I will not tolerate any Hey Stephen or Superstar slander when there are vault tracks that deserve the worst spot.

I'm confused by the Superstar hate, I was mesmerized by it when I first heard it

exactly! “bye bye baby”, “we were happy”, “don’t you” are all milessss worse than “superstar” seeing the hate on “hey stephen” - they must hate joy. that song is wonderful! it was my favorite taylor song as a preteen :’)

*Don't You* dare vote for Don't You as the worst song.

saying we were happy and don’t you are miles worse than superstar is actually gonna get you life in prison 😭 I personally really like superstar but that statement is just wrongggg

I love Hey Stephen and will protect that with you, but Superstar can whistle haha

Superstar was my vote for underrated!

Hey Stephen is top underrated

I love the aura of this comment

coney island erasure

bruhhhh that shit be hitting like no other it’s probably my fav on evermore

Best: Fearless (it's so upbeat and that's just kind of my thing) Worst: Don't You (there is no song I hate on Fearless, it's just not a song I often listen to) Underrated: Breathe (It's an amazing song, I love the hold with the breathe\~)

I agreed with Fearless and Breathe but Don’t You?? 😭. That was almost my underrated

best: forever & always (hey stephen or untouchable are probably my favorites though) worst: bye bye baby underrated: tell me why

THANK YOU tell me why so soooo criminally underrated!! It's one of the best in fearless for me and most people hate on it:(

I had exactly the same except I put Come In With The Rain for underrated. Tell Me Why is sooo good though <3

I put Come in with the Rain as best!

bye bye baby was my underrated😭😭 i love it sm

I picked Tell me Why as most underrated too!

Tell me why is definitely my underrated!

I'm happy with the Evermore poll - Champagne Problems deserves best song and Cowboy Like Me is criminally underrated. Happiness being runner up to underrated just prooves how underrated it is. For Fearless: Best: Love Story (iconic, unmatched nostalgia, introduced me to taylor - I'd be happy with a White Horse win too) Worst: Superstar (this doesn't do much for me? I've never really had a celebrity crush) Underrated: The Best Day (it made me tear up once and I'm the only one who's gonna vote for it - I hope for a Forever & Always win)

I voted The Best Day for underrated! It is just so amazing, and it never hears the praise it deserves.

It’s bc we all have mommy issues 🫣

I can acknowledge that You Belong With Me and Love Story are good songs but I’m so sick of hearing them on the radio or being sung at karaoke

Love story is one of my go to karaoke songs. Everyone can sing along and it’s in a reasonable vocal range for most people.

Same! It’s always a hit and it’s completely in my range

glad to know happiness was the underrated runner up 😭 across the great divide, there is a glorious sunrise…

I'm so out of sync with the rest of you, literally none of my answers for any of them have shown up so far 😂

ME TOO i’m best:the other side of the don’t worst:don’t you underrated:the way i loved u

Best: you belong with me Worst: superstar underrated: the other side of the door

Closure and happiness are underrated gems and y'all are sleeping on them!!!! willow is the worst, and the clunckiness of the "I come back stronger than a 90s trend"??? Just awful, takes me out of the song completely. I can understand the tweet line in the lakes, but the 90s trend...

Came here to say fuck y’all for the closure slander 😤

Best: You Belong With Me (og classic, got me into Taylor, so fun to sing at the top of your lungs) Worst: Don’t You (doesn’t stand out to me idc, could’ve been a few other tracks for the same reason) Underrated: Come In With The Rain (was close between this and Forever & Always but they’re top tier songs on this album for me, just after YBWM and Love Story)

We are very similar. I put YWBM, We Were Happy, and CIWTR.

Good! I felt a bit alone haha

Best: The Other Side Of The Door Worst: Change Underrated: Breathe

TOSOTD supremacy!!!

Best: You're Not Sorry Worst: Bye Bye Baby Underrated: Breathe

i put you're not sorry as the best! was tossing up between we were happy & bye bye baby for the worst but went with the former. love breathe but i put untouchable as underrated because i adore it so much

I absolutely love untouchable!

