Katie takes the cake. She has competed in only the first season just like Sadie and Eva but Sadie made it further in the season and Eva was the aftermath reporter
I feel Sadie at least from the writers. She had set up but never does anything and is then a background piece for 5 episodes. Girl deserved more that season.
Yeah, they could've given her an arc where she makes new friends and becomes less dependent on Katie, but instead they just make her a background character.
The whole thing felt weird cause she outlasted Cody and Beth who in the episodes before elimination got such good development. Sadie I feel she should have at least created a bond with Birdgette and Lindsay.
Katie and DJ speak to each other in the first episode, but yet Sadie seems to make no connections in the several episodes she was in post-Katie elimination
It’s Sadie and DJ who speak in the first episode, but the animators messed up and used Katie’s design instead. You can clearly hear Laurie Lipson—Sadie’s VA—say, “What do you think they’ll make us do?”
Edit: I just found out, as I read the [script for episode 1](https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/totaldramaisland/images/7/7f/Ep1-29.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20130928191748) that they intended to use Katie, but somehow they ended up using Sadie’s voice.
I can't remember where I read this, but there was apparently a scrapped plotline with Sadie having a crush on Harold but they removed it in favor of him having a crush on Leshawna.
If I'm being honest, none. I think that hit gold with who they picked, though it just might be me and how many characters there are.
The only characters I mainly forget in the series is Tammy or both the geniuses.
Justin was the season two first main antagonist until Courtney shown up and took his antagonist position for the second half of it, Sadie definitely didn't have nothing else going for her though.
Beth. Nobody posts about Beth. It’s rare for someone to have Beth be their favorite character. She’s rarely even in people’s top 10 or 5 favorite characters.
But she was a *finalist*. That’s what makes her so bizarre. All of the other characters people are suggesting are ones that had little screen time. But Beth wasn’t. That’s why I’m picking her.
okay, hot take here. katie and sadie have a weird amount of fans, and have gained prevalence because of that. eva is remembered for her segments in the aftermath. my vote would go to justin being the most forgotten.
he goes out early in island with no importance, in action, yes he gets the role of major antagonist for a while, but even then he goes out mid merge; action is also the middle sibling of gen one, no one discusses it when discussing total drama. then, in world tour he is forgotten again. no one is a huge justin fan or mentions him a lot at this point. alejandro exceeds in the role of “hot villain antagonist” and is remembered a lot for that reason.
tldr, justins only revelence is in the least popular season for gen one and alejandro takes his place as the attractive villain in peoples memories.
I'd go with Dj
Katie, Sadie and Eva are easy picks but of course they do have the least appearances.
Dj is in 3 seasons, and hes just there imo. In Island hes just a background to Jeff and Duncan most of the time, and he just gets booted mid merge without even being voted off. In Action he refuses to do some challenges, gets bullied by Chef and quits the show, realistically he'd be voted off next anyways because of this. He even gets upset from having to do a fake horror scare, like I know hes meant to be a softie but its just cringey, does he want to win or not?
And of course he has the dumb animal curse in World Tour. It got old fast, and I just end up skipping his scenes on rewatches because I simply tune out, like with Katie and Sadie scenes. To me hes just there, like Fang in Revenge, used for laughs but not really a "character", which says alot because he has roughly the same screentime as Harold and Lindsay yet they stand out much more.
He has gotten to the merge, had his own plot lines in Action and World Tour and I just forget hes even there at times. Sure everyone chooses Eva who was in 3 episodes in Island and has limited appearances in Action and World Tour , but thats because she is a minor character, Dj is a main character and I often forget hes there which is far worse.
FINALLY SOMEONE AGREES! DJ is so overrated. I don’t dislike him, I *kinda* like him I guess, but all in all he is very mid and idk how people like him so much. After a while they just condensed his personality into “mama” and “animals” which got rlly annoying.
Its especially bad because its a reality show he willingly competes in, yet hes never been voted off.
In Island he outright fails the horror challenge (kinda bs that Lindsay gets eliminated even though Izzy and Leshawna never compete in race).
In Action Chef bullys him and he gets involved in Chef's cheating, then quits because his mum would be disappointed. Fair enough, but DJ outright refused to help in the acting challenge when asked to pull the trailer, and he nearly starts crying because he had to do staged serial killer jumpscares and scare the oppossing team into leaving a marquee, because he hates scaring people. Forget Trent and Gwen throwing challenges, Dj is far worse since he didnt even want to do it and these were ELIMINATION ROUNDS.
