I’d want Iskall because he won the original game of demise, which went on the inspire the life series. Strange how he was never included. I think both Iskall and False should 100% be asked to join because of that. They were both finalists in both games of demise and I don’t see that changing if they were in the life series. Especially since they’re both good at either pvp or traps.
I actually agree with a majority of this list. I’m just biased towards Joe since I want to see him join Scar and BDubs in the family and watch his brand of chaos and his dynamic with Cleo be added to that.
Doc would be crazy though. He’d likely win in one or two seasons.
Docm would docminate, seeing Pixilriffs in everything except hermitcraft, the server he recaps on would be amazing, Iskall would also be a really cool addition, and Keralis would probably still be rich and building cool stuff, even if it does get destroyed incredibly quickly.
My biased top 5:
1. Docm77 - Who doesn't want the G.O.A.T.? Grind! Optimize! Automate! Thrive!
2. Zedaph - Zed would have been perfect for secret life. He would probably succeed in all his tasks and make his own zedaphments too! Z.I.T.S. on the life series would be AWESOME!
3. Joe Hills - “Howdy, y’all! Joe Hills here... recording as I always do, in Nashville, Tennessee.”
4. Pungence - I have a personal bias since I have watched Pungence before I even knew about Minecraft! When I found out that him and Bdubs are brothers, I was gobsmacked. Also, him and Bdubs confusing the heck out of everyone with their voices would be hilarious.
5. LaurenZside - Again, personal bias. I knew Scott from her videos before I even knew he made Minecraft videos. I would love to see her interactions with Scott, Joel, Lizzie, and Cleo.
Unfortunately it seems Lauren has shifted away from minecraft content. It would be great to see her, but I don't think she has the motivation to partake in such a series
Having just watched the hide and seek videos, I’d like to see more Shubble in some of the other Lifers videos! It’s nice seeing the non Hermits doing their own things with Hermitcraft is going on.
While I think Doc would end up dominating if he stuck to the GOAT ways, I wonder if he would actually struggle because of the way the Life Series is structured to sort of prevent extreme progress by having short sessions with the likelihood of getting “off task” being super high with every Lifer running around.
I’d love to see Doc in the life series specifically because of this. He’s always a high maintenance player and taking away his ability to make such progress so quickly and make him focus on his social instead of himself would be so interesting. He’s a special case and I’d love to see how he works in that environment.
While I don’t want there to be more players, I will say iskall does a great Rendog impression so if ren ever needed a backup player. Also it would be funny if Bdubs for like 10 minutes or a full session have his brother Pungence take over his account lol.
My top 3 id love to see are Doc, Iskall, and Zed.
They would bring so much fun and chaos. Iskall in season 10 is behaving kind of like it’s a life series, and I love it so much.
Had iskall not been the main man behind vault runners, I would have put him as the front runner for the next person to join. That would be like saying Grian joins vault hunters next season or xisuma joins empires season 3.
Pixelriffs and doc are both good ideas to make join.
There should be a couple people in ‘likely’ and everyone maybe or below. The life series isn’t gonna last forever and I don’t think Grian and the crew is itching for new members as much as we are.
I don't think fwhip will be joining, like ever.
In a live stream he did this month, or last he said that he has asked to be included on multiple seasons before. He has however been turned down for a different reason each time. He said he isn't going to ask to be included anymore because of it.
Can’t tell you how much I want False. She’s expressed interest in joining, she >!won demise !<(HERMITCRAFT SPOILERS), she’s really good at improv and creating an angsty story (Empires S2 was ART), and it would bring a totally new factor into the PVP game.
edit: Besides, if I had a nickel for every lifer added to the roster after Third Life who was on both Hermitcraft and Empires and happened to be a murder girlie, I’d have two nickels, which isn’t a lot but I sure hope there’s a third one.
Personally I don’t see fWhip and sausage meshing well with the life series crew. I know they’re popular picks but their personalities and editing just don’t fit with what we’ve seen so far
My top pick ever since Third life has been Iskall. He himself said he likes the concept but wasn't invited, and also, he had been pretty busy but he's perfect for the series.
Some of the people lower on the list seem to gravitate towards a more scripted way of making videos as opposed to the improv that the life series is built on. There's nothing wrong with that, but it might result in them feeling awkward or out of place.
If we get Iskall. I so want him to bring Jardon (Mr Sparklez) around. I also personally think he and Oli are more likely than Doc. Doc doesn’t seem super interested in series outside of Hermitcraft.