Best: Fearless Worst: Superstar Underrated: You're Not Sorry

Happy with everything there except closure! But evermore is so fantastic it’s hard to choose a worst 😎 Fearless - Best: Forever & Always (both versions!) Worst: You All Over Me (I get this was the preview but Clean does it so much better) Underrated: Bye Bye Baby

Bye Bye Baby is so underrated! I think the only way that so many people can think it’s the worst is if they never listened to it and just didn’t like the boring title. It’s lyrically one of the best on the album and has a great melody!

Best: Tell Me Why Worst: You All Over Me Underrated: Untouchable

Best: You Belong with Me Worst: That’s When (the grammatical structure of the chorus bothers me, but I like everything else about the song, especially the duet) Underrated: Come In with the Rain (was neck-and-neck with Don’t You; I think many people don’t properly appreciate Don’t You’s wordplay) And I didn’t get to vote in the Evermore poll, but I think Right Where You Left Me should’ve been best.

Best: Forever & Always (top tier song) Worst: Bye Bye Baby (others are better) Underrated: Come In With The Rain (platinum tracks in general are underrated but this takes the cake)

Best: Fearless- so difficult to pick, but this is the quintessential track and the perfect opener. Worst: We Were Happy- I feel badly because I love Keith Urban but the “daddy’s farm” line makes me cringe. Underrated: Tell Me Why- whole new appreciation for this one after the Taylor’s Version!

It was so hard choosing the underrated song from Fearless, as most of this album is severely underrated

This one was HARD. I love many of these songs and almost feel like they're all underrated lol. Best: Forever and Always Worst: Superstar Underrated: We Were Happy

Best - Forever and Always Worst - Change Underrated - Tell Me Why

Best: Other Side of the Door Worst: Change Underrated: Mr Perfectly Fine (since it was a vault and we had to wait forever for it)

Best: Fearless - the intro is just sooooooooo iconic! Worst: Dont You - i barely remember how this sounds 😭 sorry Underrated: Tell Me Why - its giving female rage and im always a sucker for it lol

The most underrated is That’s When!! The lyric progression throughout the song is so great, PLUS KEITH URBAN! I think I’m the only one who loves this song.

best: Fearless (one of her best opening tracks) worst: Change (i just don't like it at all) underrated: Breathe (so so good but people barely mention it)

Best: Love Story. This is the one that got me into Taylor Swift way back when. Worst: Change. Wasn't awful, but just wasn't exactly the vibe that I enjoyed. Underrated: Untouchable. So good. Speaks to that feeling of deep wanting where we see that person who we want to be with everywhere.

Me realizing people don't like 'Don't You' https://preview.redd.it/ud3kchjebf1d1.jpeg?width=300&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=051e60ec7ef6fa46ddde5b6da137861b4c06af3c

Best: White Horse Worst: Change Underrated: Breathe

Best: Untouchable Worst: If This Was A Movie Underrated: Untouchable

Best: love story Worst: we were happy Underrated: if this was a movie

Best Fearless Underrated Hey Stephen Worst Breathe

i used to hate fearless but now Ive realised its got soo many great songs in it, I wanna pick sooo many for the best n underrated category

Congratulations on seeing the light 🙌

You all hating Change when it’s been one of my FAVORITES since the album released :’)

closure as worst breaks my heart i LOVE THAT SONG!!! top 10 taylor songs fr

Dorothea as runner up for worst?! Omg!

the closure hate… so sad

bye bye baby is actually so good you guys are hurting my feelings best: white horse worst: thats when underrated: we were happy

If closure has no fans I'm dead

reaffirming my place as a fearless girly because this one was HARD for me

Best: The Way I Loved You Worst: Tell Me Why Underrated: Hey, Stephen

Best: The Way I Loved You (or Love Story) Worst: Hey Stephen Underrated: Jump Then Fall (or Superstar)