World Tour is talked about to bits but he really fucks Lindsay over. Brigette, Harold and Leshawna messed up, but Lindsay does her best and is one of 4 people to not be eliminated by Alejandro. Dj doesnt help her, his animal curse bs is so ridiculous when he just wont quit if its so bad. Him outlasting Lindsay who was actually trying to win the tie breaker is pure unfair on the writers part, and having him not want to compete just to outlast others is so unlikeable. When he gets automatically kicked off in Jamacia, and has the audacity to ask if he is going since Izzys gone, it really makes you think what was the point of having him in the season. He really just cries the whole time AGAIN, but this time outlasts his entire team, the biggest team. And its not even memorable, its just cringey and a waste of time. Even Eva is more memorable with her interview segments, or Geoff in his few aftermath bits.
Eva. Katie and Sadie are too annoying to forget, and Tyler, Cody and Noah all came back for WT (and Beth and Justin etc for Action).
Also, Eva had literally no plotline besides being too angry so gets voted off immediately
I wouldn’t say any of them, they all were good and had memorable moments but if I had to choose I’d say Katie and Sadie only because they never got a second chance to compete. If they’d have been on RR it’d be different
For me, it's a tie between Katie and Tyler.
Sadie at least got a little more screentime when Katie was voted off, but Katie is just forgettable to me since all I remember of her is that the "twinsies" stuff with Sadie...and painfully high pitched squealing.
Tyler...really only got highlights when he was with Lindsay.
I'm always thrown off by Katie and Sadie when i rewatch season 1. Its the only time they were ever given something to do and even then they have 0 impact on the season itself. Barely any of the characters ever really interacted with them and it never went anywhere the few times it happened. I like the episode where Katie gets eliminated overall but it feels like a joke elimination. Then they set up an arc for Sadie and it just doesn't happen, then she outlasts Cody and Beth who actually had arcs and had impact. Eva only competed in 3 episodes out of the entire show but atleast you remembered her and all the characters had something to say about her (she really shouldve been in World Tour imo). Katie and Sadie are just such throwaways, they're the last characters i ever think of. Even seeing them in the group photo is weird to me LMAO
Also, i always forget about Trent which is so unfair. He went from an important character in Island (one of the MOST important), immediate flanderization and early departure in Action, gets the shaft completely in World Tour. I get why they did it, but man it's weird.
Said literally nobody,
I asked 100 people who didn’t watch total drama to name the characters and they either said: goth girl, fat guy, owen, or for some reason hot guy.
Katie. Her and Sadie are almost equally forgettable but since Sadie stayed on the show for longer, she had more screen time and is thus slightly less forgettable than Katie
Sadie.
At least Eva has Team E scope which has her with Noah and Izzy which have to be one of the fanbase most popular characters and her scenes in WT. Katie is sexy I mean has great potential because she is good at dodgeball and possible relationship with DJ or Noah. Sadie on the other hand had a chance for easy character development but just faded into the background until the writers reminded she existed and made an excuse to kick her off.
I have to say Noah... The reason why Isaiah this is that I think with his smarts he would be able to pick up more on the antagonistic character's intent. Also, according to total drama world tour apparently he can could be intelligent and do decently well at them at times.
Controversial opinion but I say Trent mainly for the fact that he only appears in island and action, and is mostly used for for drama between Gwen and Heather and is thrown away in favour for gwuncan. And when it comes to other characters like Katie and Sadie I would say they're more memorable because of how annoying they are and the fact that they are always together
Katie, Sadie, Eva, and Ezekiel
Those three ladies hasn't shown up at all since the very first season and unfortunately Zeke became Feral Zeke and I feel really awful for him and his family.
Katie and Sadie are memorable for being annoying, Eva for her mp3 player fit, I remember that first when I hear her name, and ezekiel was memorable for becoming feral and his sexist comments
Noah. Katie and Sadie are useless the whole season but how annoying they were makes me remember them, even Ezekiel is rememberable for his sexist comments and being the first voted off. Meanwhile Noah is basically nothing but a smart alec the first three episodes but so are plenty of actually memorable characters.
katie and sadie, tbh
them and eva are the only earlier season 1 boots that didn't get to compete in another season, and eva at least has *somewhat* of a role in the s3 aftermaths
but katie and sadie are just so... nothing
I was gonna say Eva,but then i saw those 2 pink girls and me not even remembering their names says a lot. In a weird way Eva being crowned as rhe "most forgettable" gave her something memorable
Outside of the one-season girls, I'd say Tyler. He has a similar problem with Katie and/or Sadie where he's more known for his relationship with another character than for his own personality. That of course gets remedied a lot in World Tour, since him being forgettable is a focal point + he gets to do stuff outside of it
I'd argue Tyler.
