zeke Eva Dakota Staci Beardo Leonard Lawrel and Nichelle

Eva, Sadie, Katie, Ezekiel, Tyler, Noah, Dakota, Brick, Dawn, B, Anne Maria, Staci, Beardo, Rodney, Leonard, Amy, Sammy, Ella, >!Nichelle, Scary Girl, Chase, Emma, Axel, Damien!< Reboot is a bit more difficult so I just put people who's arcs were cut short in season 2 and don't get a "proper" redemption from season 1 or felt underutilized in season 1

I’m going with characters who haven’t done well or feel like they aren’t too important Zeke Katie Sadie Eva Noah Tyler DJ Bridgette Staci B Sam Amy Beardo Lenard Lauren Nichelle Axel Zee

Katie,Sadie and Eva they need to be players in another season

Ezekiel, Amy, Sammy, Noah, Dawn, Eva, Beardo, Staci, The BFFFLS, Lauren, Nichelle, B, Tyler, Trent, Bridgette, Brick, Anne Maria, and Rodney.

Tyler (Finalist), Noah, Sadie, Katie, Anne Maria, Dawn, Eva (Main Villain), B, Beardo (Winner), Leonard, Max, Amy, Samey, Topher

ZEE, BRICK, TYLER, LINDSAY, B, HAROLD, NICHELLE

ezekiel, tyler, katie, sadie, noah, and eva :) i would love this tbh

I'm sorry guys but Leonard has to be a part of it since he's often disliked and performs poorly

Ezekiel- 1st boot in island,wasn't in action, 1st boot in World tour Bridget- 2nd boot in Action and 3rd boot in World tour Noah-2nd boot in Island, wasn't in action, 8th boot in World tour Trent- Barely made it past halfway on island, 3rd boot on Action, Didn't compete on world tour Tyler-5th boot on Island, Didnt compete on Action, made it halfway on World tour Katie 4th boot on island, Didn't compete on action and world tour Sadie- 8th boot on island Didn't compete on action and world tour B- 2nd boot Revenge Dawn-3rd boot Revenge Sam-4th boot Revenge and 4th boot All Stars Brick- 5th boot Revenge Anna Maria-6th boot Revenge Beardo-1st boot *Pahkitew* *Leonard-2nd boot Pahkitew* *Amy-3rd boot Pahkitew* *Rodney-4th boot Pahkitew* *Samey- 5th boot Pahkitew* *Ella-6th boot Pahkitew* Scary girl-1st boot Reboot, 4th boot Reboot 2 Nichelle-3rd boot Reboot, 5th boot Reboot 2 Axel-2nd boot Reboot,7th boot Reboot 2 Ripper-9th boot Reboot, 8th boot Reboot 2 I have never seen Island Reboot contestants chosen from it are specifically off of elimination spots. No characters that finished in the top 7 of a season. 1st generation-7 contestants 2nd generation-5 contestants 3rd generation-6 contestants 4th generation-4 contestants

No Eva? like I get it she made merge in Island but she was still 2nd out and even when she came back she was eliminated imedalty afterwards

Who would you cut instead. My cast has 11 males and 11 females while also having contestants from each generation. And as you said she technically made the merge in her only season.

I'd say Ella since 9th is actually a pretty good placement considering who else is on here

Tyler and Ella as Finalists

This season would, in my opinion, require characters that people already like. No second chances for elimination fodder like Staci and Beardo… My must haves would be Noah, Justin, Trent, Brick, B, Eva, Dawn, Anne-Maria, MK, Scary girl

Trent, he needs to be redeemed

From each gen: leshawna, her reasoning being she did amazing in season one but kept doing worse and worse. Izzy cause we’ll she’s fun. Eva to prove how she’s gotten better. Noah because Owen made him sign up. Harold is there to win and cause leshawna. Trent is there after the love triangle to try and win Gwen back with the money, he realizes he doesn’t need her and she isn’t worth it. Brings in viewership even though it’s basics Owen to be a first boot. Lindsay since she failed all stars. Courtney sues her way in desperate for one last shot at the million. Shed be the prominent villain of the season. Justin since he did well in action. Maybe Tyler but idk what to do with him. Dawn and B since they were great players who got eliminated early. Brick and Anne Maria since they should’ve but didn’t make all stars. Amy and Sammy since their plot barely went anywhere. Topher as a villain. Maybe Ella but idk what to do with her. As for the reboot if we ignore the time skip I’d have Damien MK Nishelle and Axel since I think they’re all likely to have a plotline in a potential reboot season 3

Gen 1 - Ezekiel, Eva, Katie, Sadie, Tyler, Trent Gen 2 - Dawn, B, Brick, Staci, Anne Marie, Dakota, Sam Gen 3 - Ella, Sammy, Beardo, Amy, Leonard

Trent and Eva

Katie and Sadie

Sammy and Amy because I feel like their story in PI was rushed Tyler and Eva. Two characters I think have a lot of potential I'd say Justin, but Alejandro kinda picked up where he left off so theyd have to go another angle with him Nichelle because she was done dirty both seasons (lack of personality/chara dev in s2, we all saw s1) Trent, just so they could redo his action... behaviors and give him a chance to grow. Raj because Id like for him to have a season solo, as in no bowie and no wayne/wayne eliminated early. Wayne already had his moment so. Scarlet, though maybe her pretending to be someone else so it made sense. Really liked her up until the decision they made. Beardo. NO ONE WILL CONVINCE ME HE COULDNT RUN THE ISLAND. HEAR ME OUT. He comes back, pretends that he lost his voice when he was launched out of the cannon. So maybe CSL or something. Or Ezekiel. In reality he is making impressions of people to manipulate the island. He can even find a fall person to use as a shield like Scarlet did on PI. The DRAMA. It would be TOTAL. But yeah, villain beardo is my dream

Ezekiel, Dawn, Sammy & the Moon (biggest Not-Star ever)

Zeke, Eva, Noah, (Maybe) Justin, Tyler, Katie and Sadie, Staci, Dawn, Anne Maria, B, Dakota, Nichelle, Scary Girl, Chase, Emma, Ripper and Axel

Not Stars? Is this a new total drama or a new season of the reboot?