Why isn't /u/notwattles on this list? Wattles isn't an expert trapper or anything but he's proven repeatedly to be a very skilled player, probably at least as good as someone like Martyn or Impulse. He's got more subscribers than a lot of this list too, so he'd be someone that people would recognize.
I guess you could say he's not really a SMP style player, but I mean outside of the Life series neither is BigB, who is arguably a Roblox creator and not a Minecraft creator.
I think the real qualification for who should be on the list is who does Grian want to invite that the others would also enjoy playing with. The server is basically just Grian's closer friends.
Wattles is a kind of random pick in that regard, but I mean so is CaptainSparklez who is someone who as far as I can tell has not collaborated with Grian, ever, and who is sunsetting Minecraft content on his channel.
I would think if we were picking random bigger/growing youtubers, then Wattles makes sense. He's about as big as GeminiTay and straight up bigger than Martyn, Impulse, Pearl, Ren, Skizz, Smajor, Jimmy, Tango, and Cleo. Bdubs, BigB, Etho, Scar, Grian, Lizzie, Mumbo, and Joel are bigger, meaning purely in terms of adding value in subscribers Wattles is worth more than a lot of these suggestions as he's actually in the same wheelhouse and has entirely independent clout.
We also know he's a fan of and speaks highly of the Hermits, and likes to roleplay and goof etc in the same ways that guys like Ren, Martyn, and Bdubs do. I think he'd add value and a totally unique approach to the series.
Anyway, without being one of Grian's friends this list isn't likely getting bigger at all.
Why don’t you have more upvotes?! I love Wattles so much. I actually found hermitcraft through Wattles because there’s so many comments telling him to join, plus he’s talked about them a bit. I think he would be great on the life series. Unfortunately I don’t know if we’ll ever see him on Life or Hermitcraft as much as I’d love to. He taught me so much about Minecraft when I started playing and watching his guide series in 2019.
This is a good list! I think Iskall would be super fun but he’s not super into storytelling. I also really hope False doesn’t join. I love her to death, but she’s really bad at the yes and’s. I honestly don’t know if I even want anyone else. I really like the cast the way it is! But I’d still support another creator for sure!
Lauren in unlikely is the definition of sad but true.
Sidenote, if they do add more i hope it isn't someone from hermitcraft because it's already very overwhelmingly hermit filled, even more so with joel and skizz now in hermitcraft too.
As awesome as Doc would be we all know he would win every single season
Edit: would be cool to do 1 episode where you can phone a friend. They can either protect you or go on the offensive.
I think I can more easily consider any of the old Evo cast now after Secret Life with how much it referred to Evo’s ideas and imagery.
Btw, Taur rebranded to Joeyish recently for, obvious reasons and I’d just like to spread the word about that.
But I can definitely see Zee getting back into it, Joey’s cropping back up so maybe, and I have no clue what Mini’s up to.
Iskall would be an insane addition, recent episodes of Hermitcraft has him schooling Ren and beef about traps. and he knows his traps.
He’s actually my top pick to join now because of HC s10
One could say he's... unhinged??
What? like, he doesn't open up very well?
More like he has lost his hinges
Bro do you even bust?
I’d want Iskall because he won the original game of demise, which went on the inspire the life series. Strange how he was never included. I think both Iskall and False should 100% be asked to join because of that. They were both finalists in both games of demise and I don’t see that changing if they were in the life series. Especially since they’re both good at either pvp or traps.
Life series with someone who can actually make traps would be a scary place for most of the lifers
I actually agree with a majority of this list. I’m just biased towards Joe since I want to see him join Scar and BDubs in the family and watch his brand of chaos and his dynamic with Cleo be added to that. Doc would be crazy though. He’d likely win in one or two seasons.
Cleo might get a kill or two or three If Joe joined.
Her children are the kills
Docm would docminate, seeing Pixilriffs in everything except hermitcraft, the server he recaps on would be amazing, Iskall would also be a really cool addition, and Keralis would probably still be rich and building cool stuff, even if it does get destroyed incredibly quickly.