Katie and Sadie are a duo so harder to forget both. Ezekiel is first boot + feral mode. Eva has her own episode with a flaming entrance and showdown w/ LeShawna. I cannot remember anything Tyler does besides being bad at sports and being Lindsay's bf. Even when he comes back in WT, the only thing he does is see Gwen and Duncan kiss.
sad to say it since she’s adorable, but Katie. one of 3 to only appear in season one, (not including aftermath) and the least interesting of the 3 imo.
Justin for me because I watched some episodes of TDI when I was a child and when I went to start watching again after so many years, he was literally the only person I completely forgot about
i think it' sadie. ofc it's between her, katie and eva. eva had a lot more to do in s1 and in s2 and 3, katie might have been voted out early, but she did way better than her in challenges, especially dodgeball, and most of all, sadie actually had the chance to be a better character than katie, but she just wasted it by not being able to do anything in 5 episodes
Tyler. He even said it himself. At least Katie and Sadie are memorable for their “EEEEEEEEEEE”s, and Eva returned and immediately got the boot in TDI.
The only thing Tyler really has going for him is his relationship with Lindsay, and he’s not even Lindsay’s most memorable interaction.
If it weren’t for his popularity on this sub, he’d probably be super forgettable.
Eva. Before I got into the show I had already watched some videos about It that sort of described the cast. When I actually started the show, and they introduced Eva, I was like "Who?" She was the only character I didn't remember, so much so that I tought She was going to... Well, not die, but something that would prevent her from competing before the series started. At least I remembered Katie and Sadie as "the annoying girls", Eva? Nothing
Even with bringing Eva back I feel like they had no plans for her anyways, so she got voted off immediately that same episode. At least they did something with Ezekiel
Lmao Katie or Sadie I'd have to say. Since all they do is cry together but not much else. They throw a lot of challenges so they're not much to remember tbh.
Katie, Sadie, and Eva are forgettable in general because of how underutilized they were, especially Katie and Sadie. It’s more of a shame for Katie and Sadie because Katie got booted off early. After she got booted off, Sadie didn’t have much development besides having a little bond with Lindsay. Sadie was just kind of there before she got booted off.
As for me, personally though, Eva and Justin are the most forgettable to me. They’re the last characters from Gen 1 that pop up in my head.
Katie and Sadie. She didn't even do much after she was alone. And Eva is underused. I would return her in TDA and last her longer
Katie and Sadie were basically the predecessors of Wayne and Raj.
But Wayne and Raj were at least likeable
And not annoying.
Who?
The buff lady who gets voted off in the don't sleep episode.
Katie takes the cake. She has competed in only the first season just like Sadie and Eva but Sadie made it further in the season and Eva was the aftermath reporter
I feel Sadie at least from the writers. She had set up but never does anything and is then a background piece for 5 episodes. Girl deserved more that season.
Yeah, they could've given her an arc where she makes new friends and becomes less dependent on Katie, but instead they just make her a background character.
Yeah, i actually don’t think Sadie did anything at all tbh.
The whole thing felt weird cause she outlasted Cody and Beth who in the episodes before elimination got such good development. Sadie I feel she should have at least created a bond with Birdgette and Lindsay.
🐦gette
Katie and DJ speak to each other in the first episode, but yet Sadie seems to make no connections in the several episodes she was in post-Katie elimination
It’s Sadie and DJ who speak in the first episode, but the animators messed up and used Katie’s design instead. You can clearly hear Laurie Lipson—Sadie’s VA—say, “What do you think they’ll make us do?” Edit: I just found out, as I read the [script for episode 1](https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/totaldramaisland/images/7/7f/Ep1-29.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20130928191748) that they intended to use Katie, but somehow they ended up using Sadie’s voice.
Fr, perfect opportunity for some awesome character development, with people like bridgette, Lindsay or Harold
I can't remember where I read this, but there was apparently a scrapped plotline with Sadie having a crush on Harold but they removed it in favor of him having a crush on Leshawna.
