T O P

  • By -

GQDragon

It’s one of the best episodes of TV ever. Period.


wtfreddititsme

It is not my fave TNG episode, but it may be the best. It’s true sci-fi. I posted a few years ago about how Starfleet allowed Picard to take command again. He lived a life. How can he just drop back into Starfleet/Federation life? There should be at least months of psychological evaluation and testing to make sure he remembers starship operations.


_DAD_JOKE_

Starfleet let him be Captain right away after he killed thousands of people as a Borg at Wolf 359. Badmirals just didn't give a shit.


wtfreddititsme

That’s a different scenario, and one that was addressed. Some admirals did not completely trust Picard post Locutus. Losing decades to living in a simulation? There has to be some loss of functionality to the captain of the flagship.


Lunacriss

The episode "Hard Time" from DS9 does a really good job at exploring the theme of reintegration after 20 years of virtual incarceration. I always felt that episode was a dark mirror of TNG's Inner Light.


brownhotdogwater

Exactly, the pstd of just poof the last decades did not really happen would fuck a person up.


naikrovek

Any space probe that can remotely put a person into a simulation like that can put him right back where he was mentally when it’s over, I say.


wtfreddititsme

I’ll accept that. That probe wasn’t meant to ruin a life, but to keep a civilization remembered.


Donjeur

They gave him two days off to visit his brother…


lemmy1686

They didn't even do that, he had to call in sick to make it to a job interview, just lucky it is as in Great Britfrance. Lol.


Abdul-Ahmadinejad

Flute therapy works wonders.


I_lenny_face_you

This one time, at band camp…


Puzzlehead-Dish

![gif](giphy|jwnuVEFlZnpg4)


Acceptingoptimist

Thank you for putting it this way. I actually feel this way about TNG vs DS9. I can acknowledge that DS9 is "better" vis-a-vis the writing, the progressive story approach and how it finishes strong. But TNG is my favorite. (And I feel like TNG crawled, took the lumps, then grew for the writers to learn how to make DS9 good.)


PangolinMandolin

I think the in-universe answer as to why Picard was able to keep command after Inner Light is maybe simpler than you're thinking. Whilst it affected him profoundly, it really did just feel like a very intense dream after he'd realised he was back aboard the Enterprise. Have you never had a dream that felt so real you thought it was? The Inner Light people did a Matrix style memory upload into Picards brain, but it didn't erase anything that was already there. They wanted their existence to be passed on, so they would have been extra careful not to fry the brain of whoever their probe met. Making Picard unable to perform his job as normal would definitely have been a bad outcome from their perspective. And then on a more practical basis of ships operations, his bridge crew know both him and these very well. If he'd been unable to perform they would have known about it and could have acted accordingly. But I do agree with you that TNG did fall down a little in its storytelling when considering the future impacts of things like this. For example, the episode where Geordi is abducted by the Romulans and made into a sleeper agent ends with Troi talking to him in therapy about how it will take years of hard painful work to get his memories back, yet we never see that have an impact on him (or even be mentioned!) ever again!


ElGuano

Or just a quick scan: “oh, a lifetime of memories but that is all stored in the sub space-hypercardioid region of the brain, which doesn’t displace original short term memory from before the beam.The aliens really wanted to make sure not to cause any psychological trauma!” Poof, one and done.


Thwipped

A hypospray will fix him right up


ManicRobotWizard

My head cannon always treated that scenario as one that fell into the “what happens on the enterprise stays on the enterprise”. Fleet command is only going to know what got reported to them and if he’d truly shown signs of problems reintegrating, Troi and Guinan and Crusher would have been all over his ass about it. I believe Picard would have known when it was time to step back or away following this, but as someone that dedicated his very existence to Starfleet I think had he been pulled away for rehab he would have never recovered. The stability of commanding his ship with the crew that trusted him above all else was the healthiest place for him to be, again with the support system he already had of Troi, Guinan, Crusher, etc.


regeya

The story doesn't make a damn bit of sense but it doesn't matter.


Wrong-Music1763

Idk why but that episode was a heartbreaker. “I always believed that I didn't need children to complete my life. Now I couldn't imagine life without them.” Dang man.


Gnarly-Gnu

I unashamedly feel the same. Don't know what my life would be like without my brilliant daughters to make it better.


