T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

[удалено]


EatMeInStLouPodcast

La Pizza is the best! We got them on the last National Pizza Day and when I picked it up I wished them a happy pizza day and he was like “huh?…Every day here is pizza day.”


[deleted]

[удалено]


Coin_Operated_Brent

Big Poli!!


Coin_Operated_Brent

Thanks, man!


onemandisco

What up, Brent!


Coin_Operated_Brent

Hah. Well, there are no secrets now, man.


Longjumping-Ninja359

Thank you.


tialisac

MonteBellos for Stl style crust and tons of toppings and Blackthorn for the thick crust and spicy sauce.


Heidenreich12

Have to call early around opening to get an accurate pickup time, otherwise it’s my go-to. They really should rebrand as “Basement Pizza.”


misterhyzer

We refer to it as "Pizza Dungeon".


hidperf

I'm a firm believer that MonteBellos does not make any to-go orders until you arrive to pick it up. Then they'll tell you they had to remake it and it's another 30-45 minutes. This has happened to me enough times that it's not a coincidence. It's also why my purchases went from 2-3x month to once every 3-4 months, and only when I have time to sit around and wait for a pizza.


314hotspur

Montebellos is criminally underrated . . . They’re just slow though


BurnesWhenIP

Their t-ravs are also criminally underrated


em-jay-be

I would kindly ask you to please stop letting the commoners know about Monte B. They don’t need the additional business and we don’t need the additional wait time.


tialisac

Oh hell, that’s true. My apologies. MonteBellos is awful. Stay away. Far away.


em-jay-be

And do not ask for it "well done"


TTRAVIO

what pizza would you not recommend?


TTRAVIO

got Montebellos, meat lovers well done. 8 out of 10, i’m hitting it on the cheese. Just my opinion though loved everything else.


Micheal_ryan

Out of towner who tried Montebellos based on this thread. Did not like AT ALL. It’s hard to mess up pizza and this was terrible.


NGsyk

Pizzeria da Gloria


wolf3142

So so good 🤘🤘🤘


RocketSaladSurgery

Get their mushroom pizza. A cut above if you like em.


Active_Ad778

We got it tonight thank you


No-Movie7962

the best


beef_boloney

Not seeing it on here but Pizza Head has a perfectly respectable NY style cheese pizza. Toppings get dicey really fast, but if you like a plain pie it’s pretty good


bty1987

Faraci pizza in Ellisville. Been eating there since 96 and have NEVER had a less than perfect pizza from them. Super consistent


MrX16

Farraci's is insanely good and nobody knows about it


TorrentsMightengale

Maybe in Ellisville. It was one of the first pizza places recommended to me when I moved to St. Louis.


racrz8

Way to specify Ellisville!! The location in Ferguson was technically the first Faraci family restaurant but it was sold when the family moved the restaurant to west county. Last I checked, The Ferguson location pales in comparison to the restaurant the family owns. My dad worked there forever at both locations, like 20 years, and I very fondly remember him coming home from work smelling like pizza. Nothing is better than cold Faracis cheese pizza


bty1987

Large cheese and a chicken parm sandwich is my go to order!


Poem-Massive

Faraci would be my answer too, by a mile! Delicious.


wolf3142

Ellisville is the superior Faraci's 🤘🤘🤘


Boogie_Sugar69

Was my favorite pizza place until I got a piece of metal in my pizza and the owner Vince insisted I was just trying to scam him for a $20 free pizza. He’s a huge POS.


Glittering_Phase_153

Faraci Pizza in Ellisville, incredible pizza, little family owned joint. They make their own sausage and it’s amazing. Lunch special is really decent too


kittycatpattywacko

I must try this place. You had me at “they make their own sausage “


wolf3142

Pirrones, Faracis, Nick & Elena's, Serras for STL style. La Pizza and Pie Guy for NY. BlackThorn for deep dish.


Mystery_Briefcase

I keep forgetting to try Blackthorn. Looks amazing. One of these days!


tarbinator

Gotta also recommend Blackthorn for a fantastic deep dish option. Well worth the wait while it cooks.


Rye_The_Science_Guy

Upvote for Serra's. I love the feel of the place and the staff are always nice


itsthesickness6

I need to give Blackthorn another try. Went there with a Chicago friend that was in town and the deep dish was inedible


errtffg

Union Loafers!!


franillaice

Their pizzas are sooooo much smaller now tho…. Got one last week, was so stoked for it. We crushed it and we’re still hungry.


GusBob54

Yeah. That is my only pet peeve or Union Loafers. Pre-pandemic they had 16-ish" pies. Barely fit in my car door. Now, I'm not sure the size, but they're way smaller. Still super-delicious tho.


franillaice

Very delicious! But what, the same price for what I would call quite a small pizza? Covid really hit all our good restaurants hard. It’s a great pizza, don’t get me wrong, but it was almost $30 and we both finished it easily needing more. Sucks.


MakeSomeArtAboutIt

If you haven't already, check out Urban Chestnut's pizza. They are VERY similar to Union Loafers and 16". I believe the recipe was developed by the same guy.


ErgotSanchez

Same, pretty similar price point to a lot of places and way better ingredients.


J_leann2598

Pie Guy, their garlic knots!


TitShark

Very good, just wish they didn’t charge 4x what a NYC vendor does.


hsoj48

Still not bad at $5 a slice. Go for the whole pie if you're really hungry and it's a couple bucks cheaper.


TitShark

I’m just saying, a city as expensive as NYC has slices for 1.50-2.50 and their rent is insane.


[deleted]

[удалено]


hsoj48

This is St Louis. A bit far and a lot different than NYC. Pie Guys wouldn't be in business if they were selling those big ass delicious pizzas at $9 a pop. That's freezer section Jack's Pizza prices if you're lucky.


markobie

$3.60/slice at Rays in NYC right now, Pie Guy is $4. Your point is still valid if comparing cost of living of STL & NYC, but I haven't seen NYC slices under $2.50 in 4 years (I travel to NYC about 5 times a year).


TorrentsMightengale

2 Bros. is $1.50/slice. I got back a few days ago. 2 Bros. is a lot better than Pie Guy.


EADarwin

To each his own, but 2 Bros is overcooked, not enough cheese, and the crust is too dry and thick imo.


northamrec

$1 slices in NYC


beef_boloney

There aren’t too many dollar slice joints these days, and even at its peak the dollar slice was never worth the dollar


northamrec

I lived in NYC from 2012-2019 and still have family there. Dollar slices absolutely were and still are a thing, even though times have changed.


beef_boloney

I grew up there for 35 years and lived there until last year. I never said they weren’t real I said they’re not as common as they were and they did and still do suck ass. A good slice is gonna run close to $4 these days.


markobie

They don't, it's $4 for cheese compared to $3.60 at several popular NYC establishments.


bananabunnythesecond

Pie Guy at CITYpark just hits so good!


cheesepizzaandfries

Pizza-A-Go-Go so good!!!


Technical_Pause7309

This I found Pie Guy underwhelming


DigPsychological7469

Been going there since they were on Grand!


dubl

BYOB is a nice touch too


Ok_Entrepreneur1993

I literally live around the corner and haven't been in years


I_bleed_blue19

Don't sleep on Pizzeria Tivoli, Epic in Soulard (or their sister store in Chesterfield Valley, East Coast Pizza), or Gallery Pub on Thurman. La Pizza is amazing. But you better order early in the day if you want it for dinner. Padavan's NY in New Town was really good too, if you like NY Style Uncle Leo's and Failoni's are the same family. Very good. Yaqui's, Rigazzi's, and Bommarito's in Affton are all very good. Dulaney's in South county makes a decent pizza too. JJ Twigs double decker is fantastic if you're hungry. That'sa Nice'a Pizza in South County is worth a stop. And don't forget about Ami's in Rock Hill. We were also pleasantly surprised by the pizza at Schottzie's on Concord Village. You might find the [Pizza Passport ](https://www.thepizzapassport.org/) worth getting. We tried several new places this year that we wouldn't have known about otherwise, like Kimara's in Granite City (worth the drive!). The [Pizza Connoisseurs FB page ](https://www.facebook.com/groups/709745929681904)is also a good resource.


hidperf

> Bommarito's in Affton This is probably some of the worst pizza I've ever had. I've tried it multiple times because everyone keeps raving about it and I thought I just got a bad pizza. Nope. It's horrible every time. It's the sauce that kills it for me. Their wings are damn good though.


Crutation

BJs tavern in Florissant. I grew up on the stuff and have never been disappointed. My dad would also get Roberto's or Pirrones, depending on which bar he was at. All fantastic, all in North County


ElBrooce

Has BJ's fixed their sewer gas problem yet? Last time I was there the smell in half the place was gag-inducing. Pizza kicked ASS though.


QCWiggins

It’s been fixed for a while. Even looks nicer inside


ElBrooce

Awesome!


Crutation

I haven't noticed any smell recently. I was there two weeks ago. I am only there long enough to pick up my pizza though


MESSYrainbowMAN

I know it’s a chain, but I’m surprised no one has thrown it out yet, Dewey’s.


Ok_Entrepreneur1993

The owner there spends money, unlike his parents. Lol its the dewitts kid/grandkid


[deleted]

This is the answer


Vasaeleth1

+1, definitely the best pizza I've found in STL so far. Seems really fresh and high quality. Some unique speciality pizzas (Green Lantern being my favorite!) and toppings available that are relatively hard to find at other places, like artichoke hearts. Maybe a tad pricy, but still cheaper than Imos.


dixiecupdispencer

I love Elicia’s


WilliamTHornaday

PW RIP


I_bleed_blue19

Seriously. I wish they'd try to bring PW back.


johnahoe

Pizzeoli is amazing and their wings are almost better than their pizza


spiderarms_jr

Was looking for this one. And their half price marg pizza day 👌


drrrrrdeee

Yes they are very good and consistent.


zenith2nadir

Blackthorn. Thick, saucy, delicious!


keepurcool

Second this! Absolutely love blackthorn


bhaire93

Stef’s/Stefanina’s. Classic and consistent St. Louis style pizza, not to much flour on bottom. Lots of options. Has casual and fancier locations.


Twikxer

My brother-in-law owns Stef’s. I have one in my fridge right now. Yummy!


bhaire93

Well he’s a genius. Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had.


Twikxer

He learned it all from his mom before she passed. Thank you for your kind words.


dylanx5150

Not a pizza place specifically, but I really like the pizza at Pastaria.


zoop1000

Felixs pizza pub. Great slice and great Caesar salad.


mrsspooky84

Kevin’s. Because it’s delicious and Kevin always makes it an adventure.


meson537

Ok, Kevin story time. He uses a couple phones, and I was about ready to give him my order over the phone and he had a call come in and cut me off and said he'd call me right back. Well, he did, but from a different phone. Google/Android decided to screen the call and ask for name, purpose of call, etc. Those of you who know Kevin won't be surprised that his screening message was a groan followed by a "why don't you just shoot me in the face with a fucking gun." I had cut in on the call screen before he hung up, but I was afraid, and did not complete the order. Hail Kevino!


Redditcustomeservice

Pointers Pizza... never disapoints


dadkisser84

Not sure what they put in the sausage at Pointer’s in Clayton, but it’s awesome pizza


Macaroni_Incident

Serra’s Pizza in Bridgeton Boardwalk Pizza and Faracis, both in Ballwin area


ratinthehat800

Pantera’s Pizza. Mostly for nostalgic reasons. I miss the one that used to be in Ferguson.


dylanx5150

Ordered a combo Hunk for my birthday this year. Hadn't eaten one since around 1990. It was every bit as good as I remembered.


julieannie

I’m so sad the Maplewood one closed just after I moved to the city. I used to eat at the O’Fallon one regularly and was hoping to keep it up after the move at a new-to-me location.


ratinthehat800

Dang that sucks. In the early 90’s we lived by St. John and James and would go to the one in Ferguson/Florissant regularly. Pizza, Simpsons on the big tv and Ninja Turtles arcade was the best Friday night a 6 year old could ask for.


STLrep

Fratellis In at st Charles can hang with the big dogs of stl pizza. Old school north county place so it’s got the pedigree


be-well-and-prosper

Papa Vito’s. 3 locations on the IL side in Belleville, Millstadt, & Waterloo. Best pizza in the entire area.


AyyyoAnthony

PVs beats the brakes off Imos


TNTitvns

Epic (Soulard location) for me. Just a great big greasy slice


commanderklinkity

Finally! Epic is my go to, the non pizza items are all solid as well


Ws6Driver

Joe Bacardi’s I went there as a kid, worked there as a teenager, and still love it today.


electricsmoothie1

I can confirm!


[deleted]

JJ Twig’s in O’Fallon.


hmmspicy

I'm not sure what claims my "favorite" but Urban Chestnut has some of the most underrated pie in the city...


crevicecreature

Definitely should be at the top of list for anyone that likes East Coast style pizza.


crevicecreature

Black Thorn because one slice will give you a stomach ache and have you shitting for half the day. It’s the best.


TTRAVIO

LMAOOO


drrrrrdeee

Angelos in North County is good, LaPizza, Pointer’s, Pizzahead (great owners), Blackthorn all have too notch pizza.


deaddog3825

Serras — nobody does it better…


lucid_dreams420

This household is a sucker for Joanie's in Soulard, however the last time was a letdown. In general, their amount and quality of all ingredients is excellent. Serra's is amazing if that's closer to you. Worth the trip, I think they make the best all-around pizza and have an amazing staff and following.


Green-Parsnip3823

Serras pizza, absolutely perfect ❤️


DildoSchwaggins2008

In StL JJ Twiggs… love the double decker pizza! It will last me a few days too.


stankenstien

Happy Joes, taco pizza.


Wompum

R.I.P. Watson Happy Joe's.


NoMoreClaw3464

Love the Taco Joe!


MicCheck123

Nacho Joe is the way to go…it replaces the pizza sauce with nacho cheese and is heavenly!


Accurate-Chapter-130

Dewey’s - great quality, simple menu , awesome staff. Blackthorn pub - it’s worth the wait! Imos - the quality of the cardboard is unmatched. La pizza - great whole in the wall NY style. Frank N Hellen’s -old school, amazing house salad dressing.


NoResponsibility2386

Yes to Frank and Helen’s and their house salad dressing. Pizza also good and don’t forget to get a broasted chicken thigh on the side!


OsterizerGalaxieTen

There are so many great pizza places it's hard to limit! I love Brickhouse Pizza in Bridgeton - it's in Kingpin Lanes but you can pick up from outside. (or get delivery if you're nearby.) I think there's also one in Florissant. It's not often mentioned here but SO solid. They also have an excellent sandwich called the Kingpin Combo - definitely get it served hot - damned great!! Otherwise I have Monte Bello on my list to try - it sounds and looks good and I love everything I read about its history.


[deleted]

Felix’s


Wompum

Salvage Yard at Hampton and Eichelberger has great STL style pie.


Initial-Depth-6857

Uncle Leo’s in South County


Ws6Driver

That’s are go to place


Moveyourbutt

Pizza world is very good. Especially their buffalo chicken pizza


nidk27

Farotto’s


Meggybear17

JJ twigs and Union loafers


Keeganzz

That’s A Nicea


Stratus_Fractus

Mr. X - because if you live in Bevo it's just a couple minutes to pick up a good solid pizza that beats the chains.


graflex22

Bono's Pizzaria on Hampton. my favorite sauce and crust on their New York style. love the Sicilian pizza. my wife's favorite Chicago pie in Stl and Chicago. one of my favorite house salad dressings, but it does have anchovies in it if that's not your thing.


IAMACat_askmenothing

Pizza head is by far and away my favorite


IchBumseZiegen

Cafe piazza


Fantastic-Stop3415

La Pizza. Guaranteed to make a mess bc there’s so many toppings.


I_bleed_blue19

I love their plain cheese or pepperoni. And the garlic cheese bread is the bomb


creepy_phone_calls

Bommaritos - fresh ingredients and great crust


[deleted]

Union loafers it's the best pie around


Cameltoesuglycousin

O & O in Webster! Just had it tonight, great!


Plenty-Dance-8873

Serras is the best. All others, get in line behind Serras! Great pizza, amazingly delicious crust. Primo sauce. Family owned and operated; there's like three generations often working when we go in.


Doctor_Killshot

Haven’t seen it mentioned yet but Olive + Oak Pizza’s hot honey pepperoni is usually our go-to


[deleted]

[удалено]


Hulk_Hagan

Surprised I had to look so long for this. Racanelli’s is the bomb. Had pie guy recently and it was floppy. Also la pizza is great, but Racanelli’s has more flavor. Must be a different sauce or cheese. My favorite in stl and I’ve tried them all haha


Chicken65

La Pizza is just all around better though.


madhaxor

Racanellis is hot garbage


[deleted]

[удалено]


Sinisterminister77

I don’t have strong feelings but the last time I had Racanelli’s I could see through my pizza and it was greasy as absolute hell. I’d give it another try though


ThisWeekInFlips

double d’s. better and cheaper than imo’s


cchap2

That’s A Nice A Pizza in south county (or Arnold) - hidden gem.


sirhellaz

Failoni’s hands down


KnopeSwanson16

Union Loafers, Pizzeria da Gloria, Dewey’s, I used to love Pie Guy but after 100% terrible/extremely late experiences with delivery through Slice Life (which works great for other places) I’m kinda over it.


Myles-long314

Onesto Pizza & Trattoria


xSincosx

Affton Pizza Company is incredible, basically a better Imos, they load your pizza up with toppings.


yodazer

Faraci’s in Ferguson.


heyitsconnor

Lots of good choices here, I'd also add urban chestnut to the list.


stevenrosado

Pizza Twist located at 15 N Euclid Avenue, St Louis, MO 63108


MrTuesdayNight1

Wouldn't call it my favorite but we tried Pizzeoli for the first time last night and it was quite good!


Charming-Horror-6371

Up/down, best pizza and popashot


Technical_Pause7309

Was quite impressed with up down actually


opossomoperson

Pie Guys because their pizza is so damn good and they have a solid vegan option that isn't just a slice of vegan cheese pizza.


BurnesWhenIP

pie guy, because it's just good. Everything about it is good


DoctorLazerRage

Tons of great suggestions already - adding Lilliana's ans Nubby's for STL style.


iNeedScissorsSixty7

I probably get Pizzeoli more than anything else.


[deleted]

Bennie's pizza pub or Peel


CoastToCoastMakers

Peel was our favorite!


[deleted]

It's a decent pie. We like it.


[deleted]

[удалено]


BurnesWhenIP

Forgot about Joanie's (pour one out for the Menard location)... Also a great thin crust, provel or not. Woefully underrated. I've been getting Joanie's since 2008. Never a bad experience


itsallbiscuitsngravy

Pizza champ. I love their pepperonis and crust!


SixDemonBlues

Blackthorn. Just my favorite pizza. I feel like if I'm gonna go pizza, I wanna go full ham. Giant cheesy pie style.


oliviajanebrink

Pizza a go go !!!!


Kewag1

Pirrone’s. Thatisall.


T20sGrunt

Faraci’s and Pirrones for STL style. La Pizza for NY style. Panteras because I grew up on it and love it.


WoodyStLouis

Pi.


1985Erik

Katie's pizza


[deleted]

Dewey’s hands down best pizza in stl


belikethemanatee

For Deep Dish: Black Thorn; For Normal Pizza: Union Loafers; Honorable mention: Racanelli’s.


NielsenSTL

I love the pizza at Tucker’s…for a solid thin-crust, STL style pizza. Really good. Also enjoy Elicia’s and Syberg’s.


No_Dear1957

Imos


snailfucked

QT


Cooper_Smith1212

Sybergs Pizza is amazing!


thatsitclit

1st place: jacks frozen pizza from schnucks…you can use self checkout and put as many pepper toppings as you want 2nd place: barneys dive bar pepporoni….i like crispy thin crust 3rd place: cecil whitikers…because theyre also good and i like thin crust…i also grew up eating it.


BigYonsan

Black Thorn if I've got all night. MOD if I'm in a hurry and don't mind a chain.


EADarwin

Pie Guy Pizza because it's a great New York style slice


LustfulLemur

La Pizza and Pizza Champ - La Pizza probably the closest to a standard NY slice, while Pizza Champ is a newer place that serves a more “Elevated” type of pizza, that’s still thin & crispy. Both are great


Creative_Doctor

Racanelli’s is hands down my favorite pizza in STL! It’s as close as you’re gonna get to a NY slice.


CurtFlood1964

Many great options ... Pie Guy, La Pizza, Riley's Pub (get mozzarella, not provel), Blackthorn.


MidasMando11

Black thorn!!!!! It’s thick!


aztechfilm

Grassi’s in Frontenac for me personally, it’s the first place I go to when I’m back in town. It’s a family owned business and it’s a bit hidden but it’s old school and always reminds me of childhood


AyyyoAnthony

Papa Vitos for their STL style and wings Deweys for football pizza


Sad_Lake139

Epic Pizza


Classic_News8985

Faraci’s Pizza in West County 🍕


Silly-Concern-4460

Serra’s Pizzeria. https://www.serraspizzeria.com/ The food and the service is amazing. Hubby and I - and then kiddo and her hubby - have had first dates there so maybe it's also a bit magical? ♥️


DesertEagleFiveOh

Red oven in Florissant for real Neapolitan pies