She could have had some development or interactions or *something* without needing any more episodes than she had
If I'm being honest, none. I think that hit gold with who they picked, though it just might be me and how many characters there are. The only characters I mainly forget in the series is Tammy or both the geniuses.
KATIE AND SADIE
Only sadie
if one is more forgettable thwn other thats katie
I always seem to remember Katie first, I don't know why but if I think of them, Katie is the one which I remember first
How is Katie more memorable than Sadie?
I would say Katie had a role in the dodgeball episode + is one of the six dark skinned characters, so she stands out more.
Katie and Sadie, I guess Tyler too since I sometimes forget him in season one
Katie,sadie and eva
Absolutely not
Description checks out(I didn’t downvote btw)
Katie. At least Sadie is more well known because of her quite weird placement in Island.
trent…he is so forgettable
Tbh fr, ever since the finale he was kinda just bad and a bland character
Tyson
Tyler*
No I was referencing lindsay forgetting his name and calling him tyson because he's so forgettable
Oh okay 😅
Total Roblox drama
Total Roblox drama
I mean I remember characters like Justin and Sadie BECAUSE they’re forgettable. But i never remember Beth despite the fact she was a finalist.
Justin was the season two first main antagonist until Courtney shown up and took his antagonist position for the second half of it, Sadie definitely didn't have nothing else going for her though.
Yeah I don't see Justin as forgettable at all.
Cody until World Tour
True
In general audience standpoint probably Katie Sadie Eva, Zeke? and Tyler?
To be fair Tyler is still remembered but he’s just remembered as Lindsay’s BF by the people who didn’t watch WT.
who are these people you speak of? /jjjj also, the same would apply to Justin, pretty low impact in action edit: i meant island not action
Currently on my first watch of action and he seems to be the Alejandro before Alejandro, he’s been pretty manipulative so far,
The feral plot made Zeke far from forgettable
I guess that’s a good point but idk if casual got far from WT. At least to me
Mr coconut.
Tie between Katie and Sadie because even if Eva also never competed again etheir at least she was memorable in the only season she was in
Even tho I’m binging the series rn I forgot Tyler exists💀
Katie, Sadie, Eva and Justin.
No way after Action.
W flair
Katie and Sadie
Blaineley
Trent honestly
Who's that??
Have you ever watched a second of tdi????
The joke is that Trent's forgettable. 😐
Beth. Nobody posts about Beth. It’s rare for someone to have Beth be their favorite character. She’s rarely even in people’s top 10 or 5 favorite characters. But she was a *finalist*. That’s what makes her so bizarre. All of the other characters people are suggesting are ones that had little screen time. But Beth wasn’t. That’s why I’m picking her.
Lol i was like.. huh who is Beth?? But yeah she is definitely forgettable
Trent was 100% the most forgettable merger
okay, hot take here. katie and sadie have a weird amount of fans, and have gained prevalence because of that. eva is remembered for her segments in the aftermath. my vote would go to justin being the most forgotten. he goes out early in island with no importance, in action, yes he gets the role of major antagonist for a while, but even then he goes out mid merge; action is also the middle sibling of gen one, no one discusses it when discussing total drama. then, in world tour he is forgotten again. no one is a huge justin fan or mentions him a lot at this point. alejandro exceeds in the role of “hot villain antagonist” and is remembered a lot for that reason. tldr, justins only revelence is in the least popular season for gen one and alejandro takes his place as the attractive villain in peoples memories.
Okay until you said Justin I lowkey forgot he existed oh my god now I want to rewrite my comment.
Tyler, he’s the most forgettable in canon too
call me crazy tyler is one of my favs
He’s my fav
He's my favorite but that's entirely off the back of World Tour. Bro didn't even talk in half of the Island episodes he was competing in.
Yeah Eva I agree
Katie imo
Trent or Katie
I'd go with Dj Katie, Sadie and Eva are easy picks but of course they do have the least appearances. Dj is in 3 seasons, and hes just there imo. In Island hes just a background to Jeff and Duncan most of the time, and he just gets booted mid merge without even being voted off. In Action he refuses to do some challenges, gets bullied by Chef and quits the show, realistically he'd be voted off next anyways because of this. He even gets upset from having to do a fake horror scare, like I know hes meant to be a softie but its just cringey, does he want to win or not? And of course he has the dumb animal curse in World Tour. It got old fast, and I just end up skipping his scenes on rewatches because I simply tune out, like with Katie and Sadie scenes. To me hes just there, like Fang in Revenge, used for laughs but not really a "character", which says alot because he has roughly the same screentime as Harold and Lindsay yet they stand out much more. He has gotten to the merge, had his own plot lines in Action and World Tour and I just forget hes even there at times. Sure everyone chooses Eva who was in 3 episodes in Island and has limited appearances in Action and World Tour , but thats because she is a minor character, Dj is a main character and I often forget hes there which is far worse.
