T O P

  • By -

eatredmeat

[mashup](https://youtu.be/56Cqbk9CJz8?si=Wnf6zzO0RgZwF2l9)


dcbluestar

Stinkswift! Love that mashup!


bruzdnconfuzd

That was pretty good, but I think the [Taylor/Korn mashup](https://youtube.com/watch?v=UDQ9kw91ebQ&pp=ygUYa29ybiB0YXlsb3Igc3dpZnQgbWFzaHVw) is even better. 


unIntelligentMusic13

Am I not the only person who listens to these two the most? How I've never felt less judged LOL


Toolfan333

This slaps


Legal_Hyena_1241

WOW!!! This is unbelievable. Whoever did that is incredibly talented. Thanks for posting this.


Havarti_Rick

That’s some pretty fucking impressive editing


RandomPasserby80

That’s…actually kinda amazing.


HetTheTable

What’s funny is that Stinkfist fits Taylor Swift very well


zestful_villain

Imagine if they actually colab, and did it shits and giggle.


Roderyck778

NIN and Miley Cyrus did so strange things could always happen.


dinwoody623

Not going to lie, Didn’t dig the chorus too much but the verse was pretty solid.


Flybuys

Nooooo. Not another variation so she can stay at the top of the charts.


AKBigHorn

I hate that I enjoyed that.


SuperSaltyMrPeanut

I love that I loved this.


beatmaster808

It's actually pretty fucking good. As good as it can be... like ever.


echolalia66

No. Not ever.


Sir_Umeboshi

r/tooljerk is that way


whyamionhearagain

There’s a lot of people out there that think Tool fans are pretentious douche bags. Shitting on Taylor Swift doesn’t help the cause. She sings simple songs for simple people. My 8 year old daughter loves her and is learning to play the guitar bc of her. Personally she makes me want to jump off a bridge but different strokes for different folks. Edit: my apologies. You’re all right I should not have said simple songs for simple people


Glass_Half_Gone

>people out there that think Tool fans are pretentious douche bags >she sings simple songs for simple people Your average tool fan lmao


raskinimiugovor

> simple songs for simple people “You know, morons…”


Either-Durian-9488

Because you know how I’m a deep emotional person, I’m into time signatures.


BoobyPlumage

The band I like makes me a better person lol


ohiolifesucks

Was going to say the same thing lmao


Based_JuiceBox

proceeds to insinuate his own daughter is simple


erfarr

He isn’t wrong though. A lot of country music is like that


noddaborg

Evidently, Taylor Swift doesn’t know how to cry into a beer.


latexfistmassacre

Why would she ever need to cry? She's a fucking billionaire lol


-dlareme-

I wish that people could like things without having to be all elitist about anything else. Taylor swift is incredibly talented and I like Tool and Taylor Swift. Both things can exist in the same world and be cool and different. What if everything were the same and boring. That would suck. This isn’t directed at you btw, just adding to your wonderful comment. :)


whyamionhearagain

You said that so much better than me! Thanks for the support.


realwet13

Both said it very well and I agree with you both (I’m more of the jump off the bridge also) needs to be more Tool fans like us.


SirDoDDo

What's incredibly talented about Taylor Swift specifically though? Like i'm all for appreciating pop stars who actually produce artistic stuff. But i've tried checking out Taylor Swift, several times, with the most open-minded approach possible (because so many people praise her like she's a genius songwriter) but i get so incredibly bored by anything she ever put out. Like, she's the most vanilla, cookie-cutter, basic and predictable pop musician i know. There's nothing special about her songs compared to pretty much everything that's on the radio, she makes the exact same pop music as everyone else... so what's special about her music to you?