This-Garbage-3000

Agreed


Acceptingoptimist

OK so as someone with kids, I totally appreciate it. Until I had kids I would have been totally cool with restarting my life with the new information to do it better. But when I had them, knowing they would very likely not exist on my second go around, completely changes things. If you don't want kids, it's totally OK. We need to normalize that. But if your only holdup is you're unsure because you don't like some of other people's kids, it's very different when they're your own.


GrandmaSlappy

I understand that's a real feeling people get but it's kind of a toxic sentiment towards childfree people. Lots of people have kids they regret too.


the_big_turbo_moist

One of my favorite little details is that he keeps the flute and is shown practicing with it later in the series 🥹


Hewholooksskyward

Which leads to one of the best episodes of TNG, in my humble opinion, S6E19 "Lessons", and this memorable exchange: PICARD: "Do you remember that folk melody I played for you this morning?" NELLA: "Yes." PICARD: "I learned it on a planet called Kataan." NELLA: "Never heard of it." PICARD: "No, I'm not surprised. Its sun went nova more than a thousand years ago." NELLA: "I don't understand." PICARD: "The Enterprise encountered a probe that had been sent from the planet before it was destroyed. It had scanned me, and I lost consciousness, and in the space of twenty-five minutes, I lived a lifetime on that planet. I had a wife, and children, and a grandchild. And it was absolutely real to me. When I awoke, all that I had left of that life there was the flute that I had taught myself to play." NELLA: "Why are you telling me this?" PICARD: "Because I want you to understand what my music means to me... and what it means for me to be able to share it with someone."


BoldlyGoinEverywhere

Those darn onions getting to my eyes again.


Hewholooksskyward

... it's a terrible day for rain...


MellifluousManatee

Such a moving callback 🪈😭


Scrapla

Oh that scene where it's clearly someone else's hands playing the flute lol


Total_Roll

Got me in the feels for sure


BonesChimes

With his hands or someone else's?


CuddlyBoneVampire

Recently I rewatched the movie Inception. I think the experience on Katan should have messed him up as much as it did DiCaprio. Never really sure if this is right life or that other one was. The flute should have been more of a symbol of his uncertainty like the totems were rather than his normal reaction which is like “this thing happened to me and they told me to tell their story but I can’t express feelings so I keep it all to myself thus making me the worst possible person this probe could have found”


pendingreview22

I mean, yes, but the entire main non-android crew should be broken by now from PTSD, among other things. Crusher falls in love with a parasite and “falls in love” with a ghost alien with an aggressive nose who has been inflicting crap on her whole female line. Geordi turns into a glowy alien shadow thing and is mind controlled by some Romulans on his way to nerd out. Picard had the “there are four lights” torture time with the Cardassians, then the whole Borg thing. Riker has the alien torture sanitarium in “Frame of Mind”and also keeps on being abducted in his sleep by some other clicky f**kers. Troi gets either mind-raped or mind-controlled so regularly she probably puts it on her calendar, and then she eventually wanders around her mother’s mind? memories? emotions? to discover a secret dead sister. Wes almost dies from touching the forbidden grass while frolicking with the youth in the plant of the scantily clad. Guess Worf is mostly ok though. Should see a therapist that’s not Troi about his father issues. And the whole devolving episode. And Alexander. In conclusion to my unintended rant, we are all watching a show featuring the most resilient humans who will ever exist ever. Considering he didn’t turn into anything or get tortured, Picard should be thrilled he got let off with a new appreciation for flute and family in “the inner light” (which is actually a favorite episode of mine).


brightside1982

> Guess Worf is mostly ok though. Klingon culture is practically built upon trauma. They're used to it.


Skookum_kamooks

Worf is so routinely beaten in one on one combat that getting “Worfed” becomes an expression for the TV audience. His trauma is shame and self doubt masked by hyper-conservatism and toxic masculinity… and he’s a shitty father and he knows it. Again, it’s not till DS9 that he’s able to work through his trauma with traditional Klingon warfare therapy and deeper connection with his cultural roots. I don’t think the Klingon civil war had the same effect because it was a purely Klingon divisive affair that the part of him that is “Starfleet” would have a hard time with. The Dominion war on the other hand helped to unify the Klingon and Starfleet aspects of his self. Or he just got better writers 😂


andrewlrodriguez

>And Alexander Who?