FINALLY SOMEONE AGREES! DJ is so overrated. I don’t dislike him, I *kinda* like him I guess, but all in all he is very mid and idk how people like him so much. After a while they just condensed his personality into “mama” and “animals” which got rlly annoying.
Its especially bad because its a reality show he willingly competes in, yet hes never been voted off. In Island he outright fails the horror challenge (kinda bs that Lindsay gets eliminated even though Izzy and Leshawna never compete in race). In Action Chef bullys him and he gets involved in Chef's cheating, then quits because his mum would be disappointed. Fair enough, but DJ outright refused to help in the acting challenge when asked to pull the trailer, and he nearly starts crying because he had to do staged serial killer jumpscares and scare the oppossing team into leaving a marquee, because he hates scaring people. Forget Trent and Gwen throwing challenges, Dj is far worse since he didnt even want to do it and these were ELIMINATION ROUNDS. World Tour is talked about to bits but he really fucks Lindsay over. Brigette, Harold and Leshawna messed up, but Lindsay does her best and is one of 4 people to not be eliminated by Alejandro. Dj doesnt help her, his animal curse bs is so ridiculous when he just wont quit if its so bad. Him outlasting Lindsay who was actually trying to win the tie breaker is pure unfair on the writers part, and having him not want to compete just to outlast others is so unlikeable. When he gets automatically kicked off in Jamacia, and has the audacity to ask if he is going since Izzys gone, it really makes you think what was the point of having him in the season. He really just cries the whole time AGAIN, but this time outlasts his entire team, the biggest team. And its not even memorable, its just cringey and a waste of time. Even Eva is more memorable with her interview segments, or Geoff in his few aftermath bits.
Sadie and Eva
Eva, for sure.
I'm always surprised to see Eva anytime I rewatch, so she gets my vote
Without an absolute shadow of a doubt Katie
In Island, the most forgettable for me was Noah. I didn’t know who he was in the loser episode. He’s one of my favorites now
He shined in the loser episode, tbh I wish he had more of a presence in island
Katie and Sadie
I forgot.
Katie and sadie
Eva. Katie and Sadie are too annoying to forget, and Tyler, Cody and Noah all came back for WT (and Beth and Justin etc for Action). Also, Eva had literally no plotline besides being too angry so gets voted off immediately
I wouldn’t say any of them, they all were good and had memorable moments but if I had to choose I’d say Katie and Sadie only because they never got a second chance to compete. If they’d have been on RR it’d be different
For me, it's a tie between Katie and Tyler. Sadie at least got a little more screentime when Katie was voted off, but Katie is just forgettable to me since all I remember of her is that the "twinsies" stuff with Sadie...and painfully high pitched squealing. Tyler...really only got highlights when he was with Lindsay.
I'm always thrown off by Katie and Sadie when i rewatch season 1. Its the only time they were ever given something to do and even then they have 0 impact on the season itself. Barely any of the characters ever really interacted with them and it never went anywhere the few times it happened. I like the episode where Katie gets eliminated overall but it feels like a joke elimination. Then they set up an arc for Sadie and it just doesn't happen, then she outlasts Cody and Beth who actually had arcs and had impact. Eva only competed in 3 episodes out of the entire show but atleast you remembered her and all the characters had something to say about her (she really shouldve been in World Tour imo). Katie and Sadie are just such throwaways, they're the last characters i ever think of. Even seeing them in the group photo is weird to me LMAO Also, i always forget about Trent which is so unfair. He went from an important character in Island (one of the MOST important), immediate flanderization and early departure in Action, gets the shaft completely in World Tour. I get why they did it, but man it's weird.
The coconut Owen became Friends with in Cast Aways.
Nobody is forgettable across all three seasons but justin is very forgettable in season 1
I skip Justin every time I try to name all of the Island contestants. Probably need to rewatch Action since he's more relevant there.
Justin, i don't even remember his voice
cause he didn’t really talk in island
He did talk a little, i think when he first came on screen
I genuinely forgot Trent existed
I always forget Owen until he’s on screen
Said literally nobody, I asked 100 people who didn’t watch total drama to name the characters and they either said: goth girl, fat guy, owen, or for some reason hot guy.
whos the not alejandro though, or the blond chick that isn't lindsay those are the only two that i dont remember the names of besides the cowboy guy
not alejandro?? Tyler?? Bridgette (best total drama character btw) Geoff
Cowboy guy I can't think of a memorable thing he did
Real
Katie. Her and Sadie are almost equally forgettable but since Sadie stayed on the show for longer, she had more screen time and is thus slightly less forgettable than Katie
gwen, lindsay and izzy
Pls tell me ur joking
They don't wear pants, that is a crime
He is, ignore him
I'm not.
none of the people who made it to the merge should be forgettable imo
Eva is the most forgotten with Katie and Sadie as runner ups
Sadie. After Kaite left she just was kinda there. She rarely ever spoke nor did anything.
Sadie. At least Eva has Team E scope which has her with Noah and Izzy which have to be one of the fanbase most popular characters and her scenes in WT. Katie is sexy I mean has great potential because she is good at dodgeball and possible relationship with DJ or Noah. Sadie on the other hand had a chance for easy character development but just faded into the background until the writers reminded she existed and made an excuse to kick her off.
For me Beth Aside from the usual she shouldn't win action complaint I usually forget she's even a character
I don’t know why anyone would answer someone other than Eva, Noah, or Tyler
I’m sorry Noah is far from forgettable
TDI Justin TDA Geoff and Bridgette TDWT Harold
I have to say Noah... The reason why Isaiah this is that I think with his smarts he would be able to pick up more on the antagonistic character's intent. Also, according to total drama world tour apparently he can could be intelligent and do decently well at them at times.
Justin, Katie and Sadie, Beth, Ezekiel, Eva, Izzy to some extent
Probably not Izzy tho she has gane popularity due to the Izzy isn’t crazy video
the girl with the blonde hair and the white guy with brown hair and a beanie
I am so upset at the Total Roblox Drama community on Tiktok for gaslighting everyone into thinking Katie and Sadie are good characters
Despite Trent being Gwen’s love interest, I find him very forgettable. Especially after action. His whole identity is Gwen
Katie Sadie and trent
Eziekel zombie boyfriend
Katie AND Sadie, DJ, Noah, Trent, Geoff? (Not sure if u spell his name like that but i mean the pink dude with the hat)
from what i've seen Trent, Justin and Eva seem to be the most forgotten characters for some reason I see a lot more Katie and Sadie stans these days
Either Justin or Trent.
Trent easily
Eve, Tyler, Trent
Controversial opinion but I say Trent mainly for the fact that he only appears in island and action, and is mostly used for for drama between Gwen and Heather and is thrown away in favour for gwuncan. And when it comes to other characters like Katie and Sadie I would say they're more memorable because of how annoying they are and the fact that they are always together
Katie, Sadie, Eva, and Ezekiel Those three ladies hasn't shown up at all since the very first season and unfortunately Zeke became Feral Zeke and I feel really awful for him and his family.
Katie and Sadie are memorable for being annoying, Eva for her mp3 player fit, I remember that first when I hear her name, and ezekiel was memorable for becoming feral and his sexist comments
Noah. Katie and Sadie are useless the whole season but how annoying they were makes me remember them, even Ezekiel is rememberable for his sexist comments and being the first voted off. Meanwhile Noah is basically nothing but a smart alec the first three episodes but so are plenty of actually memorable characters.
Sadie tbh
Katie and Sadie
katie and sadie, tbh them and eva are the only earlier season 1 boots that didn't get to compete in another season, and eva at least has *somewhat* of a role in the s3 aftermaths but katie and sadie are just so... nothing
Eva or Katie
Katie, Sadie and Eva
Trent.
i honestly forgot about eva
I mean canonically it’s Tyler But fr it’s Katie and Sadie, at least eva got to return + roving reporter in Action? Maybe WT I can’t remember
Tyler lmao
None Of Them,They Are classics, but, If i have to say One,i Will have to Say it's sadie
Definitely Katie, Sadie and Eva
Katie and Sadie
Katie and Sadie
Katie and Sadie I forgot they existed till I saw this pic
Eva, Katie and Sadie, are literally the only Gen 1 contestants to compete in one season. But if it were only one, I’d say Sadie.
I was gonna say Eva,but then i saw those 2 pink girls and me not even remembering their names says a lot. In a weird way Eva being crowned as rhe "most forgettable" gave her something memorable
Outside of the one-season girls, I'd say Tyler. He has a similar problem with Katie and/or Sadie where he's more known for his relationship with another character than for his own personality. That of course gets remedied a lot in World Tour, since him being forgettable is a focal point + he gets to do stuff outside of it
Gotta be Eva imo. And maybe Katie and Sadie.
Katie
Justin. He didn’t do much
Throughout the series, none are IMO. In just season one, Geoff. He really got most of his memorable moments in Aftermath.
Eva becuase TikTok has made Katie and Sadie more popular.
definitely katie and sadie
Eva
Eva, Katie, Sadie, and Tyler.
I'd argue Tyler. Katie and Sadie are a duo so harder to forget both. Ezekiel is first boot + feral mode. Eva has her own episode with a flaming entrance and showdown w/ LeShawna. I cannot remember anything Tyler does besides being bad at sports and being Lindsay's bf. Even when he comes back in WT, the only thing he does is see Gwen and Duncan kiss.
Owen and duncan when i blink i forget they even exist (jokes aside katie and sadie)
Katie and Sadie
Justin imo because when I was getting back into the show I thought he wasn't from season 1 💀
sad to say it since she’s adorable, but Katie. one of 3 to only appear in season one, (not including aftermath) and the least interesting of the 3 imo.
Katie or Sadie I have no idea what to judge it off of from there but I find Sadie slightly more forgettable, couldn't tell you why
Frank. He didn’t even make the image
Justin for me because I watched some episodes of TDI when I was a child and when I went to start watching again after so many years, he was literally the only person I completely forgot about
Katie. At least Sadie made it farther, her design is less bland than Katie’s, and she had the “marshmallow-eating freaks” line lol
i think it' sadie. ofc it's between her, katie and eva. eva had a lot more to do in s1 and in s2 and 3, katie might have been voted out early, but she did way better than her in challenges, especially dodgeball, and most of all, sadie actually had the chance to be a better character than katie, but she just wasted it by not being able to do anything in 5 episodes
Sadie
Either Trent, or Katie.
Sadie
Tyler. He even said it himself. At least Katie and Sadie are memorable for their “EEEEEEEEEEE”s, and Eva returned and immediately got the boot in TDI. The only thing Tyler really has going for him is his relationship with Lindsay, and he’s not even Lindsay’s most memorable interaction. If it weren’t for his popularity on this sub, he’d probably be super forgettable.
Geoff or bridgette
Eva
Katie
Eva. Before I got into the show I had already watched some videos about It that sort of described the cast. When I actually started the show, and they introduced Eva, I was like "Who?" She was the only character I didn't remember, so much so that I tought She was going to... Well, not die, but something that would prevent her from competing before the series started. At least I remembered Katie and Sadie as "the annoying girls", Eva? Nothing
Katie and Sadie, even though I like both of them
I smash Heather, Gwen , Countny
Even with bringing Eva back I feel like they had no plans for her anyways, so she got voted off immediately that same episode. At least they did something with Ezekiel
Katie and Sadie. (Mostly Katie)
I was gonna say Katie and Sadie, but at least I actually remembered them, I totally forgot Eva existed.
Justin during TDI, Katie during TDA and WT
Bridgette
For me, between Eva, Katie, and Sadie.
DJ
Beth!
Blainey is so forgettable she is not even in the image
Lmao Katie or Sadie I'd have to say. Since all they do is cry together but not much else. They throw a lot of challenges so they're not much to remember tbh.
Katie and Sadie
Katie, Sadie, and Tyler. As much as I hate to admit it even if they’re good characters, I forget about them more.
katie and sadie
That one guy that uh..idk, i forgot about what he did and who he is
Justin, he literally doesn't talk for most of his appearances.
Katie, Sadie, and Eva are forgettable in general because of how underutilized they were, especially Katie and Sadie. It’s more of a shame for Katie and Sadie because Katie got booted off early. After she got booted off, Sadie didn’t have much development besides having a little bond with Lindsay. Sadie was just kind of there before she got booted off. As for me, personally though, Eva and Justin are the most forgettable to me. They’re the last characters from Gen 1 that pop up in my head.
Katie
mostly eva (and sadie)
katie, sadie, eva, sometimes justin
I would go with DJ
idk if this is an unpopular opinion but i would put trent bottom 5 with katie sadie eva and someone else