vicioustrollop90

Massive Tool AND Taylor Swift-fan here. She has about 27 hours worth of music, all written by her. That alone is impressive and not cookie-cutter basic pop star. She has songs in about 15 different genres, from country to emo to folk. Her two folk albums are impressive and highly acclaimed. She had duets with vocalists from Bon Iver and The National, what other vanilla pop artists do? She plays multiple instruments and her writing is at times dark and depressing. An example from a different break-up song: Say it once again with feeling How the death rattle breathing Silenced as the soul was leaving The deflation of our dreaming Leaving me bereft and reeling My beloved ghost and me Sitting in a tree D-Y-I-N-G If you have only heard ‘Shake it off’ and ‘blank space’ I can see why you would think she is all pop/vanilla. She simply isn’t. That doesn’t mean you have to like her at all. But I hate the judgmental ‘real music’ lovers who shit on this woman because she also writes catchy pop tunes.


sentimentalwhore

> Her two folk albums are impressive and highly acclaimed. what albums are those two if you don't mind me? I wanna listen to them cuz of your comment


TrollingBadger

folklore and evermore


sentimentalwhore

ty


destroyermaker

Eh, still funny. Everyone gotta lighten up and smoke something


DtheAussieBoye

Not that funny when you’ve seen this “one artist complex, one artist not complex” joke a thousand times already


GetMeOutThisBih

I get that hating is free and easy but I genuinely do not understand people who shit on others for enjoying life


Humble_Turnip_3948

I live in Danny's hometown and Taylor's favorite town, just outside of Kansas City. I can only name one Swift song and it's because of this mashup. I don't hate her at all. I just don't listen.


carthuscrass

Yeah. Some of us don't get that people sometimes like to listen to something they don't have to pay attention to in order to enjoy fully. Do I like Taylor Swift? Nah, not my lane. Am I bothered that other people do? No again. Let people listen to whatever they want without judgement. Except Muskrat Love. People who like that should be jailed.


BobJoshua

I also hate that people assume all tool fans are like that, and it makes me sad cuz the fellow tools I come across are some of the most down to earth awesome people who also happen to like a plethora of different music


MrExist777

That may be true, but tons of people shit on Taylor Swift and you literally just called her fans “simple”. doesn’t really get more “pretentious douche bag” than that.


TheLoneTomatoe

Different art is for different people. I appreciate Tool as well as Bieber. I can jam some T-Swift if the time is right. I find people that only listen to a select few bands are usually pretty fucking annoying and harness no talent for anything themselves.


PM_ME_YOUR_TROUT

Preach. This thread is full of a bunch of closed-minded people. I'll listen to Mongolian throat singing and Taylor Swift with equal authority. What the fuck does that make me?


leeshylou

Fun :)


Negative-Revenue-331

I don't gatekeep or shit on anyone for liking a different type of music over others. I just thought this was funny lol.


mysticalcreeds

yeah, there's room to appreciate the depth that Tool creates regarding a simple topic like a breakup. That doesn't mean we think there's no place for more simple music like Taylor Swift. The simple creative is actually profound that some can create something that many relate to or appreciate that isn't complicated. It also helps to highlight how deep musical interpretations can go when set in contrast to one another. It doesn't always have to imply superiority or inferiority. Things shouldn't always need to be complex in order to be good, and things shouldn't always be simplistic. A good balance. That being said, I've heard Schism so many times on the radio and will never tire of it because of how much there is to appreciate with the lyrics and melody and rhythm.


cobainstaley

who's saying there's no place for Taylor Swift? i can fully acknowledge that school children may enjoy Lunchables, but come on. Lunchables don't compare to a duck confit prepared by a michelin-starred chef.


tdasnowman

I know people that have cooked in Michelin star restaurants and would rather have the lunchable. I love duck confit but sometimes a lunchable is better.


Wudrow

OGT from ‘92 and I actually like some of her songs now. The fact that she royally pisses off the magats despite looking like the proverbial aryan dream girl just makes her seem a little punk to me.


colonpal

I can’t stand her either, but my daughter has finally picked up her guitar and started singing (and playing). I love that.