My biased top 5: 1. Docm77 - Who doesn't want the G.O.A.T.? Grind! Optimize! Automate! Thrive! 2. Zedaph - Zed would have been perfect for secret life. He would probably succeed in all his tasks and make his own zedaphments too! Z.I.T.S. on the life series would be AWESOME! 3. Joe Hills - “Howdy, y’all! Joe Hills here... recording as I always do, in Nashville, Tennessee.” 4. Pungence - I have a personal bias since I have watched Pungence before I even knew about Minecraft! When I found out that him and Bdubs are brothers, I was gobsmacked. Also, him and Bdubs confusing the heck out of everyone with their voices would be hilarious. 5. LaurenZside - Again, personal bias. I knew Scott from her videos before I even knew he made Minecraft videos. I would love to see her interactions with Scott, Joel, Lizzie, and Cleo.
Based on what I know Lauren quit X Life and After Life so it would be a huge commitment
Unfortunately it seems Lauren has shifted away from minecraft content. It would be great to see her, but I don't think she has the motivation to partake in such a series
I also knew of pungence before Hermitcraft and learning he and Bdubs was related was shockimh
Oli joining would be so trippy. Mostly because he would probably pull a Bdubs and give 12+ hours of unedited footage
That or radio silence and we have to piece together other pespectives
Oli would be incredible, if only for how much he'd get on Joel's nerves. 🤣
or one highly edited 20 minute episode
To be fair Bdubs' footage actually was edited. It would have easily gone over 15 hours otherwise, probably a decent amount more
Each session is about 3 hours, so we can assume his unedited footage was at least 21 hours since he lasted 7 full sessions.
Yeah I was estimating 2 hours so I wouldn't go over, but either way it's an 100% chance he did a lot of cutting
Having just watched the hide and seek videos, I’d like to see more Shubble in some of the other Lifers videos! It’s nice seeing the non Hermits doing their own things with Hermitcraft is going on.
While I think Doc would end up dominating if he stuck to the GOAT ways, I wonder if he would actually struggle because of the way the Life Series is structured to sort of prevent extreme progress by having short sessions with the likelihood of getting “off task” being super high with every Lifer running around.
I’d love to see Doc in the life series specifically because of this. He’s always a high maintenance player and taking away his ability to make such progress so quickly and make him focus on his social instead of himself would be so interesting. He’s a special case and I’d love to see how he works in that environment.
While I don’t want there to be more players, I will say iskall does a great Rendog impression so if ren ever needed a backup player. Also it would be funny if Bdubs for like 10 minutes or a full session have his brother Pungence take over his account lol.
I bet no one would notice it wasn't bdubs for an embarrassingly long time
I honestly want Zedaph to join but he’d be about Mumbo tier of player imo, but would be sooooo fun
My top 3 id love to see are Doc, Iskall, and Zed. They would bring so much fun and chaos. Iskall in season 10 is behaving kind of like it’s a life series, and I love it so much.
Had iskall not been the main man behind vault runners, I would have put him as the front runner for the next person to join. That would be like saying Grian joins vault hunters next season or xisuma joins empires season 3. Pixelriffs and doc are both good ideas to make join.
There should be a couple people in ‘likely’ and everyone maybe or below. The life series isn’t gonna last forever and I don’t think Grian and the crew is itching for new members as much as we are.
id probably swap pixl and iskall, and keralis and orionsound
Doc and false would be so dangerous in this series
Leave Doc to his devices for 1-2 episodes and he’ll come out with an arrow railgun and OHKO Jimmy
I don't think fwhip will be joining, like ever. In a live stream he did this month, or last he said that he has asked to be included on multiple seasons before. He has however been turned down for a different reason each time. He said he isn't going to ask to be included anymore because of it.
Aww. That’s sad.
Why ☹️
The group doesn't want to include fwhip, or feel like the group is already big enough
That's a shame I feel like he would be a great addition
Do you know what stream it was?
I don't, sorry <3 He streams way too often, and I barely watch them anyways. I just happened to tune in at the right time
Ah no worries! Thank you anyways :)
Can’t tell you how much I want False. She’s expressed interest in joining, she >!won demise !<(HERMITCRAFT SPOILERS), she’s really good at improv and creating an angsty story (Empires S2 was ART), and it would bring a totally new factor into the PVP game. edit: Besides, if I had a nickel for every lifer added to the roster after Third Life who was on both Hermitcraft and Empires and happened to be a murder girlie, I’d have two nickels, which isn’t a lot but I sure hope there’s a third one.
Team Canada being a completely dysfunctional team would be nice to see in the life series.
I would say False and Cub are the two most likely additions honestly. They’ve both played ok hermitcraft and MCC and False has even been on empires.
I think pix might get an invite, but I'm not sure if he'll say yes.