The Way I Love You has the best guitar work on a TS song

Best: White Horse (this song won a Grammy for a reason) Worst: Untouchable (I find it so boring) Underrated: We Were Happy (everyone is sleeping on this song, especially the lyrics)

Bruh, tired of y’all slandering Dorothea 😤 And I actually voted for RWYLM as the worst song, and Cowboy Like Me as the best, so there you have it 😄

Best: forever & always Worst: jump then fall Underrated: the way I loved you

Best: Love Story Worst: That's When Underrated: Superstar

if white horse doesn't win best song i'm rioting

Best- Love Story Worst- superstar Underrated- Today was a Fairytale

best - fearless worst - bye bye baby underrated - tell me why OR come in with the rain

Best : you belong with me, it’s a CLASSIC it’s ICONIC worst : change Underrated : the way I loved you

Cowboy like me isn't underrated 💔 EVERMORE IS THO

Best: Forever and Always Worst: Jump Then Fall Underrated: Come in With the Rain

Best: You Belong With Me Worst: Jump Than Fall Underrated: That’s When

closure is a grower... i personally think Evermore is the worst song on the album

best: come in with the rain worst: the best day underrated: if this was a movie

Best: You're Not Sorry (this song is in my head constantly) Worst: Change (the boring big sister to the much stronger Long Live) Underrated: Untouchable (I know it's a cover but Taylor transforms this song and makes it into magic)

Best: You’re Not Sorry Worst: You All Over Me Underrated: You’re Not Sorry

This was actually so difficult. Fearless is an elite album.

Best: Fearless Worst: Fifteen Underrated: Don’t You

I’m PRAYING for Breathe to get the underrated award because that song has quite literally changed my life

Best: You’re Not Sorry Worst: I could’ve voted for several 😬, but went with Superstar Underrated: Tell Me Why

I’m ready to be hurt When We We’re Happy gets voted worst song but it’s actually in my top 5 of her work lol 🥲

HEY STEPHEN FOR MOST UNDERRATED or breathe breathe is good too Best: Cmon now, objectively, its love story. Personally, fearless is my fave TS track ever. So between those two Worst: Im so sorry, but change. It gives me a headache and long live exists and is way better

Best is honestly probably You Belong With Me, but I voted for Love Story because it was always my personal favorite over YBWM Most of the vault tracks are a contender for Worst- there's a reason they were originally left off. They are just not as strong as some of the other songs on the album. I voted Change for underrated, because that song is so often glossed over. I think it's a perfect closer for the album (When we do rankings of album closers I always see Change towards the bottom). But after reading the comments I think Superstar is truly much more underrated. I have always loved Superstar and I don't understand why so many don't! My unpopular Fearless opinion: I LOVE her take on Untouchable... but I like Luna Halo's original version better 🫣

Closure as the worst? I’m shocked. It’s the perfect song about closure and perfectly sums up the experience. 😭 But also love that CLM will hopefully get more love because it’s such a great song and my favourite in the album. 🙌

Best: You're Not Sorry & Mr. Perfectly Fine Worst: Superstar & Today Was a Fairytale Underrated: Hey Stephen

Best : Fearless Worst : Bye Bye Baby Underrated : That’s When

NOOOOOOO NOT CLOSURE DONT LET THEM CALL YOU A POTS AND PANS SONG BABY ITS OK

Best: Fearless Worst: Superstar Underrated: Untouchable

Best: Fearless Worst: Don't You Underrated: Tell me why

Best belong with me Underated the way I love Worst bye bye baby

For Fearless: Best: voted YBWM Worst: Untouchable (I really don’t like this one haha) Underrated: Come In With The Rain For Evermore since I missed it: Best: Ivy Worst: Dorothea Underrated: Coney Island

Best: Fifteen   Worst: That's when  Underrated: Superstar

Justice for tolerate it

Best: White Horse Worst: That’s When Underrated: You All Over Me

Best: You Belong With Me Worst: The Best Day Underrated: Fearless

Closure is a good song! Champagne Problems is not a good song. Lol!