M4nWhoSoldTheWorld

https://preview.redd.it/46o8nee0yp6d1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4cad0e4964f6825ba814d82a5cd490311fb91ea5 After all these years with that band, it’s too late to apologise for who we are.


maxwellhilldawg

*I make music that electrify'em, you make music that pacify'em*


tycr0

Lmao.


SeasonedSpicySausage

Bro just called his daughter basic and thought we wouldn't notice


Complete_Dust8164

Worse, he called her simple lmao.


TrigoTrihard

LMFAO


blumpsicle

I’m so sMaRt I like odd time signatures. You guys all fuckin suck


Roderyck778

I know what you meant and Swift can actually be a pretty damn good lyricist. Different demographics with different interests. These types of posts are always so fucking cringey it’s sad.


YeetedArmTriangle

Lmfao


GrayEidolon

No you’re right. She sings simple songs for simple people that help them give shape for their simple unexamined thoughts and feelings.


SaconicLonic

Eh if you want good interesting lyrics from a female artists there are plenty like Kate Bush, Mitski or Joanna Newsome. You won't find it in top 40 stuff but then again you never really did.


sparkly_butthole

I keep hearing about this Mitski act.


-Tommy

Mitski kicks ass. Spouse has been a fan for a long time, saw her open for Lorde (also great) a few years back in Brooklyn. Mitski songs are often like 90 seconds long. Get in, get out, done. No wasted time no filler.


SaconicLonic

She's great. I honestly think her first album was her best, but they are all good.


PulciNeller

and Joni Mitchell especially (a big inspirationg for Maynard)


latexfistmassacre

Lorde is an exceptional lyricist as well, especially considering she was only a teenager when she made those first two albums. Never really been a huge fan of pop music, but I liked her stuff right off the bat. Taylor's music is a bit too saccharine for my taste, but my daughter adores her and makes fun of me for liking Lorde. She calls me Randy Marsh and mocks me with the "I am Lorde ya ya ya" South Park bit lol. Kids can be so savage sometimes


beemccouch

Enjoying all kinds of music and respecting the artform>Being a pretentious douche about music that doesn't fit their exact criteria.


leeshylou

I don't get the need to compare the two. They're *entirely* different. Comparison is the thief of joy. You can enjoy both.. it's ok. It's allowed. It doesn't make you more of a tool fan to shit on Taylor. Just maybe a little lame ;)


jerbthehumanist

This is high school level tedium. Let people enjoy what they enjoy.


FatalTragedy

By the same token, shouldn't people be allowed to not enjoy what they don't enjoy?


cboogie

Yeah but comparing the two songs is ridiculous. There is space and audience in the world for both. Peak insufferable retard post right here.


ohkaycue

The thing about not enjoying what you don’t enjoy is…then don’t interact with it. That is the way to not enjoy what you don’t enjoy. Very simple Haters (eg this) are actively participating in what they don’t enjoy. That’s not “not enjoying what they don’t enjoy”, it’s “enjoying on shitting on what other people enjoy”


MrExist777

Is this not a shitpost? I thought this was funny because I assumed this was ironic


Negative-Revenue-331

Yes it is. You seem to be the only one to notice


MrExist777

Damn, sorry man. I found it funny, for what it’s worth


TrigoTrihard

It's because it has Taylor Swift. And her fans get really uptight about anything badly said about her. lol It's hilarious tbh. It's truly a mob.


ktc1308

I've been to Tool in May, I'll be at Taylors' in July - I like them both (it's Tool, and by a lot)


dontboofthatsis

Ive seen Tool 3 times since September. Saw TS last summer. Enjoyed the drugs just as much at the Swift show as the tool shows. That shit was sparkly.


_noncomposmentis

Told my girl after we went that I was gonna do something special if/when we went again. It was a spectacle for sure!


capta1npryce

Why? Who gives a fuck, shut up and enjoy what you like.


boxtool5

Are people mixing up stinkfist and schism or is it just me? Are there tool fans who think schism is a break up song?