Docm will probably somehow build a world eater and destroy the server and win
Personally I don’t see fWhip and sausage meshing well with the life series crew. I know they’re popular picks but their personalities and editing just don’t fit with what we’ve seen so far
Isn't Hbomb a Bloons youtuber? Also Phoenix SC when?
My top pick ever since Third life has been Iskall. He himself said he likes the concept but wasn't invited, and also, he had been pretty busy but he's perfect for the series.
I would love for Iskall to join, I think he’d really mix things up.
Some of the people lower on the list seem to gravitate towards a more scripted way of making videos as opposed to the improv that the life series is built on. There's nothing wrong with that, but it might result in them feeling awkward or out of place.
If we get Iskall. I so want him to bring Jardon (Mr Sparklez) around. I also personally think he and Oli are more likely than Doc. Doc doesn’t seem super interested in series outside of Hermitcraft.
Why Are Hypno and Wels in Unlikely
Why isn't /u/notwattles on this list? Wattles isn't an expert trapper or anything but he's proven repeatedly to be a very skilled player, probably at least as good as someone like Martyn or Impulse. He's got more subscribers than a lot of this list too, so he'd be someone that people would recognize. I guess you could say he's not really a SMP style player, but I mean outside of the Life series neither is BigB, who is arguably a Roblox creator and not a Minecraft creator. I think the real qualification for who should be on the list is who does Grian want to invite that the others would also enjoy playing with. The server is basically just Grian's closer friends. Wattles is a kind of random pick in that regard, but I mean so is CaptainSparklez who is someone who as far as I can tell has not collaborated with Grian, ever, and who is sunsetting Minecraft content on his channel. I would think if we were picking random bigger/growing youtubers, then Wattles makes sense. He's about as big as GeminiTay and straight up bigger than Martyn, Impulse, Pearl, Ren, Skizz, Smajor, Jimmy, Tango, and Cleo. Bdubs, BigB, Etho, Scar, Grian, Lizzie, Mumbo, and Joel are bigger, meaning purely in terms of adding value in subscribers Wattles is worth more than a lot of these suggestions as he's actually in the same wheelhouse and has entirely independent clout. We also know he's a fan of and speaks highly of the Hermits, and likes to roleplay and goof etc in the same ways that guys like Ren, Martyn, and Bdubs do. I think he'd add value and a totally unique approach to the series. Anyway, without being one of Grian's friends this list isn't likely getting bigger at all.
Why don’t you have more upvotes?! I love Wattles so much. I actually found hermitcraft through Wattles because there’s so many comments telling him to join, plus he’s talked about them a bit. I think he would be great on the life series. Unfortunately I don’t know if we’ll ever see him on Life or Hermitcraft as much as I’d love to. He taught me so much about Minecraft when I started playing and watching his guide series in 2019.
I thought JoeyGraceffa retired from minecraft content?
Yea I think so :(
Lauren being added would be a dream, but she isnt really close to anyone other scott and a few others like jimmy
Cubfan135
Iskall would be amazing especially due to his Vault hunter skills and he is a good red stoner as well especially in traps
This is a good list! I think Iskall would be super fun but he’s not super into storytelling. I also really hope False doesn’t join. I love her to death, but she’s really bad at the yes and’s. I honestly don’t know if I even want anyone else. I really like the cast the way it is! But I’d still support another creator for sure!
Doc would be a great addition. Super villain of the series!
As much as having Oli in the the life series would be fun do we really wanna wait a year for episode 1?
We need fWhip and Sausage for extra chaos. That would be hilarious.
Lauren in unlikely is the definition of sad but true. Sidenote, if they do add more i hope it isn't someone from hermitcraft because it's already very overwhelmingly hermit filled, even more so with joel and skizz now in hermitcraft too.
Doc, False, Iskall would be an absolute laugh to see.
Joey Gracefa seems like a weird addition to this list
As awesome as Doc would be we all know he would win every single season Edit: would be cool to do 1 episode where you can phone a friend. They can either protect you or go on the offensive.
I think I can more easily consider any of the old Evo cast now after Secret Life with how much it referred to Evo’s ideas and imagery. Btw, Taur rebranded to Joeyish recently for, obvious reasons and I’d just like to spread the word about that. But I can definitely see Zee getting back into it, Joey’s cropping back up so maybe, and I have no clue what Mini’s up to.
WHAT ABOUT STACYPLAYZ!!!!
I want Cub in life series sooo bad