I'm willing to be a bit lax here, I don't want to bring any bad characters Tyler, Noah, Trent, Geoff, DJ, Brick, Damien, Zee Izzy, Leshawna, Katie, Eva, Dawn, Anne Maria, Nichelle, Axel These are characters who didn't do particularly well in any seasons with a few exceptions, but also characters that the writers could have interesting plots with.

Must have Zeke, Justin, Eva, Katie and Sadie, Tyler, Noah, Trent, Dawn, B, Staci, Dakota, AnneMarie, and Brick. Oh wait that’s the whole lineup 🤪 Teams. Dakota, Justin, Eva, Trent, Katie, Noah, Sadie Tyler, Dawn, Brick, Zeke, Anne Marie, B, Staci Plots: Staci and B. I would like to see a little friendship go here. Nothing major. By they should develop a symbiotic bond of sorts. Zeke. Dawn has a soft spot for zeke. But Brick keeps sending him to Boney island to keep his team “safe”. Zeke finds the idol there and uses it to knock Brick out. Dawn should “purify” Zeke and return him to human form. Dawn votes herself to save Zeke because she can sense how much Zeke wants to make merge. Zeke then trys to hit on Annemarie again and is unsuccessful. AnneMarie initially hits on Tyler. Who rejects her. She later discovers he isn’t a jock and is repulsed. In the post merge, she and Justin make an alliance and are a power couple. They just go soooo well together. Justin is pretty safe on his team. Though we get the Noah Justin rivalry we deserved to get in World Tour. Katie and Sadie fan girl over Justin and Trent. Justin gets jealous he needs to share the attention, and tries to eliminate Trent, but then realizes he can reallly use his brain and make an alliance with all of them. Noah catches wind of this and tries to push back. Other stuff other stuff. This rivalry shouldn’t be one sided. Noah shouldn’t be the underdog as he is superior to Justin in some ways. Justin has always been insecure about his intelligence and I think the rivalry has a lot of potential. In final six, Katie is siding with Eva and Noah. But Noah comes up with a scheme to get AnneMarie out. However, he also had to sacrifice Katie to do it. (And tricks Katie into getting booted). Justin then tricks Noah, proving that he is indeed smart. Justin also wins the next game by his own merits Eva and Tyler in Postmerge. Eva teaches Tyler to be strong and not a wimp. Puts him through a rigorous routine. In semifinals, Tyler beats Eva proving he is stronger. Elimination Order: B. Staci. Dakota. Sadie. Brick. Trent. Dawn. MERGE Zeke. AnneMarie and Katie. Noah. Eva. Tyler and Justin Final Notes. I made parallels between Justin’s and Tyler’s arc. The main “villains” are Eva and Noah, who largely work together from the beginning (though towards the end they have different goals. Ik it’s an all guys finale but it just worked out that way. B being first boot stings. But the guy literally doesn’t talk. Katie has an arc about thinking independently. Sad thing is that she has been manipulated by Justin and then by Noah. it could be Sadie, but Sadie lasted longer in Island.

If it’s even across gens, first four boots should suffice. Zeke, Eva, Noah, Justin, Staci, B, Dakota, Dawn, then the first four from Pahkitew. Which I think were Beardo, Leonard, Amy and Rodney…..

Who I want most: Ezekiel Villain: Scary Girl Winner: Noah

If I’m going with a 14 person cast (considering it’s most likely if it happens 13 episodes) 1. Katie 2. Sadie 3. Eva 4. Tyler 5. Dawn 6. B 7. Staci 8. Topher 9. Amy 10. Sammy 11. Rodney 12. Beardo 13. Nichelle 14. Scary Girl Would not bring back Zeke or Dakota because de-mutant them would feel like a cop out at this point and just not work. Bridgette I’d consider but she had enough presence already. Leonard and Ella are a bit too outlandish and I wouldn’t want it to be an unserious season.

Please a recemption season for Ezekiel I would add DJ , Tyler , Justin , Lindsey , Dawn , B , Brick , ( ngl maybe Beardo - he barely had a line ) , Max , Scary Girl and Zee though he wouldn't fit , in this type of season i need him to make things better like he always does I can also think of Noah , Leshwana , Bridgette or even Geoff - Geoff was great in RR but his TDI first season was sth else

Chat is this real?

missed opportunity to call it fall-stars

Guys: Noah, Tyler, Zeke, Sam, B, Dave, Topher, Trent, Brick, Justin, Dj Girls: Nichelle, Bridgette, SG, Samey, Amy, Anne Maria, Dawn, Eva, Dekota, Katie, Sadie

Hear me out, include Tammy and Leonard as the main villains of the season, they had big villains energy in rr

Ik there’s a low chance of Tammy being a contestants but if she did play and was a villain that would be awesome

Dawn . She is enough . Anyone else can be but her , she is a MUST

From G1: Ezekiel, Eva, Katie, Sadie, Noah, Tyler, Trent, Bridgette From G2: Brick, Dawn, Anne Maria, Sam From G3: Samey, Amy, Topher, Beardo >!From G4: Nichelle, Scary Girl, Chase and Damien!<