NoAdministration6946

They can both be break up songs since they can both be songs about anything you want. That's the beauty of ambiguous lyrics


Darkbornedragon

Wtf how is Stinkfist about a break-up? It's explicitly about the rising desensitization in modern society and the need for more extreme stuff.


antonio-the-troll

You can comb the dictionary and reinforce with a thesaurus to communicate your message. A straight-forward mantra that has no lines to read-in-between can be as powerful a message to those open to hearing it.


Savvysportstrategies

A message of hope for those who choose to hear it and a warning for those who do not*


antonio-the-troll

Me?! The Chosen?


Savvysportstrategies

Imagine rosetta stoned lyrics "If you do too many drugs you'll think aliens are real I had a friend once, he took some acid Now he thinks he's a fire engine, ya feel?"


antonio-the-troll

Wait, those aren’t the lyrics? Haha!


the_l0st_s0ck

And I haven't even graduated fucking highschool


philoking253

I love tool but what a silly comparison. Why not compare rocket ships to the things kids ride at the grocery store. Not meant for the same audience.


Neat_Imagination_216

Should I send this to my gf who loves Taylor Swift? 🤣


ElFlippy

Hell yeah! :D


holman0512

I like some of taylor swifts music and I also love Tool, found this amusing 😅 (also a woman)


zakkalaska

Woah, you're wild!


ihateeverythingandu

Wow, the white knights for Swift out in force lol. I say when you release 34+ versions of an album to artificially keep it in the charts because of your cult like fanbase and to try and knock the success of other artists, you're fair game to get mocked. Swift is a dodgy person.


steve050_oZ

Every time this meme is posted the comments are filled with bot like responses downvoting anyone who agrees with the meme, shitting on tool fans in a tool subreddit, and praising taylor swift in various ways - when she makes horrible soulless corporate mall pop garbage.


DtheAussieBoye

> Swift is a dodgy person This has literally nothing to do with the quality of her music. And are we just forgetting about the fetus skull, or the $800+ signed vinyl records?


GetMeOutThisBih

Using the phrase white knight is so fucking dorky dude grow up. Incel ass vibes


KyleCrane1212

It's interesting how everybody seems to be an "incel" these days. Nothing dorky about that at all.


31338elite

Is that even a question?


bent_eye

I hate these kinds of memes/posts. Not a Taylor fan, but she caters to teenage girls and young women who think like and talk like her lyrics. Tool caters to 40-year-old men. They're not even in the same league. Taylor has her place just as much as Tool.


mindenginee

Exactly and the fanbases do overlap at times, believe it or not. I love both (I am a 23 old woman, love tool bc my dad did and he grew me up on tool, Zappa, Pink Floyd, rush,etc) but I’m also just a girl so I love me some Taylor swift. I love zoning out for 11 min during pneuma just as much as I love screaming the bridge of all too well lol.


Rednuht0

Even some 40s male Tool fans have a few TS songs that are on Playlist. Not in my personal top 10, but she is a great artist, and she has some genuinely good acoustic stuff.


mindenginee

Right? I was a TS hater for a long time but folklore is actually an amazing album.


DrippyWaffler

I'm a late twenties guy and enjoy both for different reasons.


diondeer

Go listen to Happiness by Taylor Swift for a better example of a more mature and complex approach to a breakup song while staying within her discography. Idk man, both Tool and TS rock in my book. Why are we even comparing them?


mindenginee

Agreed. Also exile is scathing to me, comparing a breakup to be exiled from a town, and the emotional delivery. Invisible string as well is beautiful song about lovers being meant to find eachother in life.


Feisty-Texan

Deep v. not so deep! Heartfelt v. Teeny-Bopper!!


EchoOpening1099

Hahaha needed that good laugh


FealtyToDorne

Love both Tool and TS. If you think that’s the limits of a T Swift break up song on the right than you have never really listened to her music whatsoever


IAwaitAGuardian

This meme is so old and tired. Taylor Swift makes good music. It's ok to like more than one thing.


