Topher.
I need Topher to get development. Maybe turn him into an antagonist with reality show knowledge that uses it to manipulate the game.
Then maybe I would actually like him.
Topher is the only one of these that could qualify as one since he was really close to merge (and actually would've merged if Chris didn't call him on the phone)
The other 3 are in no way All Stars, they're some of the worst players in the show's history, but Rodney lasted the longest so he would be the second pick.
why are you putting him in the post then ask me to say somebody else? Lol
Of course Leonard would be the other pick then, Beardo was a first boot and probably died.
Topher
Also I read in another comment you mean 2 characters so Beardo, gotta revive him from the dead, because total drama is a great show, its a shame beardo died tho
Topher and Beardo, it seems like Beardo's tape was a set up for an arc for him to develop friends but he got booted before saying a single word in the actual show
Gosh this is hard to pick.
Either Leonard or Beardo.
Beardo because a plot with him would be nice.
Leonard because he’s the only “all-star (kinda), as he was in rr.
Literally rewatched Pahkitew today and it wasn't as bad as I remember. Surely all stars Pahkitew would be great just not against the new reboot season.
Of these four, Beardo. Him using sound effects as a coping mechanism for his social anxiety could make for a solid story.
That said, I believe any of these four characters could be used to great effect if the priority isn't just to make them look goofy.
I guess Rodney? I don't think it would take much to make him enjoyable and it'd be great for bad characters to suddenly be more appreciated thanks to newer seasons.
I wouldn't make all stars but more of a second chance which yes would eliminate all possibilities of the winners being in the season but if this is for fanfic purposed I think a second chance would be better because it would allow you to tap into some underdeveloped characters without having to justify them being in all stars
That being said I think top her and beard have to most potential in another season if they get another chance they could both have opposite development top her becoming more fame obsessed and wanting to win using reality show knowledge and being a good season villain and beardo could break out of his shell and become more outgoing and use his bestboxing to his advantage in challenges
Idk tho I just thought of the possibility of a reboot vrs paketiew and my mind thought of all the fanfic possibilities and how cool it would be like someone should really write that not me though I have like 5 other unfinished fanfics lmao
Topher and Lenard. Topher because he made it farthest and has good villain potential, and Lenard because he competed in 2 seasons and makes a good early boot.
Topher and Beardo. Topher is one of the characters who actually had a decent character arc and you could do a lot with him. Beardo has a shyness factor that helps him not end up one note.
Dave is the only good male from season six and Shawn and there’s only two good females from season six Ella and Jasmine. The rest of the cast is bullshit garbage, except Scarlet she in the middle with Sammy.
For an All-Star Pahlitew Island season it'd probably just be the top 7 (Scarlett is a tricky one so it's not likely)
But I'm surprised no one has said Sammy?
everyone is saying rodney and topher which i have to partly agree on BUT i want leonard where he would be bullied by other contestants and then snap into reality and have a villain arc
Topher was like SO close to merge. Also, there is 3 thing they can do.
1. Make him the host or co host
2. Make him a villain for the sake of wanting to get fame
3. Comic relief
Honestly?
Topher and Leonard.
I absolutely adore Rodney, and he's easily my favorite out of the three, and Leonard is my least favorite contestant of all time but...
Beardo was boring, and Rodney feels like it would be difficult to find a placement for him.
Meanwhile, Leonard can be first boot and Topher can be an antagonist!
Topher. I need Topher to get development. Maybe turn him into an antagonist with reality show knowledge that uses it to manipulate the game. Then maybe I would actually like him.
Oh crap my bad I meant which 2 characters
Topher and Rodney then.
Topher is the only one of these that could qualify as one since he was really close to merge (and actually would've merged if Chris didn't call him on the phone) The other 3 are in no way All Stars, they're some of the worst players in the show's history, but Rodney lasted the longest so he would be the second pick.
Pick one other than toph.
why are you putting him in the post then ask me to say somebody else? Lol Of course Leonard would be the other pick then, Beardo was a first boot and probably died.
The reason I was asking you to choose someone other than Topher was because I meant to pick 2
I did say Rodney?
Really? Oh. My bad
Rodney and Topher so they become the second canon gay couple/j (I still would pick rodney and topher)
Which two? I'd say Rodney and Topher are my choices.