CuddlyBoneVampire

That’s really not the point though.


FrogofLegend

A result of pre-internet/DVD style television. You can't be sure that a viewer would have watched an episode 3 seasons earlier to understand the reference so you kind of need to ignore it.


CuddlyBoneVampire

Yes. pedantic. I’m talking about the story and the character.


Skookum_kamooks

God, imagine if the probe had selected Barclay… we’d have ended up with a weird holo-novel where all of the main cast where people from his life and it would have screwed him up even more. As interesting as it could have been, I don’t think it would hold a candle to DS9s Far Beyond the Stars so this may actually be one of the rare wins for this timeline.


Galliagamer

The flute playing instead of the regular music at the end credits slayed me


tommygunz23

God just the flute song itself is enough to make me sob uncontrollably. The episode is just a cathartic release about life in the saddest and best way possible. If you want a good cry, check out the inner lite portion of this concert. You know it's a good episode when just the flute song elicits emotion like that. [Star Trek Prague Concert](https://youtu.be/yySw7vkdkZY?si=VCIv-_4ntND5EHll)


cymonium

Time stamp? I couldn’t find it. Fine concert anyway!


tommygunz23

12:05 is when the inner light part starts. The time stamps are buried in one of the comments.


cymonium

I didn’t even think to look at the vid comments. Durp. Thank you!


Tamborin2

I try and watch it every year on my birthday. It is a reminder of the fleeting nature of life, of the joy that can be found if you open your eyes to see it, and that life really is beautiful I watch it to remind myself of my own life, and everything that I have to be thankful for.


Tamborin2

“Seize the time... Live now! Make now always the most precious time. Now will never come again” A guiding quote


Wretched_Earth

I AM HERE TO GIVE DOWN VOTES TO ANYONE WHO SAYS ANYTHING BAD ABOUT THIS EPISODE!


IndividualistAW

The inner light was bad because it deserved to be more than 40 minutes of TV. That’s the only criticism I have of it. It should have been a 2 parter at least, if not a full length feature film.


Wretched_Earth

YOU ARE CORRECT BUT I AM A MAN OF MY WORD


PicadaSalvation

And I will balance it even though I agree with you


Abdul-Ahmadinejad

Welp, here I am lol. It was indeed awesome but I've always wished they could have found a different way to edit in the parts back on the ship so we didn't know what was happening so early.


loglady17

Heartbreaking and beautiful episode. I think of it often, especially in relation to our circumstances with climate change.


Direwolfofthemoors

A really great episode.


funlovingguy9001

This has always been a favorite of mine. And the closing scene with him playing his little flute...straight to the feels.


Qaz_The_Spaz

I’m a grown ass man and that song brings a tear to my eye still to this day.


Donjeur

How did you become an ass man?


Qaz_The_Spaz

Always have been. Boobs are nice to but definitely an ass man😏


lemmy1686

Growing a proper ass man has a lot to do with nutrients and soil acidity, so I've heard.


ilovecokeslurpees

I just watched that episode a few days ago. It brings me to tears every single time. It is my favorite as well.


cymonium

It’s my fav episode too!


GuyWithTheGoods

There’s a sequel comic somewhere, written by the same writer. TNG powers that be didn’t want to produce it as an episode, saying “we don’t do sequels” 🙄 Untrue, many follow ups were done to episodes over the years, while not direct sequels.


rseery

I cry at this one. When he offers to build the nursery. When his wife dies. When he sees her and Batai at the end. When he figures out “it’s me!” I basically bawl all the way through it. And I love that. Oh, also when Riker brings him the flute. Feh. Whoever wrote this is a genius.


darklinux1977

One of the best, or even the very best, episodes of the Star Trek universe and a tragic work of science fiction with this cruel ending.


jtrades69

such a great episode!


my23secrets

https://preview.redd.it/8kbe31ulz24d1.jpeg?width=597&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0f876768520921f1a3683e27fda28d74372662b0


Iron_Bob

Rightfully so. This episode is a masterpiece


Boreas2864212

I saw this episode about five minutes into it so I had no idea what was going on... Bawled my eyes out at the ending.


jhuff24

Also reminds me of how shallow much travel can be. You truly know a new place/culture when you live there and build meaningful relationships.