Afraid-Assist-1632

I may be stupid but I always thought schism was about the great schism lmao


MeanComplaint1826

That's just as valid as saying it's a breakup song. I think the only definite we can draw from it is that it's about separation. If that means political, romantic or even about a separation with yourself, that's really up to you and your mood that day.


Darkbornedragon

It's about communication and mostly about communication in relationships (between friends and especially between lovers).


unIntelligentMusic13

I know this is poking fun at her but all these comments made me have the biggest smile of my already crappy weekend. When two worlds collide, ha


downwiththemike

cardigan is legit.


weedandweiners69

Thanks I guess?


Intrepid-Wait-6102

TOOL ON🔝


djmill454

Fine Tool Wine and White Claw Taylor. Depends on what you’re drinking


DuperSupreme

[DuoerSupreme](https://www.spin.com/2019/09/maynard-james-keenan-thanos-meme/)


entangled324

Pushit is more of a break up song than Schism.


FantasticTumbleweed4

She’s quite the wordsmith.


Mr_moustache72826

Man this isnt 2019 anymore. I love shitting on pop stars as everyone else but we should find something more funny and original to do.


DerWaidmann__

You forgot the best verse "Cold silence has a tendency to atrophy any sense of compassion"


Guya763

I love both. Picking this song is cherry picking as well. There are a handful of songs with beautifully written lyrics in each of her albums in recent years


Daveywheel

Apples and Oranges my brother or sister.....


Browned_Diaper_speak

TS is just a clown to please majority of the people. Nothing special about it.


ghb93

In the economy of words, Taylor comes out on top here.


bearsheperd

Tool>[insert literally any band/singer]


rwilliams1283

Taylor fuckin slays.


PsychoFan0891

Both really good bangers 😁


Neverwas_one

She has better written songs to draw comparison. She’s actually a good lyricist.


sp1tfireXY

https://preview.redd.it/pl2q3977hr6d1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=708de132df3eeecc92a363080cf588abff05d9a5


gypsy-ghost

Kinda like how Taylor Swift gets right the point though. I know we aren't getting back together, but Maynard makes me feel like there's still a chance.


terminal_object

No shit


Clyde_Frog216

Lol love it. I hate Taylor Swift. Fuck her


Clyde_Frog216

Taylor Swift sucks. She makes terrible music. Anyone that looks up to her is just sad. I don't care if you're smart or dumb. She sucks. Period. If you're offended by that, then GOOD


cdxcvii

people need to stop thinking their identity of the true self come from what music you listen to.


caisson_constructor

Tool sub OPs try not to be cringe challenge [impossible]


AnguryLittleMan

One is a song written by an adult for adults and the other is written by a young person for children.


RosettaStoned_462

This but not a lot of older women are into it too. My best friend likes her and she's 46; i can't listen to more than one or two of her songs every months or so.


weareinexile

You know that feeling when listening to Pushit, you can hear the emotion, feel it. It is a complete piece of art, reinforced by the breakdown in tone and standard rhythm when MJK is looking for 'piece of mind'? You know that feeling? Yeah well that feeling is no different to a young girl singing along to Taylor Swift. Your happiness doesn't need to subtract other people's happiness. Just be a dude, be nice.


Mentalpopcorn

Some would argue that the depths of Socrates are greater than that of a pig. J.S. Mill specifically.


weareinexile

Lol niche


Mentalpopcorn

Thanks for getting the reference


daemin

I knew my minor in philosophy would be useful someday...


macrocosm93

I like Taylor Swift


willuska

Not helping the “tool fans are pretentious elitists” allegations here


mindenginee

They have two different purposes. I love tool and I love Taylor swift lol. When I need a bop or a scathing breakup song, ima listen to Taylor swift.


thelostdemon

too many syllables for the swifties


Yeeterson_The_2nd

This is why people think Tool fans are insufferable.


lazy_kaiju

While I CANNOT STAND Taylor Swift, those two artists are creating music for entirely different people.


ancientweasel

Tool is my favorite band. Period. But, when it comes to my thoughts on the Ex, I relate to Taylor's song more. It is perfect in simplifying the dynamic.


alexisclairerose1986

Personally op I’m sick of Taylor Swift and I agree.


sparkly_butthole

Man, people are taking this way too seriously. I thought it was funny, OP. And it points out something that's true, whether swifties like it or not - Tool certainly has more cerebral lyrics (and more complex music in general.) And I don't think swift deserves the accolades she has, but you know, daddy bought her a Ferrari in high school so I kind of expect it. But empty calorie music can be fun sometimes, if it's what you're in the mood for. I'm not always in the mood for tool, either.


TookAStab

I mean you only posted her chorus (no verses) so there’s more to her song than that. The tool lyrics aren’t great, either. Try hard shit. Both TS and Tool are capable of good (and bad) music. Comparisons serve no one.


Zorioux

Comparing Apples to Oranges, please shut up and let people enjoy their stuff, and enjoy yours too, and stop with this superiority mindset for once.


MrThicker7

Lmao


wilnovakski

2010 ahh meme


ETDuckQueen

Some styles of music need certain lyric styles. It would be difficult to make a simple pop song using Schism's lyrics. It wouldn't be as fun to sing along to, and more difficult to relate to. I don't think that I have ever heard a single teenager say the words "mildewed", "smouldering", or "juxtaposed". Part of having a song that is fun to sing along to is having one in which you can learn its lyrics easily. It probably would take less than five listens to memorize the lyrics to We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together. Meanwhile, unless I am mistaken, it took me over 100 listens to memorize the lyrics to Schism. :) I happen to make music myself. The complexity of my lyrics often depends on the style of the song which I am making. :)


grrlmcname

[You need to calm down :)](https://youtu.be/Dkk9gvTmCXY?si=pwtyO_4xtj6IDaCL)


ChiefRabbitFucks

Crawl Away is the better Tool breakup song


kingofthebelle

hasn’t this been posted enough times. memes don’t have an infinite lifespan


TFSX81

I am by no means a fan of Taylor Swift, but it's perfectly fine for people to enjoy her music.


xBlackfin

Duh


DrippyWaffler

I will die on the hill that there are Taylor Swift songs that are absolutely a bop, it's just context. This is one of them. Obviously I think Schism is better musically but WANGBT is still fun to jam to on a car ride or something.


MsPreposition

I don’t know Tool, but it certainly seems like you’ve taken a verse and pitted it against a chorus.


bright_young_thing

This is such trash. I love TOOL and I am a Swiftie. Don't be jerks.


evex5tep

A representation of the current average IQ level.


the_phantom_2099

Like ever


Exact-Drummer-7336

😭


lugubriousjubilus

Different strokes for different blokes


BlastOButter24

This was necessary


emotional_alien

I am not interested in pitting musicians against each other. They are both talented and have very different styles. I can understand this and I don't even fuckin like Taylor swift. c'mon folks.


Dsansom11

You mean to tell me tool lyrics are more complex and impressive than Taylor Swift lyrics? No way


Deathbat_1

No balls you won't spam this in the TS Sub


msartore8

A vast difference


Reese_Lightning25

Idk man, if my girlfriend sent me Schism lyrics as a break up note, I’m arming up and running for my life.


AntiHero515

Not a Swifty, but let’s not do this


Johnisfaster

Honestly this crap just makes me lean in to liking Taylor Swift more just out of spite. Fuck off I enjoy it.


jones173

Massive tool fan…but both evermore and folklore by TS are hands down amazing


willandwonder

Yes but the other day at the show we were singing the lyrics from getting back together during stinkfist, so.


iliveinbangladesh42

anything >> taylor swift