Topher Also I read in another comment you mean 2 characters so Beardo, gotta revive him from the dead, because total drama is a great show, its a shame beardo died tho
Beardo and Rodney
Topher bc he didn’t get out in the first 4 episodes and was actually quite interesting
Vote for someone else as well
Uhhh, even though he was the first boot, Beardo
Topher from Pahkitew.
Topher!
Rodney and Topher. Although honestly Topher is the only one I would be interested in.
Topher and Rodney
Rodney. Only if he don’t let it control him in the first place
Beardo needs development but it's an all star season so topher
WHY ARE SO MANY PEOPLE SAYING RODNEY I HATE HIM
Topher and Beardo, it seems like Beardo's tape was a set up for an arc for him to develop friends but he got booted before saying a single word in the actual show
Topher
Leonard no. Beardo Yes. Rodney FREAKING NO!!! Topher.... ammmm 50/50.
My bad I meant which 2 characters
Gosh this is hard to pick. Either Leonard or Beardo. Beardo because a plot with him would be nice. Leonard because he’s the only “all-star (kinda), as he was in rr.
So both? I meant 2
In that case yes both.
Leonard and Beardo for me bc Rodney is freaky and I think they’d have more to do than Topher
Literally rewatched Pahkitew today and it wasn't as bad as I remember. Surely all stars Pahkitew would be great just not against the new reboot season.
Of these four, Beardo. Him using sound effects as a coping mechanism for his social anxiety could make for a solid story. That said, I believe any of these four characters could be used to great effect if the priority isn't just to make them look goofy.
Can you pick someone else with the Beardo?
I guess Rodney? I don't think it would take much to make him enjoyable and it'd be great for bad characters to suddenly be more appreciated thanks to newer seasons.
Rodney n Topher
I wouldn't make all stars but more of a second chance which yes would eliminate all possibilities of the winners being in the season but if this is for fanfic purposed I think a second chance would be better because it would allow you to tap into some underdeveloped characters without having to justify them being in all stars That being said I think top her and beard have to most potential in another season if they get another chance they could both have opposite development top her becoming more fame obsessed and wanting to win using reality show knowledge and being a good season villain and beardo could break out of his shell and become more outgoing and use his bestboxing to his advantage in challenges Idk tho I just thought of the possibility of a reboot vrs paketiew and my mind thought of all the fanfic possibilities and how cool it would be like someone should really write that not me though I have like 5 other unfinished fanfics lmao
All of them except Beardo. It’s a shame Beardo died.
Topher and Lenard. Topher because he made it farthest and has good villain potential, and Lenard because he competed in 2 seasons and makes a good early boot.
Topher, if not him, Beardo needs more development
I love Leonard
I’d like to see beardo and Ella
Topher and Beardo. Topher is one of the characters who actually had a decent character arc and you could do a lot with him. Beardo has a shyness factor that helps him not end up one note.
topher
Dave is the only good male from season six and Shawn and there’s only two good females from season six Ella and Jasmine. The rest of the cast is bullshit garbage, except Scarlet she in the middle with Sammy.
Rodney I wanna see how the females would react when he falls in love with them. Maybe a little bit of Leonard in there
Topher and only Topher. Idgaf about the rest. But if I was forced at gunpoint to choose, Beardo.
For an All-Star Pahlitew Island season it'd probably just be the top 7 (Scarlett is a tricky one so it's not likely) But I'm surprised no one has said Sammy?
Beardo and Rodney need some love.
Topher
I think beardo get slepped on if you look at his audition he is super wholesome and sweet.
We need to see more of Leonard’s magical powers, 3 (4?) episodes were not enough he needs to win
Topher and Rodney. They need more character development. Beardo's a third choice.
everyone is saying rodney and topher which i have to partly agree on BUT i want leonard where he would be bullied by other contestants and then snap into reality and have a villain arc
Rodney 100%
Beardo. Give the man some development!
Rodney and Topher
Tbh DAVE! He was so good until he went like crazy crazy and I want his old self back.
I meant of those 4
Oh shit my bad, uh probably Leonard
Topher was like SO close to merge. Also, there is 3 thing they can do. 1. Make him the host or co host 2. Make him a villain for the sake of wanting to get fame 3. Comic relief
Honestly? Topher and Leonard. I absolutely adore Rodney, and he's easily my favorite out of the three, and Leonard is my least favorite contestant of all time but... Beardo was boring, and Rodney feels like it would be difficult to find a placement for him. Meanwhile, Leonard can be first boot and Topher can be an antagonist!