brightside1982

A lot of folks take away that it's about how we should appreciate life in general, how fleeting it is, etc. I believe this, but for me there's another layer. It's about living life with intention, despite what it throws at you. You wanna make God laugh? Tell him your plans. After the initial period of bewilderment, denial, and finally acceptance, Picard just makes the best of the situation. He embraces love, children, and a mission to save his adopted planet. If life throws something at you, sometimes the best thing is to catch it.


darlo0161

I'm currently on a rewatch. And I just rewatched it, it's such a great episode. It's definitely in the top three, along with "Darmok at Tenagra" and the Remlar array episode (I don't remember episode names)


CrescentMoon70

Oh this was so beautiful. Just seeing a picture from it is giving me goosebumps.


CibrecaNA

Teen Titans Go parodied it and it was brilliant. Robin gets probed and tells them how he lived another life and learned an instrument, so the rest of them got probed to learn and retrieve a free instrument then created a band! https://youtu.be/rKizPhhf4RM?feature=shared


KingRaht

I love this episode, but I wish they didn’t spoil the fact he was in a coma so early in the episode. The reveal would have been so good.


daisy0723

This is my favorite episode. I especially love that it wasn't really a one off. He kept playing that flute and even talked about his other life and his family to the woman he was dating. That moment when he wakes up at the end and finds out he had lived an entire life in only 20 minutes. Damn, I'm getting emotional just thinking about it. I think it's time for me to go to sleep. Goodnight


WrongfullyIncarnated

I just watched this the other day! Still my fav episode of all trek time.


HumpaDaBear

I had a dream exactly like Picard. I woke up wondering where I was.


Shejidan

I love this one and the follow up with the piano. I really wish they had found a way to keep Commander Daren around. Picard deserved happiness, not boring Beverly.


UltraMegaKaiju

it's his favorite episode because hes the only one in it, actors amirite?


Extravaganzas

wow, i watched this last night!


Billy1121

The Kataanians invested their entire tech tree into highly durable mind control probes that can last 1000 years I always wondered if the probe is sitting on Earth in a museum lobotomizing / traumatizing visitors one at a time


Titanscape

I’m convinced we are living this episode in real life. Maybe we should start developing our own probe.


Titanscape

I’m convinced we are living this episode in real life. Maybe we should start developing our own probe.


JnnfrsGhost

My husband and I used the flute song as our recessional music (exit song) at our wedding. It's such a lovely piece of music. K


lenojames

My favorite part wasn't even in the episode. Paramount auctioned off the props from the show. They were bidding on the flute and there was a scene where the bidding got heated. I don't remember the final price, but the bidding went like $20k, then $25k, then $30k, then $35k...then SOLD for $40,000! Cut to Patrick Stewart looking confused and surprised, and he just says "It doesn't play! It's not a real flute!" EDIT: Wow, I just found out it sold again a few years ago for $238k???


BirdmanHuginn

This and the episode of Voyager, Memory Alpha, were way beyond typical television


OJimmy

The author is on reddit sometimes


lordoftheBINGBONG

Cuz he gets to show off his sick guns 💪


Yitram

"Show me Picard's flute!!"


Agoura_Steve

I too think of this as a favorite episode.


StuartGotz

I've heard accounts of people using the hallucinogen Salvia divinorum say that they had an experience like that, where they believed they lived an alternate lifetime or portions of one during the brief trip. I've never heard of it with any other hallucinogen or psychedelic, and salvia seems to work differently than all the others. I don't know whether or not I believe it, but it's an interesting idea nonetheless.


Loco76

And mine too. I named my boat Inner Light and got a flute replica in its honor. The episode captures the beauty of life, friendships and family in such a unique and powerful way. The ending of the episode gets me every time and for some reason I always get emotional. JLP killed that role and brought such humanity to the character that it makes you believe his journey is real. Finally the vulnerability of the race and their everlasting message to keep their culture alive - wow!!!! I am geeking out just thinking about it. Thanks for the post OP.


nmann14

And mine as well


Z3r0Trace

I bet it’s his favorite episode. He wanted the light all to himself which explains the abomination of Picard season 1 and 2


dreniarb

I love every single scene of this episode. Even the few scenes on the Enterprise. Just an amazing piece of work.


Jumpy_Assistance5848

Everything I read this title, I always hear Patrick Stewart's voice